A Comparison of Cosmological Hydrodynamic Codes

Abstract

We present a detailed comparison of the simulation results of various cosmological hydrodynamic codes. Starting with identical initial conditions based on the Cold Dark Matter scenario for the growth of structure, we integrate from redshift $z=20$ to $z=0$ to determine the physical state within a representative volume of size $L^3$ where $L=64h^{-1}\mathrm{Mpc}$. Five independent codes are compared: three of them Eulerian mesh based and two variants of the Smooth Particle Hydrodynamics "SPH" Lagrangian approach. The Eulerian codes were run at $N^3=(32^3,64^3,128^3,\mathrm{and},256^3)$ cells, the SPH codes at $N^3=32^3$ and $64^3$ particles. Results were then rebinned to a $16^3$ grid with the expectation that the rebinned data should converge, by all techniques, to a common and correct result as $N\to \infty$. We find that global averages of various physical quantities do, as expected, tend to converge in the rebinned model, but that uncertainties in even primitive quantities such as $⟨T⟩$, $⟨{\rho }^2{⟩}^{1/2}$ persists at the 3\%-17\% level after completion of very large simulations. The two SPH codes and the two shock capturing Eulerian codes achieve comparable and satisfactory accuracy for comparable computer time in their treatment of the high density, high temperature regions as measured in the rebinned data; the variance among the five codes (at highest resolution) for the mean temperature (as weighted by ${\rho }^2$) is only 4.5\%. Overall the comparison allows us to better estimate errors, it points to ways of improving this current generation of hydrodynamic codes and of suiting their use to problems which exploit their individually best features.

20p plaintex to appear in The Astrophysical Journal on July 20, 1994

Cited by in corpus (42)

• GADGET: A code for collisionless and gasdynamical cosmological simulations
• Baryons in the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
• The Santa Barbara cluster comparison project: a comparison of cosmological hydrodynamics solutions
• Properties of Cosmic Shock Waves in Large Scale Structure Formation
• Approximation Methods for Non-linear Gravitational Clustering
• Comparing AMR and SPH Cosmological Simulations: I. Dark Matter & Adiabatic Simulations
• Why is the CMB fluctuation level 10^{-5}?
• Cosmic Ray Protons Accelerated at Cosmological Shocks and Their Impact on Groups and Clusters of Galaxies
• The Power Spectrum of the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect
• Parallel TreeSPH
• A Comparison of Cosmological Codes: Properties of Thermal Gas and Shock Waves in Large Scale Structures
• Simulation techniques for cosmological simulations
• Physical Bias of Galaxies From Large-Scale Hydrodynamic Simulations
• Shock-Heated Gas in the Large Scale Structure of the Universe
• Time Evolution of Galaxy Formation and Bias in Cosmological Simulations
• Tests of Spurious Transport in Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics
• A High-resolution Adaptive Moving Mesh Hydrodynamic Algorithm
• Hot and Cooled baryons in SPH simulations of galaxy clusters: physics and numerics
• Off-Center Collisions between Clusters of Galaxies
• Simulating the X-ray Forest
• Numerical and Analytical Predictions for the Large-Scale Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect
• On the role of shock waves in galaxy cluster evolution
• CosmoMHD: A Cosmological Magnetohydrodynamics Code
• Conservation Laws in Smooth Particle Hydrodynamics: the DEVA Code
• The intergalactic medium temperature and Compton y parameter
• The Structure of Cosmic String Wakes
• Are Large X-ray Clusters at Thermal Equilibrium ?
• Computational Cosmology: from the Early Universe to the Large Scale Structure
• Accuracy of Mesh Based Cosmological Hydrocodes: Tests and Corrections
• Gravitational Instability in Collisionless Cosmological Pancakes
• COSMOS: A Hybrid N-Body/Hydrodynamics Code for Cosmological Problems
• A Parallel Tree-SPH code for Galaxy Formation
• A comparison of hydrodynamics techniques for modelling collisions between main sequence stars
• Simulation of radiation driven wind from disc galaxies
• Wind-Driven Gas Networks and Star Formation in Galaxies: Reaction-Advection Hydrodynamic Simulations
• Clustering of loose groups and galaxies from the Perseus--Pisces Survey
• A cosmological hydrodynamic code based on the Piecewise Parabolic Method
• Non equilibrium thermodynamics and cosmological pancakes formation
• Clusters of galaxies: setting the stage
• Precision cosmology with baryons: non-radiative hydrodynamics of galaxy groups
• Cosmological Simulations with Scale-Free Initial Conditions I: Adiabatic Hydrodynamics
• Resolving the jeans mass in hydrodynamic simulations of hierarchical clustering