Is a deep one-cell meridional circulation essential for the flux transport Solar Dynamo?

Abstract

The solar activity cycle is successfully modeled by the flux transport dynamo, in which the meridional circulation of the Sun plays an important role. Most of the kinematic dynamo simulations assume a one-cell structure of the meridional circulation within the convection zone, with the equatorward return flow at its bottom. In view of the recent claims that the return flow occurs at a much shallower depth, we explore whether a meridional circulation with such a shallow return flow can still retain the attractive features of the flux transport dynamo (such as a proper butterfly diagram, the proper phase relation between the toroidal and poloidal fields). We consider additional cells of the meridional circulation below the shallow return flow---both the case of multiple cells radially stacked above one another and the case of more complicated cell patterns. As long as there is an equatorward flow in low latitudes at the bottom of the convection zone, we find that the solar behavior is approximately reproduced. However, if there is either no flow or a poleward flow at the bottom of the convection zone, then we cannot reproduce solar behavior. On making the turbulent diffusivity low, we still find periodic behavior, although the period of the cycle becomes unrealistically large. Also, with a low diffusivity, we do not get the observed correlation between the polar field at the sunspot minimum and the strength of the next cycle, which is reproduced when diffusivity is high. On introducing radially downward pumping, we get a more reasonable period and more solar-like behavior even with low diffusivity.

12 pages, 13 figures

References in corpus (18)

• Detection of Equatorward Meridional Flow and Evidence of Double-Cell Meridional Circulation inside the Sun
• Persistent Magnetic Wreaths in a Rapidly Rotating Sun
• Solar activity forecast with a dynamo model
• Solar differential rotation and meridional flow: The role of a subadiabatic tachocline for the Taylor-Proudman balance
• Exploring the Physical Basis of Solar Cycle Predictions: Flux Transport Dynamics and Persistence of Memory in Advection versus Diffusion Dominated Solar Convection Zones
• Solar Cycle Propagation, Memory, and Prediction: Insights from a Century of Magnetic Proxies
• On the role of meridional flows in flux transport dynamo models
• Global helioseismic evidence for a deeply penetrating Solar meridional flow consisting of multiple flow cells
• Importance of Meridional Circulation in Flux Transport Dynamo: The Possibility of a Maunder-like Grand Minimum
• Turbulent magnetic pumping in a Babcock-Leighton solar dynamo model
• The Hemispheric Asymmetry of Solar Activity During the Twentieth Century and the Solar Dynamo
• Modeling Solar Cycles 15 to 21 Using a Flux Transport Dynamo
• A Double-Ring Algorithm for Modeling Solar Active Regions: Unifying Kinematic Dynamo Models and Surface Flux-Transport Simulations
• Turbulent Pumping of Magnetic Flux Reduces Solar Cycle Memory and thus Impacts Predictability of the Sun's Activity
• The Waldmeier effect and the flux transport solar dynamo
• Kinematic active region formation in a three-dimensional solar dynamo model
• Magnetoconvection and dynamo coefficients III: alpha-effect and magnetic pumping in the rapid rotation regime
• Studies of grand minima in sunspot cycles from a flux transport solar dynamo model

Cited by in corpus (56)

• Meridional Circulation in Solar and Stellar Convection Zones
• Magnetically controlled stellar differential rotation near the transition from solar to anti-solar profiles
• Solar Cycle Variability Induced by Tilt Angle Scatter in a Babcock--Leighton Solar Dynamo Model
• Advances in mean-field dynamo theory and applications to astrophysical turbulence
• The Solar-Stellar Connection
• Meridional Flow in the Solar Convection Zone II: Helioseismic Inversions of GONG Data
• A coupled $2\times 2$D Babcock-Leighton solar dynamo model. II. Reference dynamo solutions
• Models for the long-term variations of solar activity
• Babcock-Leighton solar dynamo: the role of downward pumping and the equatorward propagation of activity
• Turbulent transport coefficients in spherical wedge dynamo simulations of solar-like stars
• Evolution of solar and stellar dynamo theory
• Physical Models for Solar Cycle Predictions
• Mean field models of flux transport dynamo and meridional circulation in the Sun and stars
• A theoretical study of the build-up of the Sun's polar magnetic field by using a 3D kinematic dynamo model
• A Three-Dimensional Babcock-Leighton Solar Dynamo Model: Initial Results with Axisymmetric Flows
• A dynamo model of magnetic activity in solar-like stars with different rotational velocities
• Starspots, Stellar Cycles and Stellar Flares: Lessons from Solar Dynamo Models
• A proposed paradigm for solar cycle dynamics mediated via turbulent pumping of magnetic flux in Babcock-Leighton type solar dynamos
• How supercritical are stellar dynamos, or why do old main-sequence dwarfs not obey gyrochronology?
• Correlation between Decay Rate and Amplitude of Solar Cycles as Revealed from Observations and Dynamo Theory
• Star-in-a-box simulations of fully convective stars
• Inversions for Deep Solar Meridional Flow Using Spherical Born Kernels
• An update of Leighton's solar dynamo model
• Is the small-scale magnetic field correlated with the dynamo cycle?
• Meridional circulation dynamics from 3D MHD global simulations of solar convection
• Influence of the Sun-like magnetic cycle on exoplanetary atmospheric escape
• The irregularities of the sunspot cycle and their theoretical modelling
• A theoretical model of the variation of the meridional circulation with the solar cycle
• Exploring cycle period and parity of stellar magnetic activity with dynamo modeling
• A joined model for solar dynamo and differential rotation
• Double-Cell Type Solar Meridional Circulation Based on Mean-Field Hydrodynamic Model
• Solar activity simulation and forecast with a flux-transport dynamo
• Dynamo Saturation in Rapidly Rotating Solar-Type Stars
• Variational estimation of the large scale time dependent meridional circulation in the Sun: proofs of concept with a solar mean field dynamo model
• The treatment of magnetic buoyancy in flux transport dynamo models
• Does the mean-field alpha effect have any impact on the memory of the solar cycle?
• Meridional circulation in the Sun and stars
• Effects of anisotropy of turbulent convection in mean-field solar dynamo models
• The solar dynamo: inferences from observations and modeling
• Nonkinematic solar dynamo models with double-cell meridional circulation
• Incorporating Surface Convection into a 3D Babcock-Leighton Solar Dynamo Model
• A Critical Assessment of the Flux Transport Dynamo
• A new simple dynamo model for stellar activity cycle
• Flux Transport Dynamo: From Modelling Irregularities to Making Predictions
• Recent advances in the 3D kinematic Babcock-Leighton solar dynamo modeling
• Modeling effects of starspots on stellar magnetic cycles
• Three-dimensional non-kinematic simulation of post-emergence evolution of bipolar magnetic regions and Babcock-Leighton dynamo of the Sun
• A Potential New Mechanism for the Butterfly Diagram of the Solar Cycle: Latitude-dependent Radial Flux Transport
• Minimal Roles of Solar Subsurface Meridional Flow in the distributed-shear Babcock-Leighton Dynamo
• Explaining the variation of the meridional circulation with the solar cycle
• Supergranulation and Poleward Migration of the Magnetic Field at High Latitudes of the Sun
• Modelling the Center-to-Limb systematic in normal-mode-coupling measurements
• Solar Cycle Prediction: Challenges, Progress, and Future Perspectives
• Time-dependent theory of solar meridional flows
• Predicting a solar cycle before its onset using a flux transport dynamo model
• IAU commission 10 "Solar Activity": Legacy report and triennial report for 2012-2015