Standard Self-Confinement and Extrinsic Turbulence Models for Cosmic Ray Transport are Fundamentally Incompatible with Observations
arXiv:2112.02153 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stac2909
Abstract
Models for cosmic ray (CR) dynamics fundamentally depend on the rate of CR scattering from magnetic fluctuations. In the ISM, for CRs with energies ~MeV-TeV, these fluctuations are usually attributed either to 'extrinsic turbulence' (ET) - a cascade from larger scales - or 'self-confinement' (SC) - self-generated fluctuations from CR streaming. Using simple analytic arguments and detailed live numerical CR transport calculations in galaxy simulations, we show that both of these, in standard form, cannot explain even basic qualitative features of observed CR spectra. For ET, any spectrum that obeys critical balance or features realistic anisotropy, or any spectrum that accounts for finite damping below the dissipation scale, predicts qualitatively incorrect spectral shapes and scalings of B/C and other species. Even if somehow one ignored both anisotropy and damping, observationally-required scattering rates disagree with ET predictions by orders-of-magnitude. For SC, the dependence of driving on CR energy density means that it is nearly impossible to recover observed CR spectral shapes and scalings, and again there is an orders-of-magnitude normalization problem. But more severely, SC solutions with super-Alfvenic streaming are unstable. In live simulations, they revert to either arbitrarily-rapid CR escape with zero secondary production, or to bottleneck solutions with far-too-strong CR confinement and secondary production. Resolving these fundamental issues without discarding basic plasma processes requires invoking different drivers for scattering fluctuations. These must act on a broad range of scales with a power spectrum obeying several specific (but plausible) constraints.
36 pages, 7 figures. Updated to match published version, added section discussing 'meso-scale' phenomenology
References in corpus (45)
- Direct detection of a break in the teraelectronvolt cosmic-ray spectrum of electrons and positrons
- Herschel Survey of Galactic OH+, H2O+, and H3O+: Probing the Molecular Hydrogen Fraction and Cosmic-Ray Ionization Rate
- Recent progress in astrophysical plasma turbulence from solar wind observations
- Cosmic Ray Propagation: Nonlinear Diffusion Parallel and Perpendicular to Mean Magnetic Field
- Numerical simulations of compressively driven interstellar turbulence: I. Isothermal gas
- Measurements of 0.2 to 20 GeV/n cosmic-ray proton and helium spectra from 1997 through 2002 with the BESS spectrometer
- Cosmic-ray propagation with DRAGON2: I. numerical solver and astrophysical ingredients
- Measurement of boron and carbon fluxes in cosmic rays with the PAMELA experiment
- Gamma-ray sky points to radial gradients in cosmic-ray transport
- Cosmic ray-driven galactic winds: streaming or diffusion?
- The Impact of Cosmic Rays on Thermal Instability in the Circumgalactic Medium
- New very local interstellar spectra for electrons, positrons, protons and light cosmic ray nuclei
- Which AGN Jets Quench Star Formation in Massive Galaxies?
- Damping of Alfven waves by Turbulence and its Consequences: from Cosmic-Rays Streaming to Launching Winds
- Galactic cosmic-ray propagation in the light of AMS-02: I. Analysis of protons, helium, and antiprotons
- MHD Turbulence
- Gas infall and radial transport in cosmological simulations of Milky Way-mass disks
- Cosmic Ray Transport, Energy Loss, and Influence in the Multiphase Interstellar Medium
- Turbulence from localized random expansion waves
- First Predicted Cosmic Ray Spectra, Primary-to-Secondary Ratios, and Ionization Rates from MHD Galaxy Formation Simulations
- Magnetohydrodynamic-Particle-in-Cell Simulations of the Cosmic-Ray Streaming Instability: Linear Growth and Quasi-linear Evolution
- Reconciling cosmic-ray transport theory with phenomenological models motivated by Milky-Way data
- Discovery of GeV emission from the direction of the luminous infrared galaxy NGC 2146
- Implications of current nuclear cross sections on secondary cosmic rays with the upcoming DRAGON2 code
- Evolution of giant molecular clouds across cosmic time
- Gamma rays as probes of cosmic-ray propagation and interactions in galaxies
- Fermi-LAT Observations of High- and Intermediate-Velocity Clouds: Tracing Cosmic Rays in the Halo of the Milky Way
- The Physics of Galactic Winds Driven by Cosmic Rays I: Diffusion
- The Physics of Galactic Winds Driven by Cosmic Rays II: Isothermal Streaming Solutions
- The theory of cosmic-ray scattering on pre-existing MHD modes meets data
- Cosmic-Ray Transport in Simulations of Star-forming Galactic Disks
- Magnetic Fields on FIRE: Comparing B-fields in the multiphase ISM and CGM of Simulated L Galaxies to Observations
- The impact of cosmic rays on dynamical balance and disk-halo interaction in Lstar disk galaxies
- Compressible turbulence in the interstellar medium: New insights from a high-resolution supersonic turbulence simulation
- Virial shocks are suppressed in cosmic ray-dominated galaxy halos
- Stellar feedback strongly alters the amplification and morphology of galactic magnetic fields
- The impact of astrophysical dust grains on the confinement of cosmic rays
- A Consistent Reduced-Speed-of-Light Formulation of Cosmic Ray Transport Valid in Weak and Strong-Scattering Regimes
- The X/gamma-ray correlation in NGC 4945 and the nature of its gamma-ray source
- Towards First-principle Characterization of Cosmic-ray Transport Coefficients from Multi-scale Kinetic Simulations
- The Launching of Cosmic Ray Driven Outflows
- The Cosmic Ray Staircase: the Outcome of the Cosmic Ray Acoustic Instability
- Probing Hot Gas Components of Circumgalactic Medium in Cosmological Simulations with the Thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect
- Search for the Gamma-ray Emission from M33 with Fermi LAT
- Anisotropic spectra of acoustic type turbulence
Cited by in corpus (21)
- FIRE-3: Updated Stellar Evolution Models, Yields, & Microphysics and Fitting Functions for Applications in Galaxy Simulations
- Cosmic ray transport in large-amplitude turbulence with small-scale field reversals
- Plasmoid Instability in the Multiphase Interstellar Medium
- Constraining Cosmic-ray Transport with Observations of the Circumgalactic Medium
- How Cosmic Rays Mediate the Evolution of the Interstellar Medium
- Why are thermally- and cosmic ray-driven galactic winds fundamentally different?
- Efficient micromirror confinement of sub-TeV cosmic rays in galaxy clusters
- Cosmic-Ray Driven Galactic Winds from the Warm Interstellar Medium
- Cosmic ray diffusion in magnetic fields amplified by nonlinear turbulent dynamo
- Diverse dark matter profiles in FIRE dwarfs: black holes, cosmic rays and the cusp-core enigma
- An accurate treatment of scattering and diffusion in piecewise power-law models for cosmic ray and radiation/neutrino transport
- A Simple Sub-Grid Model For Cosmic Ray Effects on Galactic Scales
- CONGRuENTS (COsmic-ray, Neutrino, Gamma-ray and Radio Non-Thermal Spectra). I. A predictive model for galactic non-thermal emission
- Lévy Flights and Leaky Boxes: Anomalous Diffusion of Cosmic Rays
- Cosmic-ray transport in inhomogeneous media
- Strong turbulence and magnetic coherent structures in the interstellar medium
- A new buoyancy instability in galaxy clusters due to streaming cosmic rays
- Effects of Varied Cosmic Ray Feedback from AGN on Massive Galaxy Properties
- Modelling cosmic-ray transport: magnetised versus unmagnetised motion in astrophysical magnetic turbulence
- Exploring supermassive black hole physics and galaxy quenching across halo mass in FIRE cosmological zoom simulations
- Gauging the Impact of Cosmic Ray Feedback on the Stellar Initial Mass Function