The test case of HD26965: difficulties disentangling weak Doppler signals from stellar activity

Abstract

We report the discovery of a radial velocity signal that can be interpreted as a planetary-mass candidate orbiting the K dwarf HD26965, with an orbital period of 42.364$\pm$0.015 days, or alternatively, as the presence of residual, uncorrected rotational activity in the data. Observations include data from HIRES, PFS, CHIRON, and HARPS, where 1,111 measurements were made over 16 years. Our best solution for HD26965 $b$ is consistent with a super-Earth that has a minimum mass of 6.92$\pm$0.79 M${}_{\oplus }$ orbiting at a distance of 0.215$\pm$0.008 AU from its host star. We have analyzed the correlation between spectral activity indicators and the radial velocities from each instrument, showing moderate correlations that we include in our model. From this analysis, we recover a $\sim$38 day signal, which matches some literature values of the stellar rotation period. However, from independent Mt. Wilson HK data for this star, we find evidence for a significant 42 day signal after subtraction of longer period magnetic cycles, casting doubt on the planetary hypothesis for this period. Although our statistical model strongly suggests that the 42-day signal is Doppler in origin, we conclude that the residual effects of stellar rotation are difficult to fully model and remove from this dataset, highlighting the difficulties to disentangle small planetary signals and photospheric noise, particularly when the orbital periods are close to the rotation period of the star. This study serves as an excellent test case for future works that aim to detect small planets orbiting `Sun-like' stars using radial velocity measurements.

arXiv comment16 pages, 10 figures, 13 tables, accepted for publication in AJ

References in corpus (60)

• Validation of the new Hipparcos reduction
• The generalised Lomb-Scargle periodogram. A new formalism for the floating-mean and Keplerian periodograms
• The Dartmouth Stellar Evolution Database
• Habitable Zones Around Main-Sequence Stars: New Estimates
• Improved Age Estimation for Solar-Type Dwarfs Using Activity-Rotation Diagnostics
• A terrestrial planet candidate in a temperate orbit around Proxima Centauri
• Architecture and Dynamics of Kepler's Candidate Multiple Transiting Planet Systems
• No planet for HD 166435
• Contributions to the Nearby Stars (NStars) Project: Spectroscopy of Stars Earlier than M0 within 40 parsecs: The Southern Sample
• A dynamically-packed planetary system around GJ667C with three super-Earths in its habitable zone
• Ten New and Updated Multi-planet Systems, and a Survey of Exoplanetary Systems
• A new code for automatic determination of equivalent widths: Automatic Routine for line Equivalent widths in stellar Spectra (ARES)
• Detailed Models of super-Earths: How well can we infer bulk properties?
• Stellar Activity Masquerading as Planets in the Habitable Zone of the M dwarf Gliese 581
• CHIRON - A Fiber Fed Spectrometer for Precise Radial Velocities
• The Lick-Carnegie Exoplanet Survey: A Uranus-mass Fourth Planet for GJ 876 in an Extrasolar Laplace Configuration
• A Super-Earth Transiting a Naked-Eye Star
• Bulk Composition of GJ 1214b and other sub-Neptune exoplanets
• XHIP: An Extended Hipparcos Compilation
• The Lick-Carnegie Exoplanet Survey: A 3.1 M_Earth Planet in the Habitable Zone of the Nearby M3V Star Gliese 581
• A First Comparison of Kepler Planet Candidates in Single and Multiple Systems
• A planetary system around the nearby M dwarf GJ 667C with at least one super-Earth in its habitable zone
• Bayesian search for low-mass planets around nearby M dwarfs. Estimates for occurrence rate based on global detectability statistics
• Ghost in the time series: no planet for Alpha Cen B
• SOAP. A tool for the fast computation of photometry and radial velocity induced by stellar spots
• A global analysis of Spitzer and new HARPS data confirms the loneliness and metal-richness of GJ 436 b
• Chromospheric Activities and Kinematics for Solar Type Dwarfs and Subgiants: Analysis of the Activity Distribution and the AVR
• Habitable-zone super-Earth candidate in a six-planet system around the K2.5V star HD 40307
• The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets XXXV. The interesting case of HD41248: stellar activity, no planets?
• Stellar activity mimics a habitable-zone planet around Kapteyn's star
• The GJ 436 System: Directly Determined Astrophysical Parameters of an M-Dwarf and Implications for the Transiting Hot Neptune
• Color difference makes a difference: four planet candidates around tau Ceti
• Chromospheric activity of Southern Stars from the Magellan Planet Search Program
• Evidence for 9 planets in the HD 10180 system
• Radial Velocity Planet Detection Biases at the Stellar Rotational Period
• Four new planets around giant stars and the mass-metallicity correlation of planet-hosting stars
• First Results from the CHEPS: Exoplanets and the Discovery of an Eccentric Brown Dwarf in the Desert
• New Planetary Systems from the Calan-Hertfordshire Extrasolar Planet Search
• Effective temperatures, rotational velocities, microturbulent velocities and abundances in the atmospheres of the Sun,. HD1835 and HD10700
• Comment on "Stellar activity masquerading as planets in the habitable zone of the M dwarf Gliese 581"
• The Solar Twin Planet Search. V. Close-in, low-mass planet candidates and evidence of planet accretion in the solar twin HIP 68468
• A Goldilocks principle for modeling radial velocity noise
• Detailed Abundances of Stars with Small Planets Discovered by Kepler I: The First Sample
• Five Long-period Extrasolar Planets in Eccentric orbits from the Magellan Planet Search Program
• Model Spectra of the First Potentially Habitable Super-Earth - Gl581d
• No evidence of the planet orbiting the extremely metal-poor extragalactic star HIP13044
• A Hot Uranus Orbiting the Super Metal-rich Star HD77338 and the Metallicity - Mass Connection
• Ground-Based Transit Observations of the Super-Earth 55 Cnc e
• Up to four planets around the M dwarf GJ 163. Sensitivity of Bayesian planet detection criteria to prior choice
• An upper boundary in the mass-metallicity plane of exo-Neptunes
• Planet Detectability in the Alpha Centauri System
• Secondary Eclipse Photometry of the Exoplanet WASP-5b with Warm Spitzer
• No evidence for activity correlations in the radial velocities of Kapteyn's star
• Stellar activity as a tracer of moving groups
• The curious case of HD41248. A pair of static signals buried behind red-noise
• Inferring heat recirculation and albedo for exoplanetary atmospheres: Comparing optical phase curves and secondary eclipse data
• The effects of viewing angle on the mass distribution of exoplanets
• Probabilities of exoplanet signals from posterior samplings
• CHIRON TOOLS: Integrated Target Submission, Scheduling and Observing Systems for a High Resolution Fiber Fed Spectrograph
• Ground-based detection of the near-infrared emission from the dayside of WASP-5b

Cited by in corpus (27)

• Juliet: a versatile modelling tool for transiting and non-transiting exoplanetary systems
• SPECIES I: Spectroscopic Parameters and atmosphEric ChemIstriEs of Stars
• The EXPRES Stellar Signals Project II. State of the Field in Disentangling Photospheric Velocities
• Astrophysical Insights into Radial Velocity Jitter from an Analysis of 600 Planet-search Stars
• Decoding the radial velocity variations of HD41248 with ESPRESSO
• Truly eccentric. I. Revisiting eight single-eccentric planetary systems
• Doppler Constraints on Planetary Companions to Nearby Sun-like Stars: An Archival Radial Velocity Survey of Southern Targets for Proposed NASA Direct Imaging Missions
• Proxima Centauri b is not a transiting exoplanet
• TOI-132 b: A short-period planet in the Neptune desert transiting a $V=11.3$ G-type star
• The first super-Earth Detection from the High Cadence and High Radial Velocity Precision Dharma Planet Survey
• GJ357: A low-mass planetary system uncovered by precision radial-velocities and dynamical simulations
• The Magellan/PFS Exoplanet Search: A 55-day period dense Neptune transiting the bright ($V=8.6$) star HD 95338
• Long-term stellar activity variations and their effect on radial-velocity measurements
• TOI-1416: A system with a super-Earth planet with a 1.07d period
• The GAPS programme at TNG XLIV. Projected rotational velocities of 273 exoplanet-host stars observed with HARPS-N
• The death of Vulcan: NEID reveals the planet candidate orbiting HD 26965 is stellar activity
• A collage of small planets from the Lick Carnegie Exoplanet Survey : Exploring the super-Earth and sub-Neptune mass regime
• Luminaries in the Sky: The TESS Legacy Sample of Bright Stars. I. Asteroseismic detections in naked-eye main-sequence and sub-giant solar-like oscillators
• The mu Arae planetary system: Radial velocities and astrometry
• Quiet Please: Detrending Radial Velocity Variations from Stellar Activity with a Physically Motivated Spot Model
• Radial velocity precision of ESPRESSO through the analysis of the solar twin HIP 11915
• Planet Hunters NGTS: New Planet Candidates from a Citizen Science Search of the Next Generation Transit Survey Public Data
• Deriving Iodine-free spectra for high-resolution echelle spectrographs
• SPORES-HWO. II. Companion Mass Limits and Updated Planet Properties for 120 Future Exoplanet Imaging Targets from 35 yr of Precise Doppler Monitoring
• Destruction of "Peas in a Pod?" A Candidate Multi-planet System Around the Nearby, Bright Star, HD208487
• Revisiting BD-06 1339b: A Likely False Positive Caused by Stellar Activity
• Tidal star-planet interaction and its observed impact on stellar activity in planet-hosting wide binary systems