The mass-sheet degeneracy and time-delay cosmography: Analysis of the strong lens RXJ1131-1231

Abstract

We present extended modeling of the strong lens system RXJ1131-1231 with archival data in two HST bands in combination with existing line-of-sight contribution and velocity dispersion estimates. Our focus is on source size and its influence on time-delay cosmography. We therefore examine the impact of mass-sheet degeneracy and especially the degeneracy pointed out by Schneider & Sluse (2013) using the source reconstruction scale. We also extend on previous work by further exploring the effects of priors on the kinematics of the lens and the external convergence in the environment of the lensing system. Our results coming from RXJ1131-1231 are given in a simple analytic form so that they can be easily combined with constraints coming from other cosmological probes. We find that the choice of priors on lens model parameters and source size are subdominant for the statistical errors for $H_0$ measurements of this systems. The choice of prior for the source is sub-dominant at present (2% uncertainty on $H_0$) but may be relevant for future studies. More importantly, we find that the priors on the kinematic anisotropy of the lens galaxy have a significant impact on our cosmological inference. When incorporating all the above modeling uncertainties, we find $H_0=86.6_{-6.9}^{+6.8}$ km s${}^{-1}$Mpc${}^{-1}$, when using kinematic priors similar to other studies. When we use a different kinematic prior motivated by Barnabè et al. (2012) but covering the same anisotropic range, we find $H_0=74.5_{-7.8}^{+8.0}$ km s${}^{-1}$Mpc${}^{-1}$. This means that the choice of kinematic modeling and priors have a significant impact on cosmographic inferences. The way forward is either to get better velocity dispersion measures which would down weight the impact of the priors or to construct physically motivated priors for the velocity dispersion model.

arXiv comment25 (+8) pages, 12 figures, published in JCAP

References in corpus (44)

• Nine-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Parameter Results
• Cosmological parameters from CMB and other data: a Monte-Carlo approach
• Galaxy Luminosity Functions to z~1: DEEP2 vs. COMBO-17 and Implications for Red Galaxy Formation
• Dissecting the Gravitational Lens B1608+656. II. Precision Measurements of the Hubble Constant, Spatial Curvature, and the Dark Energy Equation of State
• Is There A Cosmological Constant?
• The Structure & Dynamics of Massive Early-type Galaxies: On Homology, Isothermality and Isotropy inside one Effective Radius
• Two accurate time-delay distances from strong lensing: Implications for cosmology
• Shapelets: I. A Method for Image Analysis
• Two-dimensional kinematics of SLACS lenses: III. Mass structure and dynamics of early-type lens galaxies beyond z ~ 0.1
• The Quadruple Gravitational Lens PG1115+080: Time Delays and Models
• Mass-sheet degeneracy, power-law models and external convergence: Impact on the determination of the Hubble constant from gravitational lensing
• Cosmology from gravitational lens time delays and Planck data
• What Do Gravitational Lens Time Delays Measure?
• Gravitational Lens Time Delays: A Statistical Assessment of Lens Model Dependences and Implications for the Global Hubble Constant
• Gravitational lens modeling with basis sets
• The Hubble Constant from the Gravitational Lens B1608+656
• Fast calculation of a family of elliptical mass gravitational lens models
• COSMOGRAIL: the COSmological MOnitoring of GRAvItational Lenses XIII: Time delays and 9-yr optical monitoring of the lensed quasar RX J1131-1231
• Source-position transformation -- an approximate invariance in strong gravitational lensing
• COSMOGRAIL: the COSmological MOnitoring of GRAvItational Lenses XI. Techniques for time delay measurement in presence of microlensing
• A quadruply imaged quasar with an optical Einstein ring candidate: 1RXS J113155.4-123155
• Lensing Degeneracies Revisited
• COSMOGRAIL: the COSmological MOnitoring of GRAvItational Lenses IX. Time delays, lens dynamics and baryonic fraction in HE 0435-1223
• COSMOGRAIL: the COSmological MOnitoring of GRAvItational Lenses I. How to sample the light curves of gravitationally lensed quasars to measure accurate time delays
• The SWELLS survey. IV. Precision measurements of the stellar and dark matter distributions in a spiral lens galaxy
• The Hubble time inferred from 10 time-delay lenses
• The Hubble constant from gravitational lens CLASS B0218+357 using the Advanced Camera for Surveys
• Degeneracies and scaling relations in general power-law models for gravitational lenses
• Models for the lens and source of B0218+357 - A LensClean approach to determine H0
• COSMOGRAIL: the COSmological MOnitoring of GRAvItational Lenses XV. Assessing the achievability and precision of time-delay measurements
• Improved Constraints on the Gravitational Lens Q0957+561. II. Strong Lensing
• Time-delay Cosmography: Increased Leverage with Angular Diameter Distances
• A New Estimate of the Hubble Time with Improved Modeling of Gravitational Lenses
• An optical time delay for the double gravitational lens system FBQ 0951+2635
• Gravitational lensing model degeneracies: Is steepness all-important?
• Galaxy Number Counts and Implications for Strong Lensing
• COSMOGRAIL: the COSmological MOnitoring of GRAvItational Lenses V. The time delay in SDSS J1650+4251
• SHARP - III: First Use Of Adaptive Optics Imaging To Constrain Cosmology With Gravitational Lens Time Delays
• COSMOGRAIL: the COSmological MOnitoring of GRAvItational Lenses XIV. Time delay of the doubly lensed quasar SDSS J1001+5027
• Multi wavelength study of the gravitational lens system RXS J1131-1231: II Lens model and source reconstruction
• Lensing degeneracies and mass substructure
• Steps towards Nonlinear Cluster Inversion Through Gravitational Distortions. I. Basic Considerations and Circular Clusters
• Results of optical monitoring of 5 SDSS double QSOs with the Nordic Optical Telescope
• Unlensing HST Observations of the Einstein Ring 1RXS J1131-1231: A Bayesian Analysis

Cited by in corpus (95)

• H0LiCOW XIII. A 2.4% measurement of $H_0$ from lensed quasars: $5.3\sigma$ tension between early and late-Universe probes
• H0LiCOW V. New COSMOGRAIL time delays of HE0435-1223: $H_0$ to 3.8% precision from strong lensing in a flat $\Lambda$CDM model
• H0LiCOW - IX. Cosmographic analysis of the doubly imaged quasar SDSS 1206+4332 and a new measurement of the Hubble constant
• TDCOSMO IV: Hierarchical time-delay cosmography -- joint inference of the Hubble constant and galaxy density profiles
• Seven hints that early-time new physics alone is not sufficient to solve the Hubble tension
• H0LiCOW I. $H_0$ Lenses in COSMOGRAIL's Wellspring: Program Overview
• Lenstronomy: multi-purpose gravitational lens modelling software package
• A SHARP view of H0LiCOW: $H_0$ from three time-delay gravitational lens systems with adaptive optics imaging
• STRIDES: a 3.9 per cent measurement of the Hubble constant from the strong lens system DES J0408-5354
• Time Delay Cosmography
• TDCOSMO. I. An exploration of systematic uncertainties in the inference of $H_0$ from time-delay cosmography
• H0LiCOW IV. Lens mass model of HE 0435-1223 and blind measurement of its time-delay distance for cosmology
• lenstronomy II: A gravitational lensing software ecosystem
• AutoLens: Automated Modeling of a Strong Lens's Light, Mass and Source
• A model-independent determination of the Hubble constant from lensed quasars and supernovae using Gaussian process regression
• Is every strong lens model unhappy in its own way? Uniform modelling of a sample of 13 quadruply+ imaged quasars
• Lensing substructure quantification in RXJ1131-1231: A 2 keV lower bound on dark matter thermal relic mass
• Microlensing Makes Lensed Quasar Time Delays Significantly Time Variable
• TDCOSMO. XII. Improved Hubble constant measurement from lensing time delays using spatially resolved stellar kinematics of the lens galaxy
• Measuring the value of the Hubble constant "à la Refsdal"
• Quantifying Environmental and Line-of-Sight Effects in Models of Strong Gravitational Lens Systems
• Strong lensing time-delay cosmography in the 2020s
• TDCOSMO V: strategies for precise and accurate measurements of the Hubble constant with strong lensing
• Determining Model-independent $H_0$ and Consistency Tests
• HOLISMOKES -- I. Highly Optimised Lensing Investigations of Supernovae, Microlensing Objects, and Kinematics of Ellipticals and Spirals
• STRIDES: Automated uniform models for 30 quadruply imaged quasars
• The STRong lensing Insights into the Dark Energy Survey (STRIDES) 2016 follow-up campaign. I. Overview and classification of candidates selected by two techniques
• SHARP - III: First Use Of Adaptive Optics Imaging To Constrain Cosmology With Gravitational Lens Time Delays
• Time-delay cosmographic forecasts with strong lensing and JWST stellar kinematics
• The Hubble constant from eight time-delay galaxy lenses
• Line-of-sight effects in strong lensing: Putting theory into practice
• Fast Point Spread Function Modeling with Deep Learning
• Time Delay Lens Modelling Challenge
• Improved time-delay lens modelling and $H_0$ inference with transient sources
• The Hubble constant from strongly lensed supernovae with standardizable magnifications
• TDCOSMO. IX. Systematic comparison between lens modelling software programs: time delay prediction for WGD 2038-4008
• TDCOSMO. VII. Boxyness/discyness in lensing galaxies : Detectability and impact on $H_0$
• TDCOSMO III: Dark matter substructure meets dark energy -- the effects of (sub)halos on strong-lensing measurements of $H_0$
• Cosmological distance indicators
• Astrometric requirements for strong lensing time-delay cosmography
• Projected Cosmological Constraints from Strongly Lensed Supernovae with the Roman Space Telescope
• The first simultaneous measurement of Hubble constant and post-Newtonian parameter from Time-Delay Strong Lensing
• TDCOSMO 2025: Cosmological constraints from strong lensing time delays
• Toward an internally consistent astronomical distance scale
• Gravitational lensing formalism in a curved arc basis: A continuous description of observables and degeneracies from the weak to the strong lensing regime
• The cosmic distance duality relation with strong lensing and gravitational waves: an opacity-free test
• Large-Scale Gravitational Lens Modeling with Bayesian Neural Networks for Accurate and Precise Inference of the Hubble Constant
• Strong Lensing by Galaxies
• Revising the Hubble constant, spatial curvature and dark energy dynamics with the latest observations of quasars
• A versatile tool for cluster lensing source reconstruction. I. methodology and illustration on sources in the Hubble Frontier Field Cluster MACS J0717.5+3745
• Gravitational lensing $H_0$ tension from ultralight axion galactic cores
• Consequences of the lack of azimuthal freedom in the modeling of lensing galaxies
• Ambiguities in gravitational lens models: impact on time delays of the source position transformation
• Constraints on cosmic curvature with lensing time delays and gravitational waves
• A model independent comparison of supernova and strong lensing cosmography: implications for the Hubble constant tension
• GLaD: Gravitational Lensing and Dynamics, combined analysis to unveil properties of high-redshift galaxies
• ALMA view of RX J1131-1231: Sub-kpc CO (2-1) mapping of a molecular disk in a lensed star-forming quasar host galaxy
• Generalised model-independent characterisation of strong gravitational lenses VI: the origin of the formalism intrinsic degeneracies and their influence on $H_0$
• The impact of line-of-sight structures on measuring $H_0$ with strong lensing time-delays
• A general theory of linear cosmological perturbations: bimetric theories
• Zooming into the Cosmic Horseshoe: new insights on the lens profile and the source shape
• Cosmic Shear with Einstein Rings
• Model-independent $H_0$ within FLRW: Joint constraints from GWTC-3 standard sirens and strong lensing time delays
• Probing variation of the fine-structure constant in runaway dilaton models using Strong Gravitational Lensing and Type Ia Supernovae
• A Spectroscopic Survey of the Fields of 28 Strong Gravitational Lenses: Implications for $H_0$
• The DES Bright Arcs Survey: Candidate Strongly Lensed Galaxy Systems from the Dark Energy Survey 5,000 Sq. Deg. Footprint
• TDCOSMO VIII: A key test of systematics in the hierarchical method of time-delay cosmography
• The impact of mass map truncation on strong lensing simulations
• TDCOSMO. XI. New lensing galaxy redshift and velocity dispersion measurements from Keck spectroscopy of eight lensed quasar systems
• Strongly lensed SN Refsdal: refining time delays based on the supernova explosion models
• Hubble Constant from LSST Strong lens time delays with microlensing systematics
• On the cosmic distance duality relation and the strong gravitational lens power law density profile
• Gaia GraL: Gaia DR2 Gravitational Lens Systems. IV. Keck/LRIS spectroscopic confirmation of GRAL113100-441959 and model prediction of time-delays
• Exploiting the diversity of modeling methods to probe systematic biases in strong lensing analyses
• Point-spread function reconstruction of adaptive-optics imaging: Meeting the astrometric requirements for time-delay cosmography
• Impact of Microlensing on Observational Strategies for Gravitational Time Delay Measurements
• Chromatic Microlensing Time Delays
• A test of the evolution of gas depletion factor in galaxy clusters using strong gravitational lensing systems
• Measuring the distances to quasars at high redshifts with strong lensing
• Unveiling the Universe with Emerging Cosmological Probes
• Foreground biases in strong gravitational lensing
• Direct measurement of lensing amplification in Abell S1063 using a strongly lensed high redshift HII Galaxy
• An SU(2) gauge principle for the Cosmic Microwave Background: Perspectives on the Dark Sector of the Cosmological Model
• High-resolution imaging follow-up of doubly imaged quasars
• TDCOSMO: XX. WFI2033--4723, the First Quadruply-Imaged Quasar Modeled with JWST Imaging
• TDCOSMO. XXIII. Measurement of the Hubble constant from the doubly lensed quasar HE1104-1805
• pySPT: a package dedicated to the source position transformation
• A new quasar strongly-lensed candidate by the galaxy cluster WHJ0400-27 with a $18^{\prime \prime }$ image-separation
• Halo concentration strengthens dark matter constraints in galaxy-galaxy strong lensing analyses
• A Joint Analysis of Strong Lensing and Type Ia Supernovae to Determine the Hubble Constant
• Impact of Large-Scale Structure along Line-of-Sight on Time-Delay Cosmography
• Time delay measurements with Broken Power Law model
• SDSS-IV MaNGA: A Catalogue of Spectroscopically Detected Strong Galaxy-Galaxy Lens Candidates
• SHARP VIII: J0924+0219 lens mass distribution and time-delay prediction through adaptive-optics imaging
• A Robust Bayesian Meta-Analysis for Estimating the Hubble Constant via Time Delay Cosmography