Galaxy mergers on a moving mesh: a comparison with smoothed-particle hydrodynamics
arXiv:1309.2942 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stu957
Abstract
Galaxy mergers have been investigated for decades using smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH), but recent work highlighting inaccuracies inherent in the traditional SPH technique calls into question the reliability of previous studies. We explore this issue by comparing a suite of Gadget-3 SPH simulations of idealised (i.e., non-cosmological) isolated discs and galaxy mergers with otherwise identical calculations performed using the moving-mesh code Arepo. When black hole (BH) accretion and active galactic nucleus (AGN) feedback are not included, the star formation histories (SFHs) obtained from the two codes agree well. When BHs are included, the code- and resolution-dependent variations in the SFHs are more significant, but the agreement is still good, and the stellar mass formed over the course of a simulation is robust to variations in the numerical method. During a merger, the gas morphology and phase structure are initially similar prior to the starburst phase. However, once a hot gaseous halo has formed from shock heating and AGN feedback (when included), the agreement is less good. In particular, during the post-starburst phase, the SPH simulations feature more prominent hot gaseous haloes and spurious clumps, whereas with Arepo, gas clumps and filaments are less apparent and the hot halo gas can cool more efficiently. We discuss the origin of these differences and explain why the SPH technique yields trustworthy results for some applications (such as the idealised isolated disc and galaxy merger simulations presented here) but not others (e.g., gas flows onto galaxies in cosmological hydrodynamical simulations).
arXiv commentAccepted for publication in MNRAS. Appendix moved into main text and additional tests added. Conclusions unchanged. 26 pages, 17 figures
References in corpus (118)
- The cosmological simulation code GADGET-2
- The Global Schmidt Law in Star Forming Galaxies
- A Fundamental Relation Between Supermassive Black Holes and Their Host Galaxies
- A Relationship Between Nuclear Black Hole Mass and Galaxy Velocity Dispersion
- Energy input from quasars regulates the growth and activity of black holes and their host galaxies
- E pur si muove: Galiliean-invariant cosmological hydrodynamical simulations on a moving mesh
- Cosmological SPH simulations: A hybrid multi-phase model for star formation
- Modeling feedback from stars and black holes in galaxy mergers
- A Unified, Merger-Driven Model for the Origin of Starbursts, Quasars, the Cosmic X-Ray Background, Supermassive Black Holes and Galaxy Spheroids
- Gasdynamics and Starbursts in Major Mergers
- GADGET: A code for collisionless and gasdynamical cosmological simulations
- Minor mergers and the size evolution of elliptical galaxies
- A model for cosmological simulations of galaxy formation physics
- Cosmological SPH simulations: The entropy equation
- Black holes in galaxy mergers: The formation of red elliptical galaxies
- Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics and Magnetohydrodynamics
- Gasoline: An adaptable implementation of TreeSPH
- Fundamental differences between SPH and grid methods
- Black Holes in Galaxy Mergers: Evolution of Quasars
- How Do Disks Survive Mergers?
- A Merger-Driven Scenario for Cosmological Disk Galaxy Formation
- The effect of galaxy mass ratio on merger--driven starbursts
- Self-Regulated Star Formation in Galaxies via Momentum Input from Massive Stars
- Star formation efficiency in galaxy interactions and mergers: a statistical study
- The Aquila comparison Project: The Effects of Feedback and Numerical Methods on Simulations of Galaxy Formation
- Formation of a spiral galaxy in a major merger
- The Lyman-alpha Forest in the Cold Dark Matter Model
- Statistical Properties of Collisionless Equal- and Unequal-Mass Merger Remnants of Disk Galaxies
- The Major and Minor Galaxy Merger Rates at z < 1.5
- Size evolution of the most massive galaxies at 1.7<z<3 from GOODS NICMOS survey imaging
- A General Class of Lagrangian Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Methods and Implications for Fluid Mixing Problems
- Formation of gas disks in merging galaxies
- Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics in Astrophysics
- Modelling discontinuities and Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities in SPH
- The Lyman Alpha Forest from Gravitational Collapse in the CDM+Lambda Model
- Kinematic Structure of Merger Remnants
- Moving mesh cosmology: tracing cosmological gas accretion
- Galaxy mergers with various mass ratios: properties of remnants
- Feedback in simulations of disc-galaxy major mergers
- A physical model for cosmological simulations of galaxy formation: multi-epoch validation
- Properties of Early-Type, Dry Galaxy Mergers and the Origin of Massive Elliptical Galaxies
- GRAPE-SPH Chemodynamical Simulation of Elliptical Galaxies I: Evolution of Metallicity Gradients
- Star Formation in Galaxy Mergers with Realistic Models of Stellar Feedback & the Interstellar Medium
- The AGORA High-Resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project
- On the frequency, intensity and duration of starburst episodes triggered by galaxy interactions and mergers
- Multiple minor mergers: formation of elliptical galaxies and constraints for the growth of spiral disks
- Hydrodynamics of high-redshift galaxy collisions: From gas-rich disks to dispersion-dominated mergers and compact spheroids
- The driving mechanism of starbursts in galaxy mergers
- The influence of gas on the structure of merger remnants
- How do minor mergers promote inside-out growth of ellipticals, transforming the size, density profile and dark matter fraction?
- A Multi-Species Model for Hydrogen and Helium Absorbers in Lyman-Alpha Forest Clouds
- Direct Formation of Supermassive Black Holes via Multi-Scale Gas Inflows in Galaxy Mergers
- Equal- and unequal-mass mergers of disk and elliptical galaxies with black holes
- Galaxy Mergers and the Mass-Metallicity Relation: Evidence for Nuclear Metal Dilution and Flattened Gradients from Numerical Simulations
- The Metallicity Evolution of Interacting Galaxies
- The Evolution of the M-sigma Relation
- What Does a Submillimeter Galaxy Selection Actually Select? The Dependence of Submillimeter Flux Density on Star Formation Rate and Dust Mass
- Submillimetre galaxies in a hierarchical universe: number counts, redshift distribution, and implications for the IMF
- The Atlas3D Project - VI. Simulations of binary galaxy mergers and the link with Fast Rotators, Slow Rotators, and Kinematically Distinct Cores
- Moving mesh cosmology: numerical techniques and global statistics
- Comparing AMR and SPH Cosmological Simulations: I. Dark Matter & Adiabatic Simulations
- A Density Independent Formulation of Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics
- Astrophysical Smooth Particle Hydrodynamics
- A Theoretical Interpretation of the Black Hole Fundamental Plane
- The Formation of High Redshift Submillimeter Galaxies
- Multiphase Smoothed-Particle Hydrodynamics
- Subsonic turbulence in smoothed particle hydrodynamics and moving-mesh simulations
- On Sizes, Kinematics, M/L Gradients, and Light Profiles of Massive Compact Galaxies at z~2
- Damped Lyman-alpha and Lyman Limit Absorbers in the Cold Dark Matter Model
- Resolving mixing in Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics
- Dissipation and Extra Light in Galactic Nuclei: I. Gas-Rich Merger Remnants
- Moving mesh cosmology: the hydrodynamics of galaxy formation
- Following the flow: tracer particles in astrophysical fluid simulations
- Gamma-Rays from Intergalactic Shocks
- A Physical Model for z~2 Dust Obscured Galaxies
- Fate of Supermassive Black Holes and Evolution of the M(BH)-sigma Relation in Merging Galaxies: The Effect of Gaseous Dissipation
- Luminosity-Dependent Quasar Lifetimes: A New Interpretation of the Quasar Luminosity Function
- The line of sight velocity distributions of simulated merger remnants
- SPHS: Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics with a higher order dissipation switch
- Hydrodynamics of galaxy mergers with supermassive black holes: is there a last parsec problem ?
- Galaxy Mergers and Dark Matter Halo Mergers in LCDM: Mass, Redshift, and Mass-Ratio Dependence
- Moving mesh cosmology: characteristics of galaxies and haloes
- The Cosmic Code Comparison Project
- K+A Galaxies as the Aftermath of Gas-Rich Mergers: Simulating the Evolution of Galaxies as Seen by Spectroscopic Surveys
- On the survival of metallicity gradients to major dry-mergers
- Evolution of the mass, size, and star formation rate in high-redshift merging galaxies MIRAGE - A new sample of simulations with detailed stellar feedback
- Angular momentum transport and disk morphology in SPH simulations of galaxy formation
- How to distinguish starbursts and quiescently star-forming galaxies: The `bimodal' submillimetre galaxy population as a case study
- Moving Mesh Cosmology: Properties of Gas Disks
- The Origins of AGN Obscuration: The 'Torus' as a Dynamical, Unstable Driver of Accretion
- Generating Hot Gas in Simulations of Disk-Galaxy Major Mergers
- X-ray Emission from Hot Gas in Galaxy Mergers
- The Star-Forming Molecular Gas in High Redshift Submillimeter Galaxies
- The Role of Galactic Winds on Molecular Gas Emission from Galaxy Mergers
- The effects of a hot gaseous halo in galaxy major mergers
- High-Redshift Galaxy Kinematics: Constraints on Models of Disk Formation
- A Comparative Study of AGN Feedback Algorithms
- Galaxy disks do not need to survive in the L-CDM paradigm: the galaxy merger rate out to z~1.5 from morpho-kinematic data
- MASSIV: Mass Assembly Survey with SINFONI in VVDS. V. The major merger rate of star-forming galaxies at 0.9 < z < 1.8 from IFS-based close pairs
- rpSPH: a novel Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Algorithm
- Improving smoothed particle hydrodynamics with an integral approach to calculating gradients
- Resolving The Generation of Starburst Winds in Galaxy Mergers
- Formation of slowly rotating early-type galaxies via major mergers: a Resolution Study
- Galaxy Mergers with Adaptive Mesh Refinement: Star Formation and Hot Gas Outflow
- Moving mesh cosmology: properties of neutral hydrogen in absorption
- The merger-driven evolution of warm infrared luminous galaxies
- Thermal instabilities in cooling galactic coronae: fuelling star formation in galactic discs
- Beyond the nuclear starburst? Clustered star formation in major mergers
- Modeling Mid-Infrared Diagnostics of Obscured Quasars and Starbursts
- Numerical Simulations of the Lyman-alpha forest - A comparison of Gadget-2 and Enzo
- A study of AGN and supernova feedback in simulations of isolated and merging disc galaxies
- Generation of rotationally dominated galaxies by mergers of pressure-supported progenitors
- The effects of a hot gaseous halo on disc thickening in galaxy minor mergers
- In-shock Cooling in Numerical Simulations
- Multi-Dimensional, Compressible Viscous Flow on a Moving Voronoi Mesh
- Direct Numerical Simulation of decaying two-dimensional turbulence in a no-slip square box using Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics
- The Cosmic Evolution of Halo Pairs: I. Global Trends
- Constrained simulations of the Antennae Galaxies: Comparison with Herschel-PACS observations
Cited by in corpus (87)
- FIRE-2 Simulations: Physics versus Numerics in Galaxy Formation
- The merger rate of galaxies in the Illustris Simulation: a comparison with observations and semi-empirical models
- Theoretical Challenges in Galaxy Formation
- Gusty, gaseous flows of FIRE: galactic winds in cosmological simulations with explicit stellar feedback
- Beyond CDM: Problems, solutions, and the road ahead
- The Quest for Dual and Binary Supermassive Black Holes: A Multi-Messenger View
- The star formation main sequence and stellar mass assembly of galaxies in the Illustris simulation
- Growth and activity of black holes in galaxy mergers with varying mass ratios
- The Formation of Submillimetre-Bright Galaxies from Gas Infall over a Billion Years
- Mapping galaxy encounters in numerical simulations: The spatial extent of induced star formation
- Molecular outflows in local galaxies: Method comparison and a role of intermittent AGN driving
- Interacting galaxies on FIRE-2: The connection between enhanced star formation and interstellar gas content
- Synthetic Galaxy Images and Spectra from the Illustris Simulation
- The total infrared luminosity may significantly overestimate the star formation rate of recently quenched galaxies
- Zooming in on accretion - II. Cold Circumgalactic Gas Simulated with a super-Lagrangian Refinement Scheme
- Forming disk galaxies in wet major mergers. I. Three fiducial examples
- Should we believe the results of UV-mm galaxy SED modelling?
- Hot gas in massive halos drives both mass quenching and environment quenching
- From Starburst to Quiescence: Testing AGN feedback in Rapidly Quenching Post-Starburst Galaxies
- Zooming in on major mergers: dense, starbursting gas in cosmological simulations
- The Impact of Galactic Feedback on the Circumgalactic Medium
- HerMES: ALMA Imaging of Herschel-selected Dusty Star-forming Galaxies
- Numerical Convergence in Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics
- Spatially resolved star formation and fuelling in galaxy interactions
- A survey of dual active galactic nuclei in simulations of galaxy mergers: frequency and properties
- Determining the stellar masses of submillimetre galaxies: the critical importance of star formation histories
- Galaxies in the Illustris simulation as seen by the Sloan Digital Sky Survey - II: Size-luminosity relations and the deficit of bulge-dominated galaxies in Illustris at low mass
- Go with the Flow: Understanding Inflow Mechanisms in Galaxy Collisions
- Merger-Induced Metallicity Dilution in Cosmological Galaxy Formation Simulations
- The unorthodox evolution of major merger remnants into star-forming spiral galaxies
- Growing black holes and galaxies: black hole accretion versus star formation rate
- The bias of the submillimetre galaxy population: SMGs are poor tracers of the most massive structures in the z ~ 2 Universe
- Shapley Supercluster Survey: Ram-Pressure Stripping vs. Tidal Interactions in the Shapley Supercluster
- Rotation curve fitting and its fatal attraction to cores in realistically simulated galaxy observations
- Deriving star formation histories from photometry using energy balance spectral energy distribution modelling
- The Relation between Luminous AGNs and Star Formation in Their Host Galaxies
- MSTAR -- a fast parallelised algorithmically regularised integrator with minimum spanning tree coordinates
- Galaxy Zoo: The interplay of quenching mechanisms in the group environment
- Star formation and ISM morphology in tidally induced spiral structures
- A comparison of black hole growth in galaxy mergers with Gasoline and Ramses
- What drives the evolution of gas kinematics in star-forming galaxies?
- Panchromatic SED modelling of spatially-resolved galaxies
- The fate of the Antennae galaxies
- Galaxy Zoo: Evidence for rapid, recent quenching within a population of AGN host galaxies
- The impact of magnetic fields on cosmological galaxy mergers. I: Reshaping gas and stellar discs
- Merger Signatures in the Dynamics of Star-forming Gas
- SDSS-IV MaNGA: The Different Quenching Histories of Fast and Slow Rotators
- The IRX- relation: Insights from simulations
- Dust-Enshrouded AGN can Dominate Host-Galaxy-Scale Cold-Dust Emission
- Stellar feedback strongly alters the amplification and morphology of galactic magnetic fields
- A Bayesian Analysis of SDSS J0914+0853, a Low-Mass Dual AGN Candidate
- Rise and fall of post-starburst galaxies in Magneticum Pathfinder
- Compact Starburst Galaxies with Fast Outflows: Central Escape Velocities and Stellar Mass Surface Densities from Multi-band Hubble Space Telescope Imaging
- EAGLE-Auriga: effects of different subgrid models on the baryon cycle around Milky Way-mass galaxies
- ALMA observations of HCN and HCO+ outflows in the merging galaxy NGC 3256
- Strategies for Detecting the Missing Hot Baryons in the Universe
- The Role of Star-Formation and AGN in Dust Heating of z=0.3-2.8 Galaxies - II. Informing IR AGN fraction estimates through simulations
- The formation and evolution of star clusters in interacting galaxies
- Diffuse X-ray-emitting Gas in Major Mergers
- Accurate Identification of Galaxy Mergers with Stellar Kinematics
- Comparing Simulations of AGN Feedback
- The AGN Luminosity Fraction in Merging Galaxies
- What shapes the far-infrared spectral energy distributions of galaxies?
- Investigating the Relation between CO (3-2) and Far Infrared Luminosities for Nearby Merging Galaxies Using ASTE
- Star formation in mergers with cosmologically motivated initial conditions
- Simulations of black hole fueling in isolated and merging galaxies with an explicit, multiphase ISM
- Consistent SPH Simulations of Protostellar Collapse and Fragmentation
- The Hot Gas Exhaust of Starburst Engines in Mergers: Testing Models of Stellar Feedback and Star Formation Regulation
- Particle ejection during mergers of dark matter halos
- The ecology of dark matter haloes I: The rates and types of halo interactions
- Star Formation of Merging Disk Galaxies with AGN Feedback Effects
- Connection of supernovae 2002ap, 2003gd, 2013ej, and 2019krl in M74 with atomic gas accretion and spiral structure
- Hydrodynamical Simulations of the Triggering of Nuclear Activities by Minor Mergers of Galaxies
- On the Origin of High-velocity Clouds in the Galaxy
- The Formation of a Milky Way-sized Disk Galaxy 1. A Comparison of Numerical Methods
- NGC 2770: high supernova rate due to interaction
- Response of the LMC's Bar to a Recent SMC Collision and Implications for the SMC's Dark Matter Profile
- Forming disc galaxies in major mergers II. The central mass concentration problem and a comparison of GADGET3 with GIZMO
- Variations of the ISM Compactness Across the Main Sequence of Star-Forming Galaxies: Observations and Simulations
- Simulating gas kinematic studies of high-redshift galaxies with the HARMONI Integral Field Spectrograph
- Multi-Epoch Machine Learning 2: Identifying physical drivers of galaxy properties in simulations
- The collaborative effect of ram pressure and merging on star formation and stripping fraction
- A Galactic Transformation -- Understanding the SMC's Structural and Kinematic Disequilibrium
- Astrophysical black holes
- Method for Determining AGN Accretion Phase in Field Galaxies
- Gas flows in galaxy mergers: supersonic turbulence in bridges, accretion from the circumgalactic medium, and metallicity dilution
- Magnetic field and kinetic helicity evolution in simulations of interacting disk galaxies