A Comparison of Cosmological Codes: Properties of Thermal Gas and Shock Waves in Large Scale Structures
arXiv:1106.2159 · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2966.2011.19546.x
Abstract
[...] We present results for the statistics of thermal gas and the shock wave properties for a large volume simulated with three different cosmological numerical codes: the Eulerian total variations diminishing code TVD, the Eulerian piecewise parabolic method-based code ENZO, and the Lagrangian smoothed-particle hydrodynamics code GADGET. Starting from a shared set of initial conditions, we present convergence tests for a cosmological volume of side-length 100 Mpc/h, studying in detail the morphological and statistical properties of the thermal gas as a function of mass and spatial resolution in all codes. By applying shock finding methods to each code, we measure the statistics of shock waves and the related cosmic ray acceleration efficiencies, within the sample of simulations and for the results of the different approaches. We discuss the regimes of uncertainties and disagreement among codes, with a particular focus on the results at the scale of galaxy clusters. Even if the bulk of thermal and shock properties are reasonably in agreement among the three codes, yet some significant differences exist (especially between Eulerian methods and smoothed particle hydrodynamics). In particular, we report: a) differences of huge factors (10-100) in the values of average gas density, temperature, entropy, Mach number and shock thermal energy flux in the most rarefied regions of the simulations between grid and SPH methods; b) the hint of an entropy core inside clusters simulated in grid codes; c) significantly different phase diagrams of shocked cells in grid codes compared to SPH; d) sizable differences in the morphologies of accretion shocks between grid and SPH methods.
arXiv comment30 pages, 24 figures. Version accepted by MNRAS. Only minor changes and updated references list compared to the first submitted version
References in corpus (90)
- Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Three Year Results: Implications for Cosmology
- The cosmological simulation code GADGET-2
- Large scale bias and the peak background split
- E pur si muove: Galiliean-invariant cosmological hydrodynamical simulations on a moving mesh
- Profiles of dark haloes: evolution, scatter, and environment
- Statistical Properties of X-ray Clusters: Analytic and Numerical Comparisons
- GADGET: A code for collisionless and gasdynamical cosmological simulations
- Radiative Transfer in a Clumpy Universe: II. The Utraviolet Extragalactic Background
- A Cosmology Calculator for the World Wide Web
- The Inner Structure of LambdaCDM Halos I: A Numerical Convergence Study
- Cosmological SPH simulations: The entropy equation
- Fundamental differences between SPH and grid methods
- Precision Determination of the Mass Function of Dark Matter Halos
- The Santa Barbara cluster comparison project: a comparison of cosmological hydrodynamics solutions
- Cosmological Shock Waves and Their Role in the Large Scale Structure of the Universe
- Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics in Astrophysics
- Modelling discontinuities and Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities in SPH
- The Energy Spectrum of Primary Cosmic Ray Electrons in Clusters of Galaxies and Inverse Compton Emission
- The baseline intracluster entropy profile from gravitational structure formation
- Baryons at the Edge of the X-ray Brightest Galaxy Cluster
- Cosmic Rays, Radio Halos and Non-Thermal X-ray Emission in Clusters of Galaxies
- Properties of Cosmic Shock Waves in Large Scale Structure Formation
- Clusters of Galaxies as a Storage Room for Cosmic Rays
- A low-frequency radio halo associated with a cluster of galaxies
- Detecting shock waves in cosmological smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations
- Cosmic Ray Electrons in Groups and Clusters of Galaxies: Primary and Secondary Populations from a Numerical Cosmological Simulation
- A Cluster Merger and the Origin of the Extended Radio Emission in Abell 3667
- Effects of cooling and star formation on the baryon fractions in clusters
- Turbulent Motions and Shocks Waves in Galaxy Clusters simulated with AMR
- Radio signature of cosmological structure formation shocks
- Gamma-Ray Background from Structure Formation in the Intergalactic Medium
- Cosmic ray feedback in hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy formation
- Comparing AMR and SPH Cosmological Simulations: I. Dark Matter & Adiabatic Simulations
- Measuring Omega_0 using cluster evolution
- GRAPESPH: Cosmological SPH simulations with the special purpose hardware GRAPE
- Cosmic ray transport in galaxy clusters: implications for radio halos, gamma-ray signatures, and cool core heating
- Acceleration of primary and secondary particles in galaxy clusters by compressible MHD turbulence: from radio halos to gamma rays
- Cosmological simulations of galaxy clusters
- Shock Waves in Eulerian Cosmological Simulations: Main Properties and Acceleration of Cosmic Rays
- Simulating cosmic rays in clusters of galaxies - II. A unified scheme for radio halos and relics with predictions of the gamma-ray emission
- Gas Clumping in the Outskirts of Lambda-CDM Clusters
- GeV Gamma-ray Flux Upper Limits from Clusters of Galaxies
- Measuring the non-thermal pressure in early type galaxy atmospheres: A comparison of X-ray and optical potential profiles in M87 and NGC1399
- Cosmological Shocks in Adaptive Mesh Refinement Simulations and the Acceleration of Cosmic Rays
- Cosmic rays and Radio Halos in galaxy clusters : new constraints from radio observations
- X-ray Spectroscopy of the Virgo Cluster out to the Virial Radius
- A test suite for quantitative comparison of hydrodynamics codes in astrophysics
- Cosmic Ray Protons Accelerated at Cosmological Shocks and Their Impact on Groups and Clusters of Galaxies
- MAGIC Gamma-ray Telescope Observation of the Perseus Cluster of Galaxies: implications for cosmic rays, dark matter, and NGC1275
- Simulating cosmic rays in clusters of galaxies - I. Effects on the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect and the X-ray emission
- On the Origin of Cores in Simulated Galaxy Clusters
- Cosmological Shock Waves in the Large Scale Structure of the Universe: Non-gravitational Effects
- The Cosmic Code Comparison Project
- Prospects of detecting gamma-ray emission from galaxy clusters: cosmic rays and dark matter annihilations
- Simulating the gamma-ray emission from galaxy clusters: a universal cosmic ray spectrum and spatial distribution
- The baryon fraction in hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy clusters
- Simulated X-ray galaxy clusters at the virial radius: slopes of the gas density, temperature and surface brightness profiles
- Diffuse radio emission from clusters in the MareNostrum Universe simulation
- Two--body heating in numerical galaxy formation experiments
- Computational Eulerian Hydrodynamics and Galilean Invariance
- Numerical Modeling of Gamma Radiation from Galaxy Clusters
- Simulation techniques for cosmological simulations
- Gamma rays from clusters of galaxies
- Simulating cosmic rays in clusters of galaxies - III. Non-thermal scaling relations and comparison to observations
- Particle acceleration mechanisms
- Galaxy Clusters at the Edge: Temperature, Entropy, and Gas Dynamics at the Virial Radius
- Galaxy Cluster Radio Relics in Adaptive Mesh Refinement Cosmological Simulations: Relic Properties and Scaling Relationships
- Particle hydrodynamics with tessellation techniques
- Accretion Shocks in Clusters of Galaxies and their SZ Signature from Cosmological Simulations
- Massive and refined: a sample of large galaxy clusters simulated at high resolution. I:Thermal gas and shock waves properties
- The chemical enrichment of the ICM from hydrodynamical simulations
- A Comparison of Cosmological Hydrodynamic Codes
- Radio Halos From Simulations And Hadronic Models I: The Coma cluster
- Comparison of Different Methods for Nonlinear Diffusive Shock Acceleration
- Exploring the magnetized cosmic web through low frequency radio emission
- The non-thermal radiation - Cluster merger connection
- Diffusive Shock Acceleration in Test-Particle Regime
- A search for a dark matter annihilation signal towards the Canis Major overdensity with H.E.S.S
- Radio Galaxy NGC 1265 unveils the Accretion Shock onto the Perseus Galaxy Cluster
- The scatter in the radial profiles of X-ray luminous galaxy clusters as diagnostic of the thermodynamical state of the ICM
- EvoL: The new Padova T-SPH parallel code for cosmological simulations - I. Basic code: gravity and hydrodynamics
- The Mixing and Transport Properties of the Intra Cluster Medium: a numerical study using tracers particles
- Introducing Enzo, an AMR Cosmology Application
- Signatures in a Giant Radio Galaxy of a Cosmological Shock Wave at Intersecting Filaments of Galaxies
- Acceleration of Cosmic Rays at Large Scale Cosmic Shocks in the Universe
- Global cluster morphology and its evolution: X-ray data vs CDM, LCDM and mixed models
- The entropy core in galaxy clusters: numerical and physical effects in cosmological grid simulations
- Numerical convergence of physical variables in hydrodynamical simulations of cooling clusters
- The quest for cosmic ray protons in galaxy clusters
- Simulating Galaxy Clusters
Cited by in corpus (82)
- Enzo: An Adaptive Mesh Refinement Code for Astrophysics
- Cosmic rays in galaxy clusters and their non-thermal emission
- The Baryon Census in a Multiphase Intergalactic Medium: 30% of the Baryons May Still Be Missing
- On the Cluster Physics of Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Surveys I: The Influence of Feedback, Non-thermal Pressure and Cluster Shapes on Y-M Scaling Relations
- Lensing and X-ray mass estimates of clusters (SIMULATION)
- A refined sub-grid model for black hole accretion and AGN feedback in large cosmological simulations
- Simulating cosmic ray physics on a moving mesh
- Giant radio relics in galaxy clusters: reacceleration of fossil relativistic electrons?
- Search for cosmic-ray induced gamma-ray emission in Galaxy Clusters
- Following the flow: tracer particles in astrophysical fluid simulations
- Discovery of radio halos and double-relics in distant MACS galaxy clusters: clues to the efficiency of particle acceleration
- Evidence for particle re-acceleration in the radio relic in the galaxy cluster PLCKG287.0 +32.9
- The "toothbrush-relic": evidence for a coherent linear 2-Mpc scale shock wave in a massive merging galaxy cluster?
- On the amplification of magnetic fields in cosmic filaments and galaxy clusters
- Cosmological MHD Simulations of Galaxy Cluster Radio Relics: Insights and Warnings for Observations
- Turbulence and Vorticity in Galaxy Clusters Generated by Structure Formation
- Turbulence and Particle Acceleration in Giant Radio Haloes: the Origin of Seed Electrons
- Turbulence in the ICM from mergers, cool-core sloshing and jets: results from a new multi-scale filtering approach
- Properties of Merger Shocks in Merging Galaxy Clusters
- Properties of gas clumps and gas clumping factor in the intra cluster medium
- Measurements and simulation of Faraday rotation across the Coma radio relic
- Chaos and Variance in Galaxy Formation
- Vorticity, Shocks and Magnetic Fields in Subsonic, ICM-like Turbulence
- Comparing Masses in Literature (CoMaLit)-I. Bias and scatter in weak lensing and X-ray mass estimates of clusters
- Constraining the efficiency of cosmic ray acceleration by cluster shocks
- Simulations of ultra-high Energy Cosmic Rays in the local Universe and the origin of Cosmic Magnetic Fields
- Shock finding on a moving-mesh: I. Shock statistics in non-radiative cosmological simulations
- Analytical model for non-thermal pressure in galaxy clusters
- Forecasts for the detection of the magnetised cosmic web from cosmological simulations
- The Importance of Quantum Pressure of Fuzzy Dark Matter on Lyman-Alpha Forest
- Shock Waves and Cosmic Ray Acceleration in the Outskirts of Galaxy Clusters
- Why are central radio relics so rare?
- Can cluster merger shocks reproduce the luminosity and shape distribution of radio relics?
- Encounters of Merger and Accretion Shocks in Galaxy Clusters and their Effects on Intracluster Medium
- Shocks and non-thermal particles in clusters of galaxies
- Morphology of radio relics I: What causes the substructure of synchrotron emission?
- Galaxies going MAD: The Galaxy-Finder Comparison Project
- Evolution of cosmic filaments and of their galaxy population from MHD cosmological simulations
- Simulations of the merging galaxy cluster Abell 3376
- A large H survey of star formation in relaxed and merging galaxy cluster environments at
- Curved Radio Spectra of Weak Cluster Shocks
- Detecting shocked intergalactic gas with X-ray and radio observations
- Properties of Cosmological Filaments extracted from Eulerian Simulations
- Thermal and non-thermal traces of AGN feedback: results from cosmological AMR simulations
- Locations of Accretion Shocks around Galaxy Clusters and the ICM properties: insights from Self-Similar Spherical Collapse with arbitrary mass accretion rates
- Shock finding on a moving-mesh: II. Hydrodynamic shocks in the Illustris universe
- Understanding `galaxy groups' as a unique structure in the universe
- Shocks in the Stacked Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Profiles of Clusters II: Measurements from SPT-SZ + Planck Compton-y Map
- Shock-multicloud interactions in galactic outflows -- I. Cloud layers with log-normal density distributions
- Adaptive mesh refinement simulations of a galaxy cluster merger - I. Resolving and modelling the turbulent flow in the cluster outskirts
- Mapping "out-of-the-box" the properties of the baryons in massive halos
- Simulations and observational tests of primordial magnetic fields from Cosmic Microwave Background constraints
- On the small scale turbulent dynamo in the intracluster medium: A comparison to dynamo theory
- Cosmological shock waves: clues to the formation history of haloes
- Shock waves in the magnetized cosmic web: the role of obliquity and cosmic-ray acceleration
- Boosting galactic outflows with enhanced resolution
- Statistical properties of mass, star formation, chemical content and rotational patterns in early z > 9 structures
- Probing the Curious Case of a Galaxy Cluster Merger in Abell 115 with High Fidelity Chandra X-ray Temperature and Radio Maps
- Simulations of cosmic rays in large-scale structures: numerical and physical effects
- Structure and kinematics of shocked gas in Sgr B2: further evidence of a cloud-cloud collision from SiO emission maps
- On the redshift evolution of the baryon and gas fraction in simulated groups and clusters of galaxies
- Turbulence in the Inter-galactic Medium: Solenoidal and Dilatational Motions, and the Impact of Numerical Viscosity
- Geometrical on-the-fly shock detection in SPH
- On The Road To More Realistic Galaxy Cluster Simulations: The Effects of Radiative Cooling and Thermal Feedback Prescriptions on the Observational Properties of Simulated Galaxy Clusters
- Simulations of Galaxy Cluster Collisions with a Dark Plasma Component
- On the complexity and the information content of cosmic structures
- A Particle-In-Cell Code Comparison for Ion Acceleration: EPOCH, LSP, and WarpX
- AGN feedback and entropy injection in galaxy cluster cores
- The evolution of cosmic ray electrons in the cosmic web: seeding by AGN, star formation and shocks
- nIFTy Galaxy Cluster simulations VI: The dynamical imprint of substructure on gaseous cluster outskirts
- Simulating the LOcal Web (SLOW) -- III: Synchrotron emission from the local cosmic web
- Excess entropy and energy feedback from within cluster cores up to r
- Manufacturing cosmic rays in the evolving dynamical states of galaxy clusters
- Charge exchange in the ultraviolet: implication for interacting clouds in the core of NGC 1275
- Correlations of the feedback energy and BCG radio luminosity in galaxy clusters
- How complex is the cosmic web?
- Exploring the role of cosmological shock waves in the Dianoga simulations of galaxy clusters
- Cosmic accretion shocks as a tool to measure the dark matter mass of galaxy clusters
- Diffusive Shock Acceleration by Multiple Weak Shocks
- Two merging galaxy clusters with very hot shock fronts observed shortly before pericentric passage
- Shock waves in Interstellar Cloud-Cloud and Wind-Cloud Collisions
- Re-acceleration of Cosmic Ray Electrons by Multiple ICM Shocks