Direct Collapse to Supermassive Black Hole Seeds: Comparing the AMR and SPH Approaches

Abstract

We provide detailed comparison between the AMR code Enzo-2.4 and the SPH/N- body code GADGET-3 in the context of isolated or cosmological direct baryonic collapse within dark matter (DM) halos to form supermassive black holes. Gas flow is examined by following evolution of basic parameters of accretion flows. Both codes show an overall agreement in the general features of the collapse, however, many subtle differences exist. For isolated models, the codes increase their spatial and mass resolutions at different pace, which leads to substantially earlier collapse in SPH than in AMR cases due to higher gravitational resolution in GADGET-3. In cosmological runs, the AMR develops a slightly higher baryonic resolution than SPH during halo growth via cold accretion permeated by mergers. Still, both codes agree in the buildup of DM and baryonic structures. However, with the onset of collapse, this difference in mass and spatial resolution is amplified, so evolution of SPH models begins to lag behind. Such a delay can have effect on formation/destruction rate of H2 due to UV background, and on basic properties of host halos. Finally, isolated non-cosmological models in spinning halos, with spin parameter λ ~ 0.01 - 0.07, show delayed collapse for greater λ, but pace of this increase is faster for AMR. Within our simulation setup, GADGET-3 requires significantly larger computational resources than Enzo- 2.4 during collapse, and needs similar resources, during the pre-collapse, cosmological structure formation phase. Yet it benefits from substantially higher gravitational force and hydrodynamic resolutions, except at the end of collapse.

19 pages, 14 figures, Referees' comments incorporated. Accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (11)

• Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
• Formation of Supermassive Black Holes by Direct Collapse in Pregalactic Halos
• The 2013 Release of Cloudy
• The Formation of Population III Binaries from Cosmological Initial Conditions
• Inviscid SPH
• Quasars at z=6: the survival of the fittest
• The Birth of a Galaxy. II. The Role of Radiation Pressure
• Quasistars: Accreting black holes inside massive envelopes
• A test suite for quantitative comparison of hydrodynamics codes in astrophysics
• The critical radiation intensity for direct collapse black hole formation: dependence on the radiation spectral shape
• Formation of an embryonic supermassive star in the first galaxy

Cited by in corpus (7)

• Cosmological Simulations of Early Blackhole Formation: Halo Mergers, Tidal Disruption, and the Conditions for Direct Collapse
• Direct Collapse to Supermassive Black Hole Seeds with Radiative Transfer: Isolated Halos
• Direct collapse to supermassive black hole seeds: the critical conditions for suppression of ${\mathrm{H}}_2$ cooling
• Direct Collapse to Supermassive Black Hole Seeds with Radiation Transfer: Cosmological Halos
• Rapid formation of black holes in galaxies: a self-limiting growth mechanism
• Direct Collapse to Precursors of Supermassive Black Hole Seeds:Radiation-feedback-generated Outflows
• Direct Collapse Pre-supermassive Black Hole Objects as Ly$\alpha$ Emitters