Chaos and Variance in Galaxy Formation
arXiv:1803.05445 · doi:10.1093/mnras/sty2859
Abstract
The evolution of galaxies is governed by equations with chaotic solutions: gravity and compressible hydrodynamics. While this micro-scale chaos and stochasticity has been well studied, it is poorly understood how it couples to macro-scale properties examined in simulations of galaxy formation. In this paper, we show how perturbations introduced by floating-point roundoff, random number generators, and seemingly trivial differences in algorithmic behaviour can produce non-trivial differences in star formation histories, circumgalactic medium (CGM) properties, and the distribution of stellar mass. We examine the importance of stochasticity due to discreteness noise, variations in merger timings and how self-regulation moderates the effects of this stochasticity. We show that chaotic variations in stellar mass can grow until halted by feedback-driven self-regulation or gas exhaustion. We also find that galaxy mergers are critical points from which large (as much as a factor of 2) variations in quantities such as the galaxy stellar mass can grow. These variations can grow and persist for more than a Gyr before regressing towards the mean. These results show that detailed comparisons of simulations require serious consideration of the magnitude of effects compared to run-to-run chaotic variation, and may significantly complicate interpreting the impact of different physical models. Understanding the results of simulations requires us to understand that the process of simulation is not a mapping of an infinitesimal point in configuration space to another, final infinitesimal point. Instead, simulations map a point in a space of possible initial conditions points to a volume of possible final states.
arXiv commentreplaced preprint with final MNRAS published version
References in corpus (75)
- E pur si muove: Galiliean-invariant cosmological hydrodynamical simulations on a moving mesh
- Cosmological SPH simulations: A hybrid multi-phase model for star formation
- Introducing the Illustris Project: Simulating the coevolution of dark and visible matter in the Universe
- Modeling feedback from stars and black holes in galaxy mergers
- Cosmological Hydrodynamics with Adaptive Mesh Refinement: a new high resolution code called RAMSES
- Simulating Galaxy Formation with the IllustrisTNG Model
- The EAGLE simulations of galaxy formation: calibration of subgrid physics and model variations
- A Multi-Code Analysis Toolkit for Astrophysical Simulation Data
- Interstellar Turbulence I: Observations and Processes
- GIZMO: A New Class of Accurate, Mesh-Free Hydrodynamic Simulation Methods
- Cosmological Simulations with TreeSPH
- Star Formation and Feedback in Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamic Simulations--I. Isolated Galaxies
- Global survey of star clusters in the Milky Way II. The catalogue of basic parameters
- Effects of Galaxy Formation on Thermodynamics of the Intracluster Medium
- Gasoline: An adaptable implementation of TreeSPH
- Fundamental differences between SPH and grid methods
- Compressible Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence: mode coupling, scaling relations, anisotropy, new regime and astrophysical implications
- Simulating galactic outflows with thermal supernova feedback
- Forming Realistic Late-Type Spirals in a LCDM Universe: The Eris Simulation
- The Santa Barbara cluster comparison project: a comparison of cosmological hydrodynamics solutions
- Self-Regulated Star Formation in Galaxies via Momentum Input from Massive Stars
- Simulating galactic outflows with kinetic supernova feedback
- The Aquila comparison Project: The Effects of Feedback and Numerical Methods on Simulations of Galaxy Formation
- Making Galaxies in a Cosmological Context: The Need for Early Stellar Feedback
- Cusp-core transformations in dwarf galaxies: observational predictions
- The Enrichment of the Intergalactic Medium with Adiabatic Feedback I: Metal Cooling and Metal Diffusion
- A Constant Molecular Gas Depletion Time in Nearby Disk Galaxies
- Regulation of Star Formation Rates in Multiphase Galactic Disks: a Thermal/Dynamical Equilibrium Model
- NIHAO project I: Reproducing the inefficiency of galaxy formation across cosmic time with a large sample of cosmological hydrodynamical simulations
- Physical properties of molecular clouds for the entire Milky Way disk
- The Romulus Cosmological Simulations: A Physical Approach to the Formation, Dynamics and Accretion Models of SMBHs
- Nested and Single Bars in Seyfert and Non-Seyfert Galaxies
- Galaxy Zoo: Bars in Disk Galaxies
- Feedback, Disk Self-regulation and Galaxy Formation
- Dark Matter Substructure in Numerical Simulations: A Tale of Discreteness Noise, Runaway Instabilities, and Artificial Disruption
- The AGORA High-Resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project
- Gasoline2: A Modern SPH Code
- The History of the Baryon Budget: Cosmic Logistics in a Hierarchical Universe
- The E-MOSAICS Project: simulating the formation and co-evolution of galaxies and their star cluster populations
- Bar-driven dark halo evolution: a resolution of the cusp--core controversy
- Implementing Feedback in Simulations of Galaxy Formation: A Survey of Methods
- A Superbubble Feedback Model for Galaxy Simulations
- A Necessary Condition for Individual Time-Steps in SPH Simulations
- A Uniform Catalog of Molecular Clouds in the Milky Way
- Fast Magnetic Reconnection and Spontaneous Stochasticity
- Feedback first: the surprisingly weak effects of magnetic fields, viscosity, conduction, and metal diffusion on galaxy formation
- Multiphase Smoothed-Particle Hydrodynamics
- Cosmological Galaxy Formation Simulations Using SPH
- Resolving mixing in Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics
- Star formation and molecular hydrogen in dwarf galaxies: a non-equilibrium view
- The AGORA High-Resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project. II: Isolated Disk Test
- A Quantification of the Butterfly Effect in Cosmological Simulations and Implications for Galaxy Scaling Relations
- Supernova feedback in numerical simulations of galaxy formation: separating physics from numerics
- A Comparison of Cosmological Codes: Properties of Thermal Gas and Shock Waves in Large Scale Structures
- On the Dynamical Stability of the Solar System
- Discreteness Effects in Lambda Cold Dark Matter Simulations: A Wavelet-Statistical View
- A Comparative Study of AGN Feedback Algorithms
- Cosmological Galaxy Evolution with Superbubble Feedback I: Realistic Galaxies with Moderate Feedback
- A two-phase scenario for bulge assembly in LCDM cosmologies
- Stochasticity in N-body Simulations of Disc Galaxies
- Cosmological Galaxy Evolution with Superbubble Feedback II: The Limits of Supernovae
- Discrete Effects in Stellar Feedback: Individual Supernovae, Hypernovae, and IMF Sampling in Dwarf Galaxies
- The anatomy of a star-forming galaxy: Pressure-driven regulation of star formation in simulated galaxies
- Modeling for Stellar Feedback in Galaxy Formation Simulations
- A new paradigm for reproducing and analyzing N-body simulations of planetary systems
- The stellar metallicity distribution of disc galaxies and bulges in cosmological simulations
- On the effect of galactic outflows in cosmological simulations of disc galaxies
- The effect of non-equilibrium metal cooling on the interstellar medium
- N-body simulations with two-orders-of-magnitude higher performance using wavelets
- Stochasticity & Predictability in Terrestrial Planet Formation
- On the Onset of Stochasticity in CDM Cosmological Simulations
- Towards time symmetric N-body integration
- JANUS: A bit-wise reversible integrator for N-body dynamics
- The luminosity function of diverse satellite galaxy systems
- Particle number dependence in the non-linear evolution of N-body self-gravitating systems
Cited by in corpus (65)
- Simulating cosmic structure formation with the GADGET-4 code
- Be it therefore resolved: Cosmological Simulations of Dwarf Galaxies with Extreme Resolution
- But What About... Cosmic Rays, Magnetic Fields, Conduction, & Viscosity in Galaxy Formation
- Large-scale dark matter simulations
- Hydrodynamical simulations of the galaxy population: enduring successes and outstanding challenges
- Observable tests of self-interacting dark matter in galaxy clusters: cosmological simulations with SIDM and baryons
- Stochastic modelling of star-formation histories II: star-formation variability from molecular clouds and gas inflow
- The SAMI Galaxy Survey: the third and final data release
- A Quantification of the Butterfly Effect in Cosmological Simulations and Implications for Galaxy Scaling Relations
- The Diversity and Variability of Star Formation Histories in Models of Galaxy Evolution
- Heart of Darkness: the influence of galactic dynamics on quenching star formation in galaxy spheroids
- Efficient early stellar feedback can suppress galactic outflows by reducing supernova clustering
- The dynamical evolution of molecular clouds near the Galactic Centre - II. Spatial structure and kinematics of simulated clouds
- Determining the full satellite population of a Milky Way-mass halo in a highly resolved cosmological hydrodynamic simulation
- EDGE: From quiescent to gas-rich to star-forming low-mass dwarf galaxies
- Dwarf Galaxies in CDM, WDM, and SIDM: Disentangling Baryons and Dark Matter Physics
- The importance of black hole repositioning for galaxy formation simulations
- 3-D gas-phase elemental abundances across the formation histories of Milky Way-mass galaxies in the FIRE simulations: initial conditions for chemical tagging
- First Predicted Cosmic Ray Spectra, Primary-to-Secondary Ratios, and Ionization Rates from MHD Galaxy Formation Simulations
- Forming early-type galaxies without AGN feedback: a combination of merger-driven outflows and inefficient star formation
- Numerical convergence of hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy formation: the abundance and internal structure of galaxies and their cold dark matter haloes
- Dust evolution in zoom-in cosmological simulations of galaxy formation
- Roll of the Dice: A Stochastically Sampled IMF Alters the Stellar Content of Simulated Dwarf Galaxies
- AGN jet feedback on a moving mesh: gentle cluster heating by weak shocks and lobe disruption
- Barred galaxies in the Illustris-1 and TNG100 simulations
- The challenge of simultaneously matching the observed diversity of chemical abundance patterns in cosmological hydrodynamical simulations
- The sensitivity of stellar feedback to IMF averaging versus IMF sampling in galaxy formation simulations
- Quenching and morphological evolution due to circumgalactic gas expulsion in a simulated galaxy with a controlled assembly history
- Satellites of Milky Way- and M31-like galaxies with TNG50: quenched fractions, gas content, and star formation histories
- Spatial Decorrelation of Young Stars and Dense Gas as a Probe of the Star Formation-Feedback Cycle in Galaxies
- How much metals did the first stars provide to the ultra-faint dwarfs?
- Uncertainties in supernova input rates drive qualitative differences in simulations of galaxy evolution
- EDGE: The sensitivity of ultra-faint dwarfs to a metallicity-dependent initial mass function
- How cosmological merger histories shape the diversity of stellar haloes
- Boosting galactic outflows with enhanced resolution
- Sensitivity of dark matter haloes to their accretion histories
- EAGLE-Auriga: effects of different subgrid models on the baryon cycle around Milky Way-mass galaxies
- Simba: The average properties of the circumgalactic medium of quasars are determined primarily by stellar feedback
- Empirically-motivated early feedback: momentum input by stellar feedback in galaxy simulations inferred through observations
- EDGE: The emergence of dwarf galaxy scaling relations from cosmological radiation-hydrodynamics simulations
- Calibrating cosmological simulations with implicit likelihood inference using galaxy growth observables
- EDGE: A new approach to suppressing numerical diffusion in adaptive mesh simulations of galaxy formation
- The baryon cycle of Seven Dwarfs with superbubble feedback
- There and back again: understanding the critical properties of backsplash galaxies
- Calibration of a star formation and feedback model for cosmological simulations with Enzo
- Impact of H-driven star formation and stellar feedback from low-enrichment environments on the formation of spiral galaxies
- Progenitor-mass-dependent yields amplify intrinsic scatter in dwarf-galaxy elemental abundance ratios
- Self-Interacting Dark Matter and the Delay of Super-Massive Black Hole Growth
- Star Formation Variability as a Probe for the Baryon Cycle within Galaxies
- On the Origin of the High Star-Formation Efficiency in Massive Galaxies at Cosmic Dawn
- Errors, chaos and the collisionless limit
- ARTEMIS emulator: exploring the effect of cosmology and galaxy formation physics on Milky Way-mass haloes and their satellites
- Diverse dark matter profiles in FIRE dwarfs: black holes, cosmic rays and the cusp-core enigma
- Quantifying the intrinsic variability due to randomness of the Auriga galaxy formation model
- Escaping the maze: a statistical sub-grid model for cloud-scale density structures in the interstellar medium
- Where Did the Outskirts Go? Outer Stellar Haloes as a Sensitive Probe of Supernova Feedback
- A Simple Sub-Grid Model For Cosmic Ray Effects on Galactic Scales
- The formation and disruption of globular cluster populations in simulations of present-day galaxies with controlled assembly histories
- Machine-guided Exploration and Calibration of Astrophysical Simulations
- Merger Tree-based Galaxy Matching: A Comparative Study Across Different Resolutions
- ARCHITECTS I: Impact of subgrid physics on the simulated properties of the circumgalactic medium
- Variability in Cosmological Hydrodynamical Simulations: how Stochastic Processes, Numerical Effects, and Reproducibility Limits impact Predictability
- Turning Points in the Age-Metallicity Relations -- Created by Late Satellite Infall and Enhanced by Radial Migration
- EDGE-INFERNO: How chemical enrichment assumptions impact the individual stars of a simulated ultra-faint dwarf galaxy
- Galaxy mergers can initiate quenching by unlocking an AGN-driven transformation of the baryon cycle