TDCOSMO. IX. Systematic comparison between lens modelling software programs: time delay prediction for WGD 2038-4008

Abstract

The importance of alternative methods for measuring the Hubble constant, such as time-delay cosmography, is highlighted by the recent Hubble tension. It is paramount to thoroughly investigate and rule out systematic biases in all measurement methods before we can accept new physics as the source of this tension. In this study, we perform a check for systematic biases in the lens modelling procedure of time-delay cosmography by comparing independent and blind time-delay predictions of the system WGD 2038-4008 from two teams using two different software programs: GLEE and LENSTRONOMY. The predicted time delays from the two teams incorporate the stellar kinematics of the deflector and the external convergence from line-of-sight structures. The un-blinded time-delay predictions from the two teams agree within $1.2\sigma$, implying that once the time delay is measured the inferred Hubble constant will also be mutually consistent. However, there is a $\sim$4$\sigma$ discrepancy between the power-law model slope and external shear, which is a significant discrepancy at the level of lens models before the stellar kinematics and the external convergence are incorporated. We identify the difference in the reconstructed point spread function (PSF) to be the source of this discrepancy. When the same reconstructed PSF was used by both teams, we achieved excellent agreement, within $\sim$0.6$\sigma$, indicating that potential systematics stemming from source reconstruction algorithms and investigator choices are well under control. We recommend that future studies supersample the PSF as needed and marginalize over multiple algorithms or realizations for the PSF reconstruction to mitigate the systematics associated with the PSF. A future study will measure the time delays of the system WGD 2038-4008 and infer the Hubble constant based on our mass models.

arXiv commentAccepted version by A&A. 34 pages, 26 figures, 3 tables

References in corpus (88)

• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• emcee: The MCMC Hammer
• Stellar population synthesis at the resolution of 2003
• A Universal Density Profile from Hierarchical Clustering
• The Structure of Cold Dark Matter Halos
• Simulating the joint evolution of quasars, galaxies and their large-scale distribution
• Binary companions of evolved stars in APOGEE DR14: Search method and catalog of ~5,000 companions
• Cosmological parameters from CMB and other data: a Monte-Carlo approach
• The Complete Light-curve Sample of Spectroscopically Confirmed Type Ia Supernovae from Pan-STARRS1 and Cosmological Constraints from The Combined Pantheon Sample
• A Comprehensive Measurement of the Local Value of the Hubble Constant with 1 km/s/Mpc Uncertainty from the Hubble Space Telescope and the SH0ES Team
• dynesty: A Dynamic Nested Sampling Package for Estimating Bayesian Posteriors and Evidences
• H0LiCOW XIII. A 2.4% measurement of $H_0$ from lensed quasars: $5.3\sigma$ tension between early and late-Universe probes
• Early Dark Energy Can Resolve The Hubble Tension
• The Carnegie-Chicago Hubble Program. VIII. An Independent Determination of the Hubble Constant Based on the Tip of the Red Giant Branch
• The Hubble Hunter's Guide
• The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: DR4 Maps and Cosmological Parameters
• A standard stellar library for evolutionary synthesis: II. The M dwarf extension
• Measurements of the Hubble Constant: Tensions in Perspective
• The Sloan Lens ACS Survey. I. A Large Spectroscopically Selected Sample of Massive Early-Type Lens Galaxies
• Efficient Multi-Gaussian Expansion of galaxies
• Structure and Kinematics of Early-Type Galaxies from Integral-Field Spectroscopy
• COLOSSUS: A python toolkit for cosmology, large-scale structure, and dark matter halos
• The Sloan Lens ACS Survey. IV: the mass density profile of early-type galaxies out to 100 effective radii
• H0LiCOW V. New COSMOGRAIL time delays of HE0435-1223: $H_0$ to 3.8% precision from strong lensing in a flat $\Lambda$CDM model
• Dissecting the Gravitational Lens B1608+656. II. Precision Measurements of the Hubble Constant, Spatial Curvature, and the Dark Energy Equation of State
• Calibration of the Tip of the Red Giant Branch (TRGB)
• H0LiCOW - IX. Cosmographic analysis of the doubly imaged quasar SDSS 1206+4332 and a new measurement of the Hubble constant
• TDCOSMO IV: Hierarchical time-delay cosmography -- joint inference of the Hubble constant and galaxy density profiles
• Two accurate time-delay distances from strong lensing: Implications for cosmology
• The Megamaser Cosmology Project. XIII. Combined Hubble constant constraints
• H0LiCOW I. $H_0$ Lenses in COSMOGRAIL's Wellspring: Program Overview
• Shapelets: I. A Method for Image Analysis
• Ray-tracing through the Millennium Simulation: Born corrections and lens-lens coupling in cosmic shear and galaxy-galaxy lensing
• Lenstronomy: multi-purpose gravitational lens modelling software package
• Dark matter in elliptical galaxies: II. Estimating the mass within the virial radius
• To H0 or not to H0?
• An accurate physical model for halo concentrations
• The Sloan-Lens ACS Survey II: stellar populations and internal structure of early-type lens galaxies
• A Bayesian analysis of regularised source inversions in gravitational lensing
• A SHARP view of H0LiCOW: $H_0$ from three time-delay gravitational lens systems with adaptive optics imaging
• STRIDES: a 3.9 per cent measurement of the Hubble constant from the strong lens system DES J0408-5354
• Time Delay Cosmography
• Cosmology from gravitational lens time delays and Planck data
• TDCOSMO. I. An exploration of systematic uncertainties in the inference of $H_0$ from time-delay cosmography
• H0LiCOW IV. Lens mass model of HE 0435-1223 and blind measurement of its time-delay distance for cosmology
• lenstronomy II: A gravitational lensing software ecosystem
• The Halos of Satellite Galaxies: the Companion of the Massive Elliptical Lens SL2S J08544-0121
• The Hubble Constant from Infrared Surface Brightness Fluctuation Distances
• Disentangling Baryons and Dark Matter in the Spiral Gravitational Lens B1933+503
• Gravitational lens modeling with basis sets
• Strong Lens Time Delay Challenge: II. Results of TDC1
• Fast calculation of a family of elliptical mass gravitational lens models
• Pseudo Elliptical Lensing Mass Model: Application to the NFW Mass Distribution
• Source-position transformation -- an approximate invariance in strong gravitational lensing
• Dark matter halos of massive elliptical galaxies at $z\sim 0.2$ are well described by the Navarro-Frenk-White profile
• Is every strong lens model unhappy in its own way? Uniform modelling of a sample of 13 quadruply+ imaged quasars
• The mass-sheet degeneracy and time-delay cosmography: Analysis of the strong lens RXJ1131-1231
• H0LiCOW III. Quantifying the effect of mass along the line of sight to the gravitational lens HE 0435-1223 through weighted galaxy counts
• H0LiCOW XII. Lens mass model of WFI2033-4723 and blind measurement of its time-delay distance and $H_0$
• COSMOGRAIL: the COSmological MOnitoring of GRAvItational Lenses I. How to sample the light curves of gravitationally lensed quasars to measure accurate time delays
• Cosmicflows-4: The Catalog of ~10000 Tully-Fisher Distances
• A 40-billion solar mass black hole in the extreme core of Holm 15A, the central galaxy of Abell 85
• Over-constrained Gravitational Lens Models and the Hubble Constant
• Improving the precision of time-delay cosmography with observations of galaxies along the line of sight
• The SWELLS survey. II. Breaking the disk-halo degeneracy in the spiral galaxy gravitational lens SDSS J2141-0001
• TDCOSMO V: strategies for precise and accurate measurements of the Hubble constant with strong lensing
• Improving time-delay cosmography with spatially resolved kinematics
• Time-delay Cosmography: Increased Leverage with Angular Diameter Distances
• DES meets Gaia: discovery of strongly lensed quasars from a multiplet search
• Time-delay cosmographic forecasts with strong lensing and JWST stellar kinematics
• SHARP - III: First Use Of Adaptive Optics Imaging To Constrain Cosmology With Gravitational Lens Time Delays
• Cosmography from two-image lens systems: overcoming the lens profile slope degeneracy
• Strong Lens Time Delay Challenge: I. Experimental Design
• Evidence for radial variations in the stellar mass-to-light ratio of massive galaxies from weak and strong lensing
• Time Delay Lens Modelling Challenge
• The Hubble constant from strongly lensed supernovae with standardizable magnifications
• TDCOSMO. VII. Boxyness/discyness in lensing galaxies : Detectability and impact on $H_0$
• TDCOSMO III: Dark matter substructure meets dark energy -- the effects of (sub)halos on strong-lensing measurements of $H_0$
• Astrometric requirements for strong lensing time-delay cosmography
• Gravitational lensing formalism in a curved arc basis: A continuous description of observables and degeneracies from the weak to the strong lensing regime
• Looking at the Fundamental Plane through a gravitational lens
• Consequences of the lack of azimuthal freedom in the modeling of lensing galaxies
• TDCOSMO VI: Distance Measurements in Time-delay Cosmography under the Mass-sheet transformation
• The quest for the largest depleted galaxy core: supermassive black hole binaries and stalled in-falling satellites
• STRIDES: Spectroscopic and photometric characterization of the environment and effects of mass along the line of sight to the gravitational lenses DES J0408-5354 and WGD 2038-4008
• The MASSIVE Survey XIII -- Spatially Resolved Stellar Kinematics in the Central 1 kpc of 20 Massive Elliptical Galaxies with the GMOS-North Integral-Field Spectrograph
• First black hole mass estimation for the quadruple lensed system WGD2038-4008
• The most massive galaxies with large depleted cores: structural parameter relations and black hole masses

Cited by in corpus (31)

• Strong lensing time-delay cosmography in the 2020s
• Cosmography with Supernova Refsdal through time-delay cluster lensing: independent measurements of the Hubble constant and geometry of the Universe
• Project Dinos I: A joint lensing-dynamics constraint on the deviation from the power law in the mass profile of massive ellipticals
• TDCOSMO 2025: Cosmological constraints from strong lensing time delays
• TDCOSMO X. Automated Modeling of 9 Strongly Lensed Quasars and Comparison Between Lens Modeling Software
• Using wavelets to capture deviations from smoothness in galaxy-scale strong lenses
• Strong Lensing by Galaxies
• LensWatch: I. Resolved HST Observations and Constraints on the Strongly-Lensed Type Ia Supernova 2022qmx ("SN Zwicky")
• TDCOSMO VIII: Cosmological distance measurements in light of the mass-sheet degeneracy -- forecasts from strong lensing and IFU stellar kinematics
• $\Lambda$CDM is alive and well
• Strong lensing constraints on primordial black holes as a dark matter candidate
• TDCOSMO. XVI. Measurement of the Hubble Constant from the Lensed Quasar WGD2038$-$4008
• HOLISMOKES -- IX. Neural network inference of strong-lens parameters and uncertainties from ground-based images
• HOLISMOKES -- X. Comparison between neural network and semi-automated traditional modeling of strong lenses
• TDCOSMO. XI. New lensing galaxy redshift and velocity dispersion measurements from Keck spectroscopy of eight lensed quasar systems
• TDCOSMO XIX. Measuring stellar velocity dispersion with sub-percent accuracy for cosmography
• Exploiting the diversity of modeling methods to probe systematic biases in strong lensing analyses
• Improved model of the Supernova Refsdal cluster MACS J1149.5+2223 thanks to VLT/MUSE
• HOLISMOKES XIII: Strong-lens candidates at all mass scales and their environments from the Hyper-Suprime Cam and deep learning
• Strong Lensing and $H_0$
• Constraining Cosmology with Double-source-plane Strong Gravitational Lenses from the AGEL Survey
• Elliptical multipoles for gravitational lenses
• TDCOSMO: XX. WFI2033--4723, the First Quadruply-Imaged Quasar Modeled with JWST Imaging
• TDCOSMO. XXIII. Measurement of the Hubble constant from the doubly lensed quasar HE1104-1805
• HOLISMOKES XVI: Lens search in HSC-PDR3 with a neural network committee and post-processing for false-positive removal
• Macromodel-free flux-ratio prediction in quadruply imaged quasars with local constraints from lensed arcs
• Investigating the relation between environment and internal structure of massive elliptical galaxies using strong lensing
• Time delay measurements with Broken Power Law model
• JAXtronomy: A JAX port of lenstronomy
• A Robust Bayesian Meta-Analysis for Estimating the Hubble Constant via Time Delay Cosmography
• Time Delay Cosmography: Analysis of Quadruply Lensed QSO SDSSJ1433 from Wendelstein Observatory