Directly comparing GW150914 with numerical solutions of Einstein's equations for binary black hole coalescence

Abstract

We compare GW150914 directly to simulations of coalescing binary black holes in full general relativity, accounting for all the spin-weighted quadrupolar modes, and separately accounting for all the quadrupolar and octopolar modes. Consistent with the posterior distributions reported in LVC_PE[1] (at 90% confidence), we find the data are compatible with a wide range of nonprecessing and precessing simulations. Followup simulations performed using previously-estimated binary parameters most resemble the data. Comparisons including only the quadrupolar modes constrain the total redshifted mass Mz \in [64 - 82M_\odot], mass ratio q = m2/m1 \in [0.6,1], and effective aligned spin χ_eff \in [-0.3, 0.2], where χ_{eff} = (S1/m1 + S2/m2) \cdot\hat{L} /M. Including both quadrupolar and octopolar modes, we find the mass ratio is even more tightly constrained. Simulations with extreme mass ratios and effective spins are highly inconsistent with the data, at any mass. Several nonprecessing and precessing simulations with similar mass ratio and χ_{eff} are consistent with the data. Though correlated, the components' spins (both in magnitude and directions) are not significantly constrained by the data. For nonprecessing binaries, interpolating between simulations, we reconstruct a posterior distribution consistent with previous results. The final black hole's redshifted mass is consistent with Mf,z between 64.0 - 73.5M_\odot and the final black hole's dimensionless spin parameter is consistent with af = 0.62 - 0.73. As our approach invokes no intermediate approximations to general relativity and can strongly reject binaries whose radiation is inconsistent with the data, our analysis provides a valuable complement to LVC_PE[1].

arXiv comment29 pages. Full version of tables available electronically with this submission

References in corpus (127)

• Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger
• Quasinormal modes of black holes and black branes
• Tests of general relativity with GW150914
• Evolution of Binary Black Hole Spacetimes
• Accurate Evolutions of Orbiting Black-Hole Binaries Without Excision
• Gravitational wave extraction from an inspiraling configuration of merging black holes
• On the Numerical Integration of Einstein's Field Equations
• Frequency-domain gravitational waves from non-precessing black-hole binaries. II. A phenomenological model for the advanced detector era
• Properties of the Binary Black Hole Merger GW150914
• Robust parameter estimation for compact binaries with ground-based gravitational-wave observations using the LALInference software library
• The first gravitational-wave source from the isolated evolution of two 40-100 Msun stars
• Astrophysical Implications of the Binary Black-Hole Merger GW150914
• A simple model of complete precessing black-hole-binary gravitational waveforms
• Evolutions in 3D numerical relativity using fixed mesh refinement
• Coalescence of Two Spinning Black Holes: An Effective One-Body Approach
• A new route towards merging massive black holes
• Measuring gravitational waves from binary black hole coalescences: I. Signal to noise for inspiral, merger, and ringdown
• The Einstein Toolkit: A Community Computational Infrastructure for Relativistic Astrophysics
• Gravitational waves from inspiralling compact binaries: Parameter estimation using second-post-Newtonian waveforms
• A simple construction of initial data for multiple black holes
• Matching post-Newtonian and numerical relativity waveforms: systematic errors and a new phenomenological model for non-precessing black hole binaries
• Effective-one-body model for black-hole binaries with generic mass ratios and spins
• Numerical Relativity Using a Generalized Harmonic Decomposition
• A catalog of 174 binary black-hole simulations for gravitational-wave astronomy
• Towards models of gravitational waveforms from generic binaries II: Modelling precession effects with a single effective precession parameter
• Calibration of Moving Puncture Simulations
• Model Waveform Accuracy Standards for Gravitational Wave Data Analysis
• A single-domain spectral method for black hole puncture data
• Inspiral-merger-ringdown waveforms of spinning, precessing black-hole binaries in the effective-one-body formalism
• Spinning-black-hole binaries: The orbital hang up
• A New Generalized Harmonic Evolution System
• Phenomenological template family for black-hole coalescence waveforms
• Analysis of spin precession in binary black hole systems including quadrupole-monopole interaction
• High-accuracy waveforms for binary black hole inspiral, merger, and ringdown
• Inspiral-merger-ringdown multipolar waveforms of nonspinning black-hole binaries using the effective-one-body formalism
• Prototype effective-one-body model for nonprecessing spinning inspiral-merger-ringdown waveforms
• Black-hole binaries, gravitational waves, and numerical relativity
• A multidomain spectral method for solving elliptic equations
• Compact Binary Merger Rates: Comparison with LIGO/Virgo Upper Limits
• Numerical Relativity: A review
• On the final spin from the coalescence of two black holes
• Solving Einstein's Equations With Dual Coordinate Frames
• Estimating the final spin of a binary black hole coalescence
• Harmonic coordinate method for simulating generic singularities
• Fast and accurate prediction of numerical relativity waveforms from binary black hole coalescences using surrogate models
• Spin Flips and Precession in Black-Hole-Binary Mergers
• Frequency domain reduced order models for gravitational waves from aligned-spin compact binaries
• Gravitational recoil from spinning binary black hole mergers
• Observing gravitational-wave transient GW150914 with minimal assumptions
• Binary-black-hole initial data with nearly-extremal spins
• Accurate black hole evolutions by fourth-order numerical relativity
• Measuring coalescing massive binary black holes with gravitational waves: The impact of spin-induced precession
• Simulations of Binary Black Hole Mergers Using Spectral Methods
• High-spin binary black hole mergers
• Remnant Masses, Spins and Recoils from the Merger of Generic Black-Hole Binaries
• Parameter estimation for compact binary coalescence signals with the first generation gravitational-wave detector network
• Remnant mass, spin, and recoil from spin aligned black-hole binaries
• Reducing phase error in long numerical binary black hole evolutions with sixth order finite differencing
• Anatomy of the binary black hole recoil: A multipolar analysis
• Error-analysis and comparison to analytical models of numerical waveforms produced by the NRAR Collaboration
• On the mass radiated by coalescing black-hole binaries
• Testing gravitational-wave searches with numerical relativity waveforms: Results from the first Numerical INJection Analysis (NINJA) project
• Multi-timescale analysis of phase transitions in precessing black-hole binaries
• Comparisons of binary black hole merger waveforms
• A novel scheme for rapid parallel parameter estimation of gravitational waves from compact binary coalescences
• Numerical Relativity and Astrophysics
• Binary Black Holes: Spin Dynamics and Gravitational Recoil
• Circularization and Final Spin in Eccentric Binary Black Hole Inspirals
• Effective potentials and morphological transitions for binary black-hole spin precession
• Zoom-Whirl Orbits in Black Hole Binaries
• Comparisons of eccentric binary black hole simulations with post-Newtonian models
• Simulations of non-equal mass black hole binaries with spectral methods
• The NINJA-2 catalog of hybrid post-Newtonian/numerical-relativity waveforms for non-precessing black-hole binaries
• Kranc: a Mathematica application to generate numerical codes for tensorial evolution equations
• Comparison of Numerical and Post-Newtonian Waveforms for Generic Precessing Black-Hole Binaries
• Orbital Evolution of Extreme-Mass-Ratio Black-Hole Binaries with Numerical Relativity
• Boosted three-dimensional black-hole evolutions with singularity excision
• Improved methods for simulating nearly extremal binary black holes
• Gravitational-wave observations of binary black holes: Effect of non-quadrupole modes
• Gravitational wave extraction and outer boundary conditions by perturbative matching
• Reducing orbital eccentricity of precessing black-hole binaries
• Testing outer boundary treatments for the Einstein equations
• Can we measure individual black-hole spins from gravitational-wave observations?
• Foundations of multiple black hole evolutions
• Numerical relativity reaching into post-Newtonian territory: a compact-object binary simulation spanning 350 gravitational-wave cycles
• Dynamical Excision Boundaries in Spectral Evolutions of Binary Black Hole Spacetimes
• Stable characteristic evolution of generic 3-dimensional single-black-hole spacetimes
• Impact of gravitational radiation higher order modes on single aligned-spin gravitational wave searches for binary black holes
• Matched Filtering of Numerical Relativity Templates of Spinning Binary Black Holes
• Estimating the parameters of non-spinning binary black holes using ground-based gravitational-wave detectors: Statistical errors
• Superkicks in Hyperbolic Encounters of Binary Black Holes
• Relativistic Mergers of Supermassive Black Holes and their Electromagnetic Signatures
• On the accuracy and precision of numerical waveforms: Effect of waveform extraction methodology
• Binary black hole merger: symmetry and the spin expansion
• Nonlinear Gravitational Recoil from the Mergers of Precessing Black-Hole Binaries
• The Samurai Project: verifying the consistency of black-hole-binary waveforms for gravitational-wave detection
• Comparing gravitational waves from nonprecessing and precessing black hole binaries in the corotating frame
• Gravitational waves from BH-NS binaries: Effective Fisher matrices and parameter estimation using higher harmonics
• Observing mergers of non-spinning black-hole binaries
• Extreme black hole simulations: collisions of unequal mass black holes and the point particle limit
• Modeling the remnant mass, spin, and recoil from unequal-mass, precessing black-hole binaries: The Intermediate Mass Ratio Regime
• Accuracy and precision of gravitational-wave models of inspiraling neutron star -- black hole binaries with spin: comparison with numerical relativity in the low-frequency regime
• The NINJA-2 project: Detecting and characterizing gravitational waveforms modelled using numerical binary black hole simulations
• Neutron stars versus black holes: probing the mass gap with LIGO/Virgo
• Perturbative extraction of gravitational waveforms generated with Numerical Relativity
• Status of NINJA: the Numerical INJection Analysis project
• Status of black-hole-binary simulations for gravitational-wave detection
• Precessional instability in binary black holes with aligned spins
• Parameter Estimation of Gravitational Waves from Precessing BH-NS Inspirals with higher harmonics
• Measuring parameters of massive black hole binaries with partially aligned spins
• Precession during merger 1: Strong polarization changes are observationally accessible features of strong-field gravity during binary black hole merger
• Comparing Post-Newtonian and Numerical-Relativity Precession Dynamics
• Nearly extremal apparent horizons in simulations of merging black holes
• Nonspinning searches for spinning binaries in ground-based detector data: Amplitude and mismatch predictions in the constant precession cone approximation
• Accuracy of binary black hole waveform models for aligned-spin binaries
• Black hole binary remnant mass and spin: A new phenomenological formula
• Flip-flopping binary black holes
• A single-spin precessing gravitational wave in closed form
• Parameter Estimation of Gravitational Waves from Nonprecessing BH-NS Inspirals with higher harmonics: Comparing MCMC posteriors to an Effective Fisher Matrix
• Parameter estimation for coalescing massive binary black holes with LISA using the full 2-post-Newtonian gravitational waveform and spin-orbit precession
• Distinguishing black-hole spin-orbit resonances by their gravitational wave signatures. II: Full parameter estimation
• Exploring the Outer Limits of Numerical Relativity
• Template Mode Hierarchies for Binary Black Hole Mergers
• Template Banks for Binary black hole searches with Numerical Relativity waveforms
• Final Mass and Spin of Merged Black Holes and the Golden Black Hole
• Intrinsic selection biases of ground-based gravitational wave searches for high-mass BH-BH mergers
• Efficient method for measuring the parameters encoded in a gravitational-wave signal

Cited by in corpus (106)

• GWTC-1: A Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog of Compact Binary Mergers Observed by LIGO and Virgo during the First and Second Observing Runs
• GW170104: Observation of a 50-Solar-Mass Binary Black Hole Coalescence at Redshift 0.2
• GW170814: A Three-Detector Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Coalescence
• GW170608: Observation of a 19-solar-mass Binary Black Hole Coalescence
• Binary Black Hole Mergers in the first Advanced LIGO Observing Run
• Tests of General Relativity with the Binary Black Hole Signals from the LIGO-Virgo Catalog GWTC-1
• Black holes, gravitational waves and fundamental physics: a roadmap
• Properties and astrophysical implications of the 150 Msun binary black hole merger GW190521
• The SXS Collaboration catalog of binary black hole simulations
• Testing the no-hair theorem with GW150914
• A guide to LIGO-Virgo detector noise and extraction of transient gravitational-wave signals
• Deep Learning for Real-time Gravitational Wave Detection and Parameter Estimation: Results with Advanced LIGO Data
• Distinguishing Spin-Aligned and Isotropic Black Hole Populations With Gravitational Waves
• Deep Neural Networks to Enable Real-time Multimessenger Astrophysics
• Surrogate model of hybridized numerical relativity binary black hole waveforms
• A Numerical Relativity Waveform Surrogate Model for Generically Precessing Binary Black Hole Mergers
• Reconstructing phenomenological distributions of compact binaries via gravitational wave observations
• Laying the foundation of the effective-one-body waveform models SEOBNRv5: improved accuracy and efficiency for spinning non-precessing binary black holes
• An information-theoretic approach to the gravitational-wave burst detection problem
• Effects of waveform model systematics on the interpretation of GW150914
• Localization accuracy of compact binary coalescences detected by the third-generation gravitational-wave detectors and implication for cosmology
• The RIT binary black hole simulations catalog
• Gravitational Wave Denoising of Binary Black Hole Mergers with Deep Learning
• On the properties of the massive binary black hole merger GW170729
• Remnant of binary black-hole mergers: New simulations and peak luminosity studies
• Explaining LIGO's observations via isolated binary evolution with natal kicks
• Polarization-based Tests of Gravity with the Stochastic Gravitational-Wave Background
• Detectability of gravitational waves from binary black holes: Impact of precession and higher modes
• Modeling the source of GW150914 with targeted numerical-relativity simulations
• A Parameter Estimation Method that Directly Compares Gravitational Wave Observations to Numerical Relativity
• The second RIT binary black hole simulations catalog and its application to gravitational waves parameter estimation
• Inferences about supernova physics from gravitational-wave measurements: GW151226 spin misalignment as an indicator of strong black-hole natal kicks
• Numerical Relativity of Compact Binaries in the 21st Century
• Improved Cauchy-characteristic evolution system for high-precision numerical relativity waveforms
• Effects of nonquadrupole modes in the detection and parameter estimation of black hole binaries with nonprecessing spins
• The Third RIT binary black hole simulations catalog
• Accelerating parameter inference with graphics processing units
• Validating gravitational-wave detections: The Advanced LIGO hardware injection system
• Statistical Gravitational Waveform Models: What to Simulate Next?
• Gravitational wave sources: reflections and echoes
• Tracking black hole kicks from gravitational wave observations
• Accurate waveforms for eccentric, aligned-spin binary black holes: The multipolar effective-one-body model SEOBNRv5EHM
• Impact of subdominant modes on the interpretation of gravitational-wave signals from heavy binary black hole systems
• Gravitational signatures of a non--commutative stable black hole
• Denoising of gravitational wave signals via dictionary learning algorithms
• The hangup effect in unequal mass binary black hole mergers and further studies of their gravitational radiation and remnant properties
• Novel Gravastar Solutions: Investigating Stability, Energy, and Entropy in the Presence of Cloud of Strings and Quintessence
• Absorption, Scattering, Geodesics, Shadows and Lensing Phenomena of Black Holes in Effective Quantum Gravity
• Physics of eccentric binary black hole mergers: A numerical relativity perspective
• Analytic gravitational waveforms for generic precessing compact binaries
• Post-Newtonian templates for binary black-hole inspirals: the effect of the horizon fluxes and the secular change in the black-hole masses and spins
• Constraining the parameters of GW150914 & GW170104 with numerical relativity surrogates
• Impact of Numerical Relativity information on effective-one-body waveform models
• Post-Newtonian Quasicircular Initial Orbits for Numerical Relativity
• Blind spots and biases: the dangers of ignoring eccentricity in gravitational-wave signals from binary black holes
• Gravitational traces of bumblebee gravity in metric-affine formalism
• Multi-waveform inference of gravitational waves
• Puncture Initial Data for Black-Hole Binaries with High Spins and High Boosts
• Comprehensive analysis of the tidal effect in gravitational waves and implication for cosmology
• Analysis of a regular black hole in Verlinde's gravity
• Kicking gravitational wave detectors with recoiling black holes
• Quasinormal modes and shadows of a new family of Ayón-Beato-Garc\'ıa black holes
• Quasinormal mode and spectroscopy of a Schwarzschild black hole surrounded by a cloud of strings in Rastall gravity
• ESIGMAHM: An Eccentric, Spinning inspiral-merger-ringdown waveform model with Higher Modes for the detection and characterization of binary black holes
• The existence and stability of marginally trapped surfaces
• Investigating the relation between gravitational wave tests of general relativity
• Effects of non-commutative geometry on black hole properties
• Targeted numerical simulations of binary black holes for GW170104
• Systematic challenges for future gravitational wave measurements of precessing binary black holes
• Constraints on the contributions to the observed binary black hole population from individual evolutionary pathways in isolated binary evolution
• Numerical-relativity validation of effective-one-body waveforms in the intermediate-mass-ratio regime
• The nonspinning binary black hole merger scenario revisited
• Improved analysis of GW190412 with a precessing numerical relativity surrogate waveform model
• Including mode mixing in a higher-multipole model for gravitational waveforms from nonspinning black-hole binaries
• Characterization of numerical relativity waveforms of eccentric binary black hole mergers
• Evolutions of Nearly Maximally Spinning Black Hole Binaries Using the Moving Puncture Approach
• $f(Q,L_m)$ gravity, and its cosmological implications
• An architecture for efficient gravitational wave parameter estimation with multimodal linear surrogate models
• Investigating the noise residuals around the gravitational wave event GW150914
• High-dimensional Schwarzschild black holes in scalar-tensor-vector gravity theory
• Geodesics, accretion disk, gravitational lensing, time delay, and effects on neutrinos induced by a non-commutative black hole
• Quasinormal Modes of the Generalized Ayón-Beato-Garc\'ıa Scalar-Tensor-Vector Gravity Black Hole in the Scalar-Tensor-Vector Gravity
• Exploring Supernova Gravitational Waves with Machine Learning
• Antisymmetric tensor influence on charged black hole lensing phenomena and time delay
• Non-commutativity in Hayward spacetime
• Application of the third RIT binary black hole simulations catalog to parameter estimation of gravitational waves signals from the LIGO-Virgo O1/O2 observational runs
• Gravitational-wave parameter inference with the Newman-Penrose scalar ${\psi }_4$
• Boson star head-on collisions with constraint-violating and constraint-satisfying initial data
• Evolutions of unequal mass, highly spinning black hole binaries
• Python Open Source Waveform Extractor (POWER): An open source, Python package to monitor and post-process numerical relativity simulations
• Accounting for numerical-relativity calibration uncertainty in gravitational-wave modeling and inference
• Second MAYA Catalog of Binary Black Hole Numerical Relativity Waveforms
• Gravitational wave extraction in higher dimensional numerical relativity using the Weyl tensor
• Note on Accuracy of the Post-Newtonian Approximation for Extreme-Mass Ratio Inspirals: Retrograde Orbits
• Initial Data and Eccentricity Reduction Toolkit for Binary Black Hole Numerical Relativity Waveforms
• Adapted gauge to a quasilocal measure of the black holes recoil
• Misaligned Spin Merging Black Holes in Modified Gravity (MOG)
• Advancing the Effective-One-Body Framework in the Test-Mass Limit
• Five dimensional rotating and Quintessence black hole and their hypershadows
• Testing Lorentz symmetry with space-based gravitational-wave detectors
• Testing Gauss-Bonnet Gravity with DESI BAO Data
• AstroDance: Engaging Deaf and Hard-of-Hearing Students in Astrophysics via Multimedia Performances
• Inferences about the distribution, merger rate, and evolutionary processes of compact binaries from gravitational wave observations
• Localized five-dimensional rotating brane-world black hole Analytically Connected to an to an AdS${}_5$ boundary
• The Fourth RIT binary black hole simulations catalog: Extension to Eccentric Orbits
• Connections between entropy surface density and microscopic property in black holes