The formation of entropy cores in non-radiative galaxy cluster simulations: SPH versus AMR
arXiv:1307.0668 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stu418
Abstract
Abridged: We simulate a massive galaxy cluster in a LCDM Universe using three different approaches to solving the equations of non-radiative hydrodynamics: `classic' Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH); a novel SPH with a higher order dissipation switch (SPHS); and adaptive mesh refinement (AMR). We find that SPHS and AMR are in excellent agreement, with both forming a well-defined entropy core that rapidly converges with increasing mass and force resolution. By contrast, SPH exhibits rather different behaviour. At low redshift, entropy decreases systematically with decreasing cluster-centric radius, converging on ever lower central values with increasing resolution. At higher redshift, SPH is in better agreement with SPHS and AMR but shows much poorer numerical convergence. We trace these discrepancies to artificial surface tension in SPH at phase boundaries. At early times, the passage of massive substructures close to the cluster centre stirs and shocks gas to build an entropy core. At later times, artificial surface tension causes low entropy gas to sink artificially to the centre of the cluster. We use SPHS to study the contribution of numerical versus physical dissipation on the entropy core, and argue that numerical dissipation is required to ensure single-valued fluid quantities in converging flows. However, provided this dissipation occurs only at the resolution limit, and provided that it does not propagate errors to larger scales, its effect is benign. There is no requirement to build `sub-grid' models of unresolved turbulence for galaxy cluster simulations. We conclude that entropy cores in non-radiative simulations of galaxy clusters are physical, resulting from entropy generation in shocked gas during cluster assembly, putting to rest the long-standing puzzle of cluster entropy cores in AMR simulations versus their apparent absence in classic SPH simulations.
arXiv comment14 pages, 10 figures; submitted to MNRAS
References in corpus (41)
- The cosmological simulation code GADGET-2
- E pur si muove: Galiliean-invariant cosmological hydrodynamical simulations on a moving mesh
- Cosmological Hydrodynamics with Adaptive Mesh Refinement: a new high resolution code called RAMSES
- Chandra sample of nearby relaxed galaxy clusters: mass, gas fraction, and mass-temperature relation
- The Inner Structure of LambdaCDM Halos I: A Numerical Convergence Study
- Cosmological SPH simulations: The entropy equation
- Ahf: Amiga's Halo Finder
- Tracing cosmic evolution with clusters of galaxies
- The large-scale structure of the Universe
- Improving convergence in smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations without pairing instability
- Fundamental differences between SPH and grid methods
- The Aquila comparison Project: The Effects of Feedback and Numerical Methods on Simulations of Galaxy Formation
- A General Class of Lagrangian Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Methods and Implications for Fluid Mixing Problems
- Modelling discontinuities and Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities in SPH
- Turbulent gas motions in galaxy cluster simulations: The role of SPH viscosity
- Stellar and total baryon mass fractions in groups and clusters since redshift 1
- Inviscid SPH
- The baseline intracluster entropy profile from gravitational structure formation
- Fully Threaded Tree for Adaptive Refinement Fluid Dynamics Simulations
- Reformulation of Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics with Riemann Solver
- Implementing Feedback in Simulations of Galaxy Formation: A Survey of Methods
- Comparing AMR and SPH Cosmological Simulations: I. Dark Matter & Adiabatic Simulations
- A Density Independent Formulation of Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics
- Multiphase Smoothed-Particle Hydrodynamics
- Resolving mixing in Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics
- Moving mesh cosmology: the hydrodynamics of galaxy formation
- N-body simulations of gravitational dynamics
- SPHS: Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics with a higher order dissipation switch
- On the Origin of Cores in Simulated Galaxy Clusters
- Towards a Holistic View of the Heating and Cooling of the Intracluster Medium
- Astrophysical Weighted Particle Magnetohydrodynamics
- Subgrid Modeling of AGN-Driven Turbulence in Galaxy Clusters
- The Dynamical State of Dark Matter Haloes in Cosmological Simulations I: Correlations with Mass Assembly History
- Particle hydrodynamics with tessellation techniques
- Adaptively refined large eddy simulations of clusters
- rpSPH: a novel Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Algorithm
- Calibrating an updated SPH scheme within GCD+
- Thermal instabilities in cooling galactic coronae: fuelling star formation in galactic discs
- Hydrodynamic simulations with the Godunov SPH
- The entropy core in galaxy clusters: numerical and physical effects in cosmological grid simulations
- Gradient Particle Magnetohydrodynamics
Cited by in corpus (24)
- Galaxies on FIRE (Feedback In Realistic Environments): Stellar Feedback Explains Cosmologically Inefficient Star Formation
- GIZMO: A New Class of Accurate, Mesh-Free Hydrodynamic Simulation Methods
- FIRE-2 Simulations: Physics versus Numerics in Galaxy Formation
- The AGORA High-Resolution Galaxy Simulations Comparison Project
- Neutral hydrogen in galaxy halos at the peak of the cosmic star formation history
- The redshift evolution of massive galaxy clusters in the MACSIS simulations
- nIFTy galaxy cluster simulations I: dark matter & non-radiative models
- Temperature Structure of the Intra-Cluster Medium from SPH and AMR simulations
- Rhapsody-G simulations I: the cool cores, hot gas and stellar content of massive galaxy clusters
- Introducing a new, robust galaxy finder algorithm for simulations
- Cosmological simulations of galaxy clusters with feedback from active galactic nuclei: profiles and scaling relations
- nIFTy Galaxy Cluster simulations IV: Quantifying the Influence of Baryons on Halo Properties
- Comparing Simulations of AGN Feedback
- A study of cool core resiliency and entropy mixing in simulations of galaxy cluster mergers
- The role of the artificial conductivity in SPH simulations of galaxy clusters: effects on the ICM properties
- Santa Barbara Cluster Comparison Test with DISPH
- The Robustness of Cosmological Hydrodynamic Simulation Predictions to Changes in Numerics and Cooling Physics
- Simulating Hydrodynamics in Cosmology with CRK-HACC
- nIFTy Galaxy Cluster simulations VI: The dynamical imprint of substructure on gaseous cluster outskirts
- Excess entropy and energy feedback from within cluster cores up to r
- The SAMI Galaxy Survey: understanding observations of large-scale outflows at low redshift with EAGLE simulations
- Little evidence for entropy and energy excess beyond - An end to ICM preheating?
- Extended Stellar Components of Galaxies & the Nature of Dark Matter
- On the consistency of jet feedback modelling across different astrophysics hydrodynamical codes