A systematic search for close supermassive black hole binaries in the Catalina Real-Time Transient Survey

Abstract

Hierarchical assembly models predict a population of supermassive black hole (SMBH) binaries. These are not resolvable by direct imaging but may be detectable via periodic variability (or nanohertz frequency gravitational waves). Following our detection of a 5.2 year periodic signal in the quasar PG 1302-102 (Graham et al. 2015), we present a novel analysis of the optical variability of 243,500 known spectroscopically confirmed quasars using data from the Catalina Real-time Transient Survey (CRTS) to look for close (< 0.1 pc) SMBH systems. Looking for a strong Keplerian periodic signal with at least 1.5 cycles over a baseline of nine years, we find a sample of 111 candidate objects. This is in conservative agreement with theoretical predictions from models of binary SMBH populations. Simulated data sets, assuming stochastic variability, also produce no equivalent candidates implying a low likelihood of spurious detections. The periodicity seen is likely attributable to either jet precession, warped accretion disks or periodic accretion associated with a close SMBH binary system. We also consider how other SMBH binary candidates in the literature appear in CRTS data and show that none of these are equivalent to the identified objects. Finally, the distribution of objects found is consistent with that expected from a gravitational wave-driven population. This implies that circumbinary gas is present at small orbital radii and is being perturbed by the black holes. None of the sources is expected to merge within at least the next century. This study opens a new unique window to study a population of close SMBH binaries that must exist according to our current understanding of galaxy and SMBH evolution.

29 pages, 10 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS - this version contains extended table and figure

References in corpus (30)

• A Catalog of Quasar Properties from SDSS DR7
• Modeling the Time Variability of SDSS Stripe 82 Quasars as a Damped Random Walk
• Biases in Virial Black Hole Masses: An SDSS Perspective
• Measuring the rotation period distribution of field M-dwarfs with Kepler
• A Compact Supermassive Binary Black Hole System
• A massive binary black-hole system in OJ287 and a test of general relativity
• Global General Relativistic MHD Simulation of a Tilted Black-Hole Accretion Disk
• A possible close supermassive black-hole binary in a quasar with optical periodicity
• Is Quasar Optical Variability a Damped Random Walk?
• The Population of Viscosity- and Gravitational Wave-Driven Supermassive Black Hole Binaries Among Luminous AGN
• A Candidate Sub-Parsec Supermassive Binary Black Hole System
• The Lick AGN Monitoring Project 2011: Spectroscopic Campaign and Emission-Line Light Curves
• Massive binary black holes in galactic nuclei and their path to coalescence
• Powerful radiative jets in super-critical accretion disks around non-spinning black holes
• Are the Variability Properties of the Kepler AGN Light Curves Consistent with a Damped Random Walk?
• An all-sky search for continuous gravitational waves in the Parkes Pulsar Timing Array data set
• NANOGrav Limits on Gravitational Waves from Individual Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in Circular Orbits
• A milliparsec supermassive black hole binary candidate in the galaxy SDSS J120136.02+300305.5
• A Periodically Varying Luminous Quasar at z=2 from the Pan-STARRS1 Medium Deep Survey: A Candidate Supermassive Black Hole Binary in the Gravitational Wave-Driven Regime
• A supermassive binary black hole with triple disks
• The jet-disc connection in AGN
• Periodic accretion from a circumbinary disk in the young binary UZ Tau E
• Modeling of Emission Signatures of Massive Black Hole Binaries: I Methods
• Warping and precession in galactic and extragalactic accretion disks
• A reduced orbital period for the supermassive black hole binary candidate in the quasar PG 1302-102?
• Improved AGN light curve analysis with the z-transformed discrete correlation function
• Measuring Quasar Variability with Pan-STARRS1 and SDSS
• Supermassive Black Hole Binaries: The Search Continues
• Reprocessing model for the optical quasi-periodic oscillations in black hole binaries
• Warped Circumbinary Disks in Active Galactic Nuclei

Cited by in corpus (207)

• Black holes, gravitational waves and fundamental physics: a roadmap
• The NANOGrav 15-year Data Set: Constraints on Supermassive Black Hole Binaries from the Gravitational Wave Background
• False periodicities in quasar time-domain surveys
• The Astrophysics of Nanohertz Gravitational Waves
• The Quest for Dual and Binary Supermassive Black Holes: A Multi-Messenger View
• A Population of Short-Period Variable Quasars from PTF as Supermassive Black Hole Binary Candidates
• X-ray Quasi-Periodic Eruptions from two previously quiescent galaxies
• A Mid-IR Selected Changing-Look Quasar and Physical Scenarios for Abrupt AGN Fading
• The NANOGrav 15-year Data Set: Bayesian Limits on Gravitational Waves from Individual Supermassive Black Hole Binaries
• Circumbinary Accretion from Finite and Infinite Disks
• Gas-driven inspiral of binaries in thin accretion disks
• Understanding extreme quasar optical variability with CRTS: I. Major AGN flares
• ASASSN-14ko is a Periodic Nuclear Transient in ESO 253-G003
• Astrophysics Milestones For Pulsar Timing Array Gravitational Wave Detection
• Optical variability of AGN in the PTF/iPTF survey
• Understanding extreme quasar optical variability with CRTS: II. Changing-state quasars
• Sciences with the 2.5-meter Wide Field Survey Telescope (WFST)
• Single Sources in the Low-Frequency Gravitational Wave Sky: properties and time to detection by pulsar timing arrays
• Electromagnetic Counterparts to Massive Black Hole Mergers
• A transition in circumbinary accretion discs at a binary mass ratio of 1:25
• Spectroscopic Indication for a Centi-parsec Supermassive Black Hole Binary in the Galactic Center of NGC 5548
• Equilibrium eccentricity of accreting binaries
• The Gravitational-Wave Physics II: Progress
• Electromagnetic Emission from Supermassive Binary Black Holes Approaching Merger
• Supermassive Black Hole Binary Candidates from the Pan-STARRS1 Medium Deep Survey
• Lunar Gravitational-Wave Antenna
• Detection of Possible Quasi-periodic Oscillations in the Long-term Optical Light Curve of the BL Lac Object OJ 287
• Periodic self-lensing from accreting massive black hole binaries
• From Bright Binaries To Bumpy Backgrounds: Mapping Realistic Gravitational Wave Skies With Pulsar-Timing Arrays
• A self-lensing binary massive black hole interpretation of quasi-periodic eruptions
• A Large Systematic Search for Close Supermassive Binary and Rapidly Recoiling Black Holes - III. Radial Velocity Variations
• Testing the binary hypothesis: pulsar timing constraints on supermassive black hole binary candidates
• Autoregressive Times Series Methods for Time Domain Astronomy
• Probing Massive Black Hole Binary Populations with LISA
• Massive BH Binaries as Periodically-Variable AGN
• Evidence for periodicity in 43 year-long monitoring of NGC 5548
• Constraining Sub-Parsec Binary Supermassive Black Holes in Quasars with Multi-Epoch Spectroscopy. III. Candidates from Continued Radial Velocity Tests
• The Unanticipated Phenomenology of the Blazar PKS~2131$-$021: A Unique Super-Massive Black Hole Binary Candidate
• A Family Tree of Optical Transients from Narrow-Line Seyfert 1 Galaxies
• Gamma-ray quasi-periodicities of blazars. A cautious approach
• Pulsar Timing Array Based Search for Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in the Square Kilometer Array Era
• Minidisks in Binary Black Hole Accretion
• How frequent are close supermassive binary black holes in powerful jet sources?
• A Systematic Search for Periodically Varying Quasars in Pan-STARRS1: An Extended Baseline Test in Medium Deep Survey Field MD09
• SDSS J0159+0105: A Radio-Quiet Quasar with a Centi-Parsec Supermassive Black Hole Binary Candidate
• Varstrometry for Off-nucleus and Dual sub-Kpc AGN (VODKA): Methodology and Initial Results with Gaia DR2
• Quasi-periodicities of BL Lac Objects
• Gamma-ray and Optical Oscillations of 0716+714, MRK 421, and BL Lac
• Optical Variability of Narrow and Broad line Seyfert 1 galaxies
• Varstrometry for Off-nucleus and Dual sub-Kpc AGN (VODKA): Hubble Space Telescope Discovers Double Quasars
• A Survey of Disc Thickness and Viscosity in Circumbinary Accretion: Binary Evolution, Variability, and Disc Morphology
• Examining AGN UV/optical Variability Beyond the Simple Damped Random Walk
• Did ASAS-SN Kill the Supermassive Black Hole Binary Candidate PG1302-102?
• Multi-band light curves from eccentric accreting supermassive black hole binaries
• LISA parameter estimation and source localization with higher harmonics of the ringdown
• Candidate Periodically Variable Quasars from the Dark Energy Survey and the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Radio and $\gamma$-ray variability in the BL Lac PKS 0219 -164: Detection of quasi-periodic oscillations in the radio light curve
• Mini-disk accretion onto spinning black hole binaries: quasi-periodicities and outflows
• Electromagnetic Signatures from Supermassive Binary Black Holes Approaching Merger
• Testing the relativistic Doppler boost hypothesis for supermassive black hole binary candidates
• Spikey: Self-Lensing Flares from Eccentric SMBH Binaries
• TeraHertz Exploration and Zooming-in for Astrophysics (THEZA): ESA Voyage 2050 White Paper
• Preventing Anomalous Torques in Circumbinary Accretion Simulations
• Multi-messenger Time-domain Signatures Of Supermassive Black Hole Binaries
• Minidisk dynamics in accreting, spinning black hole binaries: Simulations in full general relativity
• Ultra-Short-Period Massive Black Hole Binary Candidates in LSST as LISA "Verification Binaries"
• Searching for Binary Supermassive Black Holes via Variable Broad Emission Line Shifts: Low Binary Fraction
• A Possible ~20 yr Periodicity in Long-term Optical Photometric and Spectral Variations of the Nearby Radio-Quiet Active Galactic Nucleus Ark 120
• An analysis of feature relevance in the classification of astronomical transients with machine learning methods
• Gaia-like astrometry and gravitational waves
• Quasar Variability in the Mid-Infrared
• Pulsar Timing Constraints on the Fermi Massive Black-Hole Binary Blazar Population
• Looking at Blazar Light Curve Periodicities with Gaussian Processes
• Disks Around Merging Binary Black Holes: From GW150914 to Supermassive Black Holes
• Changing-look active galactic nuclei: close binaries of supermassive black holes in action
• Self-lensing flares from black hole binaries I: general-relativistic ray tracing of black hole binaries
• Repeated Imaging of Massive Black Hole Binary Orbits with Millimeter Interferometry: measuring black hole masses and the Hubble constant
• The first high-redshift changing-look quasars
• Deep modeling of quasar variability
• Circumbinary Disk Accretion into Spinning Black Hole Binaries
• Astrophysical constraints on massive black hole binary evolution from Pulsar Timing Arrays
• The Decoupling of Binaries from Their Circumbinary Disks
• X-ray spectral components of the blazar and binary black hole candidate OJ 287 (2005-2020)
• Discovery of a Candidate Binary Supermassive Black Hole in a Periodic Quasar from Circumbinary Accretion Variability
• The NANOGrav 12.5-year Data Set: Bayesian Limits on Gravitational Waves from Individual Supermassive Black Hole Binaries
• Unveiling sub-parsec supermassive black hole binary candidates in active galactic nuclei
• Gravitational Self-Lensing in Populations of Massive Black Hole Binaries
• Toward the unambiguous identification of supermassive binary black holes through Bayesian inference
• Population Estimates for Electromagnetically-Distinguishable Supermassive Binary Black Holes
• Self-lensing flares from black hole binaries II: observing black hole shadows via light-curve tomography
• Black hole accretion disc impacts
• The NANOGrav 11yr Data Set: Limits on Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in Galaxies within 500Mpc
• Absence of the predicted 2022 October outburst of OJ 287 and implications for binary SMBH scenarios
• Quasars with Periodic Variability: Capabilities and Limitations of Bayesian Searches for Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in Time-Domain Surveys
• Joint constraints on cosmological parameters using future multi-band gravitational wave standard siren observations
• Galaxy fields of LISA massive black hole mergers in a simulated Universe
• The Nanohertz Gravitational Wave Astronomer
• Improving timing sensitivity in the microhertz frequency regime: limits from PSR J1713$+$0747 on gravitational waves produced by super-massive black-hole binaries
• VLBI studies of DAGN and SMBHB hosting galaxies
• Multiwavelength variability study and search for periodicity of PKS 1510-089
• Lighthouse in the Dust: Infrared Echoes of Periodic Emission from Massive Black Hole Binaries
• Multi-messenger Approaches to Supermassive Black Hole Binary Detection and Parameter Estimation: Implications for Nanohertz Gravitational Wave Searches with Pulsar Timing Arrays
• Multimessenger pulsar timing array constraints on supermassive black hole binaries traced by periodic light curves
• An Improved Test of the Binary Black Hole Hypothesis for Quasars with Double-peaked Broad Balmer Lines
• A Chandra X-ray Survey of Optically Selected AGN Pairs
• Very Long Baseline Array Imaging of Type-2 Seyferts with Double-Peaked Narrow Emission Lines: Searches for Sub-kpc Dual AGNs and Jet-Powered Outflows
• Quasi-periodic behaviour in the $\gamma$-ray light curve of the blazar PKS 0405-385
• Parsec-scale jet properties of the quasar PG 1302$-$102
• Confirmed short periodic variability of subparsec supermassive binary black hole candidate Mrk 231
• The Variability and Period Analysis for the BL Lac AO 0235+164
• Real-Time Data Mining of Massive Data Streams from Synoptic Sky Surveys
• Detectability of Gravitational Waves from High-Redshift Binaries
• Emission Signatures from Sub-parsec Binary Supermassive Black Holes III: Comparison of Models with Observations
• Testing the relativistic Doppler boost hypothesis for the binary candidate quasar PG1302-102 with multi-band Swift data
• The BAT AGN Spectroscopic Survey -- XVIII. Searching for Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in the X-rays
• Likelihood for Detection of Sub-parsec Supermassive Black Hole Binaries in Spectroscopic Surveys
• Correlation between Optical and UV Variability of Quasars
• The gamma-ray and Optical Variability Analysis of the BL Lac Object 3FGL J0449.4-4350
• Dynamical evidence of the sub-parsec counter-rotating disc for a close binary of supermassive black holes in the nucleus of NGC 1068
• The NANOGrav 15 yr Data Set: Looking for Signs of Discreteness in the Gravitational-wave Background
• Spectral Energy Distributions of Candidate Periodically-Variable Quasars: Testing the Binary Black Hole Hypothesis
• Properties and merger signatures of galaxies hosting LISA coalescing massive black hole binaries
• Minidisk Influence on Flow Variability in Accreting Spinning Black Hole Binaries: Simulations in Full General Relativity
• Dependence of NLRs sizes on [OIII] luminosity in low redshift AGN with double-peaked broad Balmer emission lines
• The Bardeen-Petterson effect in accreting supermassive black-hole binaries: a systematic approach
• On using inspiralling supermassive binary black holes in the PTA frequency band as standard sirens to constrain dark energy
• Optical follow-up of the tick-tock massive black hole binary candidate
• Variation of Broad Emission Lines from QSOs with Optical/UV Periodicity to Test the Interpretation of Supermassive Binary Black Holes
• A 6.4yr optical quasi-periodic oscillations in SDSS J075217.84+193542.2: a new candidate for central binary black hole system
• Two Transient Quasi-periodic Oscillations in $\gamma$-Ray Emission from the Blazar S4 0954+658
• Extreme Variability in a Broad Absorption Line Quasar
• Eccentric Minidisks in Accreting Binaries
• Testing the relativistic Doppler boost hypothesis for supermassive binary black holes candidates via broad emission line profiles
• Evidence for a milliparsec-separation Supermassive Binary Black Hole with quasar microlensing
• Reliable Identification of Binary Supermassive Black Holes from Rubin Observatory Time-Domain Monitoring
• Unveiling the hosts of parsec-scale massive black hole binaries: morphology and electromagnetic signatures
• No Evidence for Periodic Variability in the Light Curve of Active Galaxy J0045+41
• The Search for Binary Supermassive Black Holes Amongst Quasars with Offset Broad Lines Using the Very Long Baseline Array
• Suppressed accretion onto massive black hole binaries surrounded by thin disks
• Variable classification in the LSST era: Exploring a model for quasi-periodic light curves
• Supermassive Binary Black Hole Evolution can be traced by a small SKA Pulsar Timing Array
• Continuum optical-UV and X-ray variability of AGN: current results and future challenges
• Detecting subparsec super-massive binary black holes: Long termmonitoring perspective
• Radio Crickets: Chirping Jets from Black Hole Binaries Entering their Gravitational Wave Inspiral
• Dynamics and spin alignment in massive, gravito-turbulent circumbinary discs around supermassive black hole binaries
• A note on periodicity of long-term variations of optical continuum in active galactic nuclei
• Broad-line region configuration of the supermassive binary black hole candidate PG1302-102 in the relativistic Doppler boosting scenario
• Detecting the periodicity of highly irregularly sampled light-curves with Gaussian processes: the case of SDSSJ025214.67-002813.7
• A 3.8yr optical quasi-periodic oscillations in blue quasar SDSS J132144+033055 through combined light curves from CSS and ZTF
• Periodicity in the continua and broad line curves of a quasar E1821+643
• Multimessenger Approaches to Supermassive Black Hole Binary Detection and Parameter Estimation II: Optimal Strategies for a Pulsar Timing Array
• Predicting the broad lines polarization emitted by supermassive binary black holes
• Quasi periodic whispers from a transient ULX in M\,101: signatures of a fast-spinning neutron star?
• SDSS J154751.94+025550 with double-peaked broad Hβbut single-peaked broad Hα: a candidate for central binary black hole system?
• ESPRESSO reveals a single but perturbed broad-line region in the supermassive black hole binary candidate PG 1302-102
• Detecting the Orbital Motion of Nearby Supermassive Black Hole Binaries with Gaia
• Final stage of merging binaries of supermassive black holes: observational signatures
• The Twisted Radio Structure of PSO J334.2028+01.4075, Still a Supermassive Binary Black Hole Candidate
• Solving the puzzle of discrepant quasar variability on monthly time-scales implied by SDSS and CRTS data sets
• Probing the Delay Time of Supermassive Black Hole Binary Mergers With Gravitational Waves
• Non-steady-state long-term evolution of supermassive black hole binaries surrounded by accretion discs
• Constraints on individual supermassive binary black holes using observations of PSR J1909-3744
• A fast test for the identification and confirmation of massive black hole binaries
• Conditional Neural Process for non-parametric modeling of AGN light curve
• X-ray view of a merging supermassive black hole binary candidate SDSSJ1430+2303: Results from the first ~200 days of observations
• OJ~287: a new BH mass estimate of the secondary
• A candidate of binary black hole system in AGN with broad Balmer emission lines having quite different line widths
• Deep VLBI Observations Challenge Previous Evidence of a Binary Supermassive Black Hole Residing in the Seyfert Galaxy NGC 7674
• Three Cases of Optical Periodic Modulation in Active Galactic Nuclei
• Differential Interferometric Signatures of Close Binaries of Supermassive Black Holes in Active Galactic Nuclei: II. Merged Broad Line Regions
• A catalogue of candidate milli-parsec separation massive black hole binaries from long term optical photometric monitoring
• Unusual Hard X-ray Flares Caught in NICER Monitoring of the Binary Supermassive Black Hole Candidate AT2019cuk/Tick Tock/SDSS J1430+2303
• Periodic optical variability of AGN
• Coincident Multimessenger Bursts from Eccentric Supermassive Binary Black Holes
• Very Large Array imaging rules out precessing radio jets in three DES$-$SDSS-selected candidate periodic quasars
• Broadband spectral and temporal study of Ton 599 during the brightest January 2023 flare
• Exploring possible relations between optical variability time scales and broad emission line shapes in AGN
• Prospects for Time-Domain and Multi-Messenger Science with eXTP
• Diffractive lensing of nano-Hertz gravitational waves emitted from supermassive binary black holes by intervening galaxies
• Astrophysics with the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna
• Polarization of Astrophysical Events with Precessing Jets
• Periodic variability of the z=2.0 quasar QSO B1312+7837
• Signatures of a spinning supermassive black hole binary on the mas-scale jet of the quasar S5 1928+738 based on 25 years of VLBI data
• Damping of long wavelength gravitational waves by the intergalactic medium
• Strange Quasar Candidates with Abnormal Astrometric Characteristics from Gaia EDR3 and SDSS (SQUAB-II): Optical Identifications
• DULAG: A DUal and Lensed AGN candidate catalog with GMP method
• Velocity offset between emission and absorption lines might be an effective indicator of dual core system
• Ultra-low-frequency gravitational waves from individual supermassive black hole binaries as standard sirens
• Effects of eccentricity on accreting binary black holes: MHD simulations in full GR reveal novel periodicities in jet power and synchrotron spectra
• On Variation of Light Curves and Broad Emission Lines for Periodic QSOs from co-rotating Supermassive binary black holes in elliptical orbits
• The rare extended radio-loud narrow-line Seyfert 1 galaxy SDSS J1030+5516 at high resolution
• Variations of Broad Emission Lines from periodicity QSOs under the interpretation of supermassive binary black holes with misaligned circumbinary broad line regions
• Controlling Outlier Contamination In Multimessenger Time-domain Searches For Supermasssive Binary Black Holes
• Search for Quasar Pairs with $Gaia$ Astrometric Data. I. Method and Candidates
• Prospects for observing supermassive black hole binaries with the space-ground interferometer
• Searching for supermassive black holes binaries within SRG/eROSITA-De I: Properties of the X-ray selected candidates
• Identifying massive black hole binaries via light curve variability in optical time-domain surveys
• Electromagnetic variability from circumbinary discs around binary black holes during their post-decoupling epoch
• Binary black holes gone MAD: Magnetically arrested minidisks around nonspinning black holes
• Search for Continuous Gravitational Wave Signals in Pulsar Timing Residuals: A New Scalable Approach with Diffusive Nested Sampling
• India's first robotic eye for time domain astrophysics: the GROWTH-India telescope
• The possible long-term periodic variability of the extremely luminous quasar WISE J090924.01+000211.1
• Binary black hole signatures in polarized light curves
• Multi-Band Optical Variability of Blazar 1ES 2344+514 on Diverse Time-Scales
• SDSS J153231.80+420342.7: a triple black hole candidate with a close binary black hole
• Rapid multi-band space-based optical timing: revolutionizing accretion physics
• A Population Study for Searching Supermassive Binary Black Holes in Active Galactic Nuclei: Continuum Spectral Features and Periodic Variabilities