nIFTY galaxy cluster simulations III: The Similarity & Diversity of Galaxies & Subhaloes

Abstract

We examine subhaloes and galaxies residing in a simulated LCDM galaxy cluster ($M_{200}^{\mathrm{crit}}=1.1\times 10^{15}{M}_{\odot }/h$) produced by hydrodynamical codes ranging from classic Smooth Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH), newer SPH codes, adaptive and moving mesh codes. These codes use subgrid models to capture galaxy formation physics. We compare how well these codes reproduce the same subhaloes/galaxies in gravity only, non-radiative hydrodynamics and full feedback physics runs by looking at the overall subhalo/galaxy distribution and on an individual objects basis. We find the subhalo population is reproduced to within $\lesssim 10\%$ for both dark matter only and non-radiative runs, with individual objects showing code-to-code scatter of $\lesssim 0.1$ dex, although the gas in non-radiative simulations shows significant scatter. Including feedback physics significantly increases the diversity. Subhalo mass and $V_{max}$ distributions vary by $\approx 20\%$. The galaxy populations also show striking code-to-code variations. Although the Tully-Fisher relation is similar in almost all codes, the number of galaxies with $10^9{M}_{\odot }/h\lesssim M_{\ast }\lesssim 10^{12}{M}_{\odot }/h$ can differ by a factor of 4. Individual galaxies show code-to-code scatter of $\sim 0.5$ dex in stellar mass. Moreover, strong systematic differences exist, with some codes producing galaxies $70\%$ smaller than others. The diversity partially arises from the inclusion/absence of AGN feedback. Our results combined with our companion papers demonstrate that subgrid physics is not just subject to fine-tuning, but the complexity of building galaxies in all environments remains a challenge. We argue even basic galaxy properties, such as the stellar mass to halo mass, should be treated with errors bars of $\sim 0.2-0.4$ dex.

17 pages (+4 page appendix), 16 figures, 2 tables; accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (22)

• The EAGLE project: Simulating the evolution and assembly of galaxies and their environments
• The EAGLE simulations of galaxy formation: calibration of subgrid physics and model variations
• Properties of galaxies reproduced by a hydrodynamic simulation
• The effect of photo-ionization on the cooling rates of enriched, astrophysical plasmas
• A unified model for AGN feedback in cosmological simulations of structure formation
• Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics and Magnetohydrodynamics
• A New Calculation of the Ionizing Background Spectrum and the Effects of HeII Reionization
• Chemical enrichment in cosmological, smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations
• The Illustris simulation: the evolving population of black holes across cosmic time
• Mass, Metal, and Energy Feedback in Cosmological Simulations
• The 2013 Release of Cloudy
• Chemical enrichment of galaxy clusters from hydrodynamical simulations
• Cool Core Clusters from Cosmological Simulations
• A refined sub-grid model for black hole accretion and AGN feedback in large cosmological simulations
• A test suite for quantitative comparison of hydrodynamics codes in astrophysics
• The GALEX Ultraviolet Virgo Cluster Survey (GUViCS). IV: The role of the cluster environment on galaxy evolution
• On the Origin of Cores in Simulated Galaxy Clusters
• The Cosmic Code Comparison Project
• The Argo Simulation: I. Quenching of Massive Galaxies at High Redshift as a Result of Cosmological Starvation
• The SAMI Galaxy Survey: Towards a unified dynamical scaling relation for galaxies of all types
• Cosmological simulations of galaxy clusters with feedback from active galactic nuclei: profiles and scaling relations
• Subhaloes gone Notts: Spin across subhaloes and finders

Cited by in corpus (31)

• The Three Hundred project: a large catalogue of theoretically modelled galaxy clusters for cosmological and astrophysical applications
• Introducing RomulusC: A Cosmological Simulation of a Galaxy Cluster with Unprecedented Resolution
• Hunting for Galaxies and Halos in simulations with VELOCIraptor
• \textsc{The Three Hundred} project: The \textsc{Gizmo-Simba} run
• How baryons affect halos and large-scale structure: a unified picture from the Simba simulation
• Return to [Log-]Normalcy: Rethinking Quenching, The Star Formation Main Sequence, and Perhaps Much More
• SZE Observables, Pressure Profiles and Center Offsets in Magneticum Simulation Galaxy Clusters
• Mapping and characterisation of cosmic filaments in galaxy cluster outskirts: strategies and forecasts for observations from simulations
• Black hole feeding and feedback: the physics inside the "subgrid"
• nIFTy galaxy cluster simulations II: radiative models
• How does our choice of observable influence our estimation of the centre of a galaxy cluster? Insights from cosmological simulations
• Introducing a new, robust galaxy finder algorithm for simulations
• The Three Hundred Project: Ram pressure and gas content of haloes and subhaloes in the phase-space plane
• Accurate mass and velocity functions of dark matter halos
• nIFTy Galaxy Cluster simulations IV: Quantifying the Influence of Baryons on Halo Properties
• Stellar Property Statistics of Massive Halos from Cosmological Hydrodynamics Simulations: Common Kernel Shapes
• Climbing Halo Merger Trees with TreeFrog
• The Three Hundred Project: The influence of environment on simulated galaxy properties
• The Star Formation Histories of Disk Galaxies: the Live, the Dead, and the Undead
• Constraining the halo mass function with observations
• Galaxy clusters in simulations of the local Universe: a matter of constraints
• The Three Hundred: Cluster Dynamical States and Relaxation Time Scale
• nIFTy galaxy cluster simulations V: Investigation of the Cluster Infall Region
• The AGORA High-resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project. V: Satellite Galaxy Populations In A Cosmological Zoom-in Simulation of A Milky Way-mass Halo
• The Three Hundred Project: The gas disruption of infalling objects in cluster environments
• On the coherent rotation of diffuse matter in numerical simulations of galaxy clusters
• Virgo: an unlikely cluster of galaxies because of its environment
• Reionization time of the Local Group and Local-Group-like halo pairs
• The Formation of a Milky Way-sized Disk Galaxy 1. A Comparison of Numerical Methods
• The Three Hundred Project: The stellar angular momentum evolution of cluster galaxies
• Dark Matter Annihilation Feedback in Cosmological Simulations II: The Influence on Gas and Halo Structure