Low False-Positive Rate of Kepler Candidates Estimated From A Combination Of Spitzer And Follow-Up Observations

Abstract

(Abridged) NASA's Kepler mission has provided several thousand transiting planet candidates, yet only a small subset have been confirmed as true planets. Therefore, the most fundamental question about these candidates is the fraction of bona fide planets. Estimating the rate of false positives of the overall Kepler sample is necessary to derive the planet occurrence rate. We present the results from two large observational campaigns that were conducted with the Spitzer telescope during the the Kepler mission. These observations are dedicated to estimating the false positive rate (FPR) amongst the Kepler candidates. We select a sub-sample of 51 candidates, spanning wide ranges in stellar, orbital and planetary parameter space, and we observe their transits with Spitzer at 4.5 microns. We use these observations to measures the candidate's transit depths and infrared magnitudes. A bandpass-dependent depth alerts us to the potential presence of a blending star that could be the source of the observed eclipse: a false-positive scenario. For most of the candidates (85%), the transit depths measured with Kepler are consistent with the depths measured with Spitzer as expected for planetary objects, while we find that the most discrepant measurements are due to the presence of unresolved stars that dilute the photometry. The Spitzer constraints on their own yield FPRs between 5-40%, depending on the KOIs. By considering the population of the Kepler field stars, and by combining follow-up observations (imaging) when available, we find that the overall FPR of our sample is low. The measured upper limit on the FPR of our sample is 8.8% at a confidence level of 3 sigma. This observational result, which uses the achromatic property of planetary transit signals that is not investigated by the Kepler observations, provides an independent indication that Kepler's false positive rate is low.

arXiv comment33 pages, 16 figures, 3 tables; accepted for publication in ApJ on February 7, 2015

References in corpus (97)

• The Infrared Array Camera (IRAC) for the Spitzer Space Telescope
• The Spitzer Space Telescope Mission
• Analytic Lightcurves for Planetary Transit Searches
• The Dartmouth Stellar Evolution Database
• Theoretical isochrones in several photometric systems I. Johnson-Cousins-Glass, HST/WFPC2, HST/NICMOS, Washington, and ESO Imaging Survey filter sets
• Kepler Mission Design, Realized Photometric Performance, and Early Science
• Planet Occurrence within 0.25 AU of Solar-type Stars from Kepler
• The false positive rate of Kepler and the occurrence of planets
• Planetary Candidates Observed by Kepler, III: Analysis of the First 16 Months of Data
• Characteristics of planetary candidates observed by Kepler, II: Analysis of the first four months of data
• On the Unique Solution of Planet and Star Parameters from an Extrasolar Planet Transit Light Curve
• Kepler Input Catalog: Photometric Calibration and Stellar Classification
• Prevalence of Earth-size planets orbiting Sun-like stars
• On detecting terrestrial planets with timing of giant planet transits
• DHP Framework: Digital Health Passports Using Blockchain -- Use case on international tourism during the COVID-19 pandemic
• A Closely-Packed System of Low-Mass, Low-Density Planets Transiting Kepler-11
• Detection of Thermal Emission from an Extrasolar Planet
• The Occurrence Rate of Small Planets around Small Stars
• Star counts in the Galaxy. Simulating from very deep to very shallow photometric surveys with the TRILEGAL code
• Absolute Calibration of the Infrared Array Camera on the Spitzer Space Telescope
• Improved parameters for extrasolar transiting planets
• Kepler Eclipsing Binary Stars. I. Catalog and Principal Characterization of 1879 Eclipsing Binaries in the First Data Release
• Validation of Kepler's Multiple Planet Candidates. III: Light Curve Analysis & Announcement of Hundreds of New Multi-planet Systems
• Masses, Radii, and Orbits of Small Kepler Planets: The Transition from Gaseous to Rocky Planets
• Kepler Asteroseismology Program: Introduction and First Results
• Revised Stellar Properties of Kepler Targets for the Quarter 1-16 Transit Detection Run
• Quantifying the Uncertainty in the Orbits of Extrasolar Planets
• TrES-1: The Transiting Planet of a Bright K0V Star
• Kepler Eclipsing Binary Stars. II. 2165 Eclipsing Binaries in the Second Data Release
• Efficient identification of exoplanetary transit candidates from SuperWASP light curves
• Fundamental Properties of Kepler Planet-Candidate Host Stars using Asteroseismology
• Initial Characteristics of Kepler Long Cadence Data For Detecting Transiting Planets
• Almost All of Kepler's Multiple Planet Candidates are Planets
• Selection, Prioritization, and Characteristics of Kepler Target Stars
• The Mass of KOI-94d and a Relation for Planet Radius, Mass, and Incident Flux
• Initial Characteristics of Kepler Short Cadence Data
• HAT-P-1b: A Large-Radius, Low-Density Exoplanet Transiting one Member of a Stellar Binary
• An Efficient Automated Validation Procedure for Exoplanet Transit Candidates
• Modeling Kepler transit light curves as false positives: Rejection of blend scenarios for Kepler-9, and validation of Kepler-9d, a super-Earth-size planet in a multiple system
• Kepler-62: A five-planet system with planets of 1.4 and 1.6 Earth radii in the Habitable Zone
• Lack of Inflated Radii for Kepler Giant Planet Candidates Receiving Modest Stellar Irradiation
• Transit Timing Observations from Kepler: IV. Confirmation of 4 Multiple Planet Systems by Simple Physical Models
• Kepler-22b: A 2.4 Earth-radius Planet in the Habitable Zone of a Sun-like Star
• On the Low False Positive Probabilities of Kepler Planet Candidates
• Validation of Kepler's Multiple Planet Candidates. II: Refined Statistical Framework and Descriptions of Systems of Special Interest
• Density and Eccentricity of Kepler Planets
• Planetary Candidates Observed by Kepler IV: Planet Sample From Q1-Q8 (22 Months)
• The Exoplanet Census: A General Method, Applied to Kepler
• Expected Detection and False Alarm Rates for Transiting Jovian Planets
• Search for Carbon Monoxide in the atmosphere of the Transiting Exoplanet HD189733b
• PASTIS: Bayesian extrasolar planet validation. I. General framework, models, and performance
• The hot-Jupiter Kepler-17b: discovery, obliquity from stroboscopic starspots, and atmospheric characterization
• Kepler 18-b, c, and d: A System Of Three Planets Confirmed by Transit Timing Variations, Lightcurve Validation, Spitzer Photometry and Radial Velocity Measurements
• Transit Timing Observations from Kepler: VII. Confirmation of 27 planets in 13 multiplanet systems via Transit Timing Variations and orbital stability
• A First Comparison of Kepler Planet Candidates in Single and Multiple Systems
• Transit Timing Observations from Kepler: III. Confirmation of 4 Multiple Planet Systems by a Fourier-Domain Study of Anti-correlated Transit Timing Variations
• SOPHIE velocimetry of Kepler transit candidates VII. A false-positive rate of 35% for Kepler close-in giant exoplanet candidates
• The statistics of multi-planet systems
• Identification of Background False Positives from Kepler Data
• Instrument Performance in Kepler's First Months
• Pre-Spectroscopic False Positive Elimination of Kepler Planet Candidates
• The Kepler Pixel Response Function
• The Kepler-19 System: A Transiting 2.2 R_Earth Planet and a Second Planet Detected via Transit Timing Variations
• Robotic Laser-Adaptive-Optics Imaging of 715 Kepler Exoplanet Candidates using Robo-AO
• Testing blend scenarios for extrasolar transiting planet candidates. I. -- OGLE-TR-33: a false positive
• Asymmetric transit curves as indication of orbital obliquity: clues from the late-type dwarf companion in KOI-13
• High-resolution imaging of $Kepler$ planet host candidates. A comprehensive comparison of different techniques
• Contamination in the Kepler Field. Identification of 685 KOIs as False Positives Via Ephemeris Matching Based On Q1-Q12 Data
• Planet-Planet Eclipse and the Rossiter-McLaughlin Effect of a Multiple Transiting System: Joint Analysis of the Subaru Spectroscopy and the Kepler Photometry
• Adaptive Optics Images of Kepler Objects of Interest
• Kepler-20: A Sun-like Star with Three Sub-Neptune Exoplanets and Two Earth-size Candidates
• Detection Of KOI-13.01 Using The Photometric Orbit
• Measurement of the Spin-Orbit Misalignment of KOI-13.01 from its Gravity-Darkened Kepler Transit Lightcurve
• Kepler-4b: Hot Neptune-Like Planet of a G0 Star Near Main-Sequence Turnoff
• Discovery and Rossiter-McLaughlin Effect of Exoplanet Kepler-8b
• Kepler-10c, a 2.2-Earth radius transiting planet in a multiple system
• Multiplicity in transiting planet host stars. A Lucky Imaging study of Kepler candidates
• Kepler-68: Three Planets, One With a Density Between That of Earth and Ice Giants
• What asteroseismology can do for exoplanets: Kepler-410A b is a Small Neptune around a bright star, in an eccentric orbit consistent with low obliquity
• Terrestrial, Habitable-Zone Exoplanet Frequency from Kepler
• Kepler-14b: A massive hot Jupiter transiting an F star in a close visual binary
• HATNet Field G205: Follow-Up Observations of 28 Transiting-Planet candidates and Confirmation of the Planet HAT-P-8b
• The Occurrence Rate of Earth Analog Planets Orbiting Sunlike Stars
• Measuring Transit Signal Recovery in the Kepler Pipeline I: Individual Events
• A High False Positive Rate for Kepler Planetary Candidates of Giant Stars using Asterodensity Profiling
• Adaptive Optics Images II: 12 Kepler Objects of Interest and 15 Confirmed Transiting Planets
• A super-Earth-sized planet orbiting in or near the habitable zone around Sun-like star
• Discovery and Atmospheric Characterization of Giant Planet Kepler-12b: An Inflated Radius Outlier
• Kepler-93b: A Terrestrial World Measured to within 120 km, and a Test Case for a New Spitzer Observing Mode
• In-flight performance and calibration of the Infrared Array Camera (IRAC) for the Spitzer Space Telescope
• The atmospheres of the hot-Jupiters Kepler-5b and Kepler-6b observed during occultations with Warm-Spitzer and Kepler
• Hubble Space Telescope High Resolution Imaging of Kepler Small and Cool Exoplanet Host Stars
• Transit spectrophotometry of the exoplanet HD189733b. II. New Spitzer observations at 3.6 microns
• Constraining the False Positive Rate for Kepler Planet Candidates with Multi-Color Photometry from the GTC
• Exoplanet Characterization by Proxy: a Transiting 2.15 R_Earth Planet Near the Habitable Zone of the Late K dwarf Kepler-61
• A Discovery of a Candidate Companion to a Transiting System KOI-94: A Direct Imaging Study for a Possibility of a False Positive
• Minimizing follow-up for space-based transit surveys using full lightcurve analysis

Cited by in corpus (42)

• False positive probabilties for all Kepler Objects of Interest: 1284 newly validated planets and 428 likely false positives
• Terrestrial Planet Occurrence Rates for the Kepler GK Dwarf Sample
• The California-Kepler Survey. I. High Resolution Spectroscopy of 1305 Stars Hosting Kepler Transiting Planets
• SOPHIE velocimetry of Kepler transit candidates XVII. The physical properties of giant exoplanets within 400 days of period
• Hot super-Earths stripped by their host stars
• The Kepler Follow-Up Observation Program. I. A Catalog of Companions to Kepler Stars from High-Resolution Imaging
• The orbital eccentricity of small planet systems
• Stellar and Planetary Properties of K2 Campaign 1 Candidates and Validation of 17 Planets, Including a Planet Receiving Earth-like Insolation
• A Catalog of Kepler Habitable Zone Exoplanet Candidates
• Spitzer Observations Confirm and Rescue the Habitable-Zone Super-Earth K2-18b for Future Characterization
• TESS Hunt for Young and Maturing Exoplanets (THYME) II: A 17 Myr Old Transiting Hot Jupiter in the Sco-Cen Association
• A Lucky Imaging search for stellar sources near 74 transit hosts
• The Ĝ Search for Extraterrestrial Civilizations with Large Energy Supplies. IV. The Signatures and Information Content of Transiting Megastructures
• TESS Hunt for Young and Maturing Exoplanets (THYME) VI: an 11 Myr giant planet transiting a very low-mass star in Lower Centaurus Crux
• Robo-AO Kepler Planetary Candidate Survey III: Adaptive Optics Imaging of 1629 Kepler Exoplanet Candidate Host Stars
• TESS Hunt for Young and Maturing Exoplanets (THYME) V: A Sub-Neptune Transiting a Young Star in a Newly Discovered 250 Myr Association
• The Solar System as an Exoplanetary System
• TESS Hunt for Young and Maturing Exoplanets (THYME) IV: Three small planets orbiting a 120 Myr-old star in the Pisces--Eridanus stream
• Characterizing Undetected Stellar Companions with Combined Datasets
• Exoplanet Characterization by Multi-Observatory Transit Photometry with TESS and CHEOPS
• Perturbation of Compact Planetary Systems by Distant Giant Planets
• The Kepler Follow-Up Observation Program. II. Stellar Parameters from Medium- and High-Resolution Spectroscopy
• The First Habitable Zone Earth-Sized Planet From TESS II: $Spitzer$ Confirms TOI-700 d
• Giants are bullies: how their growth influences systems of inner sub-Neptunes and super-Earths
• Identifying False Alarms in the Kepler Planet Candidate Catalog
• Formation of planetary systems by pebble accretion and migration: Hot super-Earth systems from breaking compact resonant chains
• Spitzer Observations of Exoplanets Discovered with The Kepler K2 Mission
• Vetting Kepler Planet Candidates in the Sub-Jovian Desert with Multi-Band Photometry
• Rocky Planet Formation: Quick and Neat
• TOI-150b and TOI-163b: two transiting hot Jupiters, one eccentric and one inflated, revealed by TESS near and at the edge of the JWST CVZ
• TESS Investigation -- Demographics of Young Exoplanets (TI-DYE) II: a second giant planet in the 17-Myr system HIP 67522
• Average Albedos of Close-in Super-Earths and Neptunes from Statistical Analysis of Long Cadence Kepler Secondary Eclipse Data
• The K2-ESPRINT Project II: Spectroscopic follow-up of three exoplanet systems from Campaign 1 of K2
• Transit Probabilities in Secularly Evolving Planetary Systems
• Tidally-Distorted, Iron-Enhanced Exoplanets Closely Orbiting Their Stars
• Probability of Physical Association of 104 Blended Companions to \textit{Kepler} Objects of Interest Using Visible and Near-Infrared Adaptive Optics Photometry
• A systematic search for transiting planets in the K2 data
• Kepler-62f: Kepler's First Small Planet in the Habitable Zone, but Is It Real?
• A low-mass sub-Neptune planet transiting the bright active star HD 73344
• Temperate super-Earths/mini-Neptunes around M/K dwarfs Consist of 2 Populations Distinguished by Their Atmospheres
• K2, Spitzer, and TESS Transits of Four Sub-Neptune Exoplanets
• NGTS-EB-8: A double-lined eclipsing M+M binary discovered by citizen scientists