How Popular is Your Paper? An Empirical Study of the Citation Distribution

Abstract

Numerical data for the distribution of citations are examined for: (i) papers published in 1981 in journals which are catalogued by the Institute for Scientific Information (783,339 papers) and (ii) 20 years of publications in Physical Review D, vols. 11-50 (24,296 papers). A Zipf plot of the number of citations to a given paper versus its citation rank appears to be consistent with a power-law dependence for leading rank papers, with exponent close to -1/2. This, in turn, suggests that the number of papers with x citations, N(x), has a large-x power law decay N(x)~x^{-alpha}, with alpha approximately equal to 3.

4 pages, 4 figures, 1 table, revtex 2 column format. A small error in the description of one of the data sets corrected, no change in results

Cited by in corpus (356)

• Emergence of scaling in random networks
• Statistical mechanics of complex networks
• The structure and function of complex networks
• Community structure in social and biological networks
• Finding and evaluating community structure in networks
• Power-law distributions in empirical data
• Finding community structure in very large networks
• Error and attack tolerance of complex networks
• Power laws, Pareto distributions and Zipf's law
• Fast algorithm for detecting community structure in networks
• Evolution of networks
• Mixing patterns in networks
• Classes of behavior of small-world networks
• Who is the best connected scientist? A study of scientific coauthorship networks
• Analysis of weighted networks
• Defining and identifying communities in networks
• Mean-field theory for scale-free random networks
• Evolution of the social network of scientific collaborations
• Cascade-based attacks on complex networks
• Structure of Growing Networks: Exact Solution of the Barabasi--Albert's Model
• Topology of evolving networks: local events and universality
• Universal Behavior of Load Distribution in Scale-free Networks
• Connectivity of Growing Random Networks
• Growing Scale-Free Networks with Tunable Clustering
• Hyperbolic Geometry of Complex Networks
• A tool for filtering information in complex systems
• Extracting the multiscale backbone of complex weighted networks
• Scale-free networks are rare
• Quantifying Long-Term Scientific Impact
• Organization of Growing Random Networks
• Universality of citation distributions: towards an objective measure of scientific impact
• Bose-Einstein condensation in complex networks
• Analyzing and Modeling Real-World Phenomena with Complex Networks: A Survey of Applications
• Kronecker Graphs: An Approach to Modeling Networks
• Problems with Fitting to the Power-Law Distribution
• Popularity versus Similarity in Growing Networks
• Growing networks with local rules: preferential attachment, clustering hierarchy and degree correlations
• An index to quantify an individual's scientific research valid across disciplines
• Spectra of "Real-World" Graphs: Beyond the Semi-Circle Law
• Finding Scientific Gems with Google
• Are randomly grown graphs really random?
• The Matthew effect in empirical data
• Evolution of reference networks with aging
• Citation Statistics from 110 Years of Physical Review
• Highly clustered scale-free networks
• Growing Scale-Free Networks with Small World Behavior
• Diffusion of scientific credits and the ranking of scientists
• Generic scale of the "scale-free" growing networks
• The Simultaneous Evolution of Author and Paper Networks
• A Local Method for Detecting Communities
• Maximal planar networks with large clustering coefficient and power-law degree distribution
• Power laws and Self-Organized Criticality in Theory and Nature
• Scaling properties of scale-free evolving networks: Continuous approach
• Incomplete ordering of the voter model on small-world networks
• Scaling Behaviour of Developing and Decaying Networks
• Spectra and eigenvectors of scale-free networks
• Weighted Multiplex Networks
• Emergence of bimodality in controlling complex networks
• Subgraphs in random networks
• Crises and collective socio-economic phenomena: simple models and challenges
• Effect of the accelerating growth of communications networks on their structure
• Correlation based networks of equity returns sampled at different time horizons
• The network topology of a potential energy landscape: A static scale-free network
• Optimization of Robustness of Complex Networks
• Characterizing and modeling citation dynamics
• The first-mover advantage in scientific publication
• Exact solutions for models of evolving networks with addition and deletion of nodes
• A Geometric Fractal Growth Model for Scale Free Networks
• Greedy Forwarding in Dynamic Scale-Free Networks Embedded in Hyperbolic Metric Spaces
• Optimization of Network Robustness to Waves of Targeted and Random Attack
• Citation Networks in High Energy Physics
• Generalized percolation in random directed networks
• All scale-free networks are sparse
• Google matrix analysis of directed networks
• On the robustness of the h-index
• Competition-induced criticality in a model of meme popularity
• Evidence for Power-law tail of the Wealth Distribution in India
• Zipf's Law Leads to Heaps' Law: Analyzing Their Relation in Finite-Size Systems
• Large-scale structure of time evolving citation networks
• Spanning Trees and bootstrap reliability estimation in correlation based networks
• Growing Random Networks with Fitness
• A Simple Generative Model of Collective Online Behaviour
• Power-law Distributions in Information Science - Making the Case for Logarithmic Binning
• The Topology of Music Recommendation Networks
• The effect of aging on network structure
• Maximum entropy principle and power-law tailed distributions
• Nonuniversal power law scaling in the probability distribution of scientific citations
• Dynamics of directed graphs: the world-wide Web
• Topological Properties of Citation and Metabolic Networks
• Methods for measuring the citations and productivity of scientists across time and discipline
• Heterogeneous Bond Percolation on Multitype Networks with an Application to Epidemic Dynamics
• Predicting the long-term citation impact of recent publications
• An evolving network model with community structure
• Understanding scaling through history-dependent processes with collapsing sample space
• A reverse engineering approach to the suppression of citation biases reveals universal properties of citation distributions
• A quantitative analysis of measures of quality in science
• Emergence of Soft Communities from Geometric Preferential Attachment
• Random graph models for directed acyclic networks
• Scaling and universality in the micro-structure of urban space
• Power-law distribution in the number of confirmed COVID-19 cases
• The effects of network structure, competition and memory time on social spreading phenomena
• Scale-free networks with an exponent less than two
• Community Detecting By Signaling on Complex Networks
• A New Comparative Definition of Community and Corresponding Identifying Algorithm
• q-exponential, Weibull, and q-Weibull distributions: an empirical analysis
• Extreme self-organization in networks constructed from gene expression data
• Weighted Scale-Free Networks with Stochastic Weight Assignments
• A Biased Review of Sociophysics
• Subgraphs and network motifs in geometric networks
• Evolution of scaling emergence in large-scale spatial epidemic spreading
• Experience versus Talent Shapes the Structure of the Web
• Network Community Detection: A Review and Visual Survey
• Zipf's Law in Importance of Genes for Cancer Classification Using Microarray Data
• Fitting Power-laws in empirical data with estimators that work for all exponents
• Dynamics of hate based networks
• q-Exponential Distribution in Urban Agglomeration
• The discretised lognormal and hooked power law distributions for complete citation data: Best options for modelling and regression
• Network Structures from Selection Principles
• Positional Effects on Citation and Readership in arXiv
• Extracting Information from Multiplex Networks
• Zipf law in the popularity distribution of chess openings
• Power-law Distribution of Family Names in Japanese Societies
• Statistical regularities in the rank-citation profile of scientists
• Synchronized clusters in coupled map networks: Self-organized and driven phase synchronization
• Emergence of scale-free leadership structure in social recommender systems
• Modelling Aging Characteristics in Citation Networks
• On fitting the Pareto-Levy distribution to stock market index data: selecting a suitable cutoff value
• Inter-Package Dependency Networks in Open-Source Software
• Stochastic dynamical model of a growing network based on self-exciting point process
• Quantifying the connectivity of a network: The network correlation function method
• Mesoscopic Structures Reveal the Network Between the Layers of Multiplex Datasets
• Scientific impact quantity and quality: Analysis of two sources of bibliographic data
• Opinion modeling on social media and marketing aspects
• The evolution of interdisciplinarity in physics research
• Inheritance patterns in citation networks reveal scientific memes
• Quantifying the interdisciplinarity of scientific journals and fields
• Reciprocity and the Emergence of Power Laws in Social Networks
• The Gompertz-Pareto Income Distribution
• Universality of citation distributions for academic institutions and journals
• Good practices for a literature survey are not followed by authors while preparing scientific manuscripts
• Stochastic Opinion Formation in Scale-Free Networks
• Complex Networks
• Modelling Citation Networks
• Network Sampling: From Static to Streaming Graphs
• Degree correlations in directed scale-free networks
• Modeling the clustering in citation networks
• Analysis of bibliometric indicators for individual scholars in a large data set
• Modeling scientific-citation patterns and other triangle-rich acyclic networks
• Giant Clusters in Random Ad Hoc Networks
• Self Organized Scale-Free Networks from Merging and Regeneration
• Scaling of random spreading in small world networks
• Sampling from Social Networks with Attributes
• Distributions for cited articles from individual subjects and years
• Regularities in football goal distributions
• Dynamical approach to Zipf's law
• The statistical laws of popularity: Universal properties of the box office dynamics of motion pictures
• Fame and Obsolescence: Disentangling growth and ageing dynamics of patent citations
• Satellite-based photonic quantum networks are small-world
• The Time Dimension of Science: Connecting the Past to the Future
• Runaway Events Dominate the Heavy Tail of Citation Distributions
• Self-organized evolution in socio-economic environments
• Degree Correlation in Scale-Free Graphs
• Local versus Global Knowledge in the Barabasi-Albert scale-free network model
• Empirical nonextensive laws for the county distribution of total personal income and gross domestic product
• Zipf's law and log-normal distributions in measures of scientific output across fields and institutions: 40 years of Slovenia's research as an example
• Unraveling the dynamics of growth, aging and inflation for citations to scientific articles from specific research fields
• Bifurcation of Stretched Exponential Relaxation in Microscopically Homogeneous Glasses
• The Aging Effect in Evolving Scientific Citation Networks
• Re-inventing Willis
• Are there too many uncited articles? Zero inflated variants of the discretised lognormal and hooked power law distributions
• A Group-Based Yule Model for Bipartite Author-Paper Networks
• Loss of sustainability in scientific work
• Six Susceptible-Infected-Susceptible Models on Scale-free Networks
• Characterizing scientific production and consumption in Physics
• Correlations of record events as a test for heavy-tailed distributions
• Evaluating the impact of interdisciplinary research: a multilayer network approach
• On the distribution of career longevity and the evolution of home run prowess in professional baseball
• Shorter Distances between Papers over Time are Due to More Cross-Field References and Increased Citation Rate to Higher Impact Papers
• Power-law citation distributions are not scale-free
• Complex network analysis of literary and scientific texts
• Impact Factors and the Central Limit Theorem: Why Citation Averages Are Scale Dependent
• The role of modularity in self-organisation dynamics in biological networks
• Preferencial growth: exact solution of the time dependent distributions
• Accelerated growth in outgoing links in evolving networks: deterministic vs. stochastic picture
• Citation entropy and research impact estimation
• Complex scale-free networks with tunable power-law exponent and clustering
• Multifractal properties of growing networks
• The distribution of shortest path lengths in a class of node duplication network models
• What is the dimension of citation space?
• Hollywood blockbusters and long-tailed distributions: An empirical study of the popularity of movies
• Bias in generation of random graphs
• Binding Social and Cultural Networks: A Model
• Fragmentation with a Steady Source
• Effects of accelerating growth on the evolution of weighted complex networks
• The Fractional Preferential Attachment Scale-Free Network Model
• Growing networks with preferential addition and deletion of edges
• A preferential attachment model with Poisson growth for scale-free networks
• Models of Opinion Formation: Influence of Opinion Leaders
• Spin glass behavior of the antiferromagnetic Ising model on a scale-free network
• Citation count distributions for large monodisciplinary journals
• Scale-free download network for publications
• Detrending career statistics in professional baseball: Accounting for the steroids era and beyond
• Exploration of an Interdisciplinary Scientific Landscape
• Modeling and verifying a broad array of network properties
• Income Distribution Dependence of Poverty Measure: A Theoretical Analysis
• Coexistence in preferential attachment networks
• The Importance of Being First: Position Dependent Citation Rates on arXiv:astro-ph
• Topological Centrality and Its Applications
• Organization of networks with tagged nodes and biased links: a priori distinct communities. The case of Intelligent Design Proponents and Darwinian Evolution Defenders
• Role of social environment and social clustering in spread of opinions in co-evolving networks
• Long-Range Connections in Transportation Networks
• Global Mapping of Gene/Protein Interactions in PubMed Abstracts: A Framework and an Experiment with P53 Interactions
• Random spreading phenomena in annealed small world networks
• Identifying time dependence in network growth
• Power-law distributions from additive preferential redistributions
• Jigsaw percolation: What social networks can collaboratively solve a puzzle?
• Scale free networks by preferential depletion
• Growing dynamics of Internet providers
• Supremacy distribution in evolving networks
• Dynamic scaling, data-collapse and self-similarity in Barabási-Albert networks
• Properties of a random attachment growing network
• Parallel Generation of Massive Scale-Free Graphs
• Don't follow the leader: How ranking performance reduces meritocracy
• Robustness of the in-degree exponent for the world-wide web
• Analysis of the convergence of the degree distribution of contracting random networks towards a Poisson distribution using the relative entropy
• Construction of bipartite and unipartite weighted networks from collections of journal papers
• How important is choice of the scaling factor in standardizing citations?
• Analytical results for the distribution of shortest path lengths in directed random networks that grow by node duplication
• Robustness of community structure to node removal
• Convergence towards an Erd{\H o}s-Rényi graph structure in network contraction processes
• Directed Accelerated Growth: Application in Citation Network
• The scaling of the minimum sum of edge lengths in uniformly random trees
• Scientometric engineering: Exploring citation dynamics via arXiv eprints
• Disentangling Visibility and Self-Promotion Bias in the arXiv:astro-ph Positional Citation Effect
• Socio-economic inequalities: a statistical physics perspective
• Critical properties of a dissipative sandpile model on small world networks
• Theory of citing
• Preferential attachment with information filtering - node degree probability distribution properties
• Synchronization in Scale-free Dynamical Networks: Robustness and Fragility
• Blockbusters, Bombs and Sleepers: The income distribution of movies
• The structure of networks that evolve under a combination of growth, via node addition and random attachment, and contraction, via random node deletion
• Effects of aging and links removal on epidemic dynamics in scale-free networks
• Fractal Structure with a Typical Scale
• Scale-free networks with tunable degree distribution exponents
• Agent-based model for the h-index - Exact solution
• An analysis of the abstracts presented at the annual meetings of the Society for Neuroscience from 2001 to 2006
• The narrowing of literature use and the restricted mobility of papers in the sciences
• Complex hypergraphs
• A self-consistent approach to measure preferential attachment in networks and its application to an inherent structure network
• Towards a more realistic citation model: The key role of research team sizes
• Complex systems: features, similarity and connectivity
• Weighted distances in scale-free configuration models
• Size of quantum networks
• Power-law weighted networks from local attachments
• A bibliometric index based on the complete list of cited publications
• Statistical Investigation of Avalanches of Three Dimensional Small-World Networks and their Boundary and Bulk Cross-Sections
• Preferential growth: Solution and application to modeling stock market
• Allometric Scaling in Scientific Fields
• Rising Novelties on Evolving Networks: Recent Behavior Dominant and Non-Dominant Model
• The Diffusive Epidemic Process on Barabasi-Albert Networks
• Spacing ratio statistics of multiplex directed networks
• Random Ancestor Trees
• Analytical results for the in-degree and out-degree distributions of directed random networks that grow by node duplication
• Power-law exponent of the Bouchaud-Mézard model on regular random network
• An evolutionary model of long tailed distributions in the social sciences
• Generation of scale-free networks using a simple preferential rewiring dynamics
• Anomalous diffusion in the citation time series of scientific publications
• Power laws of the in-degree and out-degree distributions of complex networks
• Nodal domain partition and the number of communities in networks
• Live and Dead Nodes
• A SIR epidemic model for citation dynamics
• Comparing the impact of subfields in scientific journals
• Communities in C.elegans connectome through the prism of non-backtracking walks
• Relations between a typical scale and averages in the breaking of fractal distribution
• Edge Balance Ratio: Power Law from Vertices to Edges in Directed Complex Network
• Universal features of mountain ridge networks on Earth
• Growing Networks: Limit in-degree distribution for arbitrary out-degree one
• Universality in Bibliometrics
• A complete data frame work for fitting power law distributions
• Phase transition in evolving networks that combine preferential attachment and random node deletion
• Kinetics of node splitting in evolving complex networks
• Synchronization in an evolving network
• Citation distribution of individual scientist: approximations of stretch exponential distribution with power law tails
• Estimating Formation Mechanisms and Degree Distributions in Mixed Attachment Networks
• Bipartite Yule Processes in Collections of Journal Papers
• The Demise of Single-Authored Publications in Computer Science: A Citation Network Analysis
• Quantum phase transition of the transverse-field quantum Ising model on scale-free networks
• We cite as we communicate: A communication model for the citation process
• Do 'altmetric mentions' follow Power Laws? Evidence from social media mention data in Altmetric.com
• Generating Scale-free Networks with Adjustable Clustering Coefficient Via Random Walks
• Diffusion in Colocation Contact Networks: the Impact of Nodal Spatiotemporal Dynamics
• Scale-free networks are not robust under neutral evolution
• A proposal for a quantitative indicator of original research output
• A Simple Model of the Evolution of Simple Models of Evolution
• Exploring Citation Diversity in Scholarly Literature: An Entropy-Based Approach
• Modeling citation networks based on vigorousness and dormancy
• Generating Local Maps of Science using Deep Bibliographic Coupling
• Evolutionary game on networks with high clustering coefficient
• An Extended Network Model with a Packages Diffusion Process
• On the evolution and utility of annual citation indices
• Network Extreme Eigenvalue - from Multimodal to Scale-free Network
• Cost of material or information flow in complex transportation networks
• An Agent-based Model of Citation Behavior
• Weighted networks of scientific communication: the measurement and geometrical role of weight
• Estimation of heavy tails in optical non-linear processes
• Evolution of citation networks with the hypergraph formalism
• Stabilization of biodiversity in the coevolutionary rock-paper-scissors game on complex networks
• Missing Data as Part of the Social Behavior in Real-World Financial Complex Systems
• Existence of Hierarchies and Human's Pursuit of Top Hierarchy Lead to Power Law
• The Adequate Bootstrap
• Mean-Field and Non-Mean-Field Behaviors in Scale-free Networks with Random Boolean Dynamics
• Is it possible to control the spread of a globalized culture?
• The Evolution of the Cuban HIV/AIDS Network
• A New Clustering Algorithm Based Upon Flocking On Complex Network
• Properties of Stochastic Kronecker Graph
• Comment: Citation Statistics
• Applying weighted PageRank to author citation networks
• A Simple Conceptual Generator for the Internet Graph
• Dynamical Structure Functions for the Estimation of LTI Networks with Limited Information
• Tsallis $q$-exponential describes the distribution of scientific citations - A new characterization of the impact
• Citation graph, weighted impact factors and performance indices
• A Comparison of On-Line Computer Science Citation Databases
• The skewness of computer science
• Modeling a Century of Citation Distributions
• A Stochastic Evolutionary Model Exhibiting Power-Law Behaviour with an Exponential Cutoff
• Small-World File-Sharing Communities
• On the universality of rank distributions of website popularity
• On Novel Peer Review System for Academic Journals: Experimental Study Based on Social Computing
• Power law dynamics in genealogical graphs
• Fractional stochastic model of citation dynamics with memory and volatility
• On the Heterogeneous Distributions in Paper Citations
• Complete asymptotic type-token relationship for growing complex systems with inverse power-law count rankings
• Italian Business-to-Business Invoicing Data: A Network Analysis
• Zipf-Gramming: Scaling Byte N-Grams Up to Production Sized Malware Corpora
• Nonreciprocal random networks and their percolation properties
• Identification of Community Structures in Networks Employing a Modified Divisive Algorithm
• CUQ-GNN: Committee-based Graph Uncertainty Quantification using Posterior Networks
• Modeling and Analysis of Cascading Failures in Interdependent Cyber-Physical Systems
• Extreme value analysis of gut microbial alterations in colorectal cancer
• The Truth about Power Laws: Theory and Reality
• Random Matrix Analysis of Multiplex Networks
• Characterizing the head of the degree distributions of growing networks
• Birth-Burst in Evolving Networks
• Modeling trend progression through an extension of the Polya Urn Process
• Multi-Gaussian random variables
• On the Estimation and Use of Statistical Modelling in Information Retrieval
• NEDindex: A new metric for community structure in networks
• On the Approximability of Independent Set Problem on Power Law Graphs
• ComReg: A Complex Network Approach to Prioritize Test Cases for Regression Testing
• Mathematical models for epidemic spreading on complex networks
• A Model for Collaboration Networks Giving Rise to a Power Law Distribution with an Exponential Cutoff
• A Fitness Model for Scholarly Impact Analysis
• A bird's-eye view of scientific trading: Dependency relations among fields of science
• A New Benchmark For Evaluation Of Graph-Theoretic Algorithms
• Popular and/or Prestigious? Measures of Scholarly Esteem
• Discovering author impact: A PageRank perspective