Mass-sheet degeneracy, power-law models and external convergence: Impact on the determination of the Hubble constant from gravitational lensing

Abstract

The light travel time differences in strong gravitational lensing systems allows an independent determination of the Hubble constant. This method has been successfully applied to several lens systems. The formally most precise measurements are, however, in tension with the recent determination of $H_0$ from the Planck satellite for a spatially flat six-parameters $\Lambda CDM$ cosmology. We reconsider the uncertainties of the method, concerning the mass profile of the lens galaxies, and show that the formal precision relies on the assumption that the mass profile is a perfect power law. Simple analytical arguments and numerical experiments reveal that mass-sheet like transformations yield significant freedom in choosing the mass profile, even when exquisite Einstein rings are observed. Furthermore, the characterization of the environment of the lens does not break that degeneracy which is not physically linked to extrinsic convergence. We present an illustrative example where the multiple imaging properties of a composite (baryons + dark matter) lens can be extremely well reproduced by a power-law model having the same velocity dispersion, but with predictions for the Hubble constant that deviate by $\sim 20$. Hence we conclude that the impact of degeneracies between parametrized models have been underestimated in current $H_0$ measurements from lensing, and need to be carefully reconsidered.

Accepted for publication in Astronomy and Astrophysics. Discussion expanded (MSD and velocity dispersion, MSD and free form lens models, MSD and multiple source redshifts)

References in corpus (11)

• The Structure & Dynamics of Massive Early-type Galaxies: On Homology, Isothermality and Isotropy inside one Effective Radius
• Cosmology from gravitational lens time delays and Planck data
• The Sloan Lens ACS Survey. VI: Discovery and analysis of a double Einstein ring
• The Halos of Satellite Galaxies: the Companion of the Massive Elliptical Lens SL2S J08544-0121
• The Hubble time inferred from 10 time-delay lenses
• A New Estimate of the Hubble Time with Improved Modeling of Gravitational Lenses
• COSMOGRAIL: the COSmological MOnitoring of GRAvItational Lenses XII. Time delays of the doubly lensed quasars SDSS J1206+4332 and HS 2209+1914
• The Hubble constant inferred from 18 time-delay lenses
• A Two-Year Time Delay for the Lensed Quasar SDSS J1029+2623
• Radial density profiles of time-delay lensing galaxies
• A sharp look at the gravitationally lensed quasar SDSS J0806+2006 with Laser Guide Star Adaptive Optics

Cited by in corpus (177)

• H0LiCOW XIII. A 2.4% measurement of $H_0$ from lensed quasars: $5.3\sigma$ tension between early and late-Universe probes
• H0LiCOW V. New COSMOGRAIL time delays of HE0435-1223: $H_0$ to 3.8% precision from strong lensing in a flat $\Lambda$CDM model
• H0LiCOW - IX. Cosmographic analysis of the doubly imaged quasar SDSS 1206+4332 and a new measurement of the Hubble constant
• TDCOSMO IV: Hierarchical time-delay cosmography -- joint inference of the Hubble constant and galaxy density profiles
• H0LiCOW I. $H_0$ Lenses in COSMOGRAIL's Wellspring: Program Overview
• Detection of lensing substructure using ALMA observations of the dusty galaxy SDP.81
• Hubble Space Telescope Combined Strong and Weak Lensing Analysis of the CLASH Sample: Mass and Magnification Models and Systematic Uncertainties
• A SHARP view of H0LiCOW: $H_0$ from three time-delay gravitational lens systems with adaptive optics imaging
• iPTF16geu: A multiply imaged, gravitationally lensed type Ia supernova
• Time Delay Cosmography
• Cosmology from gravitational lens time delays and Planck data
• TDCOSMO. I. An exploration of systematic uncertainties in the inference of $H_0$ from time-delay cosmography
• H0LiCOW IV. Lens mass model of HE 0435-1223 and blind measurement of its time-delay distance for cosmology
• Characterization of subhalo structural properties and implications for dark matter annihilation signals
• Cosmology with Strong Lensing Systems
• Source-position transformation -- an approximate invariance in strong gravitational lensing
• AutoLens: Automated Modeling of a Strong Lens's Light, Mass and Source
• Strongly lensed repeating Fast Radio Bursts as precision probes of the universe
• The mass-sheet degeneracy and time-delay cosmography: Analysis of the strong lens RXJ1131-1231
• H0LiCOW III. Quantifying the effect of mass along the line of sight to the gravitational lens HE 0435-1223 through weighted galaxy counts
• H0LiCOW XII. Lens mass model of WFI2033-4723 and blind measurement of its time-delay distance and $H_0$
• "Refsdal" meets Popper: comparing predictions of the re-appearance of the multiply imaged supernova behind MACSJ1149.5+2223
• Microlensing Makes Lensed Quasar Time Delays Significantly Time Variable
• A New Hybrid Framework to Efficiently Model Lines of Sight to Gravitational Lenses
• The Sloan Lens ACS Survey. XII. Extending Strong Lensing to Lower Masses
• TDCOSMO. XII. Improved Hubble constant measurement from lensing time delays using spatially resolved stellar kinematics of the lens galaxy
• Measuring the value of the Hubble constant "à la Refsdal"
• Adaptive Semi-linear Inversion of Strong Gravitational Lens Imaging
• Quantifying Environmental and Line-of-Sight Effects in Models of Strong Gravitational Lens Systems
• Strong lensing time-delay cosmography in the 2020s
• Over-constrained Gravitational Lens Models and the Hubble Constant
• Lens galaxies in the Illustris simulation: power-law models and the bias of the Hubble constant from time-delays
• The inner structure of early-type galaxies in the Illustris simulation
• Lens Models Under the Microscope: Comparison of Hubble Frontier Field Cluster Magnification Maps
• Improving time-delay cosmography with spatially resolved kinematics
• COSMOGRAIL: the COSmological MOnitoring of GRAvItational Lenses XV. Assessing the achievability and precision of time-delay measurements
• Survey of Gravitationally-lensed Objects in HSC Imaging (SuGOHI). II. Environments and Line-of-Sight Structure of Strong Gravitational Lens Galaxies to z ~ 0.8
• A measurement of the Hubble constant from angular diameter distances to two gravitational lenses
• On the accuracy of time-delay cosmography in the Frontier Fields Cluster MACS J1149.5+2223 with supernova Refsdal
• HOLISMOKES -- I. Highly Optimised Lensing Investigations of Supernovae, Microlensing Objects, and Kinematics of Ellipticals and Spirals
• Time-delay Cosmography: Increased Leverage with Angular Diameter Distances
• STRIDES: Automated uniform models for 30 quadruply imaged quasars
• Could quasar lensing time delays hint to a core component in halos, instead of H0 tension?
• The STRong lensing Insights into the Dark Energy Survey (STRIDES) 2016 follow-up campaign. I. Overview and classification of candidates selected by two techniques
• H0LiCOW II. Spectroscopic survey and galaxy-group identification of the strong gravitational lens system HE0435-1223
• The Price of Shifting the Hubble Constant
• SHARP - III: First Use Of Adaptive Optics Imaging To Constrain Cosmology With Gravitational Lens Time Delays
• Time-delay cosmographic forecasts with strong lensing and JWST stellar kinematics
• H0LiCOW VIII. A weak lensing measurement of the external convergence in the field of the lensed quasar HE0435$-$1223
• Breaking the mass-sheet degeneracy with gravitational wave interference in lensed events
• On the Choice of Lens Density Profile in Time Delay Cosmography
• Time Delay Lens Modelling Challenge
• Hubble constant and dark energy inferred from free-form determined time delay distances
• Lensed Type Ia Supernovae as Probes of Cluster Mass Models
• The Hubble constant from strongly lensed supernovae with standardizable magnifications
• A lensed radio jet at milli-arcsecond resolution I: Bayesian comparison of parametric lens models
• TDCOSMO. VII. Boxyness/discyness in lensing galaxies : Detectability and impact on $H_0$
• Project Dinos I: A joint lensing-dynamics constraint on the deviation from the power law in the mass profile of massive ellipticals
• On the density profile of dark matter substructure in gravitational lens galaxies
• TDCOSMO III: Dark matter substructure meets dark energy -- the effects of (sub)halos on strong-lensing measurements of $H_0$
• Cosmological distance indicators
• Over-constrained Models of Time Delay Lenses Redux: How the Angular Tail Wags the Radial Dog
• The offsets between galaxies and their dark matter in Lambda-CDM
• Generalised model-independent characterisation of strong gravitational lenses IV: formalism-intrinsic degeneracies
• Constraining the microlensing effect on time delays with new time-delay prediction model in $H_0$ measurements
• TDCOSMO 2025: Cosmological constraints from strong lensing time delays
• Support Vector Machine classification of strong gravitational lenses
• Probing the small-scale structure in strongly lensed systems via transdimensional inference
• A new way to explore cosmological tensions using gravitational waves and strong gravitational lensing
• Statistical Test of Distance--Duality Relation with Type Ia Supernovae and Baryon Acoustic Oscillations
• Toward an internally consistent astronomical distance scale
• Can one determine cosmological parameters from multi-plane strong lens systems?
• Constraints on warm dark matter from weak lensing in anomalous quadruple lenses
• A robust mass estimator for dark matter subhalo perturbations in strong gravitational lenses
• Ambiguities in gravitational lens models: the density field from the source position transformation
• Gravitational lensing formalism in a curved arc basis: A continuous description of observables and degeneracies from the weak to the strong lensing regime
• Beyond the bulge-halo conspiracy? Density profiles of Early-type galaxies from extended-source strong lensing
• A High-Resolution Investigation of the Multi-Phase ISM in a Galaxy during the First Two Billion Years
• Systematic errors induced by the elliptical power-law model in galaxy-galaxy strong lens modeling
• Large-Scale Gravitational Lens Modeling with Bayesian Neural Networks for Accurate and Precise Inference of the Hubble Constant
• Prediction of Supernova Rates in Known Galaxy-galaxy Strong-lens Systems
• Unified lensing and kinematic analysis for any elliptical mass profile
• Reducing biases on $H_0$ measurements using strong lensing and galaxy dynamics: results from the EAGLE simulation
• The Herschel-ATLAS: magnifications and physical sizes of $500\mu$m-selected strongly lensed galaxies
• Consequences of the lack of azimuthal freedom in the modeling of lensing galaxies
• Gravitational lensing $H_0$ tension from ultralight axion galactic cores
• GERLUMPH Data Release 2: 2.5 billion simulated microlensing light curves
• The Hubble-Lemaître constant and sound horizon from low-redshift probes
• TDCOSMO VI: Distance Measurements in Time-delay Cosmography under the Mass-sheet transformation
• SLITronomy: towards a fully wavelet-based strong lensing inversion technique
• HOLISMOKES -- VII. Time-delay measurement of strongly lensed Type Ia supernovae using machine learning
• Lensing Model of MACS J1149.5+2223 - I. Cluster mass reconstruction
• Ambiguities in gravitational lens models: impact on time delays of the source position transformation
• Constraints on cosmic curvature with lensing time delays and gravitational waves
• Impact of the 3D source geometry on time-delay measurements of lensed type-Ia Supernovae
• Generalised model-independent characterisation of strong gravitational lenses VI: the origin of the formalism intrinsic degeneracies and their influence on $H_0$
• Sparse Lens Inversion Technique (SLIT): lens and source separability from linear inversion of the source reconstruction problem
• A model-independent characterisation of strong gravitational lensing by observables
• TDCOSMO VIII: Cosmological distance measurements in light of the mass-sheet degeneracy -- forecasts from strong lensing and IFU stellar kinematics
• Galaxy-lens determination of $H_0$: constraining density slope in the context of the mass sheet degeneracy
• Looking for dark matter trails in colliding galaxy clusters
• Generalized multi-plane gravitational lensing: time delays, recursive lens equation, and the mass-sheet transformation
• Statistical strong lensing. II. Cosmology and galaxy structure with time-delay lenses
• The impact of line-of-sight structures on measuring $H_0$ with strong lensing time-delays
• Cosmology from weak lensing alone and implications for the Hubble tension
• One never walks alone: the effect of the perturber population on subhalo measurements in strong gravitational lenses
• TDCOSMO. XVI. Measurement of the Hubble Constant from the Lensed Quasar WGD2038$-$4008
• Lensing time delays as a substructure constraint: a case study with the cluster SDSS~J1004+4112
• Precision cosmology with time delay lenses: high resolution imaging requirements
• An accurate analytic mass model for lensing galaxies
• Galaxy-lens determination of $H_0$: the effect of the ellipse+shear modeling assumption
• Generalised model-independent characterisation of strong gravitational lenses III: perturbed axisymmetric lenses
• Probing cold dark matter subhalos with simulated ALMA observations of macrolensed sub-mm galaxies
• TDCOSMO VIII: A key test of systematics in the hierarchical method of time-delay cosmography
• Analytic solutions of the nonlinear radiation diffusion equation with an instantaneous point source in non-homogeneous media
• Piston driven shock waves in non-homogeneous planar media
• The impact of mass map truncation on strong lensing simulations
• TDCOSMO XV: Population Analysis of Lines of Sight of 25 Strong Galaxy-Galaxy Lenses with Extreme Value Statistics
• TDCOSMO. XI. New lensing galaxy redshift and velocity dispersion measurements from Keck spectroscopy of eight lensed quasar systems
• Hubble Constant from LSST Strong lens time delays with microlensing systematics
• Project Dinos II: Redshift evolution of dark and luminous matter density profiles in strong-lensing elliptical galaxies across 0.1 < z < 0.9
• J1721+8842: The first Einstein zig-zag lens
• Cosmic Time Slip: Testing Gravity on Supergalactic Scales with Strong-Lensing Time Delays
• AGEL: Is the Conflict Real? Investigating Galaxy Evolution Models using Strong Lensing at 0.3 < z < 0.9
• Strongly Lensed Jets, Time Delays, and the Value of H0
• Exploiting the diversity of modeling methods to probe systematic biases in strong lensing analyses
• Gaia GraL: Gaia DR2 Gravitational Lens Systems. IV. Keck/LRIS spectroscopic confirmation of GRAL113100-441959 and model prediction of time-delays
• Large-Distance Lens Uncertainties and Time-Delay Measurements of $H_0$
• [NII] fine-structure emission at 122 and 205um in a galaxy at z=2.6: a globally dense star-forming interstellar medium
• TDCOSMO XVII. New time delays in 22 lensed quasars from optical monitoring with the ESO-VST 2.6m and MPG 2.2m telescopes
• Interlopers speak out: studying the dark universe using small-scale lensing anisotropies
• Determination of astrophysical parameters of quasars within the Gaia mission
• Impact of Microlensing on Observational Strategies for Gravitational Time Delay Measurements
• Tailoring Strong Lensing Cosmographic Observations
• El Gordo needs El Anzuelo: Probing the structure of cluster members with multi-band extended arcs in JWST data
• Constraints on dark energy from TDCOSMO & SLACS lenses
• Anisotropic strong lensing as a probe of dark matter self-interactions
• Gravitational Lensing in More Realistic Dark Matter Halo Models
• Unveiling the Universe with Emerging Cosmological Probes
• Measuring the distances to quasars at high redshifts with strong lensing
• Calibrating the standard candles with strong lensing
• Chromatic Microlensing Time Delays
• SHARP -- IX. The dense, low-mass perturbers in B1938+666 and J0946+1006: implications for cold and self-interacting dark matter
• Forecast of strongly lensed supernovae rates in the China Space Station Telescope surveys
• Weak lensing of strong lensing: beyond the tidal regime
• Mass Reconstruction of Galaxy-scale Strong Gravitational Lenses Using a Broken Power-law Model
• Foreground biases in strong gravitational lensing
• Constraining Cosmology with Double-source-plane Strong Gravitational Lenses from the AGEL Survey
• Simulation-guided galaxy evolution inference: A case study with strong lensing galaxies
• Host group degeneracy in gravitational lensing time delay determination of $H_0$
• TDCOSMO. XXIII. Measurement of the Hubble constant from the doubly lensed quasar HE1104-1805
• pySPT: a package dedicated to the source position transformation
• TDCOSMO: XX. WFI2033--4723, the First Quadruply-Imaged Quasar Modeled with JWST Imaging
• The robustness of angular diameter distances to the lens in the B1608+656 and RXJ1131-1231 systems
• Free-floating "planets'' in the macrolensed quasar Q2237+0305
• FBQ 0951+2635: time delay and structure of the main lensing galaxy
• Discovery of a Low-mass Strong-lens System in SMACS J0723.3-7327
• Along the Primary Curve: Simultaneous Source and Lens Reconstruction of Bright Arcs in Cluster Lenses
• Toward Gravitational Lensing in Modified Theories of Gravity
• A Review on Resolving the Hubble Tension via Late-Universe Physics
• A Geometric Probe of Cosmology: I. Gravitational Lensing Time Delays and Quasar Reverberation Mapping
• Line-of-sight effects on double source plane lenses
• A Geometric Probe of Cosmology -- II. Gravitational Lensing Time Delays and Quasar Reverberation Mapping Revisited
• Detection of Unresolved Strongly Lensed Supernovae with 7-Dimensional Telescope
• Systematics in ETG Mass Profile Modelling: Strong Lensing & Stellar Dynamics
• Multi-messenger lensing time delay as a probe of the graviton mass
• SHARP VIII: J0924+0219 lens mass distribution and time-delay prediction through adaptive-optics imaging
• Comments on the mass sheet degeneracy in cosmography analyses
• Kinematic Mapping of Giant Arcs: A New Method to Locate Lensing Critical Curves
• SDSS-IV MaNGA: A Catalogue of Spectroscopically Detected Strong Galaxy-Galaxy Lens Candidates
• The Optical Origin of the Mass-Sheet Transformation
• A Salpeter IMF and an NFW halo: Disentangling the dark and stellar mass of an elliptical galaxy through precise lens modelling of a double-source-plane system
• A Robust Bayesian Meta-Analysis for Estimating the Hubble Constant via Time Delay Cosmography
• Breaking the Mass-sheet Degeneracy in Time-delay Cosmology with Lensed and Unlensed Type Ia Supernovae
• Time Delay Cosmography: Analysis of Quadruply Lensed QSO SDSSJ1433 from Wendelstein Observatory
• The impact of ultraviolet suppression on the rates and properties of strongly lensed Type IIn supernovae detected by LSST
• Caustic area biases and how to deal with them