Moving mesh cosmology: numerical techniques and global statistics
arXiv:1109.1281 · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2966.2012.21590.x
Abstract
We present the first hydrodynamical simulations of structure formation using the new moving mesh code AREPO and compare the results with GADGET simulations based on a traditional smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) technique. The two codes share the same Tree-PM gravity solver and include identical sub-resolution physics, but employ different methods to solve the equations of hydrodynamics. This allows us to assess the impact of hydro-solver uncertainties on the results of cosmological studies of galaxy formation. We focus on predictions for global baryon statistics, such as the cosmic star formation rate density, after we introduce our simulation suite and numerical methods. Properties of individual galaxies and haloes are examined by Keres et al. (2011), while a third paper by Sijacki et al. (2011) uses idealised simulations to analyse the differences between the hydrodynamical schemes. We find that the global baryon statistics differ significantly between the two simulation approaches. AREPO shows higher star formation rates at late times, lower mean temperatures, and different gas mass fractions in characteristic phases of the intergalactic medium, in particular a reduced amount of hot gas. Although both codes use the same implementation of cooling, more gas cools out of haloes in AREPO compared with GADGET towards low redshifts. We show that this is caused by a higher heating rate with SPH in the outer parts of haloes, owing to viscous dissipation of SPH's inherent sonic velocity noise and SPH's efficient damping of subsonic turbulence injected in the halo infall region, and because of a higher efficiency of gas stripping in AREPO. As a result of such differences, AREPO leads also to more disk-like morphologies compared to GADGET. Our results indicate that inaccuracies in hydrodynamic solvers can lead to comparatively large systematic differences.
arXiv comment35 pages, 28 figures, MNRAS accepted. Added discussion about generic issues with SPH. Volume-rendering movies and high-resolution images can be found at http://www.cfa.harvard.edu/itc/research/movingmeshcosmology
References in corpus (110)
- Measurements of Omega and Lambda from 42 High-Redshift Supernovae
- A Universal Density Profile from Hierarchical Clustering
- Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
- The Structure of Cold Dark Matter Halos
- The cosmological simulation code GADGET-2
- The Global Schmidt Law in Star Forming Galaxies
- Simulating the joint evolution of quasars, galaxies and their large-scale distribution
- Particle Dark Matter: Evidence, Candidates and Constraints
- The many lives of active galactic nuclei: cooling flows, black holes and the luminosities and colours of galaxies
- Energy input from quasars regulates the growth and activity of black holes and their host galaxies
- Dark Matter Substructure in Galactic Halos
- E pur si muove: Galiliean-invariant cosmological hydrodynamical simulations on a moving mesh
- Statistical Properties of X-ray Clusters: Analytic and Numerical Comparisons
- Cosmological SPH simulations: A hybrid multi-phase model for star formation
- Modeling feedback from stars and black holes in galaxy mergers
- Cosmological Hydrodynamics with Adaptive Mesh Refinement: a new high resolution code called RAMSES
- The Aquarius Project: the subhalos of galactic halos
- Baryon Acoustic Oscillations in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7 Galaxy Sample
- Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Likelihoods and Parameters from the WMAP data
- Gasdynamics and Starbursts in Major Mergers
- Mass function of dark matter halos
- From dwarf spheroidals to cDs: Simulating the galaxy population in a LCDM cosmology
- Substructures in hydrodynamical cluster simulations
- At the heart of the matter: the origin of bulgeless dwarf galaxies and Dark Matter cores
- Cosmological Simulations with TreeSPH
- Halos and galaxies in the standard cosmological model: results from the Bolshoi simulation
- Constraining Warm Dark Matter candidates including sterile neutrinos and light gravitinos with WMAP and the Lyman-alpha forest
- Cosmological SPH simulations: The entropy equation
- Power Spectra for Cold Dark Matter and its Variants
- Resolving the Structure of Cold Dark Matter Halos
- A unified model for AGN feedback in cosmological simulations of structure formation
- Clumps and streams in the local dark matter distribution
- The physics driving the cosmic star formation history
- The Diversity and Similarity of Simulated Cold Dark Matter Halos
- Baryons in the Warm-Hot Intergalactic Medium
- Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics and Magnetohydrodynamics
- A New Calculation of the Ionizing Background Spectrum and the Effects of HeII Reionization
- Chemical enrichment in cosmological, smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations
- The age dependence of halo clustering
- Fundamental differences between SPH and grid methods
- Forming Disk Galaxies in Lambda CDM Simulations
- The history of star formation in a LCDM universe
- Direct cosmological simulations of the growth of black holes and galaxies
- A primer on hierarchical galaxy formation: the semi-analytical approach
- Forming Realistic Late-Type Spirals in a LCDM Universe: The Eris Simulation
- The Nature of Galaxy Bias and Clustering
- The Santa Barbara cluster comparison project: a comparison of cosmological hydrodynamics solutions
- The Low Redshift Lyman Alpha Forest in Cold Dark Matter Cosmologies
- The Aquila comparison Project: The Effects of Feedback and Numerical Methods on Simulations of Galaxy Formation
- Formation of a spiral galaxy in a major merger
- The Lyman-alpha Forest in the Cold Dark Matter Model
- Statistical Properties of Collisionless Equal- and Unequal-Mass Merger Remnants of Disk Galaxies
- Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics in Astrophysics
- Modelling discontinuities and Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities in SPH
- Kinematic Structure of Merger Remnants
- Turbulent gas motions in galaxy cluster simulations: The role of SPH viscosity
- Galacticus: A Semi-Analytic Model of Galaxy Formation
- Galaxy Formation Theory
- Constrained Simulations of the Magnetic Field in the Local Universe and the Propagation of UHECRs
- Inviscid SPH
- Probing Turbulence in the Coma Galaxy Cluster
- Thin, thick and dark discs in LCDM
- The formation of disc galaxies in a LCDM universe
- Effects of Supernova Feedback on the Formation of Galaxy Disks
- Dissipation and Extra Light in Galactic Nuclei: IV. Evolution in the Scaling Relations of Spheroids
- Galaxies-Intergalactic Medium Interaction Calculation --I. Galaxy formation as a function of large-scale environment
- Dissipation and Extra Light in Galactic Nuclei: II. 'Cusp' Ellipticals
- Detecting shock waves in cosmological smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations
- The Risetime of Nearby Type Ia Supernovae
- Disk Galaxy Formation in a LambdaCDM Universe
- Reformulation of Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics with Riemann Solver
- Phase-space structure in the local dark matter distribution and its signature in direct detection experiments
- There's no place like home? Statistics of Milky Way-mass dark matter halos
- Substructure depletion in the Milky Way halo by the disk
- Turbulent Motions and Shocks Waves in Galaxy Clusters simulated with AMR
- Simulations of AGN feedback in galaxy clusters and groups: impact on gas fractions and the Lx-T scaling relation
- Cosmic ray feedback in hydrodynamical simulations of galaxy formation
- Comparing AMR and SPH Cosmological Simulations: I. Dark Matter & Adiabatic Simulations
- Subsonic turbulence in smoothed particle hydrodynamics and moving-mesh simulations
- Damped Lyman-alpha and Lyman Limit Absorbers in the Cold Dark Matter Model
- Resolving mixing in Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics
- Dissipation and Extra Light in Galactic Nuclei: I. Gas-Rich Merger Remnants
- Thermal Conduction in Simulated Galaxy Clusters
- A test suite for quantitative comparison of hydrodynamics codes in astrophysics
- Dissipation and Extra Light in Galactic Nuclei: III. 'Core' Ellipticals and 'Missing' Light
- Galaxy Clustering and Galaxy Bias in a Lambda-CDM Universe
- SPHS: Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics with a higher order dissipation switch
- A simulation of galaxy formation and clustering
- Metal Cooling in Simulations of Cosmic Structure Formation
- The growth of galaxies in cosmological simulations of structure formation
- On the Origin of Cores in Simulated Galaxy Clusters
- The Cosmic Code Comparison Project
- The fine-grained phase-space structure of Cold Dark Matter halos
- Streams and caustics: the fine-grained structure of LCDM haloes
- Thermal conduction in cosmological SPH simulations
- Cosmological AMR MHD with Enzo
- Cosmological and astrophysical constraints from the Lyman-alpha forest flux probability distribution function
- Quasi-Resonant Theory of Tidal Interactions
- Turbulence production and turbulent pressure support in the intergalactic medium
- A High-resolution Adaptive Moving Mesh Hydrodynamic Algorithm
- Particle hydrodynamics with tessellation techniques
- Massive galaxies & EROs at z=1-3 in cosmological hydrodynamic simulations: near-IR properties
- rpSPH: a novel Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Algorithm
- Hydrodynamic simulations with the Godunov SPH
- The impact of numerical viscosity in SPH simulations of galaxy clusters
- Numerical Simulations of the Lyman-alpha forest - A comparison of Gadget-2 and Enzo
- RADAMESH: Cosmological Radiative Transfer for Adaptive Mesh Refinement Simulations
- Simulations of galaxy formation with radiative transfer: Hydrogen reionization and radiative feedback
- Particle Methods in Astrophysical Fluid Dynamics
- A comparison of hydrodynamics techniques for modelling collisions between main sequence stars
Cited by in corpus (165)
- Introducing the Illustris Project: Simulating the coevolution of dark and visible matter in the Universe
- Galaxies on FIRE (Feedback In Realistic Environments): Stellar Feedback Explains Cosmologically Inefficient Star Formation
- Physical Models of Galaxy Formation in a Cosmological Framework
- Properties of galaxies reproduced by a hydrodynamic simulation
- Simulating galaxy formation with black hole driven thermal and kinetic feedback
- GIZMO: A New Class of Accurate, Mesh-Free Hydrodynamic Simulation Methods
- FIRE-2 Simulations: Physics versus Numerics in Galaxy Formation
- Introducing the Illustris Project: the evolution of galaxy populations across cosmic time
- A model for cosmological simulations of galaxy formation physics
- The merger rate of galaxies in the Illustris Simulation: a comparison with observations and semi-empirical models
- The Illustris simulation: the evolving population of black holes across cosmic time
- The Illustris Simulation: Public Data Release
- The Arepo public code release
- A General Class of Lagrangian Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Methods and Implications for Fluid Mixing Problems
- The Connection between Galaxies and Dark Matter Structures in the Local Universe
- The Impact of Baryonic Physics on the Structure of Dark Matter Halos: the View from the FIRE Cosmological Simulations
- Improving the convergence properties of the moving-mesh code AREPO
- Moving mesh cosmology: tracing cosmological gas accretion
- The formation of disc galaxies in high resolution moving-mesh cosmological simulations
- A physical model for cosmological simulations of galaxy formation: multi-epoch validation
- Simulations of magnetic fields in isolated disk galaxies
- Star Formation in Galaxy Mergers with Realistic Models of Stellar Feedback & the Interstellar Medium
- AGN-driven quenching of star formation: morphological and dynamical implications for early-type galaxies
- Double-Disk Dark Matter
- The Formation of Massive, Compact Galaxies at z=2 in the Illustris Simulation
- The star formation main sequence and stellar mass assembly of galaxies in the Illustris simulation
- Galaxy pairs in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey - VI. The orbital extent of enhanced star formation in interacting galaxies
- On the Cluster Physics of Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Surveys I: The Influence of Feedback, Non-thermal Pressure and Cluster Shapes on Y-M Scaling Relations
- Hydrodynamics of circumbinary accretion: Angular momentum transfer and binary orbital evolution
- Introducing the THESAN project: radiation-magnetohydrodynamic simulations of the epoch of reionization
- The Bimodal Metallicity Distribution of the Cool Circumgalactic Medium at z<1
- Star formation sustained by gas accretion
- Submillimetre galaxies in a hierarchical universe: number counts, redshift distribution, and implications for the IMF
- Galaxy Morphology and Star Formation in the Illustris Simulation at z=0
- Simulating cosmic ray physics on a moving mesh
- The impact of feedback on cosmological gas accretion
- The COS/UVES Absorption Survey of the Magellanic Stream. III: Ionization, Total Mass, and Inflow Rate onto the Milky Way
- Following the flow: tracer particles in astrophysical fluid simulations
- Dust Formation in Milky Way-like Galaxies
- Simulations of ram-pressure stripping in galaxy-cluster interactions
- Stellar Feedback & Bulge Formation in Clumpy Disks
- Simulating the dust content of galaxies: successes and failures
- Simulating the interstellar medium and stellar feedback on a moving mesh: Implementation and isolated galaxies
- Synthetic Galaxy Images and Spectra from the Illustris Simulation
- Effect of baryonic feedback on two- and three-point shear statistics: prospects for detection and improved modelling
- Moving mesh cosmology: characteristics of galaxies and haloes
- The environment of bright QSOs at z ~ 6: Star forming galaxies and X-ray emission
- Hot X-ray coronae around massive spiral galaxies: a unique probe of structure formation models
- How to distinguish starbursts and quiescently star-forming galaxies: The `bimodal' submillimetre galaxy population as a case study
- Shape of Dark Matter Haloes in the Illustris Simulation: Effects of Baryons
- Should we believe the results of UV-mm galaxy SED modelling?
- Moving Mesh Cosmology: Properties of Gas Disks
- The Properties of Low Redshift Intergalactic O VI Absorbers Determined from High S/N Observations of 14 QSOs with the Cosmic Origins Spectrograph
- AREPO-RT: Radiation hydrodynamics on a moving mesh
- Simulating galactic dust grain evolution on a moving mesh
- A Quantification of the Butterfly Effect in Cosmological Simulations and Implications for Galaxy Scaling Relations
- Zooming in on accretion - I. The structure of halo gas
- Hot gas in massive halos drives both mass quenching and environment quenching
- The Diversity and Variability of Star Formation Histories in Models of Galaxy Evolution
- Supernova feedback in numerical simulations of galaxy formation: separating physics from numerics
- The Impact of Galactic Feedback on the Circumgalactic Medium
- Numerical Convergence in Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics
- Simulating the interaction of jets with the intra-cluster medium
- Galaxy mergers on a moving mesh: a comparison with smoothed-particle hydrodynamics
- Instability of Supersonic Cold Streams Feeding Galaxies IV: Survival of Radiatively Cooling Streams
- Disruption of giant molecular clouds and formation of bound star clusters under the influence of momentum stellar feedback
- A fully cosmological model of a Monoceros-like ring
- Galaxy gas as obscurer: II. Separating the galaxy-scale and nuclear obscurers of Active Galactic Nuclei
- Galaxies in the Illustris simulation as seen by the Sloan Digital Sky Survey - II: Size-luminosity relations and the deficit of bulge-dominated galaxies in Illustris at low mass
- On the Assembly of Dwarf Galaxies in Clusters and their Efficient Formation of Globular Clusters
- Large-scale mass distribution in the Illustris simulation
- On the OVI Abundance in the Circumgalactic Medium of Low-Redshift Galaxies
- Intrinsic Alignments of Galaxies in the Illustris Simulation
- The unorthodox evolution of major merger remnants into star-forming spiral galaxies
- Shock finding on a moving-mesh: I. Shock statistics in non-radiative cosmological simulations
- Detection of a luminous hot X-ray corona around the massive spiral galaxy NGC266
- Hot Gaseous Coronae around Spiral Galaxies: Probing the Illustris Simulation
- Instability of Supersonic Cold Streams Feeding Galaxies I: Linear Kelvin-Helmholtz Instability with Body Modes
- Physical properties of simulated galaxy populations at z=2 - I. Effect of metal-line cooling and feedback from star formation and AGN
- Semi-implicit anisotropic cosmic ray transport on an unstructured moving mesh
- Probing the Hot X-ray Corona around the Massive Spiral Galaxy, NGC 6753, Using Deep XMM-Newton observations
- The formation of hot gaseous haloes around galaxies
- Resolving The Generation of Starburst Winds in Galaxy Mergers
- The Impact of Galactic Winds on the Angular Momentum of Disk Galaxies in the Illustris Simulation
- Using 3D Voronoi grids in radiative transfer simulations
- Stellar feedback by radiation pressure and photoionization
- Shapley Supercluster Survey: Ram-Pressure Stripping vs. Tidal Interactions in the Shapley Supercluster
- Moving mesh cosmology: properties of neutral hydrogen in absorption
- Instability of Supersonic Cold Streams Feeding Galaxies III: Kelvin-Helmholtz Instability in Three Dimensions
- Cosmological Zoom Simulations of z = 2 Galaxies: The Impact of Galactic Outflows
- The merger and assembly histories of Milky Way- and M31-like galaxies with TNG50: disk survival through mergers
- Subhalo Demographics in the Illustris Simulation: Effects of Baryons and Halo-to-Halo Variation
- Simulating the interstellar medium of galaxies with radiative transfer, non-equilibrium thermochemistry, and dust
- A Versatile Family of Galactic Wind Models
- A purely hyperbolic discontinuous Galerkin approach for self-gravitating gas dynamics
- Hydrodynamical moving-mesh simulations of the tidal disruption of stars by supermassive black holes
- A discontinuous Galerkin method for solving the fluid and MHD equations in astrophysical simulations
- Thermal instabilities in cooling galactic coronae: fuelling star formation in galactic discs
- Rotation rates, sizes, and star formation efficiencies of a representative population of simulated disc galaxies
- Increasing blackhole feedback induced quenching with anisotropic thermal conduction
- Resolving flows around black holes: numerical technique and applications
- Diffuse gas properties and stellar metallicities in cosmological simulations of disc galaxy formation
- Fully cosmological virtual massive galaxies at z=0: kinematical, morphological, and stellar population characterisation
- Modelling the Transfer Function for the Dark Energy Survey
- A comparison of black hole growth in galaxy mergers with Gasoline and Ramses
- Accretion Does Not Drive the Turbulence in Galactic Disks
- Magnetized Moving Mesh Merger of a Carbon-Oxygen White Dwarf Binary
- The High-Ion Content and Kinematics of Low-Redshift Lyman Limit Systems
- Galaxies in the Illustris simulation as seen by the Sloan Digital Sky Survey - I: Bulge+disc decompositions, methods, and biases
- Voronoi volume function: A new probe of cosmology and galaxy evolution
- Shock finding on a moving-mesh: II. Hydrodynamic shocks in the Illustris universe
- Ly Blobs from Cold Streams Undergoing Kelvin-Helmholtz Instabilities
- Stellar orbit evolution in close circumstellar disc encounters
- Accurately simulating anisotropic thermal conduction on a moving mesh
- How Environment Affects Galaxy Metallicity through Stripping and Formation History: Lessons from the Illustris Simulation
- The Effect Of AGN Heating On The Low-Redshift Lyα Forest
- Gas Accretion onto the Milky Way
- The morphology and kinematics of the gaseous circumgalactic medium of Milky Way mass galaxies -- II. comparison of IllustrisTNG and Illustris simulation results
- SEAGLE - I: A pipeline for simulating and modeling strong lenses from cosmological hydrodynamic simulations
- Simulated Galaxy Interactions as Probes of Merger Spectral Energy Distributions
- Simulating the effect of photoheating feedback during reionization
- Simulated star formation rate functions at z~4-7, and the role of feedback in high-z galaxies
- Empirical Constraints for the Magnitude and Composition of Galactic Winds
- Discriminating Topology in Galaxy Distributions using Network Analysis
- Black hole clustering and duty cycles in the Illustris simulation
- The imprint of dark matter haloes on the size and velocity dispersion evolution of early-type galaxies
- From EMBER to FIRE: predicting high resolution baryon fields from dark matter simulations with Deep Learning
- The scattering of FRBs by the intergalactic medium: variations, strength and dependence on dispersion measures
- EAGLE-Auriga: effects of different subgrid models on the baryon cycle around Milky Way-mass galaxies
- The formation and evolution of star clusters in interacting galaxies
- Dust properties of Lyman break galaxies in cosmological simulations
- Comparing Simulations of AGN Feedback
- Planet-disc interaction on a freely moving mesh
- The moving mesh code Shadowfax
- Efficient long-range AGN feedback affects the low redshift Lyman- forest
- The low redshift Lyman- Forest as a constraint for models of AGN feedback
- The MUSE Hubble Ultra Deep Field Survey XVI. The angular momentum of low-mass star-forming galaxies. A cautionary tale and insights from TNG50
- Cosmic Star Formation: a simple model of the SFRD(z)
- The Robustness of Cosmological Hydrodynamic Simulation Predictions to Changes in Numerics and Cooling Physics
- The Supersonic Project: To cool or not to cool Supersonically Induced Gas Objects (SIGOs)?
- Galactic Habitability Re-Examined: Indications of Bimodality
- The magnetised and thermally unstable tails of jellyfish galaxies
- The impact of magnetic fields on cosmological galaxy mergers -- II. Modified angular momentum transport and feedback
- Novel Conservative Methods for Adaptive Force Softening in Collisionless and Multi-Species N-Body Simulations
- Simulating cold shear flows on a moving mesh
- Direct Collapse to Supermassive Black Hole Seeds: Comparing the AMR and SPH Approaches
- Cosmological interpretation of the color-magnitude diagrams of galaxy clusters
- Gas Cooling in Hydrodynamic Simulations with An Exact Time Integration Scheme
- Detecting the Cosmic Web: Lyα Emission from Simulated Filaments at z=3
- Implications of galaxy buildup for putative IMF variations in massive galaxies
- Removal and mixing of the coronal gas from satellites in galaxy groups: cooling the intragoup gas
- High-Frequency Voronoi Noise Reduced by Smoothed Mesh Motion
- On the Origin of High-velocity Clouds in the Galaxy
- The Formation of a Milky Way-sized Disk Galaxy 1. A Comparison of Numerical Methods
- Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Physically Reconsidered -- The Relation to Explicit Large Eddy Simulation and the Issue of Particle Duality
- From Gas to Stars Over Cosmic Time
- Implicit Molecular Stresses in Weakly-Compressible Particle-Based Discretization Methods for Fluid Flow
- CRexit: how different cosmic ray transport modes affect thermal instability in the circumgalactic medium
- Complexity Phenomena and ROMA of the Magnetospheric Cusp, Hydrodynamic Turbulence, and the Cosmic Web
- High-redshift AGN population in radiation-hydrodynamics simulations
- Comparing energy and entropy formulations for cosmic ray hydrodynamics
- Soft X-ray line emission from hot gas in intervening galaxy halos and diffuse gas in the cosmic web
- A New Model For Including Galactic Winds in Simulations of Galaxy Formation II: Implementation of PhEW in Cosmological Simulations
- Evidence on the incompatibility of smoothed particle hydrodynamics and eddy viscosity models for large eddy simulations
- Structure Formation under Inelastic Two-Component Dark Matter: Halo Statistics and Matter Power Spectra in the High- Universe