Galaxies going MAD: The Galaxy-Finder Comparison Project
arXiv:1210.2578 · doi:10.1093/mnras/sts173
Abstract
With the ever increasing size and complexity of fully self-consistent simulations of galaxy formation within the framework of the cosmic web, the demands upon object finders for these simulations has simultaneously grown. To this extent we initiated the Halo Finder Comparison Project that gathered together all the experts in the field and has so far led to two comparison papers, one for dark matter field haloes (Knebe et al. 2011), and one for dark matter subhaloes (Onions et al. 2012). However, as state-of-the-art simulation codes are perfectly capable of not only following the formation and evolution of dark matter but also account for baryonic physics (e.g. hydrodynamics, star formation, feedback) object finders should also be capable of taking these additional processes into consideration. Here we report on a comparison of codes as applied to the Constrained Local UniversE Simulation (CLUES) of the formation of the Local Group which incorporates much of the physics relevant for galaxy formation. We compare both the properties of the three main galaxies in the simulation (representing the MW, M31, and M33) as well as their satellite populations for a variety of halo finders ranging from phase-space to velocity-space to spherical overdensity based codes, including also a mere baryonic object finder. We obtain agreement amongst codes comparable to (if not better than) our previous comparisons, at least for the total, dark, and stellar components of the objects. However, the diffuse gas content of the haloes shows great disparity, especially for low-mass satellite galaxies. This is primarily due to differences in the treatment of the thermal energy during the unbinding procedure. We acknowledge that the handling of gas in halo finders is something that needs to be dealt with carefully, and the precise treatment may depend sensitively upon the scientific problem being studied.
arXiv comment14 interesting pages, 17 beautiful figures, and 2 informative tables accepted for publication in MNRAS (matches published version)
References in corpus (49)
- Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Three Year Results: Implications for Cosmology
- The cosmological simulation code GADGET-2
- Populating a cluster of galaxies - I. Results at z=0
- E pur si muove: Galiliean-invariant cosmological hydrodynamical simulations on a moving mesh
- Dwarf Galaxies of the Local Group
- Cosmological SPH simulations: A hybrid multi-phase model for star formation
- Radiative Transfer in a Clumpy Universe: II. The Utraviolet Extragalactic Background
- Substructures in hydrodynamical cluster simulations
- Ahf: Amiga's Halo Finder
- The Milky Way's bright satellites as an apparent failure of LCDM
- Cuspy No More: How Outflows Affect the Central Dark Matter and Baryon Distribution in Lambda CDM Galaxies
- Fundamental differences between SPH and grid methods
- The Cores of Dwarf Galaxy Halos
- Simulations of Galaxy Formation in a Lambda CDM Universe II: The Fine Structure of Simulated Galactic Disks
- The Santa Barbara cluster comparison project: a comparison of cosmological hydrodynamics solutions
- The evolution substructure I: a new identification method
- Haloes gone MAD: The Halo-Finder Comparison Project
- The Masses of the Milky Way and Andromeda galaxies
- The Luminosity Function of the Milky Way Satellites
- Cosmological puzzle resolved by stellar feedback in high redshift galaxies
- The effects of feedback on the morphology of galaxy discs
- Luminosity function and radial distribution of Milky Way Satellites in a LCDM Universe
- Comparing AMR and SPH Cosmological Simulations: I. Dark Matter & Adiabatic Simulations
- SubHaloes going Notts: The SubHalo-Finder Comparison Project
- Erasing Dark Matter Cusps in Cosmological Galactic Halos with Baryons
- A test suite for quantitative comparison of hydrodynamics codes in astrophysics
- The preferred direction of infalling satellite galaxies in the Local Group
- The Cosmic Code Comparison Project
- Radial distribution and strong lensing statistics of satellite galaxies and substructure using high resolution LCDM hydrodynamical simulations
- Dissecting Galaxy Formation: I. Comparison Between Pure Dark Matter and Baryonic Models
- An observer's view of simulated galaxies: disc-to-total ratios, bars, and (pseudo-)bulges
- Computational Eulerian Hydrodynamics and Galilean Invariance
- A Comparison of Cosmological Codes: Properties of Thermal Gas and Shock Waves in Large Scale Structures
- Constrained simulations of the Local Group: on the radial distribution of substructures
- The grouping, merging and survival of subhaloes in the simulated Local Group
- On effects of resolution in dissipationless cosmological simulations
- Peaks above the Maxwellian Sea: A New Approach to Finding Substructure in N-Body Haloes
- The luminosities of backsplash galaxies in constrained simulations of the Local Group
- The impact of baryonic physics on the shape and radial alignment of substructures in cosmological dark matter haloes
- Dark Matter Halo Structure in CDM Hydrodynamical Simulations
- Formation of galaxies in ΛCDM cosmologies. I. The fine structure of disc galaxies
- Too small to succeed? Lighting up massive dark matter subhaloes of the Milky Way
- Renegade Subhaloes in the Local Group
- Disentangling the dark matter halo from the stellar halo
- Bright and Dark Matter in Elliptical Galaxies: Mass and Velocity Distributions from Self-consistent Hydrodynamical Simulations
- Dissecting Galaxy Formation: II. Comparing Substructure in Pure Dark Matter and Baryonic Models
- Moderate Steepening of Galaxy Cluster Dark Matter Profiles by Baryonic Pinching
- Comparing galactic satellite properties in hydrodynamical and Nbody simulations
- Local Group progenitors: Lyman Alpha bright?
Cited by in corpus (37)
- Beyond CDM: Problems, solutions, and the road ahead
- Gas kinematics, morphology, and angular momentum in the FIRE simulations
- Structure Finding in Cosmological Simulations: The State of Affairs
- Modified Gravity N-body Code Comparison Project
- Sussing Merger Trees: The Merger Trees Comparison Project
- Atomic hydrogen in IllustrisTNG galaxies: the impact of environment parallelled with local 21-cm surveys
- Mapping substructure in the HST Frontier Fields cluster lenses and in cosmological simulations
- Hunting for Galaxies and Halos in simulations with VELOCIraptor
- A survey of high- galaxies: SERRA simulations
- The Horizon Run 5 Cosmological Hydrodynamic Simulation: Probing Galaxy Formation from Kilo- to Giga-parsec Scales
- Intrinsic alignments of galaxies in the MassiveBlack-II simulation: analysis of two-point statistics
- Rhapsody-G simulations I: the cool cores, hot gas and stellar content of massive galaxy clusters
- MultiDark-Galaxies: data release and first results
- Major Mergers Going Notts: Challenges for Modern Halo Finders
- The bursty origin of the Milky Way thick disc
- Statistics of extreme objects in the Juropa Hubble Volume simulation
- How does our choice of observable influence our estimation of the centre of a galaxy cluster? Insights from cosmological simulations
- Introducing a new, robust galaxy finder algorithm for simulations
- Sussing Merger Trees: the influence of the halo finder
- Galaxy properties and the cosmic web in simulations
- The Accuracy of Weak Lensing Simulations
- Dark Matter in the Local Universe
- Streams Going Notts: The tidal debris finder comparison project
- Using Galaxy Pairs to Probe Star Formation During Major Halo Mergers
- Where do galaxies end? Comparing measurement techniques of hydrodynamic-simulation galaxies' integrated properties
- Taking measurements of the kinematic Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect forward: including uncertainties from velocity reconstruction with forward modeling
- Systematic uncertainties in models of the cosmic dawn
- Cold versus Warm Dark Matter simulations of a galaxy group
- On the accuracy of dark matter halo merger trees and the consequences for semi-analytic models of galaxy formation
- The AGORA High-Resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project VII: Satellite quenching in zoom-in simulation of a Milky Way-mass halo
- Relative baryon-dark matter velocities in cosmological zoom simulations
- A Novel Scheme for Dark Matter Annihilation Feedback in Cosmological Simulations
- The Three Hundred: The existence of massive dark matter-deficient satellite galaxies in cosmological simulations
- Amaryllis: a digital twin of the earliest galaxies in the Universe
- Performance Enhancement of Tree-based Friends-of-friend Galaxy-finder for High-resolution Simulations of Galaxy Formation
- SubDLe: identification of substructures in cosmological simulations with deep learning
- The Hierarchical Structure of Galactic Haloes: Generalised N-Dimensional Clustering with CluSTAR-ND