Effects of waveform model systematics on the interpretation of GW150914

Abstract

Parameter estimates of GW150914 were obtained using Bayesian inference, based on three semi-analytic waveform models for binary black hole coalescences. These waveform models differ from each other in their treatment of black hole spins, and all three models make some simplifying assumptions, notably to neglect sub-dominant waveform harmonic modes and orbital eccentricity. Furthermore, while the models are calibrated to agree with waveforms obtained by full numerical solutions of Einstein's equations, any such calibration is accurate only to some non-zero tolerance and is limited by the accuracy of the underlying phenomenology, availability, quality, and parameter-space coverage of numerical simulations. This paper complements the original analyses of GW150914 with an investigation of the effects of possible systematic errors in the waveform models on estimates of its source parameters. To test for systematic errors we repeat the original Bayesian analyses on mock signals from numerical simulations of a series of binary configurations with parameters similar to those found for GW150914. Overall, we find no evidence for a systematic bias relative to the statistical error of the original parameter recovery of GW150914 due to modeling approximations or modeling inaccuracies. However, parameter biases are found to occur for some configurations disfavored by the data of GW150914: for binaries inclined edge-on to the detector over a small range of choices of polarization angles, and also for eccentricities greater than $\sim$0.05. For signals with higher signal-to-noise ratio than GW150914, or in other regions of the binary parameter space (lower masses, larger mass ratios, or higher spins), we expect that systematic errors in current waveform models may impact gravitational-wave measurements, making more accurate models desirable for future observations.

arXiv comment29 pages, 9 figures

References in corpus (112)

• Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger
• GW151226: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a 22-Solar-Mass Binary Black Hole Coalescence
• Gravitational Waves from Mergin Compact Binaries: How Accurately Can One Extract the Binary's Parameters from the Inspiral Waveform?
• Evolution of Binary Black Hole Spacetimes
• Accurate Evolutions of Orbiting Black-Hole Binaries Without Excision
• Effective one-body approach to general relativistic two-body dynamics
• Gravitational wave extraction from an inspiraling configuration of merging black holes
• On the Numerical Integration of Einstein's Field Equations
• Binary Black Hole Mergers in the first Advanced LIGO Observing Run
• Frequency-domain gravitational waves from non-precessing black-hole binaries. II. A phenomenological model for the advanced detector era
• Properties of the Binary Black Hole Merger GW150914
• Robust parameter estimation for compact binaries with ground-based gravitational-wave observations using the LALInference software library
• On gravitational-wave spectroscopy of massive black holes with the space interferometer LISA
• Physics, Astrophysics and Cosmology with Gravitational Waves
• Transition from inspiral to plunge in binary black hole coalescences
• Frequency-domain gravitational waves from non-precessing black-hole binaries. I. New numerical waveforms and anatomy of the signal
• Coalescing binary systems of compact objects to (post)$^{5/2}-Newtonian order. V. Spin Effects
• Observing binary inspiral in gravitational radiation: One interferometer
• A simple model of complete precessing black-hole-binary gravitational waveforms
• The PyCBC search for gravitational waves from compact binary coalescence
• Inspiral-merger-ringdown waveforms for black-hole binaries with non-precessing spins
• A simple construction of initial data for multiple black holes
• Matching post-Newtonian and numerical relativity waveforms: systematic errors and a new phenomenological model for non-precessing black hole binaries
• Effective-one-body model for black-hole binaries with generic mass ratios and spins
• A catalog of 174 binary black-hole simulations for gravitational-wave astronomy
• Towards models of gravitational waveforms from generic binaries II: Modelling precession effects with a single effective precession parameter
• Calibration of Moving Puncture Simulations
• Model Waveform Accuracy Standards for Gravitational Wave Data Analysis
• A single-domain spectral method for black hole puncture data
• Inspiral-merger-ringdown waveforms of spinning, precessing black-hole binaries in the effective-one-body formalism
• Characterization of transient noise in Advanced LIGO relevant to gravitational wave signal GW150914
• Higher-order spin effects in the amplitude and phase of gravitational waveforms emitted by inspiraling compact binaries: Ready-to-use gravitational waveforms
• A New Generalized Harmonic Evolution System
• Improved filters for gravitational waves from inspiralling compact binaries
• Phenomenological template family for black-hole coalescence waveforms
• Measuring gravitational waves from binary black hole coalescences: II. the waves' information and its extraction, with and without templates
• Improved resummation of post-Newtonian multipolar waveforms from circularized compact binaries
• Inspiral-merger-ringdown multipolar waveforms of nonspinning black-hole binaries using the effective-one-body formalism
• Prototype effective-one-body model for nonprecessing spinning inspiral-merger-ringdown waveforms
• A multidomain spectral method for solving elliptic equations
• An excess power statistic for detection of burst sources of gravitational radiation
• Extrinsic Curvature and the Einstein Constraints
• Faithful Effective-One-Body waveforms of small-mass-ratio coalescing black-hole binaries
• Validating the effective-one-body model of spinning, precessing binary black holes against numerical relativity
• Towards models of gravitational waveforms from generic binaries: A simple approximate mapping between precessing and non-precessing inspiral signals
• Implementing a search for aligned-spin neutron star -- black hole systems with advanced ground based gravitational wave detectors
• Solving Einstein's Equations With Dual Coordinate Frames
• An improved effective-one-body Hamiltonian for spinning black-hole binaries
• Modeling Ringdown: Beyond the Fundamental Quasi-Normal Modes
• Frequency domain reduced order models for gravitational waves from aligned-spin compact binaries
• Exploring black hole superkicks
• Georgia Tech Catalog of Gravitational Waveforms
• Observing gravitational-wave transient GW150914 with minimal assumptions
• Binary-black-hole initial data with nearly-extremal spins
• Constraint Likelihood analysis for a network of gravitational wave detectors
• Simulations of Binary Black Hole Mergers Using Spectral Methods
• A new effective-one-body description of coalescing nonprecessing spinning black-hole binaries
• Frequency domain reduced order model of aligned-spin effective-one-body waveforms with generic mass-ratios and spins
• A data-analysis driven comparison of analytic and numerical coalescing binary waveforms: nonspinning case
• Tracking the precession of compact binaries from their gravitational-wave signal
• Accurate Effective-One-Body waveforms of inspiralling and coalescing black-hole binaries
• An improved analysis of GW150914 using a fully spin-precessing waveform model
• High-accuracy numerical simulation of black-hole binaries: Computation of the gravitational-wave energy flux and comparisons with post-Newtonian approximants
• Directly comparing GW150914 with numerical solutions of Einstein's equations for binary black hole coalescence
• Post-Newtonian factorized multipolar waveforms for spinning, non-precessing black-hole binaries
• Reducing phase error in long numerical binary black hole evolutions with sixth order finite differencing
• Error-analysis and comparison to analytical models of numerical waveforms produced by the NRAR Collaboration
• X-Pipeline: An analysis package for autonomous gravitational-wave burst searches
• Complete waveform model for compact binaries on eccentric orbits
• A geometric approach to the precession of compact binaries
• Extrapolating gravitational-wave data from numerical simulations
• Calibration of the Advanced LIGO detectors for the discovery of the binary black-hole merger GW150914
• Transformations of asymptotic gravitational-wave data
• Simulations of non-equal mass black hole binaries with spectral methods
• Extending the effective-one-body Hamiltonian of black-hole binaries to include next-to-next-to-leading spin-orbit couplings
• The NINJA-2 catalog of hybrid post-Newtonian/numerical-relativity waveforms for non-precessing black-hole binaries
• Gauge invariant perturbations of Schwarzschild black holes in horizon-penetrating coordinates
• Improved methods for simulating nearly extremal binary black holes
• Gravitational-wave observations of binary black holes: Effect of non-quadrupole modes
• Reducing orbital eccentricity of precessing black-hole binaries
• Reducing eccentricity in black-hole binary evolutions with initial parameters from post-Newtonian inspiral
• Impact of Higher Harmonics in Searching for Gravitational Waves from Non-Spinning Binary Black Holes
• The Missing Link: Bayesian Detection and Measurement of Intermediate-Mass Black-Hole Binaries
• Can we measure individual black-hole spins from gravitational-wave observations?
• Numerical relativity reaching into post-Newtonian territory: a compact-object binary simulation spanning 350 gravitational-wave cycles
• Accurate gravitational waveforms for binary-black-hole mergers with nearly extremal spins
• Dynamical Excision Boundaries in Spectral Evolutions of Binary Black Hole Spacetimes
• Impact of gravitational radiation higher order modes on single aligned-spin gravitational wave searches for binary black holes
• Energy versus Angular Momentum in Black Hole Binaries
• The Advanced LIGO Photon Calibrators
• Energetics and phasing of nonprecessing spinning coalescing black hole binaries
• Modeling the source of GW150914 with targeted numerical-relativity simulations
• On the accuracy and precision of numerical waveforms: Effect of waveform extraction methodology
• The Samurai Project: verifying the consistency of black-hole-binary waveforms for gravitational-wave detection
• An Improved Gauge Driver for the Generalized Harmonic Einstein System
• Key Elements of Robustness in Binary Black Hole Evolutions using Spectral Methods
• Measuring orbital eccentricity and periastron advance in quasi-circular black hole simulations
• Observing mergers of non-spinning black-hole binaries
• Systematic biases in parameter estimation of binary black-hole mergers
• Accuracy and precision of gravitational-wave models of inspiraling neutron star -- black hole binaries with spin: comparison with numerical relativity in the low-frequency regime
• The NINJA-2 project: Detecting and characterizing gravitational waveforms modelled using numerical binary black hole simulations
• Impact of Higher-order Modes on the Detection of Binary Black Hole Coalescences
• Nearly extremal apparent horizons in simulations of merging black holes
• Measuring intermediate mass black hole binaries with advanced gravitational wave detectors
• Accuracy of binary black hole waveform models for aligned-spin binaries
• An efficient iterative method to reduce eccentricity in numerical-relativity simulations of compact binary inspiral
• Gravitational waveforms for neutron star binaries from binary black hole simulations
• Optimizing spinning time-domain gravitational waveforms for Advanced LIGO data analysis
• Numerical Relativity Injection Infrastructure
• Improving LIGO calibration accuracy by tracking and compensating for slow temporal variations
• Template Mode Hierarchies for Binary Black Hole Mergers
• Fast and efficient evaluation of gravitational waveforms via reduced-order spline interpolation

Cited by in corpus (115)

• GWTC-1: A Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog of Compact Binary Mergers Observed by LIGO and Virgo during the First and Second Observing Runs
• GW170104: Observation of a 50-Solar-Mass Binary Black Hole Coalescence at Redshift 0.2
• GWTC-2: Compact Binary Coalescences Observed by LIGO and Virgo During the First Half of the Third Observing Run
• GW170814: A Three-Detector Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Coalescence
• GWTC-3: Compact Binary Coalescences Observed by LIGO and Virgo During the Second Part of the Third Observing Run
• Properties of the binary neutron star merger GW170817
• Binary Black Hole Population Properties Inferred from the First and Second Observing Runs of Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo
• Tests of General Relativity with the Binary Black Hole Signals from the LIGO-Virgo Catalog GWTC-1
• Tests of General Relativity with Binary Black Holes from the second LIGO-Virgo Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog
• Computationally efficient models for the dominant and sub-dominant harmonic modes of precessing binary black holes
• Bayesian inference for compact binary coalescences with BILBY: Validation and application to the first LIGO--Virgo gravitational-wave transient catalogue
• The SXS Collaboration catalog of binary black hole simulations
• Self-force and radiation reaction in general relativity
• Testing the no-hair theorem with GW150914
• A guide to LIGO-Virgo detector noise and extraction of transient gravitational-wave signals
• Setting the cornerstone for the IMRPhenomX family of models for gravitational waves from compact binaries: The dominant harmonic for non-precessing quasi-circular black holes
• Distinguishing Spin-Aligned and Isotropic Black Hole Populations With Gravitational Waves
• Surrogate model of hybridized numerical relativity binary black hole waveforms
• Enriching the Symphony of Gravitational Waves from Binary Black Holes by Tuning Higher Harmonics
• First higher-multipole model of gravitational waves from spinning and coalescing black-hole binaries
• A gravitational-wave measurement of the Hubble constant following the second observing run of Advanced LIGO and Virgo
• Spin orientations of merging black holes formed from the evolution of stellar binaries
• Phenomenological model for the gravitational-wave signal from precessing binary black holes with two-spin effects
• A Numerical Relativity Waveform Surrogate Model for Generically Precessing Binary Black Hole Mergers
• Determining the population properties of spinning black holes
• A faithful analytical effective one body waveform model for spin-aligned, moderately eccentric, coalescing black hole binaries
• A Surrogate Model of Gravitational Waveforms from Numerical Relativity Simulations of Precessing Binary Black Hole Mergers
• Eccentric, nonspinning, inspiral, Gaussian-process merger approximant for the detection and characterization of eccentric binary black hole mergers
• Measuring eccentricity in binary black hole inspirals with gravitational waves
• The RIT binary black hole simulations catalog
• Gravitational Wave Denoising of Binary Black Hole Mergers with Deep Learning
• On the properties of the massive binary black hole merger GW170729
• Constraining the orbital eccentricity of inspiralling compact binary systems with Advanced LIGO
• Parameter estimation with gravitational waves
• The Science of the Einstein Telescope
• A Multipolar Effective One Body Model for Non-Spinning Black Hole Binaries
• Detectability of gravitational waves from binary black holes: Impact of precession and higher modes
• A Parameter Estimation Method that Directly Compares Gravitational Wave Observations to Numerical Relativity
• The second RIT binary black hole simulations catalog and its application to gravitational waves parameter estimation
• Parameterized tests of the strong-field dynamics of general relativity using gravitational wave signals from coalescing binary black holes: Fast likelihood calculations and sensitivity of the method
• Inferences about supernova physics from gravitational-wave measurements: GW151226 spin misalignment as an indicator of strong black-hole natal kicks
• Constraining the neutron star equation of state using multi-band independent measurements of radii and tidal deformabilities
• Effects of nonquadrupole modes in the detection and parameter estimation of black hole binaries with nonprecessing spins
• Fourier domain gravitational waveforms for precessing eccentric binaries
• The Third RIT binary black hole simulations catalog
• Defining eccentricity for gravitational wave astronomy
• General relativistic simulations of the quasi-circular inspiral and merger of charged black holes: GW150914 and fundamental physics implications
• Statistical Gravitational Waveform Models: What to Simulate Next?
• Parameter Estimation with a spinning multi-mode waveform model: IMRPhenomHM
• Relevance of tidal effects and post-merger dynamics for binary neutron star parameter estimation
• Combined search for anisotropic birefringence in the gravitational-wave transient catalog GWTC-1
• Accurate waveforms for eccentric, aligned-spin binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv5EHM
• Waveform accuracy and systematic uncertainties in current gravitational wave observations
• Follow-up Analyses to the O3 LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA Lensing Searches
• Impact of subdominant modes on the interpretation of gravitational-wave signals from heavy binary black hole systems
• Waveform uncertainty quantification and interpretation for gravitational-wave astronomy
• Testing General Relativity with Gravitational Waves: An Overview
• On the identification of individual gravitational wave image types of a lensed system using higher-order modes
• Measuring precession in asymmetric compact binaries
• Inferring eccentricity evolution from observations of coalescing binary black holes
• Analytical Black-Hole Binary Merger Waveforms
• Physics of eccentric binary black hole mergers: A numerical relativity perspective
• Measuring eccentricity of binary black holes in GWTC-1 by using inspiral-only waveform
• $\mathtt{bajes}$: Bayesian inference of multimessenger astrophysical data, methods and application to gravitational-waves
• Post-Newtonian templates for binary black-hole inspirals: the effect of the horizon fluxes and the secular change in the black-hole masses and spins
• Constraining the parameters of GW150914 & GW170104 with numerical relativity surrogates
• Identifying when Precession can be Measured in Gravitational Waveforms
• The most powerful astrophysical events: Gravitational-wave peak luminosity of binary black holes as predicted by numerical relativity
• Evidence for eccentricity in the population of binary black holes observed by LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA
• Accurate inspiral-merger-ringdown gravitational waveforms for non-spinning black-hole binaries including the effect of subdominant modes
• Blind spots and biases: the dangers of ignoring eccentricity in gravitational-wave signals from binary black holes
• High accuracy post-Newtonian and numerical relativity comparisons involving higher modes for eccentric binary black holes and a dominant mode eccentric inspiral-merger-ringdown model
• Waveform systematics for binary neutron star gravitational wave signals: Effects of spin, precession, and the observation of electromagnetic counterparts
• Correlations in gravitational-wave reconstructions from eccentric binaries: A case study with GW151226 and GW170608
• Numerical-relativity simulations of the quasi-circular inspiral and merger of non-spinning, charged black holes: methods and comparison with approximate approaches
• Gravitational Waves from Binary Black Hole Mergers Inside of Stars
• Post-Newtonian phase accuracy requirements for stellar black hole binaries with LISA
• Systematic Biases in Estimating the Properties of Black Holes Due to Inaccurate Gravitational-Wave Models
• ESIGMAHM: An Eccentric, Spinning inspiral-merger-ringdown waveform model with Higher Modes for the detection and characterization of binary black holes
• Targeted numerical simulations of binary black holes for GW170104
• Systematic challenges for future gravitational wave measurements of precessing binary black holes
• Full 3D Numerical Relativity Simulations of Neutron Star -- Boson Star Collisions with BAM
• Modified gravitational wave propagation with higher modes and its degeneracies with lensing
• Measuring the properties of nearly extremal black holes with gravitational waves
• Including mode mixing in a higher-multipole model for gravitational waveforms from nonspinning black-hole binaries
• Characterization of numerical relativity waveforms of eccentric binary black hole mergers
• Rapid and accurate parameter inference for coalescing, precessing compact binaries
• Detection and characterization of spin-orbit resonances in the advanced gravitational wave detectors era
• Constraint on Brans-Dicke theory from intermediate/extreme mass ratio inspirals
• An architecture for efficient gravitational wave parameter estimation with multimodal linear surrogate models
• Parameter estimation with the current generation of phenomenological waveform models applied to the black hole mergers of GWTC-1
• Degeneracy of gravitational waveforms in the context of GW150914
• Parametrized spin-precessing inspiral-merger-ringdown waveform model for tests of general relativity
• Analysis of GWTC-3 with fully precessing numerical relativity surrogate models
• Improved inspiral-merger-ringdown model for BBHs on elliptical orbits
• Application of the third RIT binary black hole simulations catalog to parameter estimation of gravitational waves signals from the LIGO-Virgo O1/O2 observational runs
• Universal phenomenological relations between spherical harmonic modes in non-precessing eccentric binary black hole merger waveforms
• Inconsistent black hole kick estimates from gravitational-wave models
• Rarity of precession and higher-order multipoles in gravitational waves from merging binary black holes
• Accounting for numerical-relativity calibration uncertainty in gravitational-wave modeling and inference
• Gravitational waveforms for high spin and high mass-ratio binary black holes: A synergistic use of numerical-relativity codes
• Gravitational Wave Measurement in the Mid-Band with Atom Interferometers
• High-precision source characterization of intermediate mass-ratio black hole coalescences with gravitational waves: The importance of higher-order multipoles
• Waveform systematics in identifying strongly gravitationally lensed gravitational waves: Posterior overlap method
• False positives for gravitational lensing: the gravitational-wave perspective
• Post-Newtonian theory-inspired framework for characterizing eccentricity in gravitational waveforms
• Waging a Campaign: Results from an Injection-Recovery Study involving 35 numerical Relativity Simulations and three Waveform Models
• Inferring black-hole orbital dynamics from numerical-relativity gravitational waveforms
• Comparison and application of different post-Newtonian models for inspiralling stellar-mass binary black holes with space-based GW detectors
• Trumpet Initial Data for Boosted Black Holes
• Detecting Unmodeled, Source-dependent Signals in Gravitational Waves with SCoRe
• Extremely High-Order Convergence in Simulations of Relativistic Stars
• Probing neutron stars with the full pre-merger and post-merger gravitational wave signal from binary coalescences
• The Fourth RIT binary black hole simulations catalog: Extension to Eccentric Orbits
• New numerical framework for the generalized Baumgarte-Shapiro-Shibata-Nakamura formulation: The vacuum case for spherical symmetry