Colloquium: Artificial spin ice: Designing and imaging magnetic frustration
arXiv:1306.0825 · doi:10.1103/RevModPhys.85.1473
Abstract
Frustration in the presence of competing interactions is ubiquitous in the physical sciences and is a source of degeneracy and disorder, giving rise to new and interesting physical phenomena. Perhaps nowhere does it occur more simply than in correlated spin systems, where it has been studied in the most detail. In the past few years, a new perspective has opened in the study of frustration through the creation of artificial frustrated magnetic systems. These materials consist of arrays of lithographically fabricated single-domain ferromagnetic nanostructures that behave like giant Ising spins. The nanostructures' interactions can be controlled through appropriate choices of their geometric properties and arrangement on a (frustrated) lattice. The degrees of freedom of the material can not only be directly tuned, but also individually observed. Experimental studies have unearthed intriguing connections to the out-of-equilibrium physics of disordered systems and non-thermal granular materials, while revealing strong analogies to (spin) ice materials and their fractionalized magnetic monopole excitations, lending the enterprise a distinctly interdisciplinary flavor. The experimental results have also been closely coupled to theoretical and computational analyses, facilitated by connections to classic models of frustrated magnetism, whose hitherto unobserved aspects have here found an experimental realization. We review the considerable experimental and theoretical progress in this field, including connections to other frustrated phenomena, and we outline future vistas for progress in this rapidly expanding field.
Review Article, 36 Pages, 14 Figures. To appear in Rev. Mod. Phys
References in corpus (18)
- Artificial "spin ice" in a geometrically frustrated lattice of nanoscale ferromagnetic islands
- Dirac Strings and Magnetic Monopoles in Spin Ice Dy2Ti2O7
- Direct observation of the ice rule in artificial kagome spin ice
- Geometric Frustration in Buckled Colloidal Monolayers
- Artificial square ice and related dipolar nanoarrays
- Why spin ice obeys the ice rules
- Observation of Magnetic Monopoles in Spin Ice
- Theory of the [111] magnetization plateau in spin ice
- Artificial Kagome Arrays of Nanomagnets: A Frozen Dipolar Spin Ice
- Ground state lost but degeneracy found: the effective thermodynamics of artificial spin ice
- Energy minimization and AC demagnetization in a nanomagnet array
- Realizing Colloidal Artificial Ice on Arrays of Optical Traps
- Magnetic monopole and string excitations in a two-dimensional spin ice
- Direct entropy determination and application to artificial spin ice
- Vertex dynamics in finite two dimensional square spin ices
- Comparing artificial frustrated magnets: tuning symmetry in nanomagnet arrays
- Effective temperatures and activated dynamics for a two-dimensional air-driven granular system on two approaches to jamming
- Tuning magnetic frustration of nanomagnets in triangular-lattice geometry
Cited by in corpus (261)
- Artificial flat band systems: from lattice models to experiments
- Roadmap on Spin-Wave Computing
- Combinatorial Design of Textured Mechanical Metamaterials
- Quantum phases driven by strong correlations
- Extensive degeneracy, Coulomb phase and magnetic monopoles in an artificial realization of the square ice model
- Rewritable Artificial Magnetic Charge Ice
- Fragmentation of magnetism in artificial kagome dipolar spin ice
- Quantum Spin Ice and dimer models with Rydberg atoms
- Direct-write of free-form 3D nanostructures with controlled magnetic frustration
- Realization of the kagome spin ice state in a frustrated intermetallic compound
- The Theory of Spin Noise Spectroscopy: A Review
- Chirality as Generalized Spin-Orbit Interaction in Spintronics
- Dynamic response of an artificial square spin ice
- Engineering of frustration in colloidal artificial ices realized on microfeatured grooved lattices
- The frustrated brain: From dynamics on motifs to communities and networks
- Reconfigurable spin wave band structure of artificial square spin ice
- Tenth-order high-temperature expansion for the susceptibility and the specific heat of spin-s Heisenberg models with arbitrary exchange patterns: Application to pyrochlore and kagome magnets
- Ice Rule and Emergent Frustration in Particle Ice and Beyond
- Analog quantum control of magnonic cat states on-a-chip by a superconducting qubit
- Ferromagnetism and Wigner crystallization in Kagome graphene and related structures
- Magnetic Charge Propagation upon a 3D Artificial Spin-ice
- Quantum materials for energy-efficient neuromorphic computing
- Sub-100 nm Skyrmions at Zero Magnetic Field in Ir/Fe/Co/Pt Nanostructures
- Topological defects produce exotic mechanics in complex metamaterials
- Switchable geometric frustration in an artificial-spin-ice-superconductor hetero-system
- Holographic Vector Field Electron Tomography of Three-Dimensional Nanomagnets
- Carbon Kagome lattice and orbital frustration-induced metal-insulator transition for optoelectronics
- Frustration and thermalisation in an artificial magnetic quasicrystal
- Magnetization Dynamics of Topological Defects and the Spin Solid in Kagome Artificial Spin Ice
- Orientationally Glassy Crystals of Janus Spheres
- Incompressible polaritons in a flat band
- Qubit spin ice
- Spintronics on Chiral Objects
- FePd as a material for thermally active artificial spin ice
- Continuous magnetic phase transition in artificial square ice
- Sculpting the Spin-Wave Response of Artificial Spin Ice via Microstate Selection
- Direct Visualization of Memory Effects in Artificial Spin Ice
- Experimental signatures of quantum and topological states in frustrated magnetism
- Spin-state ice in geometrically frustrated spin-crossover materials
- Semi-classical spin dynamics of the antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model on the kagome lattice
- Vogel-Fulcher-Tammann Freezing of a Thermally Fluctuating Artificial Spin Ice Probed by X-ray Photon Correlation Spectroscopy
- Emergent Disorder and Mechanical Memory in Periodic Metamaterials
- Realizing three-dimensional artificial spin ice by stacking planar nanoarrays
- Magnetic diffuse scattering in artificial kagome spin ice
- Skyrmion Spin Ice in Liquid Crystals
- A new look on the two-dimensional Ising model: thermal artificial spins
- Synthetic chiral magnets promoted by the Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction
- Topologically non-trivial magnon bands in artificial square spin ices subject to Dzyaloshinskii-Moriya interaction
- Kinetic pathways to the magnetic charge crystal in artificial dipolar spin ice
- Emergent Geometric Frustration of Artificial Magnetic Skyrmion Crystals
- Classical dipoles on the kagome lattice
- Hexagonal Plaquette Spin-spin Interactions and Quantum Magnetism in a Two-dimensional Ion Crystal
- Understanding magnetotransport signatures in networks of connected permalloy nanowires
- High frequency dynamics modulated by collective magnetization reversal in artificial spin ice
- Ground-State Candidate for the Dipolar Kagome Ising Antiferromagnet
- Defect Dynamics in Artificial Colloidal Ice: Real-Time Observation, Manipulation and Logic Gate
- Logical gates embedding in Artificial Spin Ice
- When opposites repel: from metastability to extended chiral spin textures in spin ice with short-range topological-defect interactions
- Ice Rule Fragility via Topological Charge Transfer in Artificial Colloidal Ice
- Tunable non-equilibrium dynamics: field quenches in spin ice
- Switchable X-ray Orbital Angular Momentum from an Artificial Spin Ice
- Infinite Geometric Frustration in a Cubic Dipole Cluster
- Probing photon correlations in the dark sites of geometrically frustrated cavity lattices
- Order-by-disorder and quantum Coulomb phase in quantum square ice
- Dynamic quantum kagome ice
- Observation of Giant Orbital Magnetic Moments and Paramagnetic Shift in Artificial Relativistic Atoms and Molecules
- Geometric Frustration of Colloidal Dimers on a Honeycomb Magnetic Lattice
- Magnetic force microscopy investigation of arrays of nickel nanowires and nanotubes
- Thermally and field-driven mobility of emergent magnetic charges in square artificial spin ice
- Commensurate States and Pattern Switching via Liquid Crystal Skyrmions Trapped in a Square Lattice
- Competing interactions in artificial spin chains
- The Inner Phases of Colloidal Hexagonal Ice
- Angular Dependent Magnetization Dynamics of Kagome Artificial Spin Ice Incorporating Topological Defects
- Realization of Rectangular Artificial Spin Ice and Direct Observation of High Energy Topology
- Angular Dependent Magnetization Dynamics with Mirror-symmetric Excitations in Artificial Quasicrystalline Nanomagnet Lattices
- Crystallizing Kagome artificial spin ice
- Hybrid Architecture for Engineering Magnonic Quantum Networks
- Quantum domain walls induce incommensurate supersolid phase on the anisotropic triangular lattice
- Few-body systems capture many-body physics: tensor network approach
- Ultrasonic investigations of spin-ices DyTiO and HoTiO in and out of equilibrium
- Low-temperature transport properties of intermetallic compound HoAgGe with kagome spin ice state
- Selective and Fast Plasmon-Assisted Photo-Heating of Nanomagnets; A New Route for Opto-Activated Nanomagnetic Logic and Artificial Spin Systems
- Unexpected Phenomenology in Particle-Based Ice Absent in Magnetic Spin Ice
- Magnetic order and energy-scale hierarchy in artificial spin ice
- Dumping Topological Charges on Neighbors: Ice Manifolds for Colloids and Vortices
- Dependence of energy barrier reduction on collective excitations in square artificial spin ice: A comprehensive comparison of simulation techniques
- Electrodynamics of quantum spin liquids
- Artificial spin ice and vertex models
- Response evolution of mechanical metamaterials under architectural transformations
- Proposal to recover an extensive ground state degeneracy in a two-dimensional square array of nanomagnets
- Avalanches and disorder-induced criticality in artificial spin ices
- Dipolar spin-misalignment correlations in inhomogeneous magnets: comparison between neutron scattering and micromagnetic approaches
- Monopole holes in a partially ordered spin liquid
- Effect of long-and short-range interactions on the thermodynamics of dipolar spin ice
- Quantum Spin Liquid State in the Disordered Triangular Lattice Sc2Ga2CuO7
- Higher order spin noise spectroscopy of atomic spins in fluctuating external fields
- Switchable Magnetic Frustration in Buckyball Nanoarchitectures
- Magnetic structure of the promising candidate for three-dimensional artificial spin ice: small angle neutron diffraction and micromagnetic simulations
- Boron Triangular Kagome Lattice with Half-Metallic Ferromagnetism
- Artificial out-of-plane Ising antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice with very small further neighbour couplings
- Control of spin dynamics in artificial honeycomb spin-ice-based nanodisks
- Emergence of string-valence bond solid state in the frustrated transverse field Ising model on the square lattice
- A driven-dissipative spin chain model based on exciton-polariton condensates
- Supercooling and fragile glassiness in a dipolar kagome Ising magnet
- Non-monotonic effect of confinement on the glass transition
- The pyrochlore Ho2Ti2O7: Synthesis, crystal growth and stoichiometry
- Theory of magnetotransport in artificial kagome spin ice
- Quenched Dynamics of Artificial Spin Ice: Coarsening versus Kibble-Zurek
- Reentrance of disorder in the anisotropic shuriken Ising model
- Coupled spin-charge order in frustrated itinerant triangular magnets
- Motility Induced Phase Separation and Frustration in Active Matter Swarmalators
- Tension-free Dirac strings and steered magnetic charges in 3D artificial spin ice
- Effect of FePd alloy composition on the dynamics of artificial spin ice
- Local Photothermal Control of Phase Transitions for On-demand Room-temperature Rewritable Magnetic Patterning
- Spin-liquid behaviour and the interplay between Pokrovsky-Talapov and Ising criticality in the distorted, triangular-lattice, dipolar Ising antiferromagnet
- Artificial Spin Ice Phase-Change Memory Resistors
- Mott transition and Antiferromagnetic Metal on Shastry-Sutherland Lattice
- Chiral switching and dynamic barrier reductions in artificial square ice
- Tunable artificial vortex ice in nanostructured superconductors with frustrated kagome lattice of paired antidots
- Dynamic Control of Topological Defects in Artificial Colloidal Ice
- Field-tunable interactions and frustration in underlayer-mediated artificial spin ice
- Designing hysteresis with dipolar chains
- Topologically Protected Steady Cycles in an Ice-Like Mechanical Metamaterial
- Magnetization Dynamics of Fibonacci-Distorted Kagome Artificial Spin Ice
- Doped Colloidal Artificial Ice
- Quantum spin ice in three-dimensional Rydberg atom arrays
- Heisenberg pseudo-exchange and emergent anisotropies in field-driven pinwheel artificial spin ice
- Classical topological order of the Rys F-model and its breakdown in realistic spin ice: Topological sectors of Faraday loops
- Collective magnetic dynamics in artificial spin ice probed by AC susceptibility
- Topology Restricts Quasidegeneracy in Sheared Square Colloidal Ice
- Electrically programmable magnetic coupling in an Ising network exploiting solid-state ionic gating
- Temperature Dependent Magnetism in Artificial Honeycomb Lattice of Connected Elements
- Characterization of switching field distributions in Ising-like magnetic arrays
- Spin Solid versus Magnetic Charge Ordered State in Artificial Honeycomb Lattice of Connected Elements
- Magnetic oscillation modes in square lattice artificial spin ice
- The Colored Noise of Magnetic Monopoles: Subdiffusion in a Coevolving Vacuum and Spin Ice Exponents
- Nanostructured complex oxides as a route towards thermal behavior in artificial spin ice systems
- Signatures of long range dipolar interactions in artificial square ice
- A numerical study of the F-model with domain-wall boundaries
- Multicanonical Sampling of the Space of States of H(2,n)-Vector Models
- Superconducting qubit circuit emulation of a vector spin-1/2
- Fragmented spin ice and multi- ordering in rare-earth antiperovskites
- Topologically protected superconducting ratchet effect generated by spin-ice nanomagnets
- The effect of confinement on thermally induced fluctuations in nanomagnets
- Vortex Lattices in Active Nematics with Periodic Obstacle Arrays
- Attraction Controls the Inversion of Order by Disorder
- Dynamic dependence to domain wall propagation through artificial spin ice
- Artificial Spin Ice: A Tutorial on Design and Control of Geometry, Microstate, Magnon Dynamics & Neuromorphic Computing
- Magnetic State Selected by Magnetic Dipole Interaction in Kagome Antiferromagnet NaBaMnF
- Toroidic phase transitions in a direct-kagome artificial spin ice
- Stable and unstable trajectories in a dipolar chain
- Putting a spin on metamaterials: Mechanical incompatibility as magnetic frustration
- Vertex Dependent Dynamic Response of a Connected Kagome Artificial Spin Ice
- Phase diagram of dipolar-coupled XY moments on disordered square lattices
- Ice, glass, and solid phases in artificial spin systems with quenched disorder
- Competing orders for the colloidal kagome ice: the importance of in-trap motion of the particles
- A Self-Adaptive First-Principles Approach for Magnetic Excited States
- Stability of Skyrmion Crystal Phase in Centrosymmetric Distorted Triangular-Lattice Antiferromagnets
- Spin-phonon induced magnetic order in Kagome ice
- Topological Boundary Constraints in Artificial Colloidal Ice
- Quantum phase diagram of two-dimensional transverse field Ising model: unconstrained tree tensor network and mapping analysis
- Voltage Control of Magnetic Monopoles in Artificial Spin Ice
- Continuous ground-state degeneracy of classical dipoles on regular lattices
- Accessing low-energy magnetic microstates in symmetry-broken isolated square artificial spin ice vertices with magnetic field
- Temperature induced collapse of spin dimensionality in magnetic metamaterials
- Violation of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem and effective temperatures in spin ice
- Writable spin wave nanochannels in an artificial-spin-ice-mediated ferromagnetic thin film
- Optimal control of magnetization reversal in a monodomain particle by means of applied magnetic field
- Magnetization dynamics of weakly interacting sub-100 nm square artificial spin ices
- Naked-eye visualization of geometric frustration effects in macroscopic spin ices
- Equilibrium Field Theory of Magnetic Monopoles in Degenerate Square Spin Ice: Correlations, Entropic Interactions, and Charge Screening Regimes
- Nonlinearity and Topology
- Stabilization of a Majorana Zero Mode through Quantum Frustration
- Mean-field phase diagram and spin glass phase of the dipolar Kagome Ising antiferromagnet
- Complex Magnetic Order in a Decorated Spin Chain System RbMn(MoO)(OH)
- Bilayer artificial spin ice: magnetic force switching and basic thermodynamics
- The Concept of Spin Ice Graphs and a Field Theory for their Topological Monopoles and Charges
- Spin-Induced Orbital Frustration in a Hexagonal Optical Lattice
- New Description of Evolution of Magnetic Phases in Artificial Honeycomb Lattice
- Frustration Elimination and Excited State Search in Coherent Ising Machines
- Hybrid Dyons, inverted Lorentz force and magnetic Nernst effect in quantum spin ice
- Magnetic diode at = 300 K
- Thermal excitations within and among mesospins in artificial spin ice
- Orientation-dependent stabilization of MgCrO spinel thin films
- Modal frustration and periodicity breaking in artificial spin ice
- Local excitation of kagome spin ice magnetism in HoAgGe seen by scanning tunneling microscopy
- Angular-Dependent Dynamic Response and Magnetization Reversal in Fibonacci-Distorted, Kagome Artificial Spin Ice
- Magnetization reversal of dipolar coupled nanomagnets studied by two-dimensional electron gas based micro-Hall magnetometry
- Intermediate phase and pseudo phase transition in an artificial spin ice model
- A three-state model with competing antiferromagnetic and pairing interactions
- On the robustness of strongly correlated multi-photon states in frustrated driven-dissipative cavity lattices
- Classical topological paramagnetism
- Synchronization transition in the double dimer model on the cubic lattice
- Controlled creation and annihilation of stringless robust emergent magnetic monopoles in artificial spin ice
- On the Degeneracy of Spin Ice Graphs, and its Estimate via the Bethe Permanent
- 2-Form U(1) Spin Liquids: Classical Model and Quantum Aspects
- Fingerprints of a charge ice state in the doped Mott insulator NbCl
- Magnetization Dynamics in Quasiperiodic Magnonic Crystals
- Long-range Ising spins models emerging from frustrated Josephson junctions arrays with topological constraints
- Tailoring magnetization reversal of a single-domain bar nanomagnet via its end geometry
- Ferromagnetic resonance in 3D-tilted square artificial spin ices
- Experimental Measures of Topological Sector Fluctuations in the F-Model
- A model for the Mediated Artificial Square Ice phenomenology
- Metastability and dynamics in remanent states of square artificial spin ice with long-range dipole interactions
- Quantum disordered state of magnetic charges in nanoengineered honeycomb lattice
- Metastability and dynamic modes in magnetic island chains
- RKKY plateau in zero- and one-dimensional triangular Kagome lattice models
- Neutron scattering from fragmented frustrated magnets
- Field-induced antiferromagnetic correlations in a nanopatterned van der Waals ferromagnet: a potential artificial spin ice
- Reduction of energy cost of magnetization switching in a biaxial nanoparticle by use of internal dynamics
- A Critical Edge Number Revealed for Phase Stabilities of Two-Dimensional Ball-Stick Polygons
- Persistent dynamic magnetic state in artificial honeycomb spin ice
- Time scales in the thermal dynamics of magnetic dipolar clusters
- Active Rheology and Anti-Commensuration Effects For Driven Probe Particles on Two Dimensional Periodic Pinning Substrates
- Energetic analysis of disorder effects in an artificial spin ice with dipolar interactions
- Symmetry, Superposition and Fragmentation in Classical Spin Liquids: A General Framework and Applications to Square Kagome Magnets
- Probing topological properties of 3D lattice dimer model with neural networks
- Some exactly solvable and tunable frustrated spin models
- Hopfions in lattice dimer model
- Multistable polar textures in geometrically frustrated nematic liquid crystals
- Topology by Design in Magnetic nano-Materials: Artificial Spin Ice
- Relaxation pathways and emergence of domains in square artificial spin ice
- Breaking Mechanical Holography in Combinatorial Metamaterials
- Gauge-Free Duality in Pure Square Spin Ice: Topological Currents and Monopoles
- Vortex Ordering and Dynamics on Santa Fe Artificial Ice Pinning Arrays
- Topological Aspects of Antiferromagnets
- Frustrated mixed-spin ladders: Evidence for a bond order wave phase between rung-singlet and Haldane phases
- Magnetic charge's relaxation propelled electricity in two-dimensional magnetic honeycomb lattice
- Thermal Conductivity of Square Ice
- Emergent tri-criticality in magnetic metamaterials
- Crystalline phases and devil's staircase in qubit spin ice
- Critical behavior of the 2D Ising model modulated by the Octonacci sequence
- Defect-sensitive High-frequency Modes in a Three-Dimensional Artificial Magnetic Crystal
- Transverse magnetic field effects on metastable states of magnetic island chains
- The design, verification, and applications of Hotspice: a Monte Carlo simulator for artificial spin ice
- Square ice Coulomb phase as a percolated vertex lattice
- Scaling of nonlinear susceptibilities in artificial permalloy honeycomb lattice
- Fractional diffusion without disorder in two dimensions
- Symmetrizing the Constraints -- Density Matrix Renormalization Group for Constrained Lattice Models
- Perpendicular-anisotropy artificial spin ice with spontaneous ordering: a platform for neuromorphic computing with flexible timescales
- Sub-tesla on-chip nanomagnetic metamaterial platform for angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy
- Spin-ice behavior of three-dimensional inverse opal-like magnetic structures: micromagnetic simulations
- Deconfinement of electric charges in hydrogen-bonded ferroelectrics
- Local spin ice order induced planar Hall effect in Nd-Sn artificial honeycomb lattice
- Fractional electrical dimensionality in the spin solid phase of artificial honeycomb lattice
- Nonequilibrium generation of charge defects in kagome spin ice under slow cooling
- Textured heterogeneity in square artificial spin ice
- State transitions and hysteresis in a transverse magnetic island chain
- Emergent criticality in a constrained boson model
- Fractional Wannier Orbitals and Tight-Binding Gauge Fields for Kitaev Honeycomb Superlattices with Flat Majorana Bands
- Ice on curved surfaces: defect rings and differential local dynamics
- Controlling degeneracy and magnetization switching in an artificial spin ice system of peanut-shaped nanomagnets
- Doped resonating-valence-bond states: Robustness of the spin-ice phases in three-dimensional Rydberg arrays
- Phase transitions and crtical exponents in the six-vertex model on kagome lattices
- Realization of macroscopic ratchet effect based on nonperiodic and uneven potentials
- Long-Range Magnetic Order in Structurally Embedded Mesospin Metamaterials
- Direct Imaging of Complex Spin Ice Behavior and Ordered Sublattices in Artificial Ferromagnetic Quasicrystals
- Phase-space networks and connectivity of the kagome antiferromagnet
- Computational Frameworks for Patterned Two-Dimensional Magnetism
- Interlayer charge transfer from contact electrification in conducting micro and nanoscale thin film heterostructures
- Observation of Magnetic Devil's Staircase-Like Behavior in Quasiperiodic Qubit Lattices