The Ubiquity of Coeval Starbursts in Massive Galaxy Cluster Progenitors

Abstract

The Universe's largest galaxy clusters likely built the majority of their massive $>10^{11}{M}_{\odot }$ galaxies in simultaneous, short-lived bursts of activity well before virialization. This conclusion is reached from emerging datasets on $z>2$ proto-clusters and the characteristics of their member galaxies, in particular, rare starbursts and ultraluminous active galactic nuclei (AGN). The most challenging observational hurdle in identifying such structures is their very large volumes, $\sim 10^4$ comoving Mpc${}^3$ at $z>2$, subtending areas $\sim$half a degree on the sky. Thus the contrast afforded by an overabundance of very rare galaxies in comparison to the background can more easily distinguish overdense structures from the surrounding, normal density field. Five $2<z<3$ proto-clusters from the literature are discussed in detail and are found to contain up to 12 dusty starbursts or luminous AGN galaxies each, a phenomenon that is unlikely to occur by chance even in overdense environments. Measurements of gas depletion times suggest that they are indeed short-lived on $\sim$100 Myr timescales, and the probability of finding a structure containing more than 8 such systems is $\sim$0.2\%, unless their `triggering' is correlated on very large spatial scales, $\sim$10 Mpc across. The volume density of starburst-rich proto-clusters is found to be comparable to all $>10^{15}{M}_{\odot }$ galaxy clusters in the nearby Universe, a factor of five larger than expected in some simulations. Some tension yet exists between measurements of their volume density of starburst-rich proto-clusters and the expectation that they are generated via short-lived episodes. However, improved observations of proto-clusters over large regions of sky will certainly shed more light on the assembly of galaxy clusters, and whether or not they build their galaxies through episodic bursts as suggested here. [abridged]

15 pages, 5 figures; accepted in ApJ

References in corpus (21)

• Introducing the Illustris Project: Simulating the coevolution of dark and visible matter in the Universe
• Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Data Processing, Sky Maps, and Basic Results
• A simple model to interpret the ultraviolet, optical and infrared emission from galaxies
• A massive proto-cluster of galaxies at a redshift of z {\approx} 5.3
• The Luminosity Function of X-ray Selected Active Galactic Nuclei: Evolution of Supermassive Black Holes at High Redshift
• The DEEP2 Galaxy Redshift Survey: The Role of Galaxy Environment in the Cosmic Star-Formation History
• The Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey. VLT/VIMOS Spectroscopy in the GOODS-South Field
• A Spectroscopic Survey of Redshift 1.4<z<3.0 Galaxies in the Goods-North Field: Survey Description, Catalogs, and Properties
• Protoclusters associated with z > 2 radio galaxies. I. Characteristics of high redshift protoclusters
• An excess of dusty starbursts related to the Spiderweb galaxy
• A Panoramic Mid-infrared Survey of Two Distant Clusters
• Spatial correlation between submillimetre and Lyman-alpha galaxies in the SSA 22 protocluster
• Dust Attenuation in High Redshift Galaxies -- 'Diamonds in the Sky'
• KECK/MOSFIRE spectroscopic confirmation of a Virgo-like cluster ancestor at z=2.095
• A proto-cluster at z=2.45
• Discovery of a Very Large Structure at Z=3.78
• A Deep 1.2 mm Map of the Lockman Hole North Field
• NIR spectroscopic observation of massive galaxies in the protocluster at z = 3.09
• The early phases of galaxy clusters formation in IR: coupling hydrodynamical simulations with GRASIL3D
• Physical Properties of Four SZE-Selected Galaxy Clusters in the Southern Cosmology Survey
• Constraining Star Formation and AGN in z~2 Massive Galaxies using High Resolution MERLIN Radio Observations

Cited by in corpus (91)

• The realm of the galaxy protoclusters
• Discovery of a galaxy cluster with a violently starbursting core at z=2.506
• A massive core for a cluster of galaxies at a redshift of 4.3
• High-redshift star formation in the ALMA era
• An extreme proto-cluster of luminous dusty starbursts in the early Universe
• Gas filaments of the cosmic web located around active galaxies in a proto-cluster
• The Complete Redshift Distribution of Dusty Star-forming Galaxies from the SPT-SZ Survey
• MApping the Most Massive Overdensities (MAMMOTH) II -- Discovery of an Extremely Massive Overdensity BOSS1441 at $z=2.32$
• SILVERRUSH. VIII. Spectroscopic Identifications of Early Large Scale Structures with Protoclusters Over 200 Mpc at z~6-7: Strong Associations of Dusty Star-Forming Galaxies
• CCAT-prime Collaboration: Science Goals and Forecasts with Prime-Cam on the Fred Young Submillimeter Telescope
• The Obelisk simulation: galaxies contribute more than AGN to HI reionization of protoclusters
• Spectroscopic Confirmation of a Protocluster at $z=3.37$ with a High Fraction of Quiescent Galaxies
• ALMA Deep Field in SSA22: Source Catalog and Number Counts
• An ALMA survey of the brightest sub-millimetre sources in the SCUBA-2 COSMOS field
• The implications of the surprising existence of a large, massive CO disk in a distant protocluster
• Mapping Obscuration to Reionization with ALMA (MORA): 2mm Efficiently Selects the Highest-Redshift Obscured Galaxies
• The DIANOGA simulations of galaxy clusters: characterizing star formation in proto-clusters
• Revealing environmental dependence of molecular gas content in a distant X-ray cluster at z=2.51
• Confirming Herschel candidate protoclusters from ALMA/VLA CO observations
• GA-NIFS: The core of an extremely massive proto-cluster at the Epoch of Reionization probed with JWST/NIRSpec
• Emergence of an Ultra-Red Ultra-Massive Galaxy Cluster Core at $z=4$
• Large scale structure around a z=2.1 cluster
• On the Gas Content, Star Formation Efficiency, and Environmental Quenching of Massive Galaxies in Proto-Clusters at z~2.0-2.5
• Herschel protocluster survey: A search for dusty star-forming galaxies in protoclusters at z=2-3
• A radio-to-mm census of star-forming galaxies in protocluster 4C23.56 at z=2.5 : Gas mass and its fraction revealed with ALMA
• COALAS: I. ATCA CO(1-0) survey and luminosity function in the Spiderweb protocluster at z=2.16
• Spectroscopic observations of PHz G237.01+42.50: A galaxy protocluster at z=2.16 in the Cosmos field
• Galaxy evolution in protoclusters
• A lensed protocluster candidate at $z=7.66$ identified in JWST observations of the galaxy cluster SMACS0723-7327
• Comprehensive Gas Characterization of a $z=2.5$ Protocluster: A Cluster Core Caught in the Beginning of Virialization?
• Candidate high-z proto-clusters among the Planck compact sources, as revealed by Herschel-SPIRE
• Is there enough star formation in simulated protoclusters?
• GN-z11: The environment of an AGN at $z=$10.603
• A Planck-selected dusty proto-cluster at z=2.16 associated with a strong over-density of massive H$\alpha$ emitting galaxies
• Overdensity of submillimeter galaxies around the $z\simeq 2.3$ MAMMOTH-1 nebula
• Nowhere to Hide: Radio-faint AGN in the GOODS-N field. I. Initial catalogue and radio properties
• H-ATLAS: A Candidate High Redshift Cluster/Protocluster of Star-Forming Galaxies
• Accelerated galaxy growth and environmental quenching in a protocluster at z=3.24
• On the statistics of proto-cluster candidates detected in the Planck all-sky survey
• Overdensities of Submillimetre-Bright Sources around Candidate Protocluster Cores Selected from the South Pole Telescope Survey
• Ultra-Red Galaxies Signpost Candidate Proto-Clusters at High Redshift
• No Evidence for Millimeter Continuum Source Overdensities in the Environments of $z\gtrsim 6$ Quasars
• Probing the existence of a rich galaxy overdensity at z=5.2
• Optical and near-infrared observations of the SPT2349-56 proto-cluster core at z = 4.3
• Planck far-infrared detection of Hyper Suprime-Cam protoclusters at $\mathbf{z}\sim 4$: hidden AGN and star formation activity
• A census of galaxy constituents in a Coma Progenitor observed at z>3
• Using ALMA to resolve the nature of the early star-forming large-scale structure PLCK G073.4-57.5
• Overdensities of SMGs around WISE-selected, ultra-luminous, high-redshift AGN
• A detailed study of massive galaxies in a protocluster at z=3.13
• MAMMOTH: Confirmation of Two Massive Galaxy Overdensities at $z=2.24$ with H$\alpha$ Emitters
• COSMOS2020: Identification of High-z Protocluster Candidates in COSMOS
• SCUBA-2 observations of candidate starbursting protoclusters selected by Planck and Herschel-SPIRE
• A population of ultraviolet-dim protoclusters detected in absorption
• A hidden active galactic nucleus powering bright [O III] nebulae in a protocluster at $z=4.5$ revealed by JWST
• Discovery of Protoclusters at z~3.7 & 4.9: Embedded in Primordial Superclusters
• FIR-luminous [CII] emitters in the ALMA-SCUBA-2 COSMOS survey (AS2COSMOS): The nature of submillimeter galaxies in a 10 comoving Mpc-scale structure at z~4.6
• Noema formIng Cluster survEy (NICE): Discovery of a starbursting galaxy group with a radio-luminous core at z=3.95
• JWST's PEARLS: resolved study of the stellar and dust components in starburst galaxies at cosmic noon
• A Mixture of LBG Overdensities in the Fields of Three $6<z<7$ Quasars: Implications for the Robustness of Photometric Selection
• Molecular gas properties of Planck-selected protocluster candidates at z~1.3-3
• Revealing Dust Obscured Star Formation in CLJ1449+0856, a Cluster at z=2
• Measuring the total infrared light from galaxy clusters at z=0.5-1.6: connecting stellar populations to dusty star formation
• Starbursts with suppressed velocity dispersion revealed in a forming cluster at z=2.51
• Deciphering the activity and quiescence of high-redshift cluster environments: ALMA observations of ClJ1449+0856 at z=2
• Questioning Planck-selected star-forming high-redshift galaxy protoclusters and their fate
• ASW${}^2$DF: Census of the obscured star formation in a galaxy cluster in formation at $z=2.2$
• The Environments of Luminous Radio - WISE Selected Infrared Galaxies
• JCMT/SCUBA-2 uncovers an excess of $850\mu$m counts on megaparsec scales around high-redshift quasars. Characterization of the overdensities and their alignment with the quasars' Ly$\alpha$ nebulae
• Star Formation and Chemical Enrichment in Protoclusters
• COALAS III: The ATCA CO(1-0) look at the growth and death of H$\alpha$ emitters in the Spiderweb protocluster at z=2.16
• Dust in Clusters of Galaxies
• NOEMA Redshift Measurements of Extremely Bright Submillimeter Galaxies Near the GOODS-N
• On the Origin of Dust in Galaxy Clusters at Low to Intermediate Redshift
• The relationship between cluster environment and molecular gas content of star-forming galaxies in the EAGLE simulation
• A Large Molecular Gas Reservoir in the Protocluster SPT2349$-$56 at $z=4.3$
• Quenching of Galaxies at Cosmic Noon: Understanding the Effect of Environment
• Massive molecular gas reservoir in a luminous sub-millimeter galaxy during cosmic noon
• Euclid preparation. Exploring the properties of proto-clusters in the Simulated Euclid Wide Survey
• Millimeter-wave observations of Euclid Deep Field South using the South Pole Telescope: A data release of temperature maps and catalogs
• Tracing the Total Stellar Mass and Star Formation of High-Redshift Protoclusters
• Spectroscopic characterization of the protocluster of galaxies around 7C 1756+6520 at z ~ 1.4
• PASSAGES: The Discovery of a Strongly Lensed Protocluster Core Candidate at Cosmic Noon
• An optically-dark merging system at z~6 detected by JWST
• JWST reveals extended stellar disks for ALMA-bright dusty star-forming galaxies in the Spiderweb protocluster
• Bright [CII]158$\mu$m Streamers as a Beacon for Giant Galaxy Formation in SPT2349$-$56 at $z=4.3$
• Simultaneously Modelling Dusty Star Forming Galaxies and Massive Quiescents: A Calibration Framework for Galaxy Formation Models
• The Radio Galaxy Environment Reference Survey (RAGERS): a submillimetre study of the environments of massive radio-quiet galaxies at $z=1-3$
• ALMA measures molecular gas reservoirs comparable to field galaxies in a low-mass galaxy cluster at z=1.3
• Searching Far and Long I: Pilot ALMA 2mm Follow-up of Bright Dusty Galaxies as a Redshift Filter
• The Photometric Analysis of the Environment Around Two Dusty Star-Forming Galaxies at $z\sim 2$
• Assembly History and Internal Structure of Cluster Cold Dark Matter Haloes