Testing the binary hypothesis: pulsar timing constraints on supermassive black hole binary candidates

Abstract

The advent of time domain astronomy is revolutionizing our understanding of the Universe. Programs such as the Catalina Real-time Transient Survey (CRTS) or the Palomar Transient Factory (PTF) surveyed millions of objects for several years, allowing variability studies on large statistical samples. The inspection of $\approx$250k quasars in CRTS resulted in a catalogue of 111 potentially periodic sources, put forward as supermassive black hole binary (SMBHB) candidates. A similar investigation on PTF data yielded 33 candidates from a sample of $\approx$35k quasars. Working under the SMBHB hypothesis, we compute the implied SMBHB merger rate and we use it to construct the expected gravitational wave background (GWB) at nano-Hz frequencies, probed by pulsar timing arrays (PTAs). After correcting for incompleteness and assuming virial mass estimates, we find that the GWB implied by the CRTS sample exceeds the current most stringent PTA upper limits by almost an order of magnitude. After further correcting for the implicit bias in virial mass measurements, the implied GWB drops significantly but is still in tension with the most stringent PTA upper limits. Similar results hold for the PTF sample. Bayesian model selection shows that the null hypothesis (whereby the candidates are false positives) is preferred over the binary hypothesis at about $2.3\sigma$ and $3.6\sigma$ for the CRTS and PTF samples respectively. Although not decisive, our analysis highlights the potential of PTAs as astrophysical probes of individual SMBHB candidates and indicates that the CRTS and PTF samples are likely contaminated by several false positives.

14 pages, 11 figures, 3 tables. Resubmitted to the Astrophysical Journal after some major revision of the results including a proper estimate of the intrinsic mass of the binary candidates

References in corpus (23)

• An Observational Determination of the Bolometric Quasar Luminosity Function
• Modeling the Time Variability of SDSS Stripe 82 Quasars as a Damped Random Walk
• Biases in Virial Black Hole Masses: An SDSS Perspective
• The stochastic gravitational-wave background from massive black hole binary systems: implications for observations with Pulsar Timing Arrays
• Massive black hole binary mergers within sub-pc scale gas discs
• The Population of Viscosity- and Gravitational Wave-Driven Supermassive Black Hole Binaries Among Luminous AGN
• Gravitational waves from resolvable massive black hole binary systems and observations with Pulsar Timing Arrays
• Growth and activity of black holes in galaxy mergers with varying mass ratios
• Viscous Hydrodynamics Simulations of Circumbinary Accretion Discs: Variability, Quasi-Steady State, and Angular Momentum Transfer
• The Gravitational Wave Background from Massive Black Hole Binaries in Illustris: spectral features and time to detection with pulsar timing arrays
• Self consistent model for the evolution of eccentric massive black hole binaries in stellar environments: implications for gravitational wave observations
• On the orbital evolution of supermassive black hole binaries with circumbinary accretion discs
• An all-sky search for continuous gravitational waves in the Parkes Pulsar Timing Array data set
• NANOGrav Limits on Gravitational Waves from Individual Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in Circular Orbits
• Characteristic Signatures in the Thermal Emission from Accreting Binary Black Holes
• Three Dimensional MHD Simulation of Circumbinary Accretion Disks -2. Net Accretion Rate
• Limitations on the recovery of the true AGN variability parameters using Damped Random Walk modeling
• The Effect of Orbital Eccentricity on Gravitational Wave Background Radiation from Supermassive Black Hole Binaries
• Prospects for gravitational-wave detection and supermassive black hole astrophysics with pulsar timing arrays
• Interactions between multiple supermassive black holes in galactic nuclei: a solution to the final parsec problem
• Binary super-massive black hole environments diminish the gravitational-wave signal in the pulsar timing band
• A Large Systematic Search for Close Supermassive Binary and Rapidly Recoiling Black Holes - III. Radial Velocity Variations
• Searching for Binary Supermassive Black Holes via Variable Broad Emission Line Shifts: Low Binary Fraction

Cited by in corpus (56)

• Black holes, gravitational waves and fundamental physics: a roadmap
• The NANOGrav 15-year Data Set: Constraints on Supermassive Black Hole Binaries from the Gravitational Wave Background
• The Astrophysics of Nanohertz Gravitational Waves
• The Quest for Dual and Binary Supermassive Black Holes: A Multi-Messenger View
• The NANOGrav 11-Year Data Set: Limits on Gravitational Waves from Individual Supermassive Black Hole Binaries
• A population of luminous accreting black holes with hidden mergers
• Single Sources in the Low-Frequency Gravitational Wave Sky: properties and time to detection by pulsar timing arrays
• Electromagnetic Counterparts to Massive Black Hole Mergers
• Supermassive Black Hole Binary Candidates from the Pan-STARRS1 Medium Deep Survey
• Periodic self-lensing from accreting massive black hole binaries
• From Bright Binaries To Bumpy Backgrounds: Mapping Realistic Gravitational Wave Skies With Pulsar-Timing Arrays
• A 34.5 day quasi-periodic oscillation in gamma-ray emission from the blazar PKS 2247-131
• Massive BH Binaries as Periodically-Variable AGN
• Constraining Sub-Parsec Binary Supermassive Black Holes in Quasars with Multi-Epoch Spectroscopy. III. Candidates from Continued Radial Velocity Tests
• Quasi-periodicities of BL Lac Objects
• Candidate Periodically Variable Quasars from the Dark Energy Survey and the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Multi-messenger Time-domain Signatures Of Supermassive Black Hole Binaries
• Quasi-periodic behaviour in the optical and γ-ray light curves of blazars 3C 66A and B2 1633+38
• Pulsar Timing Constraints on the Fermi Massive Black-Hole Binary Blazar Population
• Repeated Imaging of Massive Black Hole Binary Orbits with Millimeter Interferometry: measuring black hole masses and the Hubble constant
• A quasar-based supermassive black hole binary population model: implications for the gravitational-wave background
• Pulsar timing residual induced by ultralight vector dark matter
• Discovery of a Candidate Binary Supermassive Black Hole in a Periodic Quasar from Circumbinary Accretion Variability
• Unveiling sub-parsec supermassive black hole binary candidates in active galactic nuclei
• Gravitational Self-Lensing in Populations of Massive Black Hole Binaries
• The NANOGrav 11yr Data Set: Limits on Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in Galaxies within 500Mpc
• Model Dependence of Bayesian Gravitational-Wave Background Statistics for Pulsar Timing Arrays
• Quasars with Periodic Variability: Capabilities and Limitations of Bayesian Searches for Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in Time-Domain Surveys
• Kinematic signatures of reverberation mapping of close binaries of supermassive black holes in active galactic nuclei
• VLBI studies of DAGN and SMBHB hosting galaxies
• Gravitational Waves from the Inspiral of Supermassive Black Holes in Galactic-scale Simulations
• Multimessenger pulsar timing array constraints on supermassive black hole binaries traced by periodic light curves
• Multi-messenger Approaches to Supermassive Black Hole Binary Detection and Parameter Estimation: Implications for Nanohertz Gravitational Wave Searches with Pulsar Timing Arrays
• Associating Host Galaxy Candidates to Massive Black Hole Binaries resolved by Pulsar Timing Arrays
• Confirmed short periodic variability of subparsec supermassive binary black hole candidate Mrk 231
• Testing the relativistic Doppler boost hypothesis for the binary candidate quasar PG1302-102 with multi-band Swift data
• Considerations for the Observability of Kinematically Offset Binary AGN
• Likelihood for Detection of Sub-parsec Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in Spectroscopic Surveys
• Gravitational waves from supermassive black hole binaries in ultra-luminous infrared galaxies
• Spectral Energy Distributions of Candidate Periodically-Variable Quasars: Testing the Binary Black Hole Hypothesis
• Optical follow-up of the tick-tock massive black hole binary candidate
• A 6.4yr optical quasi-periodic oscillations in SDSS J075217.84+193542.2: a new candidate for central binary black hole system
• On using inspiralling supermassive binary black holes in the PTA frequency band as standard sirens to constrain dark energy
• Reliable Identification of Binary Supermassive Black Holes from Rubin Observatory Time-Domain Monitoring
• Supermassive Binary Black Hole Evolution can be traced by a small SKA Pulsar Timing Array
• A 3.8yr optical quasi-periodic oscillations in blue quasar SDSS J132144+033055 through combined light curves from CSS and ZTF
• Differential Interferometric Signatures of Close Binaries of Supermassive Black Holes in Active Galactic Nuclei
• Pulsar Timing Array Constraints on the Merger Timescale of Subparsec Supermassive Black Hole Binary Candidates
• Gravitational Radiation from Close Binaries with Time-Varying Masses
• The Fates of Merging Supermassive Black Holes and a Proposal for a New Class of X-Ray Sources
• Damping of long wavelength gravitational waves by the intergalactic medium
• Controlling Outlier Contamination In Multimessenger Time-domain Searches For Supermasssive Binary Black Holes
• Astro2020 Science White Paper: Black Hole Growth in Mergers and Dual AGN
• Binary black hole signatures in polarized light curves
• Testing No slip model with pulsar timing arrays: NANOGrav and IPTA
• A Population Study for Searching Supermassive Binary Black Holes in Active Galactic Nuclei: Continuum Spectral Features and Periodic Variabilities