Low Virial Parameters in Molecular Clouds: Implications for High Mass Star Formation and Magnetic Fields

Abstract

Whether or not molecular clouds and embedded cloud fragments are stable against collapse is of utmost importance for the study of the star formation process. Only "supercritical" cloud fragments are able to collapse and form stars. The virial parameter, alpha=M_vir/M, which compares the virial to the actual mass, provides one way to gauge stability against collapse. Supercritical cloud fragments are characterized by alpha<2, as indicated by a comprehensive stability analysis considering perturbations in pressure and density gradients. Past research has suggested that virial parameters alpha>2 prevail in clouds. This would suggest that collapse towards star formation is a gradual and relatively slow process, and that magnetic fields are not needed to explain the observed cloud structure. Here, we review a range of very recent observational studies that derive virial parameters <<2 and compile a catalogue of 1325 virial parameter estimates. Low values of alpha are in particular observed for regions of high mass star formation (HMSF). These observations may argue for a more rapid and violent evolution during collapse. This would enable "competitive accretion" in HMSF, constrain some models of "monolithic collapse", and might explain the absence of high--mass starless cores. Alternatively, the data could point at the presence of significant magnetic fields ~1 mG at high gas densities. We examine to what extent the derived observational properties might be biased by observational or theoretical uncertainties. For a wide range of reasonable parameters, our conclusions appear to be robust with respect to such biases.

accepted to ApJ

References in corpus (10)

• Theory of Star Formation
• Trigonometric Parallaxes of Massive Star Forming Regions: VI. Galactic Structure, Fundamental Parameters and Non-Circular Motions
• MAMBO Mapping of Spitzer c2d Small Clouds and Cores
• Star formation through gravitational collapse and competitive accretion
• Bolocam Survey for 1.1 mm Dust Continuum Emission in the c2d Legacy Clouds. II. Ophiuchus
• The Nature of the Dense Core Population in the Pipe Nebula: Thermal Cores Under Pressure
• An Ammonia Spectral Atlas of Dense Cores in Perseus
• A SCUBA survey of Orion, the low-mass end of the core mass function
• Six Myths on the Virial Theorem for Interstellar Clouds
• The nature of the dense core population in the Pipe Nebula: A survey of NH3, CCS, and HC5N molecular line emission

Cited by in corpus (208)

• Star Clusters Across Cosmic Time
• High-Mass Star and Massive Cluster Formation in the Milky Way
• Global Hierarchical Collapse In Molecular Clouds. Towards a Comprehensive Scenario
• Inefficient star formation through turbulence, magnetic fields and feedback
• ATLASGAL --- towards a complete sample of massive star forming clumps
• Magnetic Fields in High-Mass Infrared Dark Clouds
• On the universality of interstellar filaments: theory meets simulations and observations
• A Massive Prestellar Clump Hosting no High-Mass Cores
• The Galactic Center Molecular Cloud Survey. I. A Steep Linewidth-Size Relation & Suppression of Star Formation
• SEDIGISM: Structure, excitation, and dynamics of the inner Galactic interstellar medium
• ATLASGAL-selected massive clumps in the inner Galaxy: I. CO depletion and isotopic ratios
• Star Formation Efficiency and Dispersal of Giant Molecular Clouds with UV Radiation Feedback: Dependence on Gravitational Boundedness and Magnetic Fields
• The density structure and star formation rate of non-isothermal polytropic turbulence
• Filamentary Fragmentation and Accretion in High-Mass Star-Forming Molecular Clouds
• Interferometric observations of magnetic fields in forming stars
• ALMA unveils widespread molecular gas clumps in the ram pressure stripped tail of the Norma jellyfish galaxy
• ATLASGAL-selected massive clumps in the inner Galaxy III. Dust Continuum Characterization of an Evolutionary Sample
• The Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey. XIV. Physical Properties of Massive Starless and Star Forming Clumps
• A Model for the Onset of Self-gravitation and Star Formation in Molecular Gas Governed by Galactic Forces: I. Cloud-scale Gas Motions
• Filamentary Accretion Flows in the Infrared Dark Cloud G14.225-0.506 Revealed by ALMA
• Impact of Protostellar Outflows on Turbulence and Star Formation Efficiency in Magnetized Dense Cores
• A necklace of dense cores in the high-mass star forming region G35.20-0.74N: ALMA observations
• Gravitational contraction versus Supernova driving and the origin of the velocity dispersion-size relation in molecular clouds
• A model for the formation of stellar associations and clusters from giant molecular clouds
• Testing Larson's relationships in massive clumps
• STARFORGE: The effects of protostellar outflows on the IMF
• The Green Bank Ammonia Survey: Dense Cores Under Pressure in Orion A
• Opacity broadening and interpretation of suprathermal CO linewidths: Macroscopic Turbulence and Tangled Molecular Clouds
• Escape of ionizing radiation from high redshift dwarf galaxies: role of AGN feedback
• Effects of the environment and feedback physics on the initial mass function of stars in the STARFORGE simulations
• Gravity, Magnetic Field, and Turbulence: Relative Importance and Impact on Fragmentation in the Infrared Dark Cloud G34.43+00.24
• The integrated properties of the molecular clouds from the JCMT CO(3-2) High Resolution Survey
• Dense core properties in the Infrared Dark cloud G14.225-0.506 revealed by ALMA
• From diffuse gas to dense molecular cloud cores
• Investigating the structure and fragmentation of a highly filamentary IRDC
• The SEDIGISM survey: Molecular clouds in the inner Galaxy
• GMC Collisions as Triggers of Star Formation. II. 3D Turbulent, Magnetized Simulations
• Zooming in on Individual Star Formation: Low- and High-mass Stars
• Larson's scaling laws, and the gravitational instability of clumpy discs at high redshift
• The JCMT Plane Survey: early results from the l = 30 degree field
• CHIMPS: Physical properties of molecular clumps across the inner Galaxy
• Massive 70 micron quiet clumps II: non-thermal motions driven by gravity in massive star formation?
• Fragmentation in filamentary molecular clouds
• Formation of Massive Protostellar Clusters -- Observations of Massive 70 $\mu$m Dark Molecular Clouds
• The Onset of Massive Star Formation: The Evolution of Temperature and Density Structure in an Infrared Dark Cloud
• The ATLASGAL survey: The sample of young massive cluster progenitors
• The Galactic Center Molecular Cloud Survey. II. A Lack of Dense Gas & Cloud Evolution along Galactic Center Orbits
• Gravity or turbulence? IV. Collapsing cores in out-of-virial disguise
• G11.92-0.61-MM2: A Bonafide Massive Prestellar Core?
• Physical properties and scaling relations of molecular clouds: the effect of stellar feedback
• Evolution of giant molecular clouds across cosmic time
• Internal motions in OB-associations with Gaia DR2
• Observational constraints on star cluster formation theory - I. The mass-radius relation
• Detection of a high-mass prestellar core candidate in W43-MM1
• Numerical Calibration of the HCN$-$Star Formation Correlation
• Formation of the Hub-Filament System G33.92+0.11: Local Interplay between Gravity, Velocity, and Magnetic Field
• The fragmentation and stability of hierarchical structure in Serpens South
• Mass segregation in star clusters is not energy equipartition
• How well does CO emission measure the H${}_2$ mass of MCs?
• Massive Star Formation via the Collapse of Subvirial and Virialized Turbulent Massive Cores
• Explaining the luminosity spread in young clusters: proto and pre-main sequence stellar evolution in a molecular cloud environment
• Star cluster formation with stellar feedback and large-scale inflow
• Feeding vs. Falling: The growth and collapse of molecular clouds in a turbulent interstellar medium
• The IMF and multiplicity of stars from gravity, turbulence, magnetic fields, radiation and outflow feedback
• The ALMA Survey of 70 μm Dark High-mass Clumps in Early Stages (ASHES). VIII. Dynamics of Embedded Dense Cores
• A distance limited sample of massive star forming cores from the RMS survey
• Magnetic field properties in star formation: a review of their analysis methods and interpretation
• Synthetic observations of star formation and the interstellar medium
• The RMS Survey: Ammonia mapping of the environment of massive young stellar objects
• Magnetic fields in the early stages of massive star formation as revealed by ALMA
• ALMA observations of NGC 6334S $-$ I: Forming massive stars and cluster in subsonic and transonic filamentary clouds
• The core population and kinematics of a massive clump at early stages: an ALMA view
• Planet formation via pebble accretion in externally photoevaporating discs
• A model for the onset of self-gravitation and star formation in molecular gas governed by galactic forces: II. the bottleneck to collapse set by cloud-environment decoupling
• Can magnetized turbulence set the mass scale of stars?
• Survey of ortho-H${}_2$D${}^{+}$ in high-mass star-forming regions
• Mixing of metals during star cluster formation: statistics and implications for chemical tagging
• CN Zeeman and dust polarization in a high-mass cold clump
• Multi-scale dynamics in star-forming regions: the interplay between gravity and turbulence
• On the spatial distributions of dense cores in Orion B
• KFPA Examinations of Young STellar Object Natal Environments (KEYSTONE): Hierarchical Ammonia Structures in Galactic Giant Molecular Clouds
• The SQUALO project (Star formation in QUiescent And Luminous Objects) I: clump-fed accretion mechanism in high-mass star-forming objects
• The impact of cosmic rays on dynamical balance and disk-halo interaction in Lstar disk galaxies
• First ALMA maps of cosmic ray ionisation rate in high-mass star-forming regions
• ATOMS: ALMA Three-millimeter Observations of Massive Star-forming regions -- II. Compact objects in ACA observations and star formation scaling relations
• The Forgotten Quadrant Survey. ${}^{12}$CO and ${}^{13}$CO (1-0) survey of the Galactic Plane in the range 220°$<l<$240° -2.5°$<b<$0°
• Massive star cluster formation I. High star formation efficiency while resolving feedback of individual stars
• Star Formation Induced by Cloud-Cloud Collisions and Galactic Giant Molecular Cloud Evolution
• Origins of Scatter in the Relationship Between HCN 1-0 and Dense Gas Mass in the Galactic Center
• Simulations of the star-forming molecular gas in an interacting M51-like galaxy: cloud population statistics
• ATLASGAL - Ammonia observations towards the southern Galactic Plane
• ATOMS: ALMA Three-millimeter Observations of Massive Star-forming regions -- XII: Fragmentation and multi-scale gas kinematics in protoclusters G12.42+0.50 and G19.88-0.53
• Was Planet 9 captured in the Sun's natal star-forming region?
• Thermal balance and comparison of gas and dust properties of dense clumps in the Hi-GAL survey
• The properties of Planck Galactic cold clumps in the L1495 dark cloud
• ALMA Survey of Orion Planck Galactic Cold Clumps (ALMASOP): Detection of extremely high density compact structure of prestellar cores and multiple substructures within
• CMZoom II: Catalog of Compact Submillimeter Dust Continuum Sources in the Milky Way's Central Molecular Zone
• Surveying the Giant HII Regions of the Milky Way with SOFIA: I. W51A
• Cloud Properties and Correlations with Star Formation in Numerical Simulations of the Three-Phase ISM
• The Green Bank Ammonia Survey: Observations of Hierarchical Dense Gas Structures in Cepheus-L1251
• Molecular Clouds in the Second Quadrant of the Milky Way Mid-plane from l$=$104$.{}^{\circ }$75 to l=119$.{}^{\circ }$75 and b=$-$5$.{}^{\circ }$25 to b=5$.{}^{\circ }$25
• Molecular clouds and star formation toward the Galactic plane within 216.25${}^{\mathrm{o}}\le$ l $\le$218.75${}^{\mathrm{o}}$ and $-$0.75${}^{\mathrm{o}}\le$ b $\le$1.25${}^{\mathrm{o}}$
• Criteria for gravitational instability and quasi-isolated gravitational collapse in turbulent medium
• Microwave Continuum Emission and Dense Gas Tracers in NGC 3627: Combining Jansky VLA and ALMA Observations
• Are massive dense clumps truly sub-virial? A new analysis using Gould Belt ammonia data
• The evolution of temperature and density structures of OB cluster-forming molecular clumps
• What is the physics behind the Larson mass-size relation?
• Early-Forming Massive Stars Suppress Star Formation and Hierarchical Cluster Assembly
• Fragmentation and Kinematics of dense molecular cores in the filamentary infrared-dark cloud G011.11-0.12
• The role of the turbulence driving mode for the Initial Mass Function
• A possible observational bias in the estimation of the virial parameter in virialized clumps
• Comparing Models for IMF Variation Across Cosmological Time in Milky Way-like Galaxies
• The Nuclear Region of NGC1365: Star Formation, Negative Feedback, and Outflow Structure
• Surveying the Giant HII Regions of the Milky Way with SOFIA: II. M17
• Early Evolution and 3D Structure of Embedded Star Clusters
• The Galactic Census of High- and Medium-mass Protostars. III ${}^{12}$CO Maps and Physical Properties of Dense Clump Envelopes and their Embedding GMCs
• Implementation of stellar heating feedback in simulations of star cluster formation: effects on the initial mass function
• Galactic cold cores IX. Column density structures and radiative transfer modelling
• CARMA Large Area Star Formation Survey: Dense Gas in the Young L1451 Region of Perseus
• The dynamic centres of infrared-dark clouds and the formation of cores
• A Low-mass Cold and Quiescent Core Population in a Massive Star Protocluster
• Simultaneous evolution of the virial parameter and star formation rate in molecular clumps undergoing global hierarchical collapse
• The straight and isolated G350.54+0.69 filament: density profile and star formation content
• ATLASGAL -- physical parameters of dust clumps associated with 6.7 GHz methanol masers
• Molecular Emission in Dense Massive Clumps from the Star-Forming Regions S231-S235
• Anchoring Magnetic Fields in Turbulent Molecular Clouds II - from 0.1 to 0.01 parsec
• Simultaneous Survey of Water and Class I Methanol Masers toward Red MSX Sources
• Fast deuterium fractionation in magnetized and turbulent filaments
• Contraction Signatures Toward Dense Cores in the Perseus Molecular Cloud
• The role of turbulence, magnetic fields and feedback for star formation
• CARMA-NRO Orion Survey: unbiased survey of dense cores and core mass functions in Orion A
• Infrared dark clouds on the far side of the Galaxy
• Multiscale Dynamical Scenario of High-mass Star Formation in an IRDC Filament G34
• ATLASGAL -- Relationship between dense star forming clumps and interstellar masers
• ALMA ACA and Nobeyama observations of two Orion cores in deuterated molecular lines
• The molecular gas resolved by ALMA in the low-metallicity dwarf merging galaxy Haro 11
• Merger-induced star formation in low-metallicity dwarf galaxy NGC 4809/4810
• G-virial: Gravity-based structure analysis of molecular clouds
• Spatially associated clump populations in Rosette from CO and dust maps
• The TOPGöt high-mass star-forming sample. I. Methyl cyanide emission as tracer of early phases of star formation
• Evolution of the angular momentum during gravitational fragmentation of molecular clouds
• Identification of molecular clouds in emission maps: a comparison between methods in the \ce{^{13}CO}/\ce{C^{18}O} ($J=3-2$) Heterodyne Inner Milky Way Plane Survey
• High resolution LAsMA ${}^{12}$CO and ${}^{13}$CO observation of the G305 giant molecular cloud complex : II. Effect of feedback on clump properties
• Spinning Bar and a Star-formation Inefficient Repertoire: Turbulence in Hickson Compact Group NGC7674
• The Green Bank Ammonia Survey: Unveiling the Dynamics of the Barnard 59 star-forming Clump
• High-resolution APEX/LAsMA ${}^{12}$CO and ${}^{13}$CO (3-2) observation of the G333 giant molecular cloud complex : II. Survival and gravitational collapse of dense gas structures under feedback
• Molecular Clump Extraction Algorithm Based on Local Density Clustering
• Tracing the general structure of Galactic molecular clouds using Planck data: I. The Perseus region as a test case
• A Large-field J=1-0 Survey of CO and Its Isotopologues Toward the Cassiopeia A Supernova Remnant
• Cloud properties across spatial scales in simulations of the interstellar medium
• Magnetic Field of Molecular Gas Measured with the Velocity Gradient Technique I. Orion A
• The Column Density Structure of Orion A Depicted by N-PDF
• Extremely Energetic Outflow and Decelerated Expansion in W49N
• Probing the initial conditions of high-mass star formation. III. Fragmentation and triggered star formation
• High-Mass Starless Clumps: Dynamical State and Correlation Between Physical Parameters
• Spiral Structure and Massive Star formation in the Hub-Filament-System G326.27-0.49
• Distributions and Physical Properties of Molecular Clouds in the Third Galactic Quadrant: $l$ = [219.75, 229.75]${}^{\circ }$ and $b$ = [-5.25, 5.25]${}^{\circ }$
• Effects of stellar feedback on cores in STARFORGE
• The RMS Survey: Ammonia mapping of the environment of young massive stellar objects II
• Study of the filamentary infrared dark cloud G192.76+00.10 in the S254-S258 OB complex
• The kinetic and magnetic energy budget of hub-filament systems during the gravitational fragmentation of molecular clouds
• The Cassiopeia Filament: A Blown Spur of the Local Arm
• Sequential Star Formation in the Young SMC Region NGC 602: Insights from ALMA
• Star Formation in Extreme Environments: A 200 pc High Velocity Gas Stream in the Galactic Centre
• Emergence of high-mass stars in complex fiber networks (EMERGE) V. From filaments to spheroids: the origin of the hub-filament systems
• A Cold and Diffuse Giant Molecular Filament in the Region of $l=41^{\circ }$, $b=-1^{\circ }$
• On the thermal structure of the proto-Super Star Cluster 13 in NGC 253
• Dense Molecular Cores Being Externally Heated
• Galatic HII region IRAS 17149$-$3916 -- A multiwavelength study
• The influence of the cloud virial parameter on the initial mass function
• Planck Galactic Cold Clumps at High Galactic Latitude-A Study with CO Lines
• Chemical exploration of Galactic cold cores
• Star formation timescale in the molecular filament WB 673
• A multi-line study of the filamentary infrared dark cloud G351.78-0.54
• Multiwavelength study of the G345.5+1.5 region
• Inadequate turbulent support in low-metallicity molecular clouds
• Star formation in IRDC G31.97+0.07
• Studying the chemical and kinematical structures of dense cores TMC-1C, L1544, and TMC-1 in the Taurus molecular cloud using the CCS and NH3 observations
• Interaction between the Supernova Remnant W44 and the Infrared Dark Cloud G034.77-00.55: shock induced star formation?
• Very Large Array Ammonia Observations of the HH 111/HH 121 Protostellar System: a Detection of a New Source With a Peculiar Chemistry
• Planck Galactic Cold Clumps in Two Regions: the First Quadrant and the Anti-Center Direction Region
• Star and Cluster Formation in the Sh2-112 Filamentary Cloud Complex
• Comparing binary systems from rotating parent gas structures with different total masses
• Virial Ratio: Direct Evaluation from Molecular Cloud Data and the Challenges of Improving Accuracy
• Turbulence and its connection to episodic accretion in binary YSOs
• Wide-binary eccentricity distribution in young star clusters: dependence on the binary separation and mass
• CLOVER: Convnet Line-fitting Of Velocities in Emission-line Regions
• Effects of CO-dark Gas on Measurements of Molecular Cloud Stability and the Size-Linewidth Relationship
• Sequential Star Formation in the filamentary structures of Planck Galactic cold clump G181.84+0.31
• Fragmented atomic shell around S187 HII region and its interaction with molecular and ionized gas
• ALMA Survey of Orion Planck Galactic Cold Clumps (ALMASOP): A forming quadruple system with continuum `ribbons' and intricate outflows
• Shear-gravity transition determines the steep velocity dispersion-size relation in molecular clouds: confronting analytical formula with observations
• Molecular gas and star formation in central rings across nearby galaxies
• Investigating physical states of molecular gas in the overlapping region of interacting galaxies NGC4567/4568 using ALMA
• When did the initial mass function become bottom-heavy?
• Which Molecular Cloud Structures Are Bound?
• Star formation in cloud cores -- simulations and observations of dense molecular cores and the formation of solar mass stars
• Empirical formulae to describe some physical properties of small groups of protogalaxies with multiplicity
• Star Formation in the Galactic Center
• Unveiling Fiber Networks and Core Formation in the DR21 South Filament
• The effects of a compressive velocity pulse on a collapsing turbulent clump
• The interdependence between density PDF, CMF and IMF and their relation with Mach number in simulations
• Why most molecular clouds are gravitationally dominated
• ALMAGAL VIII. Early phases of triggered star formation in source AG286.0716$-$1.8229
• Simulations of un-equal binary collisions embedded in a turbulent gas cloud far away of a massive gravitational center
• ATOMS: ALMA Three-millimeter Observations of Massive Star-forming regions -- V. Hierarchical fragmentation and gas dynamics in IRDC G034.43+00.24
• The dominance of turbulence over magnetism in the formation of massive star cluster seeds
• Molecular Clouds at the Edge of the Galaxy II. Physical properties and scaling relations