The Star Formation Epoch of the Most Massive Early-Type Galaxies

Abstract

We present new Keck spectroscopy of early-type galaxies in three galaxy clusters at z~0.5. We focus on the fundamental plane (FP) relation, and combine the kinematics with structural parameters determined from HST images. The galaxies obey clear FP relations, which are offset from the FP of the nearby Coma cluster due to passive evolution of the stellar populations. The z~0.5 data are combined with published data for 11 additional clusters at 0.18<z<1.28, to determine the evolution of the mean M/L(B) ratio of cluster galaxies with masses M>10^11 M_sun, as implied by the FP. We find dlog(M/L(B))/dz = -0.555+-0.042, stronger evolution than was previously inferred from smaller samples. The observed evolution depends on the luminosity-weighted mean age of the stars in the galaxies, the initial mass function (IMF), selection effects due to progenitor bias, and other parameters. Assuming a normal IMF but allowing for various other sources of uncertainty we find z* = 2.01+-0.20 for the luminosity-weighted mean star formation epoch. The main uncertainty is the slope of the IMF in the range 1-2 Solar masses: we find z* = 4.0 for a top-heavy IMF with slope x=0. The M/L(B) ratios of the cluster galaxies are compared to those of recently published samples of field early-type galaxies at 0.32<z<1.14. Assuming that progenitor bias and the IMF do not depend on environment we find that the present-day age of stars in massive field galaxies is 4.1 +- 2.0 % (~0.4 Gyr) less than that of stars in massive cluster galaxies, consistent with most, but not all, previous studies of local and distant early-type galaxies. This relatively small age difference is surprising in the context of expectations from ``standard'' hierarchical galaxy formation models. [ABRIDGED]

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in ApJ. Minor corrections to match published version

References in corpus (94)

• Maps of Dust IR Emission for Use in Estimation of Reddening and CMBR Foregrounds
• Stellar population synthesis at the resolution of 2003
• Galactic Stellar and Substellar Initial Mass Function
• On the variation of the Initial Mass Function
• The many lives of active galactic nuclei: cooling flows, black holes and the luminosities and colours of galaxies
• Final Results from the Hubble Space Telescope Key Project to Measure the Hubble Constant
• The broken hierarchy of galaxy formation
• Evolutionary population synthesis: models, analysis of the ingredients and application to high-z galaxies
• The epochs of early-type galaxy formation as a function of environment
• Cosmic-Ray Rejection by Laplacian Edge Detection
• The SAURON project - IV. The mass-to-light ratio, the virial mass estimator and the fundamental plane of elliptical and lenticular galaxies
• The Photometric Performance and Calibration of the HST Advanced Camera For Surveys
• Evolution since z = 0.5 of the Morphology-Density relation for Clusters of Galaxies
• The formation history of elliptical galaxies
• Clustering of Galaxies in a Hierarchical Universe: I. Methods and Results at z=0
• Optimal Techniques in Two-dimensional Spectroscopy: Background Subtraction for the 21st Century
• The Fundamental Plane for cluster E and S0 galaxies
• First stars, very massive black holes and metals
• A Significant Population of Red, Near-IR Selected High Redshift Galaxies
• Early Star Formation and the Evolution of the Stellar Initial Mass Function in Galaxies
• Evolution of the Hubble Sequence in Hierarchical Models for Galaxy Formation
• The Recent and Continuing Assembly of Field Ellipticals by Red Mergers
• The Ages of Elliptical Galaxies in a Merger Model
• Early-type galaxies in the SDSS. III. The Fundamental Plane
• IRAC Mid-Infrared Imaging of the Hubble Deep Field South: Star Formation Histories and Stellar Masses of Red Galaxies at z>2
• The Fundamental Scaling Relations of Elliptical Galaxies
• Spitzer Observations of Massive Red Galaxies at High Redshift
• Dry Mergers in GEMS: The Dynamical Evolution of Massive Early-Type Galaxies
• A JavaScript Passive Evolution Calculator
• The Fundamenal Plane in CL0024 at z=0.4: Implications for the Evolution of the Mass-to-Light Ratio
• Early-type galaxies in the SDSS. I. The sample
• The Assembly History of Field Spheroidals: Evolution of Mass-to-light Ratios and Signatures of Recent Star Formation
• Ultradeep Near-Infrared ISAAC Observations of the HDF-S: Observations, Reduction, Multicolor Catalog, and Photometric Redshifts
• The K-band luminosity function at z=1: a powerful constraint on galaxy formation theory
• The Evolution of Early-Type Galaxies in Distant Clusters II: Internal Kinematics of 55 Galaxies in the z=0.33 Cluster CL1358+62
• Luminosity Evolution of Early-type Galaxies to z=0.83: Constraints on Formation Epoch and Omega
• Keck Spectroscopy of distant GOODS Spheroidal Galaxies: Downsizing in a Hierarchical Universe
• Red Mergers and the Assembly of Massive Elliptical Galaxies: the Fundamental Plane and its Projections
• Spectroscopic Identification of Massive Galaxies at z~2.3 with Strongly Suppressed Star Formation
• The Spatial and Kinematic Distributions of Cluster Galaxies in a LCDM Universe -- Comparison with Observations
• A Census of Optical and Near-Infrared Selected Star-Forming and Passively Evolving Galaxies at Redshift Z~2
• Spectroscopic Identification of a Proto-Cluster at z=2.300: Environmental Dependence of Galaxy Properties at High Redshift
• Mass-to-Light Ratios of Field Early-Type Galaxies at z~1 from Ultra-Deep Spectroscopy: Evidence for Mass-dependent Evolution
• The Color-Magnitude Relation in CL 1358+62 at z=0.33: Evidence for Significant Evolution in the S0 Population
• Evolution and environment of early-type galaxies
• Near-IR bright galaxies at z~2. Entering the spheroid formation epoch ?
• The Space Density and Colors of Massive Galaxies at 2<z<3: the Predominance of Distant Red Galaxies
• The evolution of field early-type galaxies to z~0.7
• The Fundamental Plane at z=1.27: First Calibration of the Mass Scale of Red Galaxies at Redshifts z>1
• A Catalog of Morphological Types in 10 Distant Rich Clusters of Galaxies
• Evolution of Early-Type Galaxies in Distant Clusters: The Fundamental Plane using HST Imaging and Keck Spectroscopy
• A Substantial Population of Red Galaxies at z > 2: Modeling of the Spectral Energy Distributions of an Extended Sample
• The Evolution and Structure of Early-type Field Galaxies: A Combined Statistical Analysis of Gravitational Lenses
• Cluster vs. Field Elliptical Galaxies and Clues on their Formation
• The Evolution of a Mass-Selected Sample of Early-Type Field Galaxies
• The Evolution of Early-Type Galaxies in Distant Clusters III.: M/L_V Ratios in the z=0.33 Cluster CL1358+62
• Clusters at Half Hubble Time: Galaxy Structure and Colors in RXJ0152.7-1357 and MS1054-03
• Spectroscopic Confirmation of a Substantial Population of Luminous Red Galaxies at Redshifts z>2
• The metal enrichment of elliptical galaxies in hierarchical galaxy formation models
• The evolution of early-type galaxies at z~1 from the K20 survey
• The Properties of Field Elliptical Galaxies at Intermediate Redshift. I: Empirical Scaling Laws
• High-Redshift Extremely Red Objects in the HST Ultra Deep Field Revealed by the GOODS IRAC Observations
• Detection of strong clustering of red K-selected galaxies at 2<z_phot<4 in the Hubble Deep Field South
• The star formation history of early-type galaxies as a function of mass and environment
• Spectroscopic Confirmation of Multiple Red Galaxy-Galaxy Mergers in MS1054-03 (z=0.83)
• Luminosity Evolution of Field Early-Type Galaxies to z=0.55
• Evolution of the Color-Magnitude relation in High-Redshift Clusters: Early-type Galaxies in the Lynx Supercluster at z~1.26
• Clustering of K-selected Galaxies at 2<z<3.5: Evidence for a Color-Density Relation
• The Fundamental Plane of Field Early Type Galaxies at z=1
• The evolution of cluster E and S0 galaxies measured from the Fundamental Plane
• The Fundamental Plane of Cluster Ellipticals at z = 1.25
• Direct Measurements of the Stellar Continua and Balmer/4000 Angstrom Breaks of Red z>2 Galaxies: Redshifts and Improved Constraints on Stellar Populations
• The detailed Fundamental Plane of two high redshift clusters: MS 2053-04 at z=0.58 and MS 1054-03 at z=0.83
• A Wide-field Hubble Space Telescope Survey of the Cluster Cl 0024+16 at z=0.4. III: Spectroscopic Signatures of Environmental Evolution in Early Type Galaxies
• Evolution of field early-type galaxies: The view from GOODS/CDFS
• The Tolman Surface Brightness Test for the Reality of the Expansion. IV. A Measurement of the Tolman Signal and the Luminosity Evolution of Early-Type Galaxies
• The Evolution of Early-Type Galaxies in Distant Clusters I.: Surface Photometry and Structural Parameters for 53 Galaxies in the z=0.33 Cluster CL1358+62
• Infall, the Butcher-Oemler Effect, and the Descendants of Blue Cluster Galaxies at z~0.6
• A Tolman Surface Brightness Test for Universal Expansion, and the Evolution of Elliptical Galaxies in Distant Clusters
• On the Assembly History of Early-Type Galaxies in the Hubble Deep Field North
• The Fundamental Plane for z=0.8-0.9 cluster galaxies
• RXJ0152.7-1357: Stellar populations in an X-ray luminous galaxy cluster at z=0.83
• Massive galaxies & EROs at z=1-3 in cosmological hydrodynamic simulations: near-IR properties
• Massive and Red Objects predicted by a semianalytical model of galaxy formation
• The Fundamental Plane and the evolution of the M/L ratio of early-type field galaxies up to z~1
• The Clustering Evolution of Distant Red Galaxies in the GOODS-MUSIC Sample
• Mergers between elliptical galaxies and the thickening of the fundamental plane
• The early-type galaxy population in Abell 2218
• On the evolutionary status of early-type galaxies in clusters at z~0.2 - I. The Fundamental Plane
• Submillimeter observations of Distant Red Galaxies: uncovering the 1mJy 850um-population
• Star Formation in Distant Red Galaxies: Spitzer observations in the Hubble Deep Field South
• A Merger Scenario for the Dynamics of Abell 665
• The Possible z=0.83 Precursors of z=0 M* Early-type Cluster Galaxies
• Chandra Constraints on the AGN Fraction and Star Formation Rate of Red z>~2 Galaxies in the FIRES MS1054-03 Field

Cited by in corpus (112)

• The Growth of Massive Galaxies Since z=2
• The stellar mass assembly of galaxies from z=0 to z=4. Analysis of a sample selected in the rest-frame near-infrared with Spitzer
• Structure and star formation in galaxies out to z=3: evidence for surface density dependent evolution and upsizing
• The Gemini Cluster Astrophysics Spectroscopic Survey (GCLASS): The Role of Environment and Self-Regulation in Galaxy Evolution at z ~ 1
• Environment and self-regulation in galaxy formation
• The galaxy stellar mass-star formation rate relation: Evidence for an evolving stellar initial mass function?
• Type-Ia supernova rates and the progenitor problem, a review
• Forming Compact Massive Galaxies
• A Spitzer-Selected Galaxy Cluster at z=1.62
• Recent Structural Evolution of Early-Type Galaxies: Size Growth from z=1 to z=0
• Dissipation and Extra Light in Galactic Nuclei: IV. Evolution in the Scaling Relations of Spheroids
• Compact High-Redshift Galaxies Are the Cores of the Most Massive Present-Day Spheroids
• Evidence of Cosmic Evolution of the Stellar Initial Mass Function
• The Era of Star Formation in Galaxy Clusters
• Spectroscopic Confirmation of the Rich z=1.80 Galaxy Cluster JKCS 041 Using the WFC3 Grism: Environmental Trends in the Ages and Structure of Quiescent Galaxies
• On the Size and Comoving Mass Density Evolution of Early-Type Galaxies
• CANDELS Observations of the Structural Properties and Evolution of Galaxies in a Cluster at z=1.62
• First Results from Z-FOURGE: Discovery of a Candidate Cluster at z = 2.2 in COSMOS
• The Assembly Histories of Quiescent Galaxies Since z=0.7 from Absorption Line Spectroscopy
• The Different Physical Mechanisms that Drive the Star-Formation Histories of Giant and Dwarf Galaxies
• The redshift evolution of early-type galaxies in COSMOS: Do massive early-type galaxies form by dry mergers?
• Galaxy evolution in overdense environments at high redshift: passive early-type galaxies in a cluster at redshift 2
• Deep Absorption Line Studies of Quiescent Galaxies at z~2: The Dynamical Mass-Size Relation, and First Constraints on the Fundamental plane
• Multi-wavelength study of XMMU J2235.3-2557: the most massive galaxy cluster at z > 1
• Central mass-to-light ratios and dark matter fractions in early-type galaxies
• On the Stellar Masses of IRAC detected Lyman Break Galaxies at z~3
• Formation epochs, star formation histories and sizes of massive early-type galaxies in cluster and field environments at z=1.2: insights from the rest-frame UV
• The Evolution of Active Galactic Nuclei in Clusters of Galaxies to Redshift 1.3
• H-alpha emitters in z~2 proto-clusters: evidence for faster evolution in dense environments
• The Stellar Initial Mass Function in Early-Type Galaxies From Absorption Line Spectroscopy. I. Data and Empirical Trends
• The fundamental plane of EDisCS galaxies - The effect of size evolution
• The Rest-Frame Optical Luminosity Function of Cluster Galaxies at z<0.8 and the Assembly of the Cluster Red Sequence
• The Angular Clustering of Distant Galaxy Clusters
• The Large Early Galaxy Astrophysics Census (LEGA-C) Data Release II: dynamical and stellar population properties of z ~< 1 galaxies in the COSMOS field
• Dissipation and the Fundamental Plane: Observational Tests
• The merger-driven evolution of massive galaxies
• The Formation of Massive Cluster Galaxies
• The Progenitors of Local Ultra-massive Galaxies Across Cosmic Time: from Dusty Star-bursting to Quiescent Stellar Populations
• The Evolution of the Field and Cluster Morphology-Density Relation for Mass-Selected Samples of Galaxies
• Galaxy Assembly Bias on the Red Sequence
• The evolution of early and late type galaxies in the COSMOS up to z~1.2
• The XMM Cluster Survey: Galaxy Morphologies and the Color-Magnitude Relation in XMMXCS J2215.9-1738 at z=1.46
• The GOGREEN Survey: A deep stellar mass function of cluster galaxies at 1.0<z<1.4 and the complex nature of satellite quenching
• The history of mass assembly of faint red galaxies in 28 galaxy clusters since z=1.3
• The Origin of Line Emission in Massive z~2.3 Galaxies: Evidence for Cosmic Downsizing of AGN Host Galaxies
• The Age Spread of Quiescent Galaxies with the NEWFIRM Medium-band Survey: Identification of the Oldest Galaxies out to z~2
• Galaxy protocluster candidates around z ~ 2.4 radio galaxies
• The Nascent Red Sequence at z~2
• Stellar populations and evolution of early-type cluster galaxies: Constraints from optical imaging and spectroscopy of z=0.5-0.9 galaxy clusters
• Tight Correlations Between Massive Galaxy Structural Properties and Dynamics: The Mass Fundamental Plane Was in Place by z~2
• The GOGREEN survey: The environmental dependence of the star-forming galaxy main sequence at $1.0<z<1.5$
• Galaxy disks do not need to survive in the L-CDM paradigm: the galaxy merger rate out to z~1.5 from morpho-kinematic data
• Growth of brightest cluster galaxies via mergers since z = 1
• Spectroscopic Confirmation of a Protocluster at z=3.786
• SPIDER - III. Environmental Dependence of the Fundamental Plane of Early-type Galaxies
• Star formation histories of early-type galaxies at z = 1.2 in cluster and field environments
• The GOGREEN survey: Post-infall environmental quenching fails to predict the observed age difference between quiescent field and cluster galaxies at z>1
• Dynamical Models of Elliptical Galaxies in z=0.5 Clusters: II. Mass-to-Light Ratio Evolution without Fundamental Plane Assumptions
• M/L and Color Evolution for A Deep Sample of M* Cluster Galaxies at z~1: The Formation Epoch and the Tilt of the Fundamental Plane
• The SAMI Galaxy Survey: stellar population and structural trends across the Fundamental Plane
• Early-Type galaxies at z ~ 1.3. III. On the dependence of Formation Epochs and Star Formation Histories on Stellar Mass and Environment
• The Ellipticities of Cluster Early-type Galaxies from z~1 to z~0: No Evolution in the Overall Distribution of Bulge-to-Disk Ratios
• The KMOS Cluster Survey (KCS) I: The fundamental plane and the formation ages of cluster galaxies at redshift $1.4<z<1.6$
• Spatially Resolved Stellar Kinematics of Field Early-Type Galaxies at z=1: Evolution of the Rotation Rate
• The Mass Scale of High-Redshift Galaxies: Virial Mass Estimates Calibrated with Stellar Dynamical Models from LEGA-C
• A morphology revaluation of galaxies in common from the Catalog of Isolated Galaxies and the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (DR6)
• One Plane for All: Massive Star-Forming and Quiescent Galaxies Lie on the Same Mass Fundamental Plane at z~0 and z~0.7
• The Ages of Passive Galaxies in a z=1.62 Protocluster
• Mergers and Star Formation: The environment and Stellar Mass Growth of the Progenitors of Ultra-Massive Galaxies since z = 2
• The Fundamental Plane in the LEGA-C Survey: unraveling the $M/L$ variations of massive star-forming and quiescent galaxies at $z\sim 0.8$
• The Number Densities and Stellar Populations of Massive Galaxies at 3 < z < 6: A Diverse, Rapidly Forming Population in the Early Universe
• The Fundamental Plane of massive quiescent galaxies out to z~2
• Galaxy halo truncation and Giant Arc Surface Brightness Reconstruction in the Cluster MACSJ1206.2-0847
• Z-FIRE: ISM properties of the z = 2.095 COSMOS Cluster
• Evidence for Two Distinct Stellar Initial Mass Functions
• Galaxy populations in massive z=0.2-0.9 clusters: I. Analysis of spectroscopy
• The Dynamical Mass of the Coma Cluster from Deep Learning
• Dynamical Models of Elliptical Galaxies in z=0.5 Clusters: I. Data-Model Comparison and Evolution of Galaxy Rotation
• A Multi-Wavelength Photometric Census of AGN and Star Formation Activity in the Brightest Cluster Galaxies of X-ray Selected Clusters
• The Evolution of Gamma-ray Burst Jet Opening Angle through Cosmic Time
• A census of galaxy constituents in a Coma Progenitor observed at z>3
• Modeling the Ages and Metallicities of Early-Type Galaxies in Fundamental Plane Space
• Determining the Halo Mass Scale where Galaxies Lose Their Gas
• The Abundance Pattern in the Hot ISM of NGC 4472: Insights and Anomalies
• Modeling the red sequence: Hierarchical growth yet slow luminosity evolution
• Identifying the progenitor set of present-day early-type galaxies: a view from the standard model
• The faint end of the red sequence galaxy luminosity function: unveiling surface brightness selection effects with the CLASH clusters
• The VIMOS Public Extragalactic Redshift Survey (VIPERS). Star formation history of passive galaxies
• A z~3 radio galaxy and its protocluster: evidence for a superstructure?
• The KMOS Cluster Survey (KCS) III: fundamental plane of cluster galaxies at $z\simeq 1.80$ in JKCS 041
• The Stellar Mass Fundamental Plane and Compact Quiescent Galaxies at z < 0.6
• How typical is the Coma cluster?
• Nature vs. nurture in the low-density environment: structure and evolution of early-type dwarf galaxies in poor groups
• Data and 2D scaling relations for galaxies in Abell 1689: a hint of size evolution at z~0.2
• Measuring the total infrared light from galaxy clusters at z=0.5-1.6: connecting stellar populations to dusty star formation
• A Radio-to-millimeter Census of Star-forming Galaxies in Protocluster 4C~23.56 at z = 2.5 : Global and local gas kinematics
• Direct Measurements of the magnification produced by galaxy clusters as gravitational lenses
• The Fundamental Plane of cluster spheroidal galaxies at z$\sim 1.3$. Evidence for mass-dependent evolution
• Tightly coupled morpho-kinematic evolution for massive star-forming and quiescent galaxies across 7 Gyr of cosmic time
• The Gemini/HST Galaxy Cluster Project: Stellar Populations in the Low Redshift Reference Cluster Galaxies
• Galaxy Formation and Dark Matter
• The Evolution of Radio Galaxies and X-ray Point Sources in Coma Cluster Progenitors Since z~1.2
• A galaxy populations study of a radio-selected protocluster at z~3.1
• The Fundamental Plane in the hierarchical context
• The scaling relations of galaxies back in time: the road toward virialization
• The Evolution of Bulge-Dominated Field Galaxies from z~1 to the Present
• A new framework for understanding the evolution of early-type galaxies
• ZFIRE: The Beginning of the End for Massive Galaxies at z ~ 2 and Why Environment Matters
• Environmental Effects in the Evolution of Galactic Bulges
• The Gemini/HST Galaxy Cluster Project: Environment Effects on the Stellar Populations in the Lynx Clusters at z=1.27
• The velocity dispersion function of red galaxies in four Hubble Frontier Fields galaxy clusters
• Past, present and Future of the Scaling Relations of Galaxies and Active Galactic Nuclei