Molecular Gas Contents and Scaling Relations for Massive Passive Galaxies at Intermediate Redshifts from the LEGA-C Survey

Abstract

A decade of study has established that the molecular gas properties of star-forming galaxies follow coherent scaling relations out to z~3, suggesting remarkable regularity of the interplay between molecular gas, star formation, and stellar growth. Passive galaxies, however, are expected to be gas-poor and therefore faint, and thus little is known about molecular gas in passive galaxies beyond the local universe. Here we present deep Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) observations of CO(2-1) emission in 8 massive (Mstar ~ 10^11 Msol) galaxies at z~0.7 selected to lie a factor of 3-10 below the star-forming sequence at this redshift, drawn from the Large Early Galaxy Astrophysics Census (LEGA-C) survey. We significantly detect half the sample, finding molecular gas fractions <~0.1. We show that the molecular and stellar rotational axes are broadly consistent, arguing that the molecular gas was not accreted after the galaxies became quiescent. We find that scaling relations extrapolated from the star-forming population over-predict both the gas fraction and gas depletion time for passive objects, suggesting the existence of either a break or large increase in scatter in these relations at low specific star formation rate. Finally, we show that the gas fractions of the passive galaxies we have observed at intermediate redshifts are naturally consistent with evolution into local massive early-type galaxies by continued low-level star formation, with no need for further gas accretion or dynamical stabilization of the gas reservoirs in the intervening 6 billion years.

arXiv comment23 pages, 9 figures, accepted to ApJ. Key results in Figures 7, 8, and 9

References in corpus (93)

• Planck 2015 results. XIII. Cosmological parameters
• Galactic Stellar and Substellar Initial Mass Function
• The Global Schmidt Law in Star Forming Galaxies
• Cosmic Star Formation History
• The many lives of active galactic nuclei: cooling flows, black holes and the luminosities and colours of galaxies
• The EAGLE project: Simulating the evolution and assembly of galaxies and their environments
• Observational Evidence of AGN Feedback
• Stellar Masses and Star Formation Histories for 10^5 Galaxies from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• How Do Galaxies Get Their Gas?
• Introducing the Illustris Project: Simulating the coevolution of dark and visible matter in the Universe
• The CO-to-H2 Conversion Factor
• Infrared Emission from Interstellar Dust. IV. The Silicate-Graphite-PAH Model in the Post-Spitzer Era
• Mass and environment as drivers of galaxy evolution in SDSS and zCOSMOS and the origin of the Schechter function
• Star Formation in AEGIS Field Galaxies since z=1.1 : The Dominance of Gradually Declining Star Formation, and the Main Sequence of Star-Forming Galaxies
• A Highly Consistent Framework for the Evolution of the Star-Forming "Main Sequence" from z~0-6
• The EAGLE simulations of galaxy formation: calibration of subgrid physics and model variations
• 3D-HST+CANDELS: The Evolution of the Galaxy Size-Mass Distribution since $z=3$
• The SINS survey: SINFONI Integral Field Spectroscopy of z ~ 2 Star-forming Galaxies
• Virial shocks in galactic haloes?
• An ultra-deep near-infrared spectrum of a compact quiescent galaxy at z=2.2
• PHIBSS: molecular gas content and scaling relations in z~1-3 normal star forming galaxies
• The Star-formation Mass Sequence out to z=2.5
• Gas-regulation of galaxies: the evolution of the cosmic sSFR, the metallicity-mass-SFR relation and the stellar content of haloes
• Constraining the Low-Mass Slope of the Star Formation Sequence at 0.5<z<2.5
• The Herschel view of the dominant mode of galaxy growth from z=4 to the present day
• Morphological quenching of star formation: making early-type galaxies red
• PHIBSS: Unified Scaling Relations of Gas Depletion Time and Molecular Gas Fractions
• Combined CO & Dust Scaling Relations of Depletion Time and Molecular Gas Fractions with Cosmic Time, Specific Star Formation Rate and Stellar Mass
• The CO-to-H2 Conversion Factor and Dust-to-Gas Ratio on Kiloparsec Scales in Nearby Galaxies
• The CO-to-H2 Conversion Factor From Infrared Dust Emission Across the Local Group
• A Molecular Star Formation Law in the Atomic Gas Dominated Regime in Nearby Galaxies
• The SCUBA Local Universe Galaxy Survey I: First Measurements of the Submillimetre Luminosity and Dust Mass Functions
• xCOLD GASS: the complete IRAM-30m legacy survey of molecular gas for galaxy evolution studies
• ISM masses and the star formation law at Z = 1 to 6 // ALMA observations of dust continuum in 145 galaxies in the COSMOS survey field
• An Analytic Model for the Evolution of the Stellar, Gas, and Metal Content of Galaxies
• COLD GASS, an IRAM legacy survey of molecular gas in massive galaxies: I. Relations between H2, HI, stellar content and structural properties
• The EAGLE simulations of galaxy formation: public release of halo and galaxy catalogues
• Structure and star formation in galaxies out to z=3: evidence for surface density dependent evolution and upsizing
• Galaxy Evolution in Cosmological Simulations with Outflows II: Metallicities and Gas Fractions
• The Atlas3D project -- IV: the molecular gas content of early-type galaxies
• A Public Ks-selected Catalog in the COSMOS/UltraVISTA Field: Photometry, Photometric Redshifts and Stellar Population Parameters
• Evolution of galaxy stellar masses and star formation rates in the EAGLE simulations
• A General Model for the CO-H2 Conversion Factor in Galaxies with Applications to the Star Formation Law
• The VLA-COSMOS 3 GHz Large Project: Continuum data and source catalog release
• Evolution of Interstellar Medium, Star Formation, and Accretion at High Redshift
• The Discovery of 1000 km/s Outflows in Massive Post-starburst Galaxies at z=0.6
• The SFR-M* Relation and Empirical Star-Formation Histories from ZFOURGE at 0.5 < z < 4
• The evolution of the dust temperatures of galaxies in the SFR$-M_{\ast }$ plane up to $z$$\sim$$2$
• The star formation main sequence and stellar mass assembly of galaxies in the Illustris simulation
• The Atlas3D project - XIV. The extent and kinematics of molecular gas in early-type galaxies
• Environmental Dependence of the Kennicutt-Schmidt Relation in Galaxies
• GAMA/G10-COSMOS/3D-HST: The 0<z<5 cosmic star-formation history, stellar- and dust-mass densities
• Molecular Gas and Star Formation in the SAURON Early-type Galaxies
• The SINS/zC-SINF survey of z~2 galaxy kinematics: evidence for gravitational quenching
• The VLT LEGA-C Spectroscopic Survey: The Physics of Galaxies at a Lookback Time of 7 Gyr
• Effects of Local Environment and Stellar Mass on Galaxy Quenching out to z~3
• Charting the evolution of the ages and metallicities of massive galaxies since z=0.7
• Fuel Efficient Galaxies: Sustaining Star Formation with Stellar Mass Loss
• The dependence of star formation activity on environment and stellar mass at z~1 from the HiZELS H-alpha survey
• The stellar mass function of star-forming galaxies and the mass-dependent SFR function since z=2.23 from HiZELS
• The ATLAS3D project - XVIII. CARMA CO imaging survey of early-type galaxies
• The Star Formation Law in Molecule-Poor Galaxies
• Low, Milky-Way like, Molecular Gas Excitation of Massive Disk Galaxies at z~1.5
• Quantifying the impact of mergers on the angular momentum of simulated galaxies
• Mid-IR Luminosities and UV/Optical Star Formation Rates at z<1.4
• The Rest-Frame Submillimeter Spectrum of High-Redshift, Dusty, Star-Forming Galaxies
• From haloes to Galaxies - I. The dynamics of the gas regulator model and the implied cosmic sSFR history
• The total infrared luminosity may significantly overestimate the star formation rate of recently quenched galaxies
• Gravitational Heating Helps Make Massive Galaxies Red and Dead
• KMOS^3D: Dynamical constraints on the mass budget in early star-forming disks
• The ATLAS3D project - XXII. Low-efficiency star formation in early-type galaxies: hydrodynamic models and observations
• ALLSMOG: an APEX Low-redshift Legacy Survey for MOlecular Gas. I - molecular gas scaling relations, and the effect of the CO/H2 conversion factor
• The SCUBA-2 Cosmology Legacy Survey: blank-field number counts of 450um-selected galaxies and their contribution to the cosmic infrared background
• The fundamental plane of star formation in galaxies revealed by the EAGLE hydrodynamical simulations
• The unexpectedly large dust and gas content of quiescent galaxies at z>1.4
• How dead are dead galaxies? Mid-Infrared fluxes of quiescent galaxies at redshift 0.3 < z < 2.5: implications for star formation rates and dust heating
• Massive quenched galaxies at z~0.7 retain large molecular gas reservoirs
• Spatially Resolved Stellar Kinematics from LEGA-C: Increased Rotational Support in z~0.8 Quiescent Galaxies
• Observational evidence of a slow downfall of star formation efficiency in massive galaxies during the last 10 Gyr
• ALMA reveals starburst-like interstellar medium conditions in a compact star-forming galaxy at z ~ 2 using [CI] and CO
• Massive Compact Galaxies with High-Velocity Outflows: Morphological Analysis and Constraints on AGN Activity
• The role of bars in quenching star formation from z = 3 to the present epoch. Halpha3: an Halpha imaging survey of HI selected galaxies from ALFALFA, VI
• Simultaneous Modeling of the Stellar and Dust Emission in Distant Galaxies: Implications for Star Formation Rate Measurements
• The formation of hot gaseous haloes around galaxies
• The EGNoG Survey: Molecular Gas in Intermediate-Redshift Star-Forming Galaxies
• Stellar Populations of over one thousand $z\sim 0.8$ Galaxies from LEGA-C: Ages and Star Formation Histories from D${}_n$4000 and H$\delta$
• Sub-kiloparsec Imaging of Cool Molecular Gas in Two Strongly Lensed Dusty, Star-Forming Galaxies
• The MASSIVE Survey - III. Molecular gas and a broken Tully-Fisher relation in the most massive early-type galaxies
• A direct constraint on the gas content of a massive, passively evolving elliptical galaxy at z = 1.43
• Low Gas Fractions Connect Compact Star-Forming Galaxies to their z ~ 2 Quiescent Descendants
• The identification of post-starburst galaxies at z~1 using multiwavelength photometry: a spectroscopic verification
• Confirming the Quiescent Galaxy Population out to $z=3$: A Stacking Analysis of Mid-, Far-Infrared and Radio Data
• Stellar Dynamics and Star-Formation Histories of z $\sim$ 1 Radio-loud Galaxies

Cited by in corpus (51)

• The Evolution of the Star-forming Interstellar Medium across Cosmic Time
• Automated Mining of the ALMA Archive in the COSMOS Field (A3COSMOS): II. Cold Molecular Gas Evolution out to Redshift 6
• Automated Mining of the ALMA Archive in the COSMOS Field (A3COSMOS): I. Robust ALMA Continuum Photometry Catalogs and Stellar Mass and Star Formation Properties for ~700 Galaxies at z=0.5-6
• Disk Growth and Quenching
• The MASSIVE survey - XI. What drives the molecular gas properties of early-type galaxies
• The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field: The nature of the faintest dusty star-forming galaxies
• Quenching of star formation from a lack of inflowing gas to galaxies
• ALMA measures rapidly depleted molecular gas reservoirs in massive quiescent galaxies at z~1.5
• Rejuvenation in $z\sim 0.8$ quiescent galaxies in LEGA-C
• On the Gas Content, Star Formation Efficiency, and Environmental Quenching of Massive Galaxies in Proto-Clusters at z~2.0-2.5
• The Typical Massive Quiescent Galaxy at z$\sim$3 is a Post-starburst
• Rejuvenated galaxies with very old bulges at the origin of the bending of the main sequence and of the "green valley"
• The Interstellar Medium of Quiescent Galaxies and its Evolution With Time
• Ubiquitous Molecular Outflows in z > 4 Massive, Dusty Galaxies II. Momentum-Driven Winds Powered by Star Formation in the Early Universe
• Extremely Low Molecular Gas Content in a Compact, Quiescent Galaxy at z=1.522
• A Preferential Growth Channel for Supermassive Black Holes in Elliptical Galaxies at z<2
• Toward a Better Understanding of Cosmic Chronometers: Stellar Population Properties of Passive Galaxies at Intermediate Redshift
• The Diverse Molecular Gas Content of Massive Galaxies Undergoing Quenching at z~1
• Molecular gas in distant galaxies from ALMA studies
• Evidence for Inside-Out Galaxy Growth and Quenching of a z~2 Compact Galaxy from High-Resolution Molecular Gas Imaging
• High Molecular-Gas to Dust Mass Ratios Predicted in Most Quiescent Galaxies
• A Catalog of Host Galaxies for WISE-Selected AGN: Connecting Host Properties with Nuclear Activity and Identifying Contaminants
• Dust temperature uncertainties hamper the inference of dust and molecular gas masses from the dust continuum emission of quiescent high-redshift galaxies
• A few StePS forward in unveiling the complexity of galaxy evolution: light-weighted stellar ages of intermediate redshift galaxies with WEAVE
• Molecular Gas Reservoirs in Massive Quiescent Galaxies at $\mathrm{z}\sim 0.7$ Linked to Late Time Star Formation
• Early Science with the Large Millimeter Telescope: Constraining the Gas Fraction of a Compact Quiescent Galaxy at z=1.883
• REQUIEM-2D: A diversity of formation pathways in a sample of spatially-resolved massive quiescent galaxies at z~2
• WEAVE-StePS. A stellar population survey using WEAVE at WHT
• Ubiquitous [OII] Emission in Quiescent Galaxies at z ~ 0.85
• The large molecular gas fraction of post-starburst galaxies at z > 1
• More is better: Strong constraints on the stellar properties of LEGA-C z ~ 1 galaxies with Prospector
• The [CII] 158 $\mu$m emission line as a gas mass tracer in high redshift quiescent galaxies
• The evolution of the gas fraction of quiescent galaxies modeled as a consequence of their creation rate
• JADES: Rest-frame UV-to-NIR Size Evolution of Massive Quiescent Galaxies from Redshift z=5 to z=0.5
• The ALMA Spectroscopic Survey in the HUDF: Constraining the Molecular Content at $\log (M_{\ast }/M_{\odot })\sim 9.5$ with CO stacking of MUSE detected $z\sim 1.5$ Galaxies
• The Gas Mass Reservoir of Quiescent Galaxies at Cosmic Noon
• Molecular gas in distant brightest cluster galaxies
• Tracing the evolutionary pathways of dust and cold gas in high-z quiescent galaxies with SIMBA
• SEEDisCS I. Molecular gas in galaxy clusters and their large scale structure: the case of CL1411.1$-$1148 at $z\sim 0.5$
• Quenched, bulge-dominated, but dynamically cold galaxies in IllustrisTNG and their real-world counterparts
• SQuIGG$\vec{L}$E: Observational Evidence of Low Ongoing Star Formation Rates in Gas-Rich Post-Starburst Galaxies
• SEEDisCS II. Molecular gas in galaxy clusters and their large scale structure: low gas fraction galaxies, the case of CL1301.7$-$1139
• The evolution of baryonic mass function of galaxies to z=3
• The nebular properties of star-forming galaxies at intermediate redshift from the Large Early Galaxy Astrophysics Census
• Feeding the Dead: Neutral Gas Inflow in a Long-Quenched Ancient Massive Galaxy at $z\sim 2.7$ Observed with JWST/NIRSpec
• Characterizing CO Emitters in the SSA22-AzTEC26 Field
• The Star Formation History of a Post-Starburst Galaxy Determined From Its Cluster Population
• Size-Mass Relation Shows Its Colours: Contrasting Physical Imprints of Galaxy Evolution in Rest-Frame UV and Optical
• Low star-formation activity and low gas content of quiescent galaxies at $z=$ 3.5-4.0 constrained with ALMA
• Now you see it, now you don't: Star formation truncation precedes the loss of molecular gas by ~100 Myr in massive post-starburst galaxies at z~0.6
• The Nun Path: The Evolution and Quenching of Satellite Galaxies