How typical is the Coma cluster?
arXiv:1312.3698 · doi:10.1093/mnras/stt2411
Abstract
Coma is frequently used as the archetype z~0 galaxy cluster to compare higher redshift work against. It is not clear, however, how representative the Coma cluster is for galaxy clusters of its mass or X-ray luminosity, and significantly: recent works have suggested that the galaxy population of Coma may be in some ways anomolous. In this work, we present a comparison of Coma to an X-ray selected control sample of clusters. We show that although Coma is typical against the control sample in terms of its internal kinematics (substructure and velocity dispersion profile), it has a significantly high (~3sigma) X-ray temperature set against clusters of comparable mass. By de-redshifting our control sample cluster galaxies star-formation rates using a fit to the galaxy main sequence evolution at z < 0.1, we determine that the typical star-formation rate of Coma galaxies as a function of mass is higher than for galaxies in our control sample at a confidence level of > 99 per cent. One way to alleviate this discrepency and bring Coma in-line with the control sample would be to have the distance to Coma to be slightly lower, perhaps through a non-negligible peculiar velocity with respect to the Hubble expansion, but we do not regard this as likely given precision measurements using a variety of approaches. Therefore in summary, we urge caution in using Coma as a z~0 baseline cluster in galaxy evolution studies.
arXiv commentaccepted for publication in MNRAS
References in corpus (89)
- Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Three Year Results: Implications for Cosmology
- The Seventh Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- The physical properties of star forming galaxies in the low redshift universe
- Star Formation in AEGIS Field Galaxies since z=1.1 : The Dominance of Gradually Declining Star Formation, and the Main Sequence of Star-Forming Galaxies
- The Mass Function of an X-Ray Flux-Limited Sample of Galaxy Clusters
- Galaxy bimodality versus stellar mass and environment
- Environmental Effects on Late-Type Galaxies in Nearby Clusters
- Galaxy Star-Formation as a Function of Environment in the Early Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- Chandra Cluster Cosmology Project II: Samples and X-ray Data Reduction
- The 2dF Galaxy Redshift Survey: The environmental dependence of galaxy star formation rates near clusters
- Gone with the wind: the origin of S0 galaxies in clusters
- Galaxy Zoo: the dependence of morphology and colour on environment
- MACS: A quest for the most massive galaxy clusters in the universe
- Optical Mass Estimates of Galaxy Clusters
- Structure and Dynamics of the Coma Cluster
- Passive spiral formation from halo gas starvation: Gradual transformation into S0s
- The evolution of the star formation activity in galaxies and its dependence on environment
- The origin of dwarf ellipticals in the Virgo cluster
- The build-up of the colour-magnitude relation in galaxy clusters since z~0.8
- The X-ray brightest clusters of galaxies from the Massive Cluster Survey
- A New Measurement of the X-ray Temperature Function of Clusters of Galaxies
- A comparison of the galaxy populations in the Coma and distant clusters: the evolution of k+a galaxies and the role of the intracluster medium
- The build-up of the red-sequence in galaxy clusters since z~0.8
- The Dawn of the Red: Star formation histories of group galaxies over the past 5 billion years
- Reconstructing the History of Star Formation in Rich Cluster Cores
- The Evolution of a Mass-Selected Sample of Early-Type Field Galaxies
- XMM- Newton Observation of the Coma Galaxy Cluster: The temperature structure in the central region
- The RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey. III. Scaling relations of galaxy clusters
- The Star Formation Epoch of the Most Massive Early-Type Galaxies
- The Mass Of The Coma Cluster From Weak Lensing In The Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- Environmentally-Driven Evolution of Simulated Cluster Galaxies
- The dynamical state of the Coma cluster with XMM-Newton
- X-ray Temperatures for the EMSS High Redshift Cluster Sample: Constraints on Cosmology and the Dark Energy Equation of State
- EVOLUTION OF IR-SELECTED GALAXIES IN Z~0.4 CLUSTERS
- The Dynamical Equilibrium of Galaxy Clusters
- An Increase in the faint red galaxy population in massive clusters since z~0.5
- The Las Campanas/AAT Rich Cluster Survey III: Spectroscopic Studies of X-ray Bright Galaxy Clusters at z~0.1
- X-Ray Scaling Relations of Galaxy Groups in a Hydrodynamic Cosmological Simulation
- The evolution of cluster E and S0 galaxies measured from the Fundamental Plane
- The HI gas content of galaxies around Abell 370, a galaxy cluster at z = 0.37
- Another Collision for the Coma Cluster
- RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey. V. The X-ray-Underluminous Abell Clusters
- Inter-cluster Filaments of Galaxies Programme: Abundance and Distribution of Filaments in the 2dFGRS Catalogue
- The XMM Cluster Survey: The interplay between the brightest cluster galaxy and the intra-cluster medium via AGN feedback
- The evolution of the red sequence slope in massive galaxy clusters
- The Fundamental Plane of Early Type Galaxies in Nearby Clusters from the WINGS Database
- The IR Luminosity Functions of Rich Clusters
- Anatomy of luminosity functions: the 2dFGRS example
- The Galaxy Population of Cluster RXJ0848+4453 at z=1.27
- The Relation Between Galaxy Morphology and Environment in the Local Universe: An RC3-SDSS Picture
- A Study of Catalogued Nearby Galaxy Clusters in the SDSS-DR4: I. Cluster Global Properties
- Plunging fireworks: Why do infalling galaxies light up on the outskirts of clusters?
- Environmental Effects in the Structural Parameters of Galaxies in the Coma Cluster
- Wide-field kinematics of globular clusters in the Leo I group
- Testing the Hypothesis of the Morphological Transformation from Field Spiral to Cluster S0
- Substructure in the Most Massive GEEC Groups: Field-like Populations in Dynamically Active Groups
- Luminosity Distributions within Rich Clusters - I: A Ubiquitous Dwarf-Rich Luminosity Function ?
- Constraints on the evolution of S0 galaxies in rich clusters at moderate redshifts
- On the evolutionary status of early-type galaxies in clusters at z~0.2 - I. The Fundamental Plane
- GALEX Observations of "Passive Spirals" in the Cluster Cl 0024+17: Clues to the Formation of S0 Galaxies
- Very deep spectroscopy of the Coma cluster line of sight: exploring new territories
- A Study of Catalogued Nearby Galaxy Clusters in the SDSS-DR4. II. Cluster Substructure
- The K band galaxy luminosity functions of three massive high redshift clusters of galaxies
- The Las Campanas/AAT Rich Cluster Survey I: Precision and Reliability of the Photometric Catalogue
- Evolution in the Cluster Early-type Galaxy Size-Surface Brightness Relation at z =~ 1
- The UV luminosity function and star formation rate of the Coma cluster
- Introducing BAX: a database for X-ray clusters and groups of galaxies
- Infrared Surface Brightness Fluctuations of the Coma Elliptical NGC 4874 and the Value of the Hubble Constant
- Spatial variations of the optical galaxy luminosity functions and red sequences in the Coma cluster: clues to its assembly history
- The Infrared Surface Brightness Fluctuation Distances to the Hydra and Coma Clusters
- RASS-SDSS Galaxy Cluster Survey. VI. The dependence of the cluster SFR on the cluster global properties
- The Globular Cluster Systems in the Coma Ellipticals. I: The Luminosity Function in NGC 4874, and Implications for Hubble's Constant
- Optical and Near-Infrared Structural Properties of Cluster Galaxies at
- The Infrared Luminosity of Galaxy Clusters
- Redshift-distance Survey of Early-type Galaxies: The D_n-sigma Relation
- Substructure in the Coma Cluster: Giants vs Dwarfs
- The Dynamical Distinction between Elliptical and Lenticular Galaxies in Distant Clusters: Further Evidence for the Recent Origin of S0 Galaxies
- The relative distances to the Virgo, Fornax, and Coma clusters of galaxies through the Dn-sigma and the Fundamental Plane relations
- Beppo-SAX temperature maps of galaxy clusters in the Corona Borealis supercluster: A2061, A2067 and A2124
- An environmental Butcher-Oemler effect in intermediate redshift X-ray clusters
- Galaxy Aggregates in the Coma Cluster
- The Galaxy Luminosity Functions down to M_R=-10 in the Coma Cluster
- Abell 1451 and 1RXS J131423.6-251521: a multi-wavelength study of two dynamically perturbed clusters of galaxies
- The role of stellar mass and environment for cluster blue fraction, AGN fraction and star-formation indicators from a targeted analysis of Abell 1691
- A low-redshift galaxy cluster X-ray Temperature Function incorporating Suzaku data
- The bright galaxy population of five medium redshift clusters. I. Color-Magnitude Relation, Blue Fractions and Visual Morphology
- A 3-D wavelet analysis of substructure in the Coma cluster: statistics and morphology
- ASCA observations of massive medium-distant clusters of galaxies. II
- The bright galaxy population of five medium redshift clusters. II. Quantitative Galaxy Morphology
Cited by in corpus (16)
- Physical Bayesian modelling of the non-linear matter distribution: new insights into the Nearby Universe
- The quenching and survival of ultra-diffuse galaxies in the Coma cluster
- Testing chameleon gravity with the Coma cluster
- Type Ia Supernovae are Excellent Standard Candles in the Near-Infrared
- The galaxy population within the virial radius of the Perseus cluster
- Testing a generalized cubic Galileon gravity model with the Coma Cluster
- A tale of a rich cluster at z0.8 as seen by the Star Formation Histories of its ETGs
- The Kinematics of Cluster Galaxies via Velocity Dispersion Profiles
- The Shape of Velocity Dispersion Profiles and the Dynamical State of Galaxy Clusters
- Classification and Evolution of Galaxies According to the Dynamical State of Host Clusters and Galaxy Luminosities
- The Gemini/HST Galaxy Cluster Project: Stellar Populations in the Low Redshift Reference Cluster Galaxies
- The Influence of the Dynamic State of Galaxy Clusters on Segregation Phenomena and Velocity Dispersion Profiles
- Iteratively Reweighted Approaches to Sparse Composite Regularization
- Testing the local supervoid solution to the Hubble tension with direct distance tracers
- The Impact of Disturbed Galaxy Clusters on the Kinematics of Active Galactic Nuclei
- Mid-IR Enhanced Galaxies in the Coma & Virgo Cluster: lenticulars with a high star formation rate