Testing blend scenarios for extrasolar transiting planet candidates. I. -- OGLE-TR-33: a false positive

Abstract

We report high-resolution spectroscopic follow-up observations of the faint transiting planet candidate OGLE-TR-33 (V = 14.7), located in the direction of the Galactic center. Small changes in the radial velocity of the star were detected that suggested initially the presence of a large planet or brown dwarf in orbit. However, further analysis revealed spectral line asymmetries that change in phase with the 1.95-day period, casting doubt on those measurements. These asymmetries make it more likely that the transit-like events in the light curve are the result of contamination from the light of an eclipsing binary along the same line of sight (referred to as a "blend"). We performed detailed simulations in which we generated synthetic light curves resulting from such blend scenarios and fitted them to the measured light curve. Guided by these fits and the inferred properties of the stars, we uncovered a second set of lines in our spectra that correspond to the primary of the eclipsing binary and explain the asymmetries. Using all the constraints from spectroscopy we were then able to construct a model that satisfies all the observations, and to characterize the three stars based on model isochrones. OGLE-TR-33 is fully consistent with being a hierarchical triple system composed of a slightly evolved F6 star (the brighter object) near the end of its main-sequence phase, and an eclipsing binary with a K7-M0 star orbiting an F4 star. The application to OGLE-TR-33 of the formalism developed to fit light curves of transit candidates illustrates the power of such simulations for predicting additional properties of the blend and for guiding further observations that may serve to confirm that scenario, thereby ruling out a planet. Tests such as this can be very important for validating faint candidates.

33 pages including 1 table and 10 figures. To appear in ApJ, October 20, 2004 issue

References in corpus (27)

• Evolutionary tracks and isochrones for low- and intermediate-mass stars: from 0.15 to 7 M_sun, and from Z=0.0004 to 0.03
• Analytic Lightcurves for Planetary Transit Searches
• Detection of Planetary Transits Across a Sun-like Star
• Detection of an Extrasolar Planet Atmosphere
• On the Unique Solution of Planet and Star Parameters from an Extrasolar Planet Transit Light Curve
• No planet for HD 166435
• Detection of oxygen and carbon in the hydrodynamically escaping atmosphere of the extrasolar planet HD209458b
• Absolute dimensions of the M-type eclipsing binary YY Geminorum (Castor C): a challenge to evolutionary models in the lower main-sequence
• RVSAO 2.0: Digital Redshifts and Radial Velocities
• The Spectroscopic Orbit of the Planetary Companion Transiting HD209458
• The Y^2 Stellar Evolutionary Tracks
• The CORALIE survey for southern extra-solar planets IX. A 1.3-day period brown dwarf disguised as a planet
• Two new "very hot Jupiters" among the OGLE transiting candidates
• Expected Detection and False Alarm Rates for Transiting Jovian Planets
• A transiting extrasolar giant planet around the star OGLE-TR-113
• The 0.4-Mo Eclipsing Binary CU Cancri: Absolute Dimensions, Comparison with Evolutionary Models and Possible Evidence for a Circumstellar Dust Disk
• First Results from the Anglo-Australian Planet Search - A Brown Dwarf Candidate and a 51 Peg-like Planet
• The ELODIE survey for northern extra-solar planets III. Three planetary candidates detected with ELODIE
• New Data and Improved Parameters for the Transiting Planet OGLE-TR-56b
• Multi-order TODCOR: application to observations taken with the CORALIE echelle spectrograph
• The Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment. Is Interstellar Extinction Toward the Galactic Center Anomalous?
• High-resolution spectroscopic follow-up of OGLE planetary transit candidates in the Galactic bulge: two possible Jupiter-mass planets and two blends
• On the Selection of Photometric Planetary Transits
• The EXPLORE Project I: A Deep Search for Transiting Extrasolar Planets
• Ellipsoidal Variability in the OGLE Planetary Transit Candidates
• The EXPLORE Project: A Deep Search for Transiting Extra-Solar Planets
• Sherlock: An Automated Follow-Up Telescope for Wide-Field Transit Searches

Cited by in corpus (103)

• Shrinking binary and planetary orbits by Kozai cycles with tidal friction
• The false positive rate of Kepler and the occurrence of planets
• KEPLER's First Rocky Planet: Kepler-10b
• Characteristics of Kepler Planetary Candidates Based on the First Data Set: The Majority are Found to be Neptune-Size and Smaller
• WASP-1b and WASP-2b: Two new transiting exoplanets detected with SuperWASP and SOPHIE
• An Earth-sized Planet in the Habitable Zone of a Cool Star
• HAT-P-1b: A Large-Radius, Low-Density Exoplanet Transiting one Member of a Stellar Binary
• Planetary Candidates Observed by Kepler VI: Planet Sample from Q1-Q16 (47 Months)
• An Efficient Automated Validation Procedure for Exoplanet Transit Candidates
• Modeling Kepler transit light curves as false positives: Rejection of blend scenarios for Kepler-9, and validation of Kepler-9d, a super-Earth-size planet in a multiple system
• Kepler-62: A five-planet system with planets of 1.4 and 1.6 Earth radii in the Habitable Zone
• Kepler-22b: A 2.4 Earth-radius Planet in the Habitable Zone of a Sun-like Star
• On the Low False Positive Probabilities of Kepler Planet Candidates
• Planetary Candidates Observed by Kepler IV: Planet Sample From Q1-Q8 (22 Months)
• A sub-Mercury-sized exoplanet
• Kepler 18-b, c, and d: A System Of Three Planets Confirmed by Transit Timing Variations, Lightcurve Validation, Spitzer Photometry and Radial Velocity Measurements
• The XO Project: Searching for Transiting Extra-solar Planet Candidates
• TrES-2: The First Transiting Planet in the Kepler Field
• Two Earth-sized planets orbiting Kepler-20
• The Hunt for Exomoons with Kepler (HEK): I. Description of a New Observational Project
• The Detection and Characterization of a Nontransiting Planet by Transit Timing Variations
• Discovery and Validation of Kepler-452b: A 1.6-Re Super Earth Exoplanet in the Habitable Zone of a G2 Star
• A transiting extrasolar giant planet around the star OGLE-TR-113
• Vetting of 384 TESS Objects of Interest with TRICERATOPS and Statistical Validation of 12 Planet Candidates
• A nearby M star with three transiting super-Earths discovered by K2
• Doppler follow-up of OGLE transiting companions in the Galactic bulge
• WASP-4b: a 12th-magnitude transiting hot-Jupiter in the Southern hemisphere
• The Kepler-19 System: A Transiting 2.2 R_Earth Planet and a Second Planet Detected via Transit Timing Variations
• HAT-P-39b--HAT-P-41b: Three Highly Inflated Transiting Hot Jupiters
• Validation of Twelve Small Kepler Transiting Planets in the Habitable Zone
• The same frequency of planets inside and outside open clusters of stars
• Kepler-21b: A 1.6REarth Planet Transiting the Bright Oscillating F Subgiant Star HD 179070
• Kepler-20: A Sun-like Star with Three Sub-Neptune Exoplanets and Two Earth-size Candidates
• Kepler-10c, a 2.2-Earth radius transiting planet in a multiple system
• A transiting extrasolar giant planet around the star OGLE-TR-10
• Kepler-68: Three Planets, One With a Density Between That of Earth and Ice Giants
• Five Kepler target stars that show multiple transiting exoplanet candidates
• WASP-10b: a 3M_J, gas-giant planet transiting a late-type K star
• The Ĝ Search for Extraterrestrial Civilizations with Large Energy Supplies. IV. The Signatures and Information Content of Transiting Megastructures
• SOPHIE velocimetry of Kepler transit candidates XII. KOI-1257 b: a highly eccentric three-month period transiting exoplanet
• Re-assessing the radial-velocity evidence for planets around CoRoT-7
• A Photometric Diagnostic to Aid in the Identification of Transiting Extra-Solar Planets
• The Challenge of Wide-Field Transit Surveys: The Case of GSC 01944-02289
• Low False-Positive Rate of Kepler Candidates Estimated From A Combination Of Spitzer And Follow-Up Observations
• The KELT Follow-Up Network and Transit False Positive Catalog: Pre-vetted False Positives for TESS
• SOPHIE velocimetry of Kepler transit candidates IX. KOI-415 b: a long-period, eccentric transiting brown dwarf to an evolved Sun
• A lucky imaging multiplicity study of exoplanet host stars
• ExoMiner: A Highly Accurate and Explainable Deep Learning Classifier that Validates 301 New Exoplanets
• Bayesian priors for the eccentricity of transiting planets
• Kepler-93b: A Terrestrial World Measured to within 120 km, and a Test Case for a New Spitzer Observing Mode
• Testing blend scenarios for extrasolar transiting planet candidates. II. -- OGLE-TR-56
• Transit Photometry of the Core-Dominated Planet HD 149026b
• OGLE2-TR-L9: An extrasolar planet transiting a fast-rotating F3 star
• Rejecting Astrophysical False Positives from the TrES Transiting Planet Survey: The Example of GSC 03885-00829
• Discovery of three new transiting hot Jupiters: WASP-161 b, WASP-163 b and WASP-170 b
• Searching for Transiting Planets in Stellar Systems
• Fast identification of transits from light-curves
• High-resolution Imaging of Transiting Extrasolar Planetary systems (HITEP). I. Lucky imaging observations of 101 systems in the southern hemisphere
• The TESS-Keck Survey XX: 15 New TESS Planets and a Uniform RV Analysis of all Survey Targets
• A lucky imaging multiplicity study of exoplanet host stars II
• A Transiting Jupiter Analog
• Independent confirmation and refined parameters of the hot Jupiter XO-5b
• Line bisectors and radial velocity jitter from SARG spectra
• OGLE-TR-211 - a new transiting inflated hot Jupiter from the OGLE survey and ESO LP666 spectroscopic follow-up program
• Lupus-TR-3b: A Low-Mass Transiting Hot Jupiter in the Galactic Plane?
• Searching for Planetary Transits in Galactic Open Clusters: EXPLORE/OC
• Discovery of a Transiting Planet Near the Snow-Line
• Exoplanet Characterization by Proxy: a Transiting 2.15 R_Earth Planet Near the Habitable Zone of the Late K dwarf Kepler-61
• A vigorous activity cycle mimicking a planetary system in HD200466
• Search for Planetary Candidates within the OGLE Stars
• Validation of small Kepler transiting planet candidates in or near the habitable zone
• K2-231 b: A sub-Neptune exoplanet transiting a solar twin in Ruprecht 147
• AutoRegressive Planet Search: Methodology
• Transit and Radial Velocity Survey Efficiency Comparison for a Habitable Zone Earth
• MARVELS-1: A face-on double-lined binary star masquerading as a resonant planetary system; and consideration of rare false positives in radial velocity planet searches
• Outcome of Six Candidate Transiting Planets from a TrES Field in Andromeda
• The TESS Grand Unified Hot Jupiter Survey. I. Ten TESS Planets
• Transiting exoplanets from the CoRoT space mission: XXVI. CoRoT-24: A transiting multi-planet system
• Re-Evaluating Small Long-Period Confirmed Planets From Kepler
• Photometric study of the variable star population in the globular cluster NGC 6397
• Investigation of transit-selected exoplanet candidates from the MACHO survey
• Millions of Multiples: Detecting and Characterizing Close-Separation Binary Systems in Synoptic Sky Surveys
• SuperWASP-North Extrasolar Planet Candidates. Candidates from Fields 17hr < RA < 18hr
• KELT-22Ab: A Massive Hot Jupiter Transiting a Near Solar Twin
• TOI 564 b and TOI 905 b: Grazing and Fully Transiting Hot Jupiters Discovered by TESS
• TOI-179: a young system with a transiting compact Neptune-mass planet and a low-mass companion in outer orbit
• Characterisation of extrasolar planetary transit candidates
• Spitzer Infrared Observations and Independent Validation of the Transiting Super-Earth CoRoT-7b
• SuperWASP-N Extra-solar Planet Candidates from Fields 06hr < RA < 16hr
• Results from the Wide Angle Search for Planets Prototype (WASP0) III: Planet Hunting in the Draco Field
• Detection of transit timing variations in excess of one hour in the Kepler multi-planet candidate system KOI 806 with the GTC
• Millimagnitude Optical Photometry for the Transiting Planetary Candidate OGLE-TR-109
• An algorithm to detect blends with eclipsing binaries in planet transit searches
• Validation of HD 183579b using archival radial velocities: a warm-neptune orbiting a bright solar analog
• The Perkins INfrared Exosatellite Survey (PINES) II. Transit Candidates and Implications for Planet Occurrence around L and T Dwarfs
• Kepler-62f: Kepler's First Small Planet in the Habitable Zone, but Is It Real?
• Investigation of a transiting planet candidate in Trumpler 37: an astrophysical false positive eclipsing spectroscopic binary star
• The color signature of the transit of HD 209458: Discrepancies between stellar atmospheric models and observations
• An extended low-density atmosphere around the Jupiter-sized planet WASP-193 b
• Variability of Known Exoplanet Host Stars Observed by TESS
• A Pair of Dynamically Interacting Sub-Neptunes Around TOI-6054
• Orbital obliquity sampling in the Kepler-20 system using the 3D animation software Blender
• Exoplanet transit search at the detection limit: detection and false alarm vetting pipeline