The Unique Na:O Abundance Distribution in NGC 6791: The First Open(?) Cluster with Multiple Populations

Abstract

Almost all globular clusters investigated exhibit a spread in their light element abundances, the most studied being a Na:O anticorrelation. In contrast, open clusters show a homogeneous composition and are still regarded as Simple Stellar Populations. The most probable reason for this difference is that globulars had an initial mass high enough to retain primordial gas and ejecta from the first stellar generation and thus formed a second generation with a distinct composition, an initial mass exceeding that of open clusters. NGC 6791 is a massive open cluster, and warrants a detailed search for chemical inhomogeneities. We collected high resolution, high S/N spectra of 21 members covering a wide range of evolutionary status and measured their Na, O and Fe content. We found [Fe/H]=+0.42$\pm 0.01$, in good agreement with previous values, and no evidence for a spread. However, the Na:O distribution is completely unprecedented. It becomes the first open cluster to show intrinsic abundance variations that cannot be explained by mixing, and thus the first discovered to host multiple populations. It is also the first star cluster to exhibit two subpopulations in the Na:O diagram with one being chemically homogeneous while the second has an intrinsic spread that follows the anticorrelation so far displayed only by globular clusters. NGC 6791 is unique in many aspects, displaying certain characteristics typical of open clusters, others more reminiscent of globulars, and yet others, in particular its Na:O behavior investigated here, that are totally unprecedented. It clearly had a complex and fascinating history.

16 pages, 4 figures, accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal Letters

References in corpus (6)

• Formation and Dynamical Evolution of Multiple Stellar Generations in Globular Clusters
• Looking outside the Galaxy: the discovery of chemical anomalies in 3 old Large Magellanic Cloud clusters
• The chemical abundance of the very metal rich old Open Clusters NGC 6253 and NGC 6791
• High resolution infrared spectroscopy of the old open cluster NGC6791
• A New Look at the Old Star Cluster NGC 6791
• O and Na abundance patterns in open clusters of the Galactic disk

Cited by in corpus (52)

• Star Clusters Across Cosmic Time
• The Hubble Space Telescope UV Legacy Survey of Galactic Globular Clusters. I. Overview of the Project and Detection of Multiple Stellar Populations
• Clusters and mirages: cataloguing stellar aggregates in the Milky Way
• What is a globular cluster? An observational perspective
• On the fine structure of the Cepheid metallicity gradient in the Galactic thin disk
• Ruprecht 106: the first single population Globular Cluster?
• The Physics of Star Cluster Formation and Evolution
• On the metallicity of open clusters II. Spectroscopy
• Final Targeting Strategy for the SDSS-IV APOGEE-2N Survey
• Searching for multiple stellar populations in the massive, old open cluster Berkeley 39
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: Sodium and aluminium abundances in giants and dwarfs - Implications for stellar and Galactic chemical evolution
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: Stellar content and elemental abundances in the massive cluster NGC 6705
• Sodium and Oxygen Abundances in the Open Cluster NGC 6791 from APOGEE H-Band Spectroscopy
• Phylogeny of the Milky Way's inner disk and bulge populations: Implications for gas accretion, (the lack of) inside-out thick disk formation, and quenching
• Searching for Chemical Signatures of Multiple Stellar Populations in the Old, Massive Open Cluster NGC 6791
• Mapping the Galactic Metallicity Gradient with Open Clusters: The State-of-the-Art and Future Challenges
• Star Clusters in Evolving Galaxies
• New atmospheric parameters and spectral interpolator for the MILES cool stars
• Zirconium, Barium, Lanthanum and Europium Abundances in Open Clusters
• NGC 6535: the lowest mass Milky Way globular cluster with a Na-O anti-correlation? Cluster mass and age in the multiple population context
• Revisiting nucleosynthesis in globular clusters: the case of NGC 2808 and the role of He and K
• Evidence of tidal distortions and mass loss from the old open cluster NGC 6791
• A VLT/FLAMES study of the peculiar intermediate-age Large Magellanic Cloud star cluster NGC 1846 - I. Kinematics
• OCCASO III. Iron peak and $\alpha$ elements of 18 open clusters. Comparison with chemical evolution models and field stars
• The OCCASO survey: Presentation and radial velocities of twelve Milky Way Open Clusters
• OCCASO II. Physical parameters and Fe abundances of Red Clump stars in 18 Open Clusters
• The Chemical Composition of Praesepe (M44)
• O, Na, Ba and Eu abundance patterns in open clusters
• Multiple stellar populations and their evolution in globular clusters: A nucleosynthesis perspective
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: Properties of the intermediate age open cluster NGC 4815
• NGC6362: the least massive globular cluster with chemically distinct multiple populations
• The Old, Super-Metal-Rich Open Cluster, NGC 6791 - Elemental Abundances in Turn-off Stars from Keck/HIRES Spectra
• Some Stars are Totally Metal: A New Mechanism Driving Dust Across Star-Forming Clouds, and Consequences for Planets, Stars, and Galaxies
• Detailed chemical composition and orbit of the new globular cluster FSR1758: Implications for the accretion of the Sequoia dwarf galaxy onto the Milky Way
• NGC 6791: a probable bulge cluster without multiple populations
• Timing the Evolution of the Galactic Disk with NGC 6791: An Open Cluster with Peculiar High-$\alpha$ Chemistry as seen by APOGEE
• ESO452-SC11: The lowest mass globular cluster with a potential chemical inhomogeneity
• NGC 6139: a normal massive globular cluster or a first-generation dominated cluster? Clues from the light elements
• The Gaia-ESO Survey: Detailed Abundances in the Metal-poor Globular Cluster NGC 4372
• Formation of globular clusters with multiple stellar populations from massive gas clumps in high-z gas-rich dwarf galaxies
• Searching for chemical inhomogeneities in Open Clusters: Analysis of the CN and CH Molecular Band Strengths in NGC 2158, NGC 2420, NGC 2682, NGC 7789 and Berkeley 29
• The blue straggler population of the old open cluster Berkeley 17
• The Distances to Open Clusters from Main-Sequence Fitting. V. Extension of Color Calibration and Test using Cool and Metal-Rich Stars in NGC 6791
• Comparison of the Asteroseismic Mass Scale of Red Clump Giants with Photometric Mass Estimates
• Star Cluster Ages in the Gaia Era
• Analysis of the CN and CH molecular band strengths in stars of the open cluster NGC 6791
• Updated properties of the old open cluster Melotte 66: Searching for multiple stellar populations
• Accretion of sub-stellar companions as the origin of chemical abundance inhomogeneities in globular clusters
• Stellar populations in star clusters
• Infrared photometry of Young Massive Clusters in the starburst galaxy NGC 4214
• Uncertainties in models of stellar structure and evolution
• Binarity as the solution to the stellar evolution enigma posed by NGC 6791