Stellar Activity Masquerading as Planets in the Habitable Zone of the M dwarf Gliese 581

Abstract

The M dwarf Gliese 581 is believed to host four planets, including one (GJ 581d) near the habitable zone that could possibly support liquid water on its surface if it is a rocky planet. The detection of another habitable-zone planet--GJ 581g--is disputed, as its significance depends on the eccentricity assumed for d. Analyzing stellar activity using the H-alpha line, we measure a stellar rotation period of 130+/-2 days and a correlation for H-alpha modulation with radial velocity. Correcting for activity greatly diminishes the signal of GJ 581d (to 1.5 sigma), while significantly boosting the signals of the other known super-Earth planets. GJ 581d does not exist, but is an artifact of stellar activity which, when incompletely corrected, causes the false detection of planet g.

arXiv commentThis is the author's version of the work. It is posted here by permission of the AAAS for personal use, not for redistribution. The definitive version was published in Science Express (3 July 2014), doi:10.1126/science.1253253

References in corpus (29)

• The generalised Lomb-Scargle periodogram. A new formalism for the floating-mean and Keplerian periodograms
• Habitable Zones Around Main-Sequence Stars: New Estimates
• The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets XXXI. The M-dwarf sample
• The Occurrence Rate of Small Planets around Small Stars
• Habitable planets around the star Gl 581?
• The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets XVIII. An Earth-mass planet in the GJ 581 planetary system
• The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets XI. Super-Earths (5 & 8 M_Earth) in a 3-planet system
• A revised estimate of the occurrence rate of terrestrial planets in the habitable zones around kepler m-dwarfs
• Gliese 581d is the first discovered terrestrial-mass exoplanet in the habitable zone
• Long-term magnetic activity of a sample of M-dwarf stars from the HARPS program I. Comparison of activity indices
• The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets. VI. A Neptune-mass planet around the nearby M dwarf Gl 581
• The Lick-Carnegie Exoplanet Survey: A 3.1 M_Earth Planet in the Habitable Zone of the Nearby M3V Star Gliese 581
• The low-level radial velocity variability in Barnard's star (=GJ 699). Secular acceleration, indications for convective redshift, and planet mass limits
• Systemic: A Testbed For Characterizing the Detection of Extrasolar Planets. I. The Systemic Console Package
• SOAP. A tool for the fast computation of photometry and radial velocity induced by stellar spots
• Long-term magnetic activity of a sample of M-dwarf stars from the HARPS program II. Activity and radial velocity
• H-alpha Activity of Old M Dwarfs: Stellar Cycles and Mean Activity Levels For 93 Low-Mass Stars in the Solar Neighborhood
• The impact of red noise in radial velocity planet searches: Only three planets orbiting GJ581?
• An Empirical Correction for Activity Effects on the Temperatures, Radii, and Estimated Masses of Low-Mass Stars and Brown Dwarfs
• Bayesian Re-analysis of the Gliese 581 Exoplanet System
• A DEBRIS Disk Around The Planet Hosting M-star GJ581 Spatially Resolved with Herschel
• The Na I D resonance lines in main sequence late-type stars
• A new analysis of the GJ581 extrasolar planetary system
• GJ 581 update: Additional Evidence for a Super-Earth in the Habitable Zone
• MARVELS-1: A face-on double-lined binary star masquerading as a resonant planetary system; and consideration of rare false positives in radial velocity planet searches
• An investigation into the radial velocity variability of GJ 581 - On the significance of GJ 581g
• The All Sky Automated Survey. The Catalog of Variable Stars. IV.18^h - 24^h Quarter of the Southern Hemisphere
• Bisectors of the HARPS Cross-Correlation-Function. The dependence on stellar atmospheric parameters
• X Ray Detection of GJ 581 and simultaneous UV Observations

Cited by in corpus (164)

• A terrestrial planet candidate in a temperate orbit around Proxima Centauri
• Extreme Water Loss and Abiotic O${}_2$ Buildup On Planets Throughout the Habitable Zones of M Dwarfs
• The MUSCLES Treasury Survey I: Motivation and Overview
• State of the Field: Extreme Precision Radial Velocities
• The Exoplanet Mass-Ratio Function from the MOA-II Survey: Discovery of a Break and Likely Peak at a Neptune Mass
• SOAP 2.0: A tool to estimate the photometric and radial velocity variations induced by stellar spots and plages
• Magnetic Cycles and Rotation Periods of Late Type Stars from photometric time series
• A High-Precision NIR Survey for RV Variable Low-Mass Stars
• Rotation periods of late-type dwarf stars from time-series high-resolution spectroscopy of chromospheric indicators
• Measuring precise radial velocities on individual spectral lines. I. Validation of the method and application to mitigate stellar activity
• Magnetic activity in the HARPS M-dwarf sample. The rotation-activity relationship for very low-mass stars through R'HK
• The Sun as a planet-host star: Proxies from SDO images for HARPS radial-velocity variations
• A Kepler Study of Starspot Lifetimes with Respect to Light Curve Amplitude and Spectral Type
• The CARMENES search for exoplanets around M dwarfs -- Planet occurrence rates from a subsample of 71 stars
• The CARMENES search for exoplanets around M dwarfs. First visual-channel radial-velocity measurements and orbital parameter updates of seven M-dwarf planetary systems
• Stellar Spectroscopy in the Near-infrared with a Laser Frequency Comb
• Placing the spotted T Tauri star LkCa 4 on an HR diagram
• The 10 parsec sample in the Gaia era
• The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets. XXXVIII. Bayesian re-analysis of three systems. New super-Earths, unconfirmed signals, and magnetic cycles
• Revisiting Proxima with ESPRESSO
• Gaia DR3 astrometric orbit determination with Markov Chain Monte Carlo and Genetic Algorithms. Systems with stellar, substellar, and planetary mass companions
• Radial-Velocity Fitting Challenge. II. First results of the analysis of the data set
• Stellar activity mimics a habitable-zone planet around Kapteyn's star
• New rotation period measurements for M dwarfs in the southern hemisphere: an abundance of slowly rotating, fully convective stars
• Measuring precise radial velocities on individual spectral lines : II. Dependance of stellar activity signal on line depth
• Modeling the RV jitter of early M dwarfs using tomographic imaging
• Stacked Bayesian general Lomb-Scargle periodogram: Identifying stellar activity signals
• MOST Observations of our Nearest Neighbor: Flares on Proxima Centauri
• Color difference makes a difference: four planet candidates around tau Ceti
• The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets XXXV. Planetary systems and stellar activity of the M dwarfs GJ 3293, GJ 3341, and GJ 3543
• The CARMENES search for exoplanets around M dwarfs: A low-mass planet in the temperate zone of the nearby K2-18
• HAT-P-11: Discovery of a Second Planet and a Clue to Understanding Exoplanet Obliquities
• A Versatile Technique to Enable sub-milli-Kelvin Instrument Stability for Precise Radial Velocity Measurements: Tests with the Habitable-zone Planet Finder
• Radial Velocity Planet Detection Biases at the Stellar Rotational Period
• Disentangling Planets and Stellar Activity for Gliese 667C
• An Empirically Derived Three-Dimensional Laplace Resonance in the Gliese 876 Planetary System
• Benchmarking the power of amateur observatories for TTV exoplanets detection
• Characterisation of the radial velocity signal induced by rotation in late-type dwarfs
• SPIRou Input Catalogue: Global properties of 440 M dwarfs observed with ESPaDOnS at CFHT
• HADES RV Programme with HARPS-N at TNG. VII. Rotation and activity of M-Dwarfs from time-series high-resolution spectroscopy of chromospheric indicators
• Radial velocity follow-up of GJ1132 with HARPS. A precise mass for planet 'b' and the discovery of a second planet
• The transiting multi-planet system HD3167: a 5.7 MEarth Super-Earth and a 8.3 MEarth mini-Neptune
• The Impact of Stellar Rotation on the Detectability of Habitable Planets Around M Dwarfs
• SPIRou Input Catalog: Activity, Rotation and Magnetic Field of Cool Dwarfs
• Radial Velocity Fitting Challenge. I. Simulating the data set including realistic stellar radial-velocity signals
• How magnetic activity alters what we learn from stellar spectra
• Towards Understanding Stellar Radial Velocity Jitter as a Function of Wavelength: The Sun as a Proxy
• RV-detected planets around M dwarfs: Challenges for core accretion models
• New Planetary Systems from the Calan-Hertfordshire Extrasolar Planet Search
• A More Precise Mass for GJ 1214 b and the Frequency of Multi-Planet Systems Around Mid-M Dwarfs
• Catalog for the ESPRESSO blind radial velocity exoplanet survey
• Planet populations inferred from debris discs: insights from 178 debris systems in the ISPY, LEECH and LIStEN planet-hunting surveys
• The EXPRES Stellar Signals Project II. State of the Field in Disentangling Photospheric Velocities
• VPLanet: The Virtual Planet Simulator
• Solar System Physics for Exoplanet Research
• Fast Bayesian Inference for Exoplanet Discovery in Radial Velocity Data
• Comment on "Stellar activity masquerading as planets in the habitable zone of the M dwarf Gliese 581"
• The CARMENES search for exoplanets around M dwarfs. Three temperate to warm super-Earths
• The Solar Neighborhood. XXXIV. A Search for Planets Orbiting Nearby M Dwarfs using Astrometry
• HADES RV Programme with HARPS-N at TNG XV. Planetary occurrence rates around early-M dwarfs
• Enhanced models for stellar Doppler noise reveal hints of a 13-year activity cycle of 55 Cancri
• Long-lived, long-period radial velocity variations in Aldebaran: A planetary companion and stellar activity
• Two temperate Earth-mass planets orbiting the nearby star GJ1002
• Stellar Activity and its Implications for Exoplanet Detection on GJ 176
• The Dawes Review 3: The Atmospheres of Extrasolar Planets and Brown Dwarfs
• The SOPHIE search for northern extrasolar planets. XIV. A temperate ($T_{\mathrm{eq}}\sim 300$ K) super-earth around the nearby star Gliese 411
• Three planets orbiting Wolf 1061
• Toward Extremely Precise Radial Velocities: II. A Tool For Using Multivariate Gaussian Processes to Model Stellar Activity
• Proxima Centauri as a Benchmark for Stellar Activity Indicators in the Near Infrared
• Persistent starspot signals on M dwarfs: multi-wavelength Doppler observations with the Habitable-zone Planet Finder and Keck/HIRES
• The CARMENES search for exoplanets around M dwarfs: Convective shift and starspot constraints from chromatic radial velocities
• Observing the Sun as a star: Design and early results from the NEID solar feed
• The Pan-Pacific Planet Search VII: The most eccentric planet orbiting a giant star
• Truly eccentric. I. Revisiting eight single-eccentric planetary systems
• The correlation between photometric variability and radial velocity jitter, based on TESS and HARPS observations
• Understanding stellar activity-induced radial velocity jitter using simultaneous K2 photometry and HARPS RV measurements
• The SPIRou Legacy Survey Rotation period of quiet M dwarfs from circular polarization in near-infrared spectral lines: I. The SPIRou APERO analysis
• Stellar Activity and Exclusion of the Outer Planet in the HD 99492 System
• The CARMENES search for exoplanets around M dwarfs: The warm super-Earths in twin orbits around the mid-type M dwarfs Ross 1020 (GJ 3779) and LP 819-052 (GJ 1265)
• Target Prioritization and Observing Strategies for the NEID Earth Twin Survey
• Detection Limits of Low-mass, Long-period Exoplanets Using Gaussian Processes Applied to HARPS-N Solar RVs
• The First Habitable Zone Earth-sized Planet from TESS. III: Climate States and Characterization Prospects for TOI-700 d
• Characterisation of stellar activity of M dwarfs. I. Long-timescale variability in a large sample and detection of new cycles
• HADES RV Programme with HARPS-N at TNG: V. A super-Earth on the inner edge of the habitable zone of the nearby M-dwarf GJ 625
• The TIME Table: Rotation and Ages of Cool Exoplanet Host Stars
• Doppler Constraints on Planetary Companions to Nearby Sun-like Stars: An Archival Radial Velocity Survey of Southern Targets for Proposed NASA Direct Imaging Missions
• The Pan-Pacific Planet Search VI: Giant planets orbiting HD 86950 and HD 222076
• A combined spectroscopic and photometric stellar activity study of Epsilon Eridani
• AD Leonis: Radial velocity signal of stellar rotation or spin-orbit resonance?
• No evidence for activity correlations in the radial velocities of Kapteyn's star
• ESPRESSO on VLT: An Instrument for Exoplanet Research
• The SOPHIE search for northern extrasolar planets. XI. Three new companions and an orbit update: Giant planets in the habitable zone
• The test case of HD26965: difficulties disentangling weak Doppler signals from stellar activity
• Photometry as a proxy for stellar activity in radial velocity analyses
• A 12-Year Activity Cycle for HD 219134
• The impact of time-dependent stellar activity on exoplanet atmospheres
• A sub-Earth-mass planet orbiting Barnard's star
• A super-Earth orbiting the nearby M-dwarf GJ 536
• Measuring precise radial velocities and cross-correlation function line-profile variations using a Skew Normal density
• Response to Comment on "Stellar activity masquerading as planets in the habitable zone of the M dwarf Gliese 581"
• K2 reveals pulsed accretion driven by the 2 Myr old hot Jupiter CI Tau b
• HADES RV program with HARPS-N at TNG. IX. A super-Earth around the M dwarf Gl686
• Cycle period, differential rotation and meridional flow for early M dwarf stars
• Kuiper Belt Analogues in Nearby M-type Planet-host Systems
• A Radial Velocity Study of the Planetary System of Pi Mensae: Improved Planet Parameters for PI Mensae c and a Third Planet on a 125-d Orbit
• Periodic Halpha variations in GL 581: Further evidence for an activity origin to GL 581d
• The Habitable-zone Planet Finder Detects a Terrestrial-mass Planet Candidate Closely Orbiting Gliese 1151: The Likely Source of Coherent Low-frequency Radio Emission from an Inactive Star
• Gaussian processes for radial velocity modeling Better rotation periods and planetary parameters with the quasi-periodic kernel and constrained priors
• The Ca II H&K Rotation-Activity Relation in 53 mid-to-late type M-Dwarfs
• Geothermal heating enhances atmospheric asymmetries on synchronously rotating planets
• Kepler-1656b's Extreme Eccentricity: Signature of a Gentle Giant
• Magnitude-squared coherence: A powerful tool for disentangling Doppler planet discoveries from stellar activity
• 3D magneto-hydrodynamical simulations of stellar convective noise for improved exoplanet detection. I. Case of regularly sampled radial velocity observations
• HADES RV Programme with HARPS-N at TNG VI. GJ 3942 b behind dominant activity signals
• Prospecting for exo-Earths in multiple planet systems with a gas giant
• Flares, Rotation, Activity Cycles and a Magnetic Star-Planet Interaction Hypothesis for the Far Ultraviolet Emission of GJ 436
• Coronal X-Ray Emission from Nearby, Low-Mass, Exoplanet Host Stars Observed by the MUSCLES and Mega-MUSCLES HST Treasury Survey Projects
• The HADES RV Programme with HARPS-N at TNG XI. GJ 685 b: a warm super-Earth around an active M dwarf
• Variability Timescales of H$\alpha$ on Active Mid-to-Late M dwarfs
• Radial Velocities as an Exoplanet Discovery Method
• $\text{GRASS}$: Distinguishing Planet-induced Doppler Signatures from Granulation with a Synthetic Spectra Generator
• Modelling stellar activity with Gaussian process regression networks
• Rotation periods of TESS Objects of Interest from the Magellan-TESS Survey with multiband photometry from Evryscope and TESS
• The SOPHIE search for northern extrasolar planets - XII. Three giant planets suitable for astrometric mass determination with Gaia
• Stable habitable zones of single Jovian planet systems
• Calculations of periodicity from Hα profiles of Proxima Centauri
• Solar Contamination in Extreme Precision Radial Velocity Measurements: Deleterious Effects and Prospects for Mitigation
• Radial velocity observations of the 2015 Mar 20 eclipse - A benchmark Rossiter-McLaughlin curve with zero free parameters
• Photometric rotation periods for 107 M dwarfs from the APACHE survey
• Simulations for Planning Next-Generation Exoplanet Radial Velocity Surveys
• Confirmation of the Long-Period Planet Orbiting Gliese 411 and the Detection of a New Planet Candidate
• The RoPES project with HARPS and HARPS-N. I. A system of super-Earths orbiting the moderately active K-dwarf HD 176986
• Magnetic properties of Proxima Centauri b analogues
• Stellar masks and bisector's shape for M-type stars observed in the GAPS Programme with HARPS-N at TNG
• Radial velocity homogeneous analysis of M dwarfs observed with HARPS I. Exoplanet detection and candidates
• Sectoral r modes and periodic RV variations of Sun-like stars
• A super-Earth on a close-in orbit around the M1V star GJ 740. A HADES and CARMENES collaboration
• HADES RV Programme with HARPS-N at TNG XIII. A sub-Neptune around the M dwarf GJ 720 A
• Diving into the planetary system of Proxima with NIRPS -- Breaking the metre per second barrier in the infrared
• The milliarcsecond-scale radio structure of AB Dor A
• The CARMENES search for exoplanets around M dwarfs. Revisiting the GJ 581 multi-planetary system with new Doppler measurements from CARMENES, HARPS, and HIRES
• Wavelength Dependence of Activity-Induced Photometric Variations for Young Cool Stars in Hyades
• Tracking Advanced Planetary Systems (TAPAS) with HARPS-N. III. HD 5583 and BD+15 2375 - two cool giants with warm companions
• Accounting for stellar activity signals in radial-velocity data by using Change Point Detection techniques
• The mu Arae planetary system: Radial velocities and astrometry
• Radio Emission from Ultra-Cool Dwarfs
• TOI-1696 and TOI-2136: Constraining the Masses of Two Mini-Neptunes with HPF
• Identifying Exoplanets with Deep Learning. IV. Removing Stellar Activity Signals from Radial Velocity Measurements Using Neural Networks
• Imaging of exocomets with infrared interferometry
• Future Astrometric Space Missions for Exoplanet Science
• H${}_{\alpha }$-activity and ages for stars in the SARG survey
• Characterisation of magnetic activity of M dwarfs. Possible impact on the surface brightness
• New Dynamical State and Habitability of the HD 45364 Planetary System
• Planetary system architectures with low-mass inner planets: Direct imaging exploration of mature systems beyond 1 au
• Precise radial velocities of giant stars -- XVII. Distinguishing planets from intrinsically induced radial velocity signals in evolved stars
• The Effects of Sunspots on Spectral Line Shapes in the Visible
• Searching for Low-Mass Exoplanets Amid Stellar Variability with a Fixed Effects Linear Model of Line-by-Line Shape Changes
• RedDots: Planetary masses in the GJ1061 system from planet-planet interaction
• Dual-Backend Multibeam Position Switching Targeted SETI Observations toward Nearby Active Planet-Hosting Systems with FAST
• Discovery of a Nearby Habitable Zone Super-Earth Candidate Amenable to Direct Imaging
• The RoPES project with HARPS and HARPS-N II. A third planet in the multi-planet system HD 176986
• Atmospheric heat redistribution and collapse on tidally locked rocky planets
• The California Legacy Survey I. A Catalog of 178 Planets from Precision Radial Velocity Monitoring of 719 Nearby Stars over Three Decades
• Activity-rotation in the dM4 star Gl 729. A possible chromospheric cycle