On the Origin of Cores in Simulated Galaxy Clusters
arXiv:0812.1750 · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2966.2009.14550.x
Abstract
(Abridged) The thermal state of the intracluster medium results from a competition between gas cooling and heating. The heating comes from two distinct sources: gravitational heating from the collapse of the dark matter halo and thermal input from galaxy/black hole formation. However, a long standing problem has been that cosmological simulations based on smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) and Eulerian mesh codes predict different results even when cooling and galaxy/black hole heating are switched off. Clusters formed in SPH simulations show near powerlaw entropy profiles, while those formed in mesh simulations develop a core and do not allow gas to reach such low entropies. Since the cooling rate is closely connected to the minimum entropy of the gas, the differences are of potentially key importance. In this paper, we investigate the origin of this discrepancy. By comparing simulations run using the GADGET-2 SPH code and the FLASH adaptive Eulerian mesh code, we show that the discrepancy arises during the idealised merger of two clusters. The difference is not sensitive to the resolution of our simulations, nor is it is due differences in the gravity solvers, Galilean non-invariance of the mesh code, or an effect of unsuitable artificial viscosity in the SPH code. Instead, we find that the difference is inherent to the treatment of eddies and fluid instabilities. These are suppressed in the SPH simulations, while the cluster mergers generate strong vortices in the mesh simulations that efficiently mix the fluid and erase the low entropy gas. Consequently, particles in the SPH simulations retain a close connection to their initial entropy, while this connection is much weaker in the mesh simulations. We discuss the potentially profound implications of these results.
arXiv comment19 pages, 10 figures, Accepted for publication in MNRAS
References in corpus (62)
- A Universal Density Profile from Hierarchical Clustering
- The Structure of Cold Dark Matter Halos
- The cosmological simulation code GADGET-2
- Simulating the joint evolution of quasars, galaxies and their large-scale distribution
- The broken hierarchy of galaxy formation
- How Do Galaxies Get Their Gas?
- GADGET: A code for collisionless and gasdynamical cosmological simulations
- Heating Hot Atmospheres with Active Galactic Nuclei
- Cosmological SPH simulations: The entropy equation
- What Shapes the Luminosity Function of Galaxies?
- The statistics of LCDM Halo Concentrations
- Galaxies in a simulated CDM Universe I: cold mode and hot cores
- Effects of Galaxy Formation on Thermodynamics of the Intracluster Medium
- Fundamental differences between SPH and grid methods
- A deep Chandra observation of the Perseus cluster: shocks and ripples
- High Resolution X-ray Spectroscopic Constraints on Cooling-Flow Models for Clusters of Galaxies
- The Santa Barbara cluster comparison project: a comparison of cosmological hydrodynamics solutions
- Thermal Conduction in Clusters of Galaxies
- Off-Axis Cluster Mergers: Effects of a Strongly Peaked Dark Matter Profile
- The detection of molecular gas in the central galaxies of cooling-flow clusters
- Modelling discontinuities and Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities in SPH
- Ram pressure stripping the hot gaseous halos of galaxies in groups and clusters
- Turbulent gas motions in galaxy cluster simulations: The role of SPH viscosity
- The origin of cold fronts in the cores of relaxed galaxy clusters
- The baseline intracluster entropy profile from gravitational structure formation
- The impact of mergers on relaxed X-ray clusters - I. Dynamical evolution and emergent transient structures
- Probing Turbulence in the Coma Galaxy Cluster
- Statistics of X-ray observables for the cooling-core and non-cooling core galaxy clusters
- Revisiting the Cosmic Cooling Crisis
- Reformulation of Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics with Riemann Solver
- Effects of cooling and star formation on the baryon fractions in clusters
- Gas Stripping of Dwarf Galaxies in Clusters of Galaxies
- Modified-Entropy Models for the Intracluster Medium
- Comparing AMR and SPH Cosmological Simulations: I. Dark Matter & Adiabatic Simulations
- Cluster Heating by Viscous Dissipation of Sound Waves
- Explaining the entropy excess in clusters and groups of galaxies without additional heating
- On the Origin of Intracluster Entropy
- A test suite for quantitative comparison of hydrodynamics codes in astrophysics
- The impact of mergers on relaxed X-ray clusters - II. Effects on global X-ray and SZ properties and their scaling relations
- Why Do Only Some Galaxy Clusters Have Cool Cores?
- The flip-side of galaxy formation: A combined model of Galaxy Formation and Cluster Heating
- An Observationally Motivated Framework for AGN Heating of Cluster Cores
- Cosmological simulations of the intracluster medium
- Towards a Holistic View of the Heating and Cooling of the Intracluster Medium
- Simulations of cosmic ray feedback by AGN in galaxy clusters
- Hydrodynamic simulations of merging clusters of galaxies
- Models of the ICM with Heating and Cooling: Explaining the Global and Structural X-ray Properties of Clusters
- Two--body heating in numerical galaxy formation experiments
- Entropy amplification from energy feedback in simulated galaxy groups and clusters
- Hydrodynamical adaptive mesh refinement simulations of turbulent flows - II. Cosmological simulations of galaxy clusters
- The impact of mergers on relaxed X-ray clusters - III. Effects on compact cool cores
- Physical viscosity in smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations of galaxy clusters
- Modelling Shock Heating in Cluster Mergers: I. Moving Beyond the Spherical Accretion Model
- Investigating Heating and Cooling in the BCS & B55 Cluster Samples
- The radial structure of galaxy groups and clusters
- Hot and Cooled baryons in SPH simulations of galaxy clusters: physics and numerics
- The influence of baryons on the mass distribution of dark matter halos
- Dynamical Friction and Cooling Flows in Galaxy Clusters
- Signatures of Galaxy Formation in the Intracluster Medium
- Testing Cold Dark Matter with the hierarchical buildup of stellar light
- Cosmological Simulations of the Preheating Scenario for Galaxy Cluster Formation: Comparison to Analytic Models and Observations
- A comparison of hydrodynamics techniques for modelling collisions between main sequence stars
Cited by in corpus (109)
- E pur si muove: Galiliean-invariant cosmological hydrodynamical simulations on a moving mesh
- A model for cosmological simulations of galaxy formation physics
- The universal galaxy cluster pressure profile from a representative sample of nearby systems (REXCESS) and the Y_SZ-M_500 relation
- The Aquila comparison Project: The Effects of Feedback and Numerical Methods on Simulations of Galaxy Formation
- Residual Gas Motions in the Intracluster Medium and Bias in Hydrostatic Measurements of Mass Profiles of Clusters
- Chaotic cold accretion onto black holes
- Simulating cosmic structure formation with the GADGET-4 code
- Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics in Astrophysics
- Towards a realistic population of simulated galaxy groups and clusters
- Self-regulated growth of supermassive black holes by a dual jet/heating AGN feedback mechanism: methods, tests and implications for cosmological simulations
- Gas entropy in a representative sample of nearby X-ray galaxy clusters (REXCESS): relationship to gas mass fraction
- Baryons Matter: Why Luminous Satellite Galaxies Have Reduced Central Masses
- Cosmological simulations of the formation of the stellar haloes around disc galaxies
- Nyx: A Massively Parallel AMR Code for Computational Cosmology
- On the Cluster Physics of Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Surveys I: The Influence of Feedback, Non-thermal Pressure and Cluster Shapes on Y-M Scaling Relations
- Lensing and X-ray mass estimates of clusters (SIMULATION)
- The Hydrangea simulations: galaxy formation in and around massive clusters
- The EAGLE simulations of galaxy formation: the importance of the hydrodynamics scheme
- Gas expulsion by quasar-driven winds as a solution to the over-cooling problem in galaxy groups and clusters
- Stirring Up the Pot: Can Cooling Flows In Galaxy Clusters Be Quenched By Gas Sloshing?
- Turbulent Motions and Shocks Waves in Galaxy Clusters simulated with AMR
- Mass Distribution in Galaxy Clusters: the Role of AGN Feedback
- Moving mesh cosmology: numerical techniques and global statistics
- Jet-regulated cooling catastrophe
- Massive and Refined. II. The statistical properties of turbulent motions in massive galaxy clusters with high spatial resolution
- Subsonic turbulence in smoothed particle hydrodynamics and moving-mesh simulations
- Following the flow: tracer particles in astrophysical fluid simulations
- Moving mesh cosmology: the hydrodynamics of galaxy formation
- Star formation quenching in simulated group and cluster galaxies: When, how, and why?
- Magnetic Field Amplification in Galaxy Clusters and its Simulation
- Hydrodynamical simulations of the galaxy population: enduring successes and outstanding challenges
- The distribution of atomic hydrogen in EAGLE galaxies: morphologies, profiles, and HI holes
- Moving mesh cosmology: characteristics of galaxies and haloes
- GAMER: a GPU-Accelerated Adaptive Mesh Refinement Code for Astrophysics
- A Parameter Space Exploration of Galaxy Cluster Mergers I: Gas Mixing and the Generation of Cluster Entropy
- Feeding compact bulges and supermassive black holes with low angular-momentum cosmic gas at high redshift
- Baryon Cycles in the Biggest Galaxies
- Evolution of shocks and turbulence in major cluster mergers
- A Comparison of Cosmological Codes: Properties of Thermal Gas and Shock Waves in Large Scale Structures
- Simulating Groups and the IntraGroup Medium: The Surprisingly Complex and Rich Middle Ground Between Clusters and Galaxies
- Large-scale inhomogeneities of the intracluster medium: improving mass estimates using the observed azimuthal scatter
- MHD Simulations of AGN Jets in a Dynamic Galaxy Cluster Medium
- nIFTy galaxy cluster simulations I: dark matter & non-radiative models
- Turbulence production and turbulent pressure support in the intergalactic medium
- Particle hydrodynamics with tessellation techniques
- Adaptively refined large eddy simulations of clusters
- Massive and refined: a sample of large galaxy clusters simulated at high resolution. I:Thermal gas and shock waves properties
- Free Form Lensing Implications for the Collision of Dark Matter and Gas in the Frontier Fields Cluster MACSJ0416.1-2403
- rpSPH: a novel Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Algorithm
- How AGN feedback and metal cooling shape cluster entropy profiles
- nIFTy galaxy cluster simulations II: radiative models
- Cosmic Rays or Turbulence can Suppress Cooling Flows (Where Thermal Heating or Momentum Injection Fail)
- The enrichment history of cosmic metals
- Calibrating an updated SPH scheme within GCD+
- Modelling injection and feedback of Cosmic Rays in grid-based cosmological simulations: effects on cluster outskirts
- Quasisteady Configurations of Conductive Intracluster Media
- Enriching the hot circumgalactic medium
- Rotation rates, sizes, and star formation efficiencies of a representative population of simulated disc galaxies
- nIFTy Galaxy Cluster simulations IV: Quantifying the Influence of Baryons on Halo Properties
- The origin of the enhanced metallicity of satellite galaxies
- AGN jet feedback on a moving mesh: gentle cluster heating by weak shocks and lobe disruption
- The impact of numerical viscosity in SPH simulations of galaxy clusters
- A Hydrodynamical Solution for the "Twin-Tailed" Colliding Galaxy Cluster "El Gordo"
- Thermal and non-thermal traces of AGN feedback: results from cosmological AMR simulations
- The scatter in the radial profiles of X-ray luminous galaxy clusters as diagnostic of the thermodynamical state of the ICM
- nIFTY galaxy cluster simulations III: The Similarity & Diversity of Galaxies & Subhaloes
- Fountains and storms: The role of AGN and mergers in disrupting the cool-core in the RomulusC simulation
- Hydrostatic mass estimates of massive galaxy clusters: a study with varying hydrodynamics flavours and non-thermal pressure support
- The Mixing and Transport Properties of the Intra Cluster Medium: a numerical study using tracers particles
- Galaxy cluster mergers
- Simulating the galaxy cluster "El Gordo" and identifying the merger configuration
- Convergence of AMR and SPH simulations - I. Hydrodynamical resolution and convergence tests
- Merging Galaxy Clusters: Offset Between the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect and X-ray Peaks
- Accurate tracer particles of baryon dynamics in the adaptive mesh refinement code Ramses
- Hybrid Cosmological Simulations with Stream Velocities
- The Megaparsec-scale Gas-sloshing Spiral in the Remnant Cool Core Cluster Abell 1763
- Offsets between the X-ray and the Sunyaev-Zel'dovich-effect peaks in merging galaxy clusters and their cosmological implications
- The formation of entropy cores in non-radiative galaxy cluster simulations: SPH versus AMR
- Hydrodynamic capabilities of an SPH code incorporating an artificial conductivity term with a gravity-based signal velocity
- Collisionless Stellar Hydrodynamics as an Efficient Alternative to N-body Methods
- The entropy core in galaxy clusters: numerical and physical effects in cosmological grid simulations
- Comparing Simulations of AGN Feedback
- A General Precipitation-Limited L_X-T-R Relation Among Early-Type Galaxies
- Estimate of the total mechanical feedback energy from galaxy cluster-centered black holes: implications for black hole evolution, cluster gas fraction and entropy
- Multi-Phenomena Modeling of the New Bullet Cluster, ZwCl008.8+52, using N-body/hydrodynamical Simulations
- A study of cool core resiliency and entropy mixing in simulations of galaxy cluster mergers
- Santa Barbara Cluster Comparison Test with DISPH
- A Parameter Space Exploration of Galaxy Cluster Mergers II: Effects of Magnetic Fields
- The role of the artificial conductivity in SPH simulations of galaxy clusters: effects on the ICM properties
- EAGLE-like simulation models do not solve the entropy core problem in groups and clusters of galaxies
- Evolution of Splashback Boundaries and Gaseous Outskirts: Insights from Mergers of Self-similar Galaxy Clusters
- Improved Performances in Subsonic Flows of an SPH Scheme with Gradients Estimated using an Integral Approach
- A parametric physical model for the intracluster medium and its use in joint SZ/X-ray analyses of galaxy clusters
- Chemo-dynamical simulations of dwarf galaxy evolution
- AGN feedback and entropy injection in galaxy cluster cores
- Simulating Hydrodynamics in Cosmology with CRK-HACC
- Gas stripping and mixing in galaxy clusters: A numerical comparison study
- Parameterization Effects in the analysis of AMI Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Observations
- Excess entropy and energy feedback from within cluster cores up to r
- Removal and mixing of the coronal gas from satellites in galaxy groups: cooling the intragoup gas
- On the Apparent Power Law in CDM Halo Pseudo Phase Space Density Profiles
- Little evidence for entropy and energy excess beyond - An end to ICM preheating?
- Correlations of the feedback energy and BCG radio luminosity in galaxy clusters
- CHEX-MATE: the intracluster medium entropy distribution in the gravity-dominated regime
- A first estimate of radio halo statistics from large-scale cosmological simulation
- Intracluster gas pressure, entropy injection and redshift evolution
- Jet interaction with galaxy cluster mergers
- Quasi-spiral solution to the mixed intracluster medium and the universal entropy profile of galaxy clusters
- Redshifted 21-cm Signals in the Dark Ages