No universal minimum-mass extrasolar nebula: Evidence against in-situ accretion of systems of hot super-Earths
arXiv:1401.3743 · doi:10.1093/mnrasl/slu011
Abstract
It has been proposed that the observed systems of hot super-Earths formed in situ from high-mass disks. By fitting a disk profile to the entire population of Kepler planet candidates, Chiang & Laughlin (2013) constructed a "minimum-mass extrasolar nebula" with surface density profile Sigma r^-1.6. Here we use multiple-planet systems to show that it is inconsistent to assume a universal disk profile. Systems with 3-6 low-mass planets (or planet candidates) produce a diversity of minimum-mass disks with surface density profiles ranging from Sigma r^-3.2 to Sigma r^0.5 (5th-95th percentile). By simulating the transit detection of populations of synthetic planetary systems designed to match the properties of observed super-Earth systems, we show that a universal disk profile is statistically excluded at high confidence. Rather, the underlying distribution of minimum-mass disks is characterized by a broad range of surface density slopes. Models of gaseous disks can only explain a narrow range of slopes (roughly between r^0 and r^-1.5). Yet accretion of terrestrial planets in a gas-free environment preserves the initial radial distribution of building blocks. The known systems of hot super-Earths must therefore not represent the structure of their parent gas disks and can not have predominantly formed in situ. We instead interpret the diversity of disk slopes as the imprint of a process that re-arranged the solids relative to the gas in the inner parts of protoplanetary disks. A plausible mechanism is inward type 1 migration of Mars- to Earth-mass planetary embryos, perhaps followed by a final assembly phase.
arXiv commentAccepted to MNRAS Letters. 5 pages, 3 figures. (Updated references)
References in corpus (49)
- Spectral Energy Distributions of T Tauri Stars With Passive Circumstellar Disks
- A low mass for Mars from Jupiter's early gas-driven migration
- Planet Occurrence within 0.25 AU of Solar-type Stars from Kepler
- Planetary Candidates Observed by Kepler, III: Analysis of the First 16 Months of Data
- Prevalence of Earth-size planets orbiting Sun-like stars
- Architecture and Dynamics of Kepler's Candidate Multiple Transiting Planet Systems
- Protoplanetary Disk Structures in Ophiuchus
- A Closely-Packed System of Low-Mass, Low-Density Planets Transiting Kepler-11
- The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets XXXI. The M-dwarf sample
- The Occurrence and Mass Distribution of Close-in Super-Earths, Neptunes, and Jupiters
- THE ORIGIN OF PLUTO'S ORBIT: IMPLICATIONS FOR THE SOLAR SYSTEM BEYOND NEPTUNE
- Dynamics of Protoplanetary Disks
- Origin of the Structure of the Kuiper Belt during a Dynamical Instability in the Orbits of Uranus and Neptune
- The Minimum-Mass Extrasolar Nebula: In-Situ Formation of Close-In Super-Earths
- A torque formula for non-isothermal Type I planetary migration - I. Unsaturated horseshoe drag
- Building the Terrestrial Planets: Constrained Accretion in the Inner Solar System
- Protoplanetary Disk Structures in Ophiuchus II: Extension to Fainter Sources
- Migration and the formation of systems of hot super-Earths and Neptunes
- The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets XXXIV. Occurrence, mass distribution and orbital properties of super-Earths and Neptune-mass planets
- Probing the structure of protoplanetary disks: a comparative study of DM Tau, LkCa 15 and MWC 480
- A dual-frequency sub-arcsecond study of proto-planetary disks at mm wavelengths: First evidence for radial variations of the dust properties
- Detailed Models of super-Earths: How well can we infer bulk properties?
- The Mass of KOI-94d and a Relation for Planet Radius, Mass, and Incident Flux
- Migration then assembly: Formation of Neptune mass planets inside 1 AU
- Structure and evolution of pre-main sequence circumstellar disks
- Testing In Situ Assembly with the Kepler Planet Candidate Sample
- Architecture of Planetary Systems Based on Kepler Data: Number of Planets and Coplanarity
- Ocean Planet or Thick Atmosphere: On the Mass-Radius Relationship for Solid Exoplanets with Massive Atmospheres
- The Exoplanet Census: A General Method, Applied to Kepler
- Overstable Librations can account for the Paucity of Mean Motion Resonances among Exoplanet Pairs
- N-body simulations of planetary accretion around M dwarf stars
- The statistics of multi-planet systems
- Migration of Protoplanets in Radiative Disks
- Observable Consequences of Planet Formation Models in Systems with Close-in Terrestrial Planets
- Stellar irradiated discs and implications on migration of embedded planets I: equilibrium discs
- They might be giants: luminosity class, planet frequency, and planet-metallicity relation of the coolest Kepler target stars
- Fast Rise of "Neptune-Size" Planets () from to days -- Statistics of Kepler Planet Candidates Up to
- Planets Near Mean-Motion Resonances
- The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets. XXVII. Up to seven planets orbiting HD 10180: probing the architecture of low-mass planetary systems
- Terrestrial Planet Formation in Disks with Varying Surface Density Profiles
- Period ratios in multi-planetary systems discovered by Kepler are consistent with planet migration
- Could we identify hot Ocean-Planets with CoRoT, Kepler and Doppler velocimetry?
- Terrestrial Planet Formation at Home and Abroad
- Two phase, inward-then-outward migration of Jupiter and Saturn in the gaseous Solar Nebula
- A Minimum-Mass Extrasolar Nebula
- New Worlds on the Horizon: Earth-Sized Planets Close to Other Stars
- A proposal for community driven and decentralized astronomical databases and the Open Exoplanet Catalogue
- The Formation of Systems with Tightly-packed Inner Planets (STIPs) via Aerodynamic Drift
- Making systems of Super Earths by inward migration of planetary embryos
Cited by in corpus (92)
- The California-Kepler Survey. III. A Gap in the Radius Distribution of Small Planets
- Extreme Water Loss and Abiotic O Buildup On Planets Throughout the Habitable Zones of M Dwarfs
- Breaking the Chains: Hot Super-Earth systems from migration and disruption of compact resonant chains
- Three regimes of extrasolar planets inferred from host star metallicities
- An Earth-sized Planet in the Habitable Zone of a Cool Star
- The structure of protoplanetary discs around evolving young stars
- Compositional imprints in density-distance-time: a rocky composition for close-in low-mass exoplanets from the location of the valley of evaporation
- Water loss from Earth-sized planets in the habitable zones of ultracool dwarfs: Implications for the planets of TRAPPIST-1
- Atmospheres of low-mass planets: the "boil-off"
- Hubble Space Telescope Near-IR Transmission Spectroscopy of the Super-Earth HD 97658b
- Zodiacal Exoplanets in Time (ZEIT) III: A short-period planet orbiting a pre-main-sequence star in the Upper Scorpius OB Association
- The Radius Distribution of Planets Around Cool Stars
- A Statistical Reconstruction of the Planet Population Around Kepler Solar-Type Stars
- Challenges in Planet Formation
- Habitable Evaporated Cores: Transforming Mini-Neptunes into Super-Earths in the Habitable Zones of M Dwarfs
- Hot super-Earths and giant planet cores from different migration histories
- The nature and origins of sub-Neptune size planets
- Formation of close in Super-Earths \& Mini-Neptunes: Required Disk Masses \& Their Implications
- The period ratio distribution of Kepler's candidate multiplanet systems
- Volatile Delivery to Planets from Water-rich Planetesimals around Low Mass Stars
- Gas giant planets as dynamical barriers to inward-migrating super-Earths
- The Mass Budget of Planet Forming Discs: Isolating the Epoch of Planetesimal Formation
- Occurrence and core-envelope structure of 1--4x Earth-size planets around Sun-like stars
- Terrestrial Planet Formation at Home and Abroad
- Terrestrial Planet Formation Constrained by Mars and the Structure of the Asteroid Belt
- The New Generation Planetary Population Synthesis (NGPPS). III. Warm super-Earths and cold Jupiters: A weak occurrence correlation, but with a strong architecture-composition link
- Formation, Orbital and Internal Evolutions of Young Planetary Systems
- The Kepler Dichotomy in Planetary Disks: Linking Kepler Observables to Simulations of Late-Stage Planet Formation
- Terrestrial Planet Formation in the Presence of Migrating Super-earths
- Formation, tidal evolution and habitability of the Kepler-186 system
- The Solar System as an Exoplanetary System
- New Constraints From Dust Lines On The Surface Densities Of Protoplanetary Disks
- Tests of In-Situ Formation Scenarios for Compact Multiplanet Systems
- A New Model of Roche-lobe Overflow for Short-Period Gaseous Planets and Binary Stars
- Chemical Diversity of Super-Earths As a Consequence of Formation
- Origins Space Telescope Mission Concept Study Report
- The Demographics of Rocky Free-Floating Planets and their Detectability by WFIRST
- Efficient Geometric Probabilities of Multi-Transiting Exoplanetary Systems from CORBITS
- Planetary migration and the origin of the 2:1 and 3:2 (near)-resonant population of close-in exoplanets
- Extreme Debris Disk Variability -- Exploring the Diverse Outcomes of Large Asteroid Impacts During the Era of Terrestrial Planet Formation
- A SMACK Model of Colliding Planetesimals in the Pictoris Debris Disk
- Vulcan Planets: Inside-Out Formation of the Innermost Super-Earths
- The Magellan-TESS Survey I: Survey Description and Mid-Survey Results
- Kuiper belt structure around nearby super-Earth host stars
- Does warm debris dust stem from asteroid belts?
- Understanding the assembly of Kepler's compact planetary systems
- Inside-Out Planet Formation. III. Planet-disk interaction at the dead zone inner boundary
- Formation of planetary systems by pebble accretion and migration: Hot super-Earth systems from breaking compact resonant chains
- Young planets under extreme UV irradiation. I. Upper atmosphere modelling of the young exoplanet K2-33b
- Rocky Planet Formation: Quick and Neat
- Inner Planetary System Gap Complexity is a Predictor of Outer Giant Planets
- Inside-Out Planet Formation. V. Structure of the Inner Disk as Implied by the MRI
- A Minimum Mass Nebula for M Dwarfs
- Did Jupiter's core form in the innermost parts of the Sun's protoplanetary disk?
- Inside-Out Planet Formation. IV. Pebble Evolution and Planet Formation Timescales
- The aeolian-erosion barrier for the growth of metre-size objects in protoplanetary-discs
- Possible Atmospheric Diversity of Low Mass Exoplanets, some Central Aspects
- Planet seeding through gas-assisted capture of interstellar objects
- Inner rocky super-Earth formation: distinguishing the formation pathways in viscously heated and passive discs
- Formation of Terrestrial Planets
- Identifying inflated super-Earths and photo-evaporated cores
- CKS IX: Revisiting the Minimum-Mass Extrasolar Nebula with Precise Stellar Parameters
- Stochasticity & Predictability in Terrestrial Planet Formation
- Building massive compact planetesimal disks from the accretion of pebbles
- Diversity of planetary systems in low-mass disks: Terrestrial-type planet formation and water delivery
- Collisional Fragmentation is Not a Barrier to Close-in Planet Formation
- External Photoevaporation of the Solar Nebula II: Effects on Disk Structure and Evolution with Non-Uniform Turbulent Viscosity due to the Magnetorotational Instability
- Saving super-Earths: Interplay between pebble accretion and type I migration
- Rotation periods of TESS Objects of Interest from the Magellan-TESS Survey with multiband photometry from Evryscope and TESS
- On the Orbital Spacing Pattern of Kepler Multiple Planet Systems
- Terrestrial Planets Formation under Migration: the Systems near 4:2:1 Mean Motion Resonance
- Exoplanet atmosphere evolution: emulation with neural networks
- The scattering outcomes of Kepler circumbinary planets: planet mass ratio
- A Pluto-Charon Sonata: The Dynamical Architecture of the Circumbinary Satellite System
- On the Formation of Super-Earths with Implications for the Solar System
- Host Star Dependence of Small Planet Mass-Radius Distributions
- MRI-active inner regions of protoplanetary discs. II. Dependence on dust, disc and stellar parameters
- Dynamical rearrangement of super-Earths during disk dispersal II. Assessment of the magnetospheric rebound model for planet formation scenarios
- Shifting of the resonance location for planets embedded in circumstellar disks
- The Terrestrial Planet Formation around M Dwarfs: In-situ, Inward Migration or Reversed Migration
- Unveiling the Planet Population at Birth
- Photoevaporation Does Not Create a Pileup of Giant Planets at 1 AU
- Erosion driven size-redistribution of protoplanetary disk solids and the onset of streaming Instability and Pebble Accretion
- K2-79b and K2-222b: Mass measurements of two small exoplanets with periods beyond 10 days that overlap with periodic magnetic activity signals
- Effects of Proxima Centauri on Planet Formation in Alpha Centauri
- Possible Outcomes of Coplanar High-eccentricity Migration: Hot Jupiters, Close-in Super-Earths, and Counter-orbiting Planets
- Can Rocky Exoplanets with Rings Pose as Sub-Neptunes?
- Planet formation: key mechanisms and global models
- On the formation of planetary systems in photoevaporating transition discs
- Global Instability of Exo-Moon System Triggered by Photo-Evaporation
- Predicting the Dominant Formation Mechanism of Multi-Planetary Systems
- Detecting Extrasolar Asteroid Belts Through Their Microlensing Signatures