Comparison of the Asteroseismic Mass Scale of Red Clump Giants with Photometric Mass Estimates

Abstract

Asteroseismology can provide joint constraints on masses and radii of individual stars. While this approach has been extensively tested for red giant branch (RGB) stars, it has been more difficult to test for helium core-burning red-clump (RC) giants because of the lack of fundamental calibrators. To provide independent mass estimates, we utilize a number of widely used horizontal-branch (HB) models in the literature, and derive photometric masses from a comparison with $griBV{I}_{C}JH{K}_s$ photometry. Our selected models disagree with each other on the predicted mass-luminosity-temperature relation. We adopt first-order corrections on colors and magnitudes to minimize the dispersion between different models by forcing models to match the observed location in the solar-metallicity cluster M67. Even for these calibrated models, however, the internal consistency between models deteriorates at higher metallicities, and photometric masses become smaller than asteroseismic masses, as seen from metal-rich field RC stars with Gaia parallaxes. Similarly, the average photometric mass for metal-rich NGC 6791 stars ranges from $0.7M_{\odot }$ to $1.1M_{\odot }$, depending on the specific set of models employed. An ensemble average of the photometric masses ($0.88\pm 0.16M_{\odot }$) in NGC 6791 is marginally consistent with the asteroseismic mass ($1.16\pm 0.04M_{\odot }$). There is a clear tension between the masses that one would predict from photometry for metal-rich field RC stars, asteroseismic masses, and those that would be expected from the ages of stars in the Galactic disk populations and canonical RGB mass loss. We conclude that standard RC models need to be re-examined in light of these powerful new data sets.

arXiv comment30 pages, 20 figures, 6 tables, accepted for publication in the Astrophysical Journal after minor revision

References in corpus (103)

• The chemical composition of the Sun
• Gaia Data Release 2. Summary of the contents and survey properties
• The Gaia mission
• The Seventh Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• PARSEC: stellar tracks and isochrones with the PAdova and TRieste Stellar Evolution Code
• MESA Isochrones and Stellar Tracks (MIST). I: Solar-Scaled Models
• A grid of MARCS model atmospheres for late-type stars I. Methods and general properties
• Gaia Data Release 2: The astrometric solution
• MESA Isochrones and Stellar Tracks (MIST) 0: Methods for the construction of stellar isochrones
• The Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment (APOGEE)
• The Dartmouth Stellar Evolution Database
• Theoretical isochrones in several photometric systems I. Johnson-Cousins-Glass, HST/WFPC2, HST/NICMOS, Washington, and ESO Imaging Survey filter sets
• Multiple populations in globular clusters. Lessons learned from the Milky Way globular clusters
• A standard stellar library for evolutionary synthesis: I. Calibration of theoretical spectra
• The origin of sdB stars (II)
• Gaia Data Release 1: Astrometry - one billion positions, two million proper motions and parallaxes
• Reddening and Extinction Toward the Galactic Bulge from OGLE-III: The Inner Milky Way's Rv ~ 2.5 Extinction Curve
• The effective temperature scale of FGK stars. II. Teff : color : [Fe/H] calibrations
• A standard stellar library for evolutionary synthesis: II. The M dwarf extension
• Chemical evolution of the Galactic bulge as traced by microlensed dwarf and subgiant stars. V. Evidence for a wide age distribution and a complex MDF
• The NextGen Model Atmosphere grid: II. Spherically symmetric model atmospheres for giant stars with effective temperatures between 3000 and 6800~K
• A Catalog of Spectroscopically Confirmed White Dwarfs from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 4
• Scaled solar tracks and isochrones in a large region of the Z-Y plane I. From the ZAMS to the TP-AGB end for 0.15 - 2.5 Mo stars
• A new implementation of the infrared flux method using the 2MASS catalogue
• The Victoria-Regina Stellar Models: Evolutionary Tracks and Isochrones for a Wide Range in Mass and Metallicity that Allow for Empirically Constrained Amounts of Convective Core Overshooting
• Distance to M31 With the HST and Hipparcos Red Clump Stars
• Asteroseismology of old open clusters with Kepler: direct estimate of the integrated RGB mass loss in NGC6791 and NGC6819
• The APOKASC Catalog: An Asteroseismic and Spectroscopic Joint Survey of Targets in the Kepler Fields
• The Sloan Digital Sky Survey Monitor Telescope Pipeline
• The SEGUE Stellar Parameter Pipeline. II. Validation with Galactic Globular and Open Clusters
• The Second APOKASC Catalog: The Empirical Approach
• The Y^2 Stellar Evolutionary Tracks
• Population effects on the Red Giant Clump absolute magnitude, and distance determinations to nearby galaxies
• Calculating asteroseismic diagrams for solar-like oscillations
• An Improved Distance and Mass Estimate for Sgr A* from a Multistar Orbit Analysis
• Synthetic Stellar Photometry - I. General considerations and new transformations for broad-band systems
• A standard stellar library for evolutionary synthesis. III. Metallicity calibration
• Galactocentric Distance With the OGLE and Hipparcos Red Clump Stars
• Theoretical isochrones in several photometric systems II. The Sloan Digital Sky Survey ugriz system
• The metallicity distribution of bulge clump giants in Baade's Window
• The relation between $\Delta \nu$ and ${\nu }_{max}$ for solar-like oscillations
• The underlying physical meaning of the ${\nu }_{\max }-{\nu }_{\mathrm{c}}$ relation
• Stellar population synthesis based modelling of the Milky Way using asteroseismology of 13000 Kepler red giants
• The old nuclear star cluster in the Milky Way: dynamics, mass, statistical parallax, and black hole mass
• The age of the oldest Open Clusters
• Bayesian distances and extinctions for giants observed by Kepler and APOGEE
• Age and helium content of the open cluster NGC 6791 from multiple eclipsing binary members. II. age dependencies and new insights
• A secondary clump of red giant stars: why and where
• The Distances to Open Clusters from Main-Sequence Fitting. III. Improved Accuracy with Empirically Calibrated Isochrones
• Asteroseismology of the open clusters NGC 6791, NGC 6811, and NGC 6819 from nineteen months of Kepler photometry
• Asymptotic and measured large frequency separations
• Galactic Globular and Open Clusters in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. I. Crowded Field Photometry and Cluster Fiducial Sequences in ugriz
• Sounding open clusters: asteroseismic constraints from Kepler on the properties of NGC 6791 and NGC 6819
• NGC 6791: an exotic open cluster or the nucleus of a tidally disrupted galaxy?
• The Stellar Metallicity Distribution Function of the Galactic Halo from SDSS Photometry
• Stellar Evolution in NGC 6791: Mass Loss on the Red Giant Branch and the Formation of Low Mass White Dwarfs
• Mass loss on the red giant branch: the value and metallicity dependence of Reimers' η in globular clusters
• Testing the Asteroseismic Mass Scale Using Metal-Poor Stars Characterized with APOGEE and Kepler
• An asteroseismic membership study of the red giants in three open clusters observed by Kepler: NGC6791, NGC6819, and NGC6811
• The Age, Extinction and Distance of the Old, Metal-Rich Open Cluster NGC 6791
• Abundances and possible diffusion of elements in M67 stars
• A High Relative-Precision Color-Magnitude Diagram of M67
• Galactic Globular and Open Clusters in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. II. Test of Theoretical Stellar Isochrones
• A new abundance scale for the globular cluster 47 Tuc
• Age and helium content of the open cluster NGC 6791 from multiple eclipsing binary members. I. Measurements, methods, and first results
• The red clump absolute magnitude based on revised Hipparcos parallaxes
• The First Empirical Mass Loss Law for Population II Giants
• Uncertainties on near-core mixing in red-clump stars: effects on the period spacing and on the luminosity of the AGB bump
• Significantly improving stellar mass and radius estimates: A new reference function for the Δν scaling relation
• Empirical photometric calibration of the Gaia Red Clump: colours, effective temperature and absolute magnitude
• Changing the ${\nu }_{\max }$ Scaling Relation: The Need For a Mean Molecular Weight Term
• The Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment. Red Clump Stars as a Distance Indicator
• Effects of Helium Enrichment in Globular Clusters I.Theoretical Plane with PGPUC stellar evolution code
• The K2 M67 Study: Revisiting old friends with K2 reveals oscillating red giants in the open cluster M67
• The Distances to Open Clusters from Main-Sequence Fitting. IV. Galactic Cepheids, the LMC, and the Local Distance Scale
• Sodium and Oxygen Abundances in the Open Cluster NGC 6791 from APOGEE H-Band Spectroscopy
• Red clump stars and Gaia: Calibration of the standard candle using a hierarchical probabilistic model
• The Distances to Open Clusters from Main-Sequence Fitting. I. New Models and a Comparison to the Properties of the Hyades Eclipsing Binary vB 22
• The Unique Na:O Abundance Distribution in NGC 6791: The First Open(?) Cluster with Multiple Populations
• Searching for Chemical Signatures of Multiple Stellar Populations in the Old, Massive Open Cluster NGC 6791
• A New Look at the Old Star Cluster NGC 6791
• Color--Magnitude Diagrams and Luminosity Functions down to the Hydrogen Burning Limit. III. A Preliminary HST Study of NGC6791
• Fiducial Stellar Population Sequences for the u'g'r'i'z' System
• Comprehensive abundance analysis of red giants in the open clusters NGC 2527, 2682, 2482, 2539, 2335, 2251 and 2266
• Infrared Photometry of NGC 6791
• The end of the white dwarf cooling sequence in M 67
• vbyCaHbeta CCD Photometry of Clusters. VIII. The Super-Metal Rich, Old Open Cluster NGC 6791
• Close binary stars in the solar-age Galactic open cluster M67
• Yonsei Evolutionary Population Synthesis (YEPS) Model. I. Spectroscopic Evolution of Simple Stellar Populations
• Gravitational redshifts in main-sequence and giant stars
• WIYN Open Cluster Study. LIX. Radial-Velocity Membership of the Evolved Population of the Old Open Cluster NGC 6791
• Spitzer Space Telescope evidence in NGC 6791: no super-mass-loss at super-solar metallicity to explain helium white dwarfs?
• A new search for planet transits in NGC 6791
• The Helium Abundance of NGC 6791 from Modeling of Stellar Oscillations
• The Distances to Open Clusters as Derived from Main-sequence Fitting. II. Construction of Empirically Calibrated Isochrones
• The Old, Super-Metal-Rich Open Cluster, NGC 6791 - Elemental Abundances in Turn-off Stars from Keck/HIRES Spectra
• Evidence for Extended Star Formation in the Old, Metal-Rich Open Cluster, NGC 6791?
• The Na-O anticorrelation in horizontal branch stars. IV. M22
• Absolute Magnitudes of Seismic Red Clumps in the Kepler Field and SAGA: the age dependency of the distance scale
• Uncertainties in stellar evolution models: convective overshoot
• The Distances to Open Clusters from Main-Sequence Fitting. V. Extension of Color Calibration and Test using Cool and Metal-Rich Stars in NGC 6791
• Mass Loss In M67 Giants: Evidence From Isochrone Fitting
• UB CCD photometry of the old, metal rich, open clusters NGC 6791, NGC 6819 and NGC 7142

Cited by in corpus (13)

• Testing the radius scaling relation with $Gaia$ DR2 in the $Kepler$ field
• Discovery of post-mass-transfer helium-burning red giants using asteroseismology
• The K2 Galactic Archaeology Program Data Release 3: Age-abundance patterns in C1-C8 and C10-C18
• TESS Asteroseismology of the known red-giant host stars HD 212771 and HD 203949
• Cannibals in the thick disk II -- Radial-velocity monitoring of the young alpha-rich stars
• The K2 Galactic Archaeology Program Data Release 2: Asteroseismic results from campaigns 4, 6, & 7
• The APO-K2 Catalog. II. Accurate Stellar Ages for Red Giant Branch Stars across the Milky Way
• A Blueprint for the Milky Way's Stellar Populations. II. Improved Isochrone Calibration in the SDSS and Pan-STARRS Photometric Systems
• Asteroseismic Study of Subgiants and Giants of the Open Cluster M67 using Kepler/K2: Expanded Sample and Precise Masses
• A Blueprint for the Milky Way's Stellar Populations. IV. A String of Pearls $-$ the Galactic Starburst Sequence
• A Blueprint for the Milky Way's Stellar Populations. V. 3D Local Dust Extinction
• Open cluster age calibration from colour-magnitude morphological indices using Gaia DR3 data
• On the Age Calibration of Open Clusters using Red Clump Stars