Feedback first: the surprisingly weak effects of magnetic fields, viscosity, conduction, and metal diffusion on galaxy formation
arXiv:1607.05274 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stx1463
Abstract
Using high-resolution simulations with explicit treatment of stellar feedback physics based on the FIRE (Feedback in Realistic Environments) project, we study how galaxy formation and the interstellar medium (ISM) are affected by magnetic fields, anisotropic Spitzer-Braginskii conduction and viscosity, and sub-grid metal diffusion from unresolved turbulence. We consider controlled simulations of isolated (non-cosmological) galaxies but also a limited set of cosmological "zoom-in" simulations. Although simulations have shown significant effects from these physics with weak or absent stellar feedback, the effects are much weaker than those of stellar feedback when the latter is modeled explicitly. The additional physics have no systematic effect on galactic star formation rates (SFRs) . In contrast, removing stellar feedback leads to SFRs being over-predicted by factors of . Without feedback, neither galactic winds nor volume filling hot-phase gas exist, and discs tend to runaway collapse to ultra-thin scale-heights with unphysically dense clumps congregating at the galactic center. With stellar feedback, a multi-phase, turbulent medium with galactic fountains and winds is established. At currently achievable resolutions and for the investigated halo mass range , the additional physics investigated here (MHD, conduction, viscosity, metal diffusion) have only weak (-level) effects on regulating SFR and altering the balance of phases, outflows, or the energy in ISM turbulence, consistent with simple equipartition arguments. We conclude that galactic star formation and the ISM are primarily governed by a combination of turbulence, gravitational instabilities, and feedback. We add the caveat that AGN feedback is not included in the present work.
References in corpus (114)
- The chemical composition of the Sun
- The Structure of Cold Dark Matter Halos
- The cosmological simulation code GADGET-2
- The Global Schmidt Law in Star Forming Galaxies
- Starburst99: Synthesis Models for Galaxies with Active Star Formation
- E pur si muove: Galiliean-invariant cosmological hydrodynamical simulations on a moving mesh
- Cosmological SPH simulations: A hybrid multi-phase model for star formation
- Hierarchical Galaxy Formation
- The Initial Mass Function of Stars: Evidence for Uniformity in Variable Systems
- The Spitzer c2d Legacy Results: Star Formation Rates and Efficiencies; Evolution and Lifetimes
- Galaxies on FIRE (Feedback In Realistic Environments): Stellar Feedback Explains Cosmologically Inefficient Star Formation
- GIZMO: A New Class of Accurate, Mesh-Free Hydrodynamic Simulation Methods
- Semi-Analytic Modelling of Galaxy Formation: The Local Universe
- High molecular gas fractions in normal massive star forming galaxies in the young Universe
- Cosmological Simulations with TreeSPH
- Athena: A New Code for Astrophysical MHD
- The effect of photo-ionization on the cooling rates of enriched, astrophysical plasmas
- Origin of Galactic and Extragalactic Magnetic Fields
- Shocks and cold fronts in galaxy clusters
- A New Calculation of the Ionizing Background Spectrum and the Effects of HeII Reionization
- Chemical enrichment in cosmological, smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations
- Gusty, gaseous flows of FIRE: galactic winds in cosmological simulations with explicit stellar feedback
- From rings to bulges: evidence for rapid secular galaxy evolution at z~2 from integral field spectroscopy in the SINS survey
- Reconciling dwarf galaxies with LCDM cosmology: Simulating a realistic population of satellites around a Milky Way-mass galaxy
- A New Model of the Galactic Magnetic Field
- Physical Conditions in Regions of Star Formation
- Forming Disk Galaxies in Lambda CDM Simulations
- Stellar Feedback in Galaxies and the Origin of Galaxy-scale Winds
- The Stellar, Gas and Dynamical Masses of Star-Forming Galaxies at z~2
- The Density Probability Distribution in Compressible Isothermal Turbulence: Solenoidal versus Compressive Forcing
- Towards a complete accounting of energy and momentum from stellar feedback in galaxy formation simulations
- Self-Regulated Star Formation in Galaxies via Momentum Input from Massive Stars
- The Origin and Evolution of the Galaxy Mass-Metallicity Relation
- Making Galaxies in a Cosmological Context: The Need for Early Stellar Feedback
- A General Class of Lagrangian Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Methods and Implications for Fluid Mixing Problems
- The Enrichment of the Intergalactic Medium with Adiabatic Feedback I: Metal Cooling and Metal Diffusion
- On the Origin of Cosmic Magnetic Fields
- The Galactic Magnetic Field
- Simulations of magnetic fields in isolated disk galaxies
- Strong magnetic fields in normal galaxies at high redshifts
- A Comparison of Methods for Determining the Molecular Content of Model Galaxies
- Molecular Hydrogen and Global Star Formation Relations in Galaxies
- The role of stellar feedback in the formation of galaxies
- A new Jeans resolution criterion for (M)HD simulations of self-gravitating gas: Application to magnetic field amplification by gravity-driven turbulence
- The Structure of the Interstellar Medium of Star Forming Galaxies
- Star Formation in Galaxy Mergers with Realistic Models of Stellar Feedback & the Interstellar Medium
- Radiation pressure from massive star clusters as a launching mechanism for super-galactic winds
- (Star)bursts of FIRE: observational signatures of bursty star formation in galaxies
- Galactic winds driven by cosmic-ray streaming
- How stellar feedback simultaneously regulates star formation and drives outflows
- The Vertical Structure of the Outer Milky Way HI Disk
- Magnetized Gas Clouds can Survive Acceleration by a Hot Wind
- ISM properties in hydrodynamic galaxy simulations: Turbulence cascades, cloud formation, role of gravity and feedback
- Galaxies in a Simulated CDM Universe II: Observable Properties and Constraints on Feedback
- The circumgalactic medium of massive galaxies at z~3: a test for stellar feedback, galactic outflows, and cold streams
- Models of Galaxy Clusters with Thermal Conduction
- Implementing Feedback in Simulations of Galaxy Formation: A Survey of Methods
- A Superbubble Feedback Model for Galaxy Simulations
- Three Dimensional Hydrodynamic Simulations of Multiphase Galactic Disks with Star Formation Feedback: I. Regulation of Star Formation Rates
- Feedback-regulated star formation in molecular clouds and galactic discs
- Simulations of disk galaxies with cosmic ray driven galactic winds
- The Meaning and Consequences of Star Formation Criteria in Galaxy Models with Resolved Stellar Feedback
- Simulating cosmic ray physics on a moving mesh
- Why are most molecular clouds not gravitationally bound?
- Global simulations of galactic winds including cosmic ray streaming
- Accurate, Meshless Methods for Magneto-Hydrodynamics
- Galactic r-process enrichment by neutron star mergers in cosmological simulations of a Milky Way-mass galaxy
- Neutral hydrogen in galaxy halos at the peak of the cosmic star formation history
- The Structure and Dynamical Evolution of the Stellar Disk of a Simulated Milky Way-Mass Galaxy
- The survival of gas clouds in the Circumgalactic Medium of Milky Way-like galaxies
- Star formation and molecular hydrogen in dwarf galaxies: a non-equilibrium view
- High-dynamic-range extinction mapping of infrared dark clouds: Dependence of density variance with sonic Mach number in molecular clouds
- A Global Probe of Cosmic Magnetic Fields to High Redshifts
- Magnetohydrodynamic Simulations of Disk Galaxy Formation: the Magnetization of The Cold and Warm Medium
- Thermal Instability with Anisotropic Thermal Conduction and Adiabatic Cosmic Rays: Implications for Cold Filaments in Galaxy Clusters
- Radiation-Hydrodynamic Simulations of the Formation of Orion-Like Star Clusters I. Implications for the Origin of the Initial Mass Function
- The impact of stellar feedback on the structure, size and morphology of galaxies in Milky Way size dark matter haloes
- A localised subgrid scale model for fluid dynamical simulations in astrophysics I: Theory and numerical tests
- The Launching of Cold Clouds by Galaxy Outflows II: The Role of Thermal Conduction
- A localised subgrid scale model for fluid dynamical simulations in astrophysics II: Application to type Ia supernovae
- Vertical Equilibrium, Energetics, and Star Formation Rates in Magnetized Galactic Disks Regulated by Momentum Feedback from Supernovae
- On the Origin of Strong Magnetic Fields in Young Supernova Remnants
- Anisotropic Diffusion in Mesh-Free Numerical Magnetohydrodynamics
- A Constrained-Gradient Method to Control Divergence Errors in Numerical MHD
- Star Formation in Disk Galaxies. II. The Effect of Star Formation and Photoelectric Heating on the Formation and Evolution of Giant Molecular Clouds
- A Stellar Feedback Origin for Neutral Hydrogen in High-Redshift Quasar-Mass Halos
- On the Origin of Radial Magnetic Fields in Young Supernova Remnants
- Supernova feedback in a local vertically stratified medium: interstellar turbulence and galactic winds
- Saturated-State Turbulence and Structure from Thermal and Magnetorotational Instability in the ISM: Three-Dimensional Numerical Simulations
- Models of Vertically Stratified Two-Phase ISM Disks with MRI-Driven Turbulence
- A direct measurement of the linear bias of mid-infrared-selected quasars at z~1 using cosmic microwave background lensing
- Low-Redshift Lyman Limit Systems as Diagnostics of Cosmological Inflows and Outflows
- Origin of strong magnetic fields in Milky-Way like galactic haloes
- Physical viscosity in smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations of galaxy clusters
- Sub-Eddington Star-Forming Regions are Super-Eddington: Momentum Driven Outflows from Supersonic Turbulence
- Cloud and Star Formation in Disk Galaxy Models with Feedback
- The MaGICC Baryon Cycle: The Enrichment History of Simulated Disc Galaxies
- Cosmological Galaxy Evolution with Superbubble Feedback I: Realistic Galaxies with Moderate Feedback
- Semi-implicit anisotropic cosmic ray transport on an unstructured moving mesh
- Scaling Laws of Passive-Scalar Diffusion in the Interstellar Medium
- Magnetised winds in dwarf galaxies
- Buoyant Bubbles in Intracluster Gas: Effects of Magnetic Fields and Anisotropic Viscosity
- Resolving The Generation of Starburst Winds in Galaxy Mergers
- Buoyancy Instabilities in Galaxy Clusters: Convection Due to Adiabatic Cosmic Rays and Anisotropic Thermal Conduction
- Radio Emission from a Young Supernova Remnant Interacting with an Interstellar Cloud: MHD Simulation with Relativistic Electrons
- Dense Molecular Gas: A Sensitive Probe of Stellar Feedback Models
- Cosmological simulations of galaxy formation with cosmic rays
- Three Dimensional Hydrodynamic Simulations of Multiphase Galactic Disks with Star Formation Feedback: II. Synthetic HI 21 cm Line Observations
- The Effects of Anisotropic Viscosity on Turbulence and Heat Transport in the Intracluster Medium
- Simulating magnetic fields in the Antennae galaxies
- Galactic ménage à trois: Simulating magnetic fields in colliding galaxies
- Accurately simulating anisotropic thermal conduction on a moving mesh
- The Effect of Anisotropic Conduction on the Thermal Instability in the Interstellar Medium
- Metal diffusion in smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations of dwarf galaxies
Cited by in corpus (127)
- FIRE-2 Simulations: Physics versus Numerics in Galaxy Formation
- FIRE in the Field: Simulating the Threshold of Galaxy Formation
- The Local Group on FIRE: Dwarf galaxy populations across a suite of hydrodynamic simulations
- The Origins of the Circumgalactic Medium in the FIRE Simulations
- But What About... Cosmic Rays, Magnetic Fields, Conduction, & Viscosity in Galaxy Formation
- STARFORGE: Toward a comprehensive numerical model of star cluster formation and feedback
- When Feedback Fails: The Scaling and Saturation of Star Formation Efficiency
- Predicting the LISA white dwarf binary population in the Milky Way with cosmological simulations
- Metal flows of the circumgalactic medium, and the metal budget in galactic halos
- Modelling chemical abundance distributions for dwarf galaxies in the Local Group: the impact of turbulent metal diffusion
- Properties of the Circumgalactic Medium in Cosmic Ray-Dominated Galaxy Halos
- Cosmic ray feedback in the FIRE simulations: constraining cosmic ray propagation with GeV gamma ray emission
- Where are the most ancient stars in the Milky Way?
- Dynamical Equilibrium in the Molecular ISM in 28 Nearby Star-Forming Galaxies
- FIRE-3: Updated Stellar Evolution Models, Yields, & Microphysics and Fitting Functions for Applications in Galaxy Simulations
- Public data release of the FIRE-2 cosmological zoom-in simulations of galaxy formation
- Star formation histories of dwarf galaxies in the FIRE simulations: dependence on mass and Local Group environment
- No missing photons for reionization: moderate ionizing photon escape fractions from the FIRE-2 simulations
- Dust attenuation, dust emission, and dust temperature in galaxies at z>=5: a view from the FIRE-2 simulations
- The origin of the diverse morphologies and kinematics of Milky Way-mass galaxies in the FIRE-2 simulations
- What FIREs Up Star Formation: the Emergence of the Kennicutt-Schmidt Law from Feedback
- A profile in FIRE: resolving the radial distributions of satellite galaxies in the Local Group with simulations
- Synthetic Gaia surveys from the FIRE cosmological simulations of Milky Way-mass galaxies
- Simulating an Isolated Dwarf Galaxy with Multi-Channel Feedback and Chemical Yields from Individual Stars
- On the Survival of Cool Clouds in the Circum-Galactic Medium
- Radiative Stellar Feedback in Galaxy Formation: Methods and Physics
- FIREbox: Simulating galaxies at high dynamic range in a cosmological volume
- Anisotropic Diffusion in Mesh-Free Numerical Magnetohydrodynamics
- Testing Physical Models for Cosmic Ray Transport Coefficients on Galactic Scales: Self-Confinement and Extrinsic Turbulence at GeV Energies
- Predicting the binary black hole population of the Milky Way with cosmological simulations
- Self-consistent proto-globular cluster formation in cosmological simulations of high-redshift galaxies
- The effect of magnetic fields on properties of the circumgalactic medium
- Chaos and Variance in Galaxy Formation
- Formation of Globular Cluster Candidates in Merging Proto-galaxies at High Redshift: A View from the FIRE Cosmological Simulations
- The Formation Times and Building Blocks of Milky Way-mass Galaxies in the FIRE Simulations
- Which AGN Jets Quench Star Formation in Massive Galaxies?
- Cosmic-Ray Driven Outflows to Mpc Scales from Galaxies
- The Fates of the Circumgalactic Medium in the FIRE Simulations
- Planes of satellites around Milky Way/M31-mass galaxies in the FIRE simulations and comparisons with the Local Group
- The bursty origin of the Milky Way thick disc
- First results from SMAUG: Uncovering the Origin of the Multiphase Circumgalactic Medium with a Comparative Analysis of Idealized and Cosmological Simulations
- The failure of stellar feedback, magnetic fields, conduction, and morphological quenching in maintaining red galaxies
- Effects of Different Cosmic Ray Transport Models on Galaxy Formation
- No Assembly Required: Mergers are Mostly Irrelevant for the Growth of Low-mass Dwarf Galaxies
- Reconciling observed and simulated stellar halo masses
- Extinguishing the FIRE: environmental quenching of satellite galaxies around Milky Way-mass hosts in simulations
- Under the Firelight: Stellar Tracers of the Local Dark Matter Velocity Distribution in the Milky Way
- A three-phase amplification of the cosmic magnetic field in galaxies
- 3-D gas-phase elemental abundances across the formation histories of Milky Way-mass galaxies in the FIRE simulations: initial conditions for chemical tagging
- Cosmic Rays or Turbulence can Suppress Cooling Flows (Where Thermal Heating or Momentum Injection Fail)
- Spatially Resolved [CII] Emission in SPT0346-52: A Hyper-Starburst Galaxy Merger at z~5.7
- Rotation curve fitting and its fatal attraction to cores in realistically simulated galaxy observations
- How primordial magnetic fields shrink galaxies
- First Predicted Cosmic Ray Spectra, Primary-to-Secondary Ratios, and Ionization Rates from MHD Galaxy Formation Simulations
- Standard Self-Confinement and Extrinsic Turbulence Models for Cosmic Ray Transport are Fundamentally Incompatible with Observations
- Born this way: thin disc, thick disc, and isotropic spheroid formation in FIRE-2 Milky-Way-mass galaxy simulations
- The role of galactic dynamics in shaping the physical properties of giant molecular clouds in Milky Way-like galaxies
- Dark and luminous satellites of LMC-mass galaxies in the FIRE simulations
- Evolution of giant molecular clouds across cosmic time
- Disk settling and dynamical heating: histories of Milky Way-mass stellar disks across cosmic time in the FIRE simulations
- The Galactic Dust-Up: Modeling Dust Evolution in FIRE
- A needle in a haystack? Catching Pop III stars in the Epoch of Reionization: I. Pop III star forming environments
- What drives the evolution of gas kinematics in star-forming galaxies?
- A Predicted Correlation Between Age Gradient and Star Formation History in FIRE Dwarf Galaxies
- Great Balls of FIRE I: The formation of star clusters across cosmic time in a Milky Way-mass galaxy
- Magnetization of the intergalactic medium in the IllustrisTNG simulations: the importance of extended, outflow-driven bubbles
- The origin of metal-poor stars on prograde disk orbits in FIRE simulations of Milky Way-mass galaxies
- Spatially Resoved 12CO(2-1)/12CO(1-0) in the Starburst Galaxy NGC 253: Assessing Optical Depth to Constrain the Molecular Mass Outflow Rate
- Unraveling the origin of magnetic fields in galaxies
- Dynamic Localised Turbulent Diffusion and its Impact on the Galactic Ecosystem
- Elevated UV luminosity density at Cosmic Dawn explained by non-evolving, weakly mass-dependent star formation efficiency
- On the effect of galactic outflows in cosmological simulations of disc galaxies
- The impact of cosmic rays on dynamical balance and disk-halo interaction in Lstar disk galaxies
- Magnetic Fields on FIRE: Comparing B-fields in the multiphase ISM and CGM of Simulated L Galaxies to Observations
- Stars made in outflows may populate the stellar halo of the Milky Way
- The global structure of magnetic fields and gas in simulated Milky Way-analogue galaxies
- Thermal Instability in the CGM of Galaxies: Testing "Precipitation" Models with the FIRE Simulations
- The Pandora project. I: the impact of radiation and cosmic rays on baryonic and dark matter properties of dwarf galaxies
- Mixing matters
- Virial shocks are suppressed in cosmic ray-dominated galaxy halos
- Stellar feedback strongly alters the amplification and morphology of galactic magnetic fields
- Reading the CARDs: the Imprint of Accretion History in the Chemical Abundances of the Milky Way's Stellar Halo
- The observable properties of galaxy accretion events in Milky Way-like galaxies in the FIRE-2 cosmological simulations
- Exploring Chemical Homogeneity in Dwarf Galaxies: A VLT-MUSE study of JKB 18
- Spiral Arms are Metal Freeways: Azimuthal Gas-Phase Metallicity Variations in Simulated Cosmological Zoom-in Flocculent Disks
- Empirically-motivated early feedback: momentum input by stellar feedback in galaxy simulations inferred through observations
- A Dusty Locale: Evolution of Galactic Dust Populations from Milky Way to Dwarf-Mass Galaxies
- The relationship between age, metallicity, and abundances for disk stars in a simulated Milky Way galaxy
- Nonlinear Evolution of the Resonant Drag Instability in Magnetized Gas
- Comparing Models for IMF Variation Across Cosmological Time in Milky Way-like Galaxies
- Simulating the Diverse Instabilities of Dust in Magnetized Gas
- Establishing Dust Rings and Forming Planets Within Them
- A jolt to the system: ram pressure on low-mass galaxies in simulations of the Local Group
- The In-situ Origins of Dwarf Stellar Outskirts in FIRE-2
- Synchrotron Emission on FIRE: Equipartition Estimators of Magnetic Fields in Simulated Galaxies with Spectrally-Resolved Cosmic Rays
- Cosmological simulations of quasar fueling to sub-parsec scales using Lagrangian hyper-refinement
- How Metals Are Transported In And Out Of A Galactic Disk: Dependence On The Hydrodynamic Schemes In Numerical Simulations
- Dust in the Wind with Resonant Drag Instabilities: I. The Dynamics of Dust-Driven Outflows in GMCs and HII Regions
- The contribution of globular clusters to cosmic reionization
- The impact of magnetic fields on cosmological galaxy mergers -- II. Modified angular momentum transport and feedback
- A Dusty Dawn: Galactic Dust Buildup at
- Spatially Resolved Gas-phase Metallicity in FIRE-2 Dwarfs: Late-Time Evolution of Metallicity Relations in Simulations with Feedback and Mergers
- Smoothed particle magnetohydrodynamics with the geometric density average force expression
- Dust Dynamics in AGN Winds: A New Mechanism For Multiwavelength AGN Variability
- Great Balls of FIRE III: Modeling Black Hole Mergers from Massive Star Clusters in Simulations of Galaxies
- Sliding into DM: Determining the local dark matter density and speed distribution using only the local circular speed of the Galaxy
- Simulations of Weakly Magnetized Turbulent Mixing Layers
- Chemical abundances in Seyfert galaxies -- VIII. Argon abundance estimates
- The physical origin of positive metallicity radial gradients in high-redshift galaxies: insights from the FIRE-2 cosmological hydrodynamic simulations
- Trial by FIRE: Probing the dark matter density profile of dwarf galaxies with GraphNPE
- A-priori Validation of Subgrid-scale Models for Astrophysical Turbulence
- Density Fluctuations in the Intracluster Medium: An Attempt to Constrain Viscosity with Cosmological Simulations
- VALES VIII: Weak ionized gas outflows in star-forming galaxies at traced with VLT/MUSE
- The imprint of bursty star formation on alpha-element abundance patterns in Milky Way-like galaxies
- Reconciling the magnetic field in central disc galaxies with the dynamical mass using the cosmological simulations
- Environment matters: stronger magnetic fields in satellite galaxies
- Early Stages of Dusty Tori: The First Infrared Spectra from a Highly Multiscale Quasar Simulation
- Variability in Cosmological Hydrodynamical Simulations: how Stochastic Processes, Numerical Effects, and Reproducibility Limits impact Predictability
- New families in our Solar neighborhood: applying Gaussian Mixture models for objective classification of structures in the Milky Way and in simulations
- A New Model For Including Galactic Winds in Simulations of Galaxy Formation II: Implementation of PhEW in Cosmological Simulations
- Two-phase formation of galaxies: the coevolution between galaxies and dark matter halos
- NIHAO-LG: The uniqueness of Local Group dwarf galaxies
- The mass-dependent interplay of active galacitc nuclei and supernova feedback in shaping the -- relation of early-type galaxies
- How non-thermal pressure impacts the modelling of star formation in galaxy formation simulations
- Metallicity Structure in Galactic Longitude-Velocity Diagrams of the Milky Way Disk and FIRE-2 Simulations
- Towards convergence of turbulent dynamo amplification in cosmological simulations of galaxies
- 3D elemental abundances of stars at formation across the histories of Milky Way-mass galaxies in the FIRE simulations