The first-mover advantage in scientific publication

Abstract

Mathematical models of the scientific citation process predict a strong "first-mover" effect under which the first papers in a field will, essentially regardless of content, receive citations at a rate enormously higher than papers published later. Moreover papers are expected to retain this advantage in perpetuity -- they should receive more citations indefinitely, no matter how many other papers are published after them. We test this conjecture against data from a selection of fields and in several cases find a first-mover effect of a magnitude similar to that predicted by the theory. Were we wearing our cynical hat today, we might say that the scientist who wants to become famous is better off -- by a wide margin -- writing a modest paper in next year's hottest field than an outstanding paper in this year's. On the other hand, there are some papers, albeit only a small fraction, that buck the trend and attract significantly more citations than theory predicts despite having relatively late publication dates. We suggest that papers of this kind, though they often receive comparatively few citations overall, are probably worthy of our attention.

7 pages, 3 figures

References in corpus (1)

• Life, Death and Preferential Attachment

Cited by in corpus (55)

• Recommender Systems
• Scale-free networks are rare
• The Matthew effect in empirical data
• Defining and identifying Sleeping Beauties in science
• Networks in Cognitive Science
• Reputation and Impact in Academic Careers
• Promoting cooperation in social dilemmas via simple coevolutionary rules
• Ranking in evolving complex networks
• Temporal effects in the growth of networks
• The misleading narrative of the canonical faculty productivity trajectory
• Coauthorship and citation in scientific publishing
• Growth and structure of Slovenia's scientific collaboration network
• Power-law distribution in the number of confirmed COVID-19 cases
• The effects of network structure, competition and memory time on social spreading phenomena
• Prediction of highly cited papers
• Dynamics of hate based networks
• Identification of milestone papers through time-balanced network centrality
• Early identification of important patents through network centrality
• Stochastic dynamical model of a growing network based on self-exciting point process
• Taking census of physics
• Fractional Dynamics of Network Growth Constrained by aging Node Interactions
• Quantifying and suppressing ranking bias in a large citation network
• Runaway Events Dominate the Heavy Tail of Citation Distributions
• The Time Dimension of Science: Connecting the Past to the Future
• On the use of topological features and hierarchical characterization for disambiguating names in collaborative networks
• Zipf's law and log-normal distributions in measures of scientific output across fields and institutions: 40 years of Slovenia's research as an example
• The Aging Effect in Evolving Scientific Citation Networks
• Loss of sustainability in scientific work
• Evaluating the impact of interdisciplinary research: a multilayer network approach
• Unbiased evaluation of ranking metrics reveals consistent performance in science and technology citation data
• Preferential attachment mechanism of complex network growth: "rich-gets-richer" or "fit-gets-richer"?
• Model-based evaluation of scientific impact indicators
• First-mover advantage explains gender disparities in physics citations
• The Evolutions of the Rich get Richer and the Fit get Richer Phenomena in Scholarly Networks: The Case of the Strategic Management Journal
• Temporal effects in trend prediction: identifying the most popular nodes in the future
• The long-term impact of ranking algorithms in growing networks
• Career Transitions and Trajectories: A Case Study in Computing
• Don't follow the leader: How ranking performance reduces meritocracy
• Simon's fundamental rich-get-richer model entails a dominant first-mover advantage
• Dynamics underlying Box-office: Movie Competition on Recommender Systems
• Time-invariant degree growth in preferential attachment network models
• Bibliometric and social network analysis on the use of satellite imagery in agriculture: an entropy-based approach
• Assortative and preferential attachment lead to core-periphery networks
• Collective dynamics behind success
• Individual and gender inequality in computer science: A career study of cohorts from 1970 to 2000
• The power-law distribution in the geometrically growing system: Statistic of the COVID-19 pandemic
• A Generative Hypergraph Model for Double Heterogeneity
• Hot-Get-Richer Network Growth Model
• Predicting Research Trends From Arxiv
• Predicting the Citations of Scholarly Paper
• Predicting the popularity of scientific publications by an age-based diffusion model
• Birth-Burst in Evolving Networks
• Does the First Mover Advantage Exist on GitHub?
• Memory-cognizant generalization to Simon's random-copying neutral model
• Fractional stochastic model of citation dynamics with memory and volatility