A fundamental problem in our understanding of low mass galaxy evolution
arXiv:1204.4184 · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2966.2012.21931.x
Abstract
Recent studies have found a dramatic difference between the observed number density evolution of low mass galaxies and that predicted by semi-analytic models. While models accurately reproduce the z=0 number density, they require that the evolution occurs rapidly at early times, which is incompatible with the strong late evolution found observationally. We report here the same discrepancy in two state-of-the-art cosmological hydrodynamical simulations, which is evidence that the problem is fundamental. We search for the underlying cause of this problem using two complementary methods. Firstly, we look for evidence of a different history of today's low mass galaxies in models and observations and we find that the models yield too few young, strongly star-forming galaxies. Secondly, we construct a toy model to link the observed evolution of specific star formation rates (sSFR) with the evolution of the galaxy stellar mass function. We infer from this model that a key problem in both semi-analytic and hydrodynamical models is the presence of a positive instead of a negative correlation between sSFR and stellar mass. A similar positive correlation is found between the specific dark matter halo accretion rate and the halo mass, indicating that model galaxies are growing in a way that follows the growth of their host haloes too closely. It therefore appears necessary to find a mechanism that decouples the growth of low mass galaxies, which occurs primarily at late times, from the growth of their host haloes, which occurs primarily at early times. We argue that the current form of star-formation driven feedback implemented in most galaxy formation models is unlikely to achieve this goal, owing to its fundamental dependence on host halo mass and time. [Abridged]
arXiv comment18 pages, 8 figures, accepted for publication in MNRAS
References in corpus (116)
- First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Determination of Cosmological Parameters
- Stellar population synthesis at the resolution of 2003
- Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Three Year Results: Implications for Cosmology
- The cosmological simulation code GADGET-2
- The Seventh Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- The many lives of active galactic nuclei: cooling flows, black holes and the luminosities and colours of galaxies
- Energy input from quasars regulates the growth and activity of black holes and their host galaxies
- The physical properties of star forming galaxies in the low redshift universe
- The broken hierarchy of galaxy formation
- Stellar Masses and Star Formation Histories for 10^5 Galaxies from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- The Optical and Near-Infrared Properties of Galaxies: I. Luminosity and Stellar Mass Functions
- Cosmological SPH simulations: A hybrid multi-phase model for star formation
- Mass and environment as drivers of galaxy evolution in SDSS and zCOSMOS and the origin of the Schechter function
- Star Formation in AEGIS Field Galaxies since z=1.1 : The Dominance of Gradually Declining Star Formation, and the Main Sequence of Star-Forming Galaxies
- Hierarchical Galaxy Formation
- Evolutionary population synthesis: models, analysis of the ingredients and application to high-z galaxies
- Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Data Processing, Sky Maps, and Basic Results
- A Simple Model for the Absorption of Starlight by Dust in Galaxies
- UV Star Formation Rates in the Local Universe
- The hierarchical formation of the brightest cluster galaxies
- New Insight on Galaxy Formation and Evolution from Keck Spectroscopy of the Hawaii Deep Fields
- The reversal of the star formation-density relation in the distant universe
- Multiwavelength study of massive galaxies at z~2. I. Star formation and galaxy growth
- NYU-VAGC: a galaxy catalog based on new public surveys
- The ages and metallicities of galaxies in the local universe
- From dwarf spheroidals to cDs: Simulating the galaxy population in a LCDM cosmology
- Constraints on the relationship between stellar mass and halo mass at low and high redshift
- A Semi-Analytic Model for the Co-evolution of Galaxies, Black Holes, and Active Galactic Nuclei
- The Fourth Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- Semi-Analytic Modelling of Galaxy Formation: The Local Universe
- The formation history of elliptical galaxies
- A Comprehensive Analysis of Uncertainties Affecting the Stellar Mass - Halo Mass Relation for 0<z<4
- The effect of photo-ionization on the cooling rates of enriched, astrophysical plasmas
- Constraining Warm Dark Matter candidates including sterile neutrinos and light gravitinos with WMAP and the Lyman-alpha forest
- The Star-formation Mass Sequence out to z=2.5
- Resolving Cosmic Structure Formation with the Millennium-II Simulation
- What Shapes the Luminosity Function of Galaxies?
- The physics driving the cosmic star formation history
- Concentration, Spin and Shape of Dark Matter Haloes as a Function of the Cosmological Model: WMAP1, WMAP3 and WMAP5 results
- Chemical enrichment in cosmological, smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations
- The age dependence of halo clustering
- On the relation between the Schmidt and Kennicutt-Schmidt star formation laws and its implications for numerical simulations
- A Catalog of Bulge+Disk Decompositions and Updated Photometry for 1.12 Million Galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- Cosmological Simulations of Intergalactic Medium Enrichment from Galactic Outflows
- The star formation history of mass-selected galaxies in the COSMOS field
- The stellar mass assembly of galaxies from z=0 to z=4. Analysis of a sample selected in the rest-frame near-infrared with Spitzer
- The Impact of cold gas accretion above a mass floor on galaxy scaling relations
- Stellar Feedback in Galaxies and the Origin of Galaxy-scale Winds
- Mass, Metal, and Energy Feedback in Cosmological Simulations
- The Evolution of the Stellar Mass Function of Galaxies from z=4.0 and the First Comprehensive Analysis of its Uncertainties: Evidence for Mass-dependent Evolution
- Forming Realistic Late-Type Spirals in a LCDM Universe: The Eris Simulation
- Connecting Galaxies, Halos, and Star Formation Rates Across Cosmic Time
- The Origin of the Galaxy Mass-Metallicity Relation and Implications for Galactic Outflows
- Feedback and Recycled Wind Accretion: Assembling the z=0 Galaxy Mass Function
- Simulating galactic outflows with kinetic supernova feedback
- The Importance of Satellite Quenching for the Build-Up of the Red Sequence of Present Day Galaxies
- The Aquila comparison Project: The Effects of Feedback and Numerical Methods on Simulations of Galaxy Formation
- A Halo-Based Galaxy Group Finder: Calibration and Application to the 2dFGRS
- A Stellar Mass Threshold for Quenching of Field Galaxies
- Galaxy Evolution in Cosmological Simulations with Outflows II: Metallicities and Gas Fractions
- The Galaxy Mass Function up to z=4 in the GOODS-MUSIC sample: into the epoch of formation of massive galaxies
- Lyman-alpha constraints on warm and on warm-plus-cold dark matter models
- The distribution of stellar mass in the low-redshift Universe
- Chemical enrichment of the intra-cluster and intergalactic medium in a hierarchical galaxy formation model
- The Many Manifestations of Downsizing: Hierarchical Galaxy Formation Models confront Observations
- Can sterile neutrinos be the dark matter?
- Galaxy Evolution in Cosmological Simulations With Outflows I: Stellar Masses and Star Formation Rates
- Evolution of the Galaxy - Dark Matter Connection and the Assembly of Galaxies in Dark Matter Halos
- The galaxy stellar mass-star formation rate relation: Evidence for an evolving stellar initial mass function?
- The Baryonic Assembly of Dark Matter Halos
- Cosmological simulations of the formation of the stellar haloes around disc galaxies
- Cores in warm dark matter haloes: a Catch 22 problem
- Natural Downsizing in Hierarchical Galaxy Formation
- Galaxies-Intergalactic Medium Interaction Calculation --I. Galaxy formation as a function of large-scale environment
- Discreteness effects in simulations of Hot/Warm dark matter
- Evolution of Galaxy Stellar Mass Functions, Mass Densities, and Mass to Light Ratios from z 7 to z 4
- The Halo Mass Function: High-Redshift Evolution and Universality
- Star Formation and the Growth of Stellar Mass
- Environmental Effects on Satellite Galaxies: The Link Between Concentration, Size and Colour Profile
- Flux-calibrated stellar population models of Lick absorption-line indices with variable element abundance ratios
- Properties of Galaxy Groups in the SDSS: II.- AGN Feedback and Star Formation Truncation
- Ultra-Light Scalar Fields and the Growth of Structure in the Universe
- A census of metals and baryons in stars in the local Universe
- MaGICC Disks: Matching Observed Galaxy Relationships Over a Wide Stellar Mass Range
- What Shapes the Galaxy Mass Function? Exploring the Roles of Supernova-Driven Winds and AGN
- The star-formation history of K-selected galaxies
- Metallicity-Dependent quenching of Star Formation at High Redshift in Small Galaxies
- On the Last 10 Billion Years of Stellar Mass Growth in Star-Forming Galaxies
- X-ray coronae in simulations of disc galaxy formation
- The Dawn of the Red: Star formation histories of group galaxies over the past 5 billion years
- The baryon fraction of LambdaCDM haloes
- How Do Star-Forming Galaxies at Z>3 Assemble Their Masses?
- Global structure and kinematics of stellar haloes in cosmological hydrodynamic simulations
- The intergalactic medium over the last 10 billion years II: Metal-line absorption and physical conditions
- Stellar Ages and Metallicities of Central and Satellite Galaxies: Implications for Galaxy Formation and Evolution
- Merger Rates of Dark-Matter Haloes
- A Robust Method for the Analysis of Integrated Spectra from Globular Clusters using Lick Indices
- The contribution of star formation and merging to stellar mass buildup in galaxies
- The Dependence of Galaxy Formation on Cosmological Parameters: Can we distinguish the WMAP1 and WMAP3 Parameter Sets?
- Halpha Equivalent Widths from the 3D-HST survey: evolution with redshift and dependence on stellar mass
- The Physical and Photometric Properties of High-Redshift Galaxies in Cosmological Hydrodynamic Simulations
- On the puzzling plateau in the specific star formation rate at z=2-7
- The Star Formation Demographics of Galaxies in the Local Volume
- Preheating by Previrialization and its Impact on Galaxy Formation
- Dwarf galaxy populations in present-day galaxy clusters: I. Abundances and red fractions
- Bayesian inference of galaxy formation from the K-band luminosity function of galaxies: tensions between theory and observation
- Faint Lyman-Break galaxies as a crucial test for galaxy formation models
- Reproducing the assembly of massive galaxies within the hierarchical cosmogony
- A modified star formation law as a solution to open problems in galaxy evolution
- A spectroscopic measurement of galaxy formation timescales with ROLES
- Star formation in the CDFS: observations confront simulations
- The specific star formation rate and stellar mass fraction of low-mass central galaxies in cosmological simulations
- Galaxy downsizing evidenced by hybrid evolutionary tracks
- The nature of red dwarf galaxies
- Hydrodynamical simulations and semi-analytic models of galaxy formation: two sides of the same coin
- The Growth of Galaxy Stellar Mass Within Dark Matter Halos
Cited by in corpus (133)
- Introducing the Illustris Project: Simulating the coevolution of dark and visible matter in the Universe
- The Average Star Formation Histories of Galaxies in Dark Matter Halos from z=0-8
- The EAGLE simulations of galaxy formation: calibration of subgrid physics and model variations
- Physical Models of Galaxy Formation in a Cosmological Framework
- Properties of galaxies reproduced by a hydrodynamic simulation
- The Evolution of the Stellar Mass Functions of Star-Forming and Quiescent Galaxies to z = 4 from the COSMOS/UltraVISTA Survey
- Galaxy formation in the Planck Cosmology - I. Matching the observed evolution of star formation rates, colours and stellar masses
- PRIMUS: Constraints on Star Formation Quenching and Galaxy Merging, and the Evolution of the Stellar Mass Function From z=0-1
- Deriving Physical Properties from Broadband Photometry with Prospector: Description of the Model and a Demonstration of its Accuracy Using 129 Galaxies in the Local Universe
- A unified multi-wavelength model of galaxy formation
- Evolution of galaxy stellar masses and star formation rates in the EAGLE simulations
- NIHAO project I: Reproducing the inefficiency of galaxy formation across cosmic time with a large sample of cosmological hydrodynamical simulations
- A White Paper on keV Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter
- Regularity underlying complexity: a redshift-independent description of the continuous variation of galaxy-scale molecular gas properties in the mass-star formation rate plane
- A physical model for cosmological simulations of galaxy formation: multi-epoch validation
- The SFR-M* Relation and Empirical Star-Formation Histories from ZFOURGE at 0.5 < z < 4
- A Model For Halo Formation With Axion Mixed Dark Matter
- Simulations of the galaxy population constrained by observations from z=3 to the present day: implications for galactic winds and the fate of their ejecta
- On the interplay between star formation and feedback in galaxy formation simulations
- Bent by baryons: the low mass galaxy-halo relation
- Star Formation in Semi-Analytic Galaxy Formation Models with Multiphase Gas
- Radiative feedback and the low efficiency of galaxy formation in low-mass haloes at high redshift
- Evolution of the atomic and molecular gas content of galaxies
- The Neutral Hydrogen Content of Galaxies in Cosmological Hydrodynamic Simulations
- Galaxy assembly, stellar feedback and metal enrichment: the view from the GAEA model
- The abundance and spatial distribution of ultra-diffuse galaxies in nearby galaxy clusters
- The JWST Extragalactic Mock Catalog: Modeling galaxy populations from the UV through the near-IR over thirteen billion years of cosmic history
- Scaling Relations Between Warm Galactic Outflows and Their Host Galaxies
- The galaxy-halo connection from a joint lensing, clustering and abundance analysis in the CFHTLenS/VIPERS field
- Taking Care of Business in a Flash: Constraining the Timescale for Low-Mass Satellite Quenching with ELVIS
- A New Census of the 0.2 < z < 3.0 Universe, Part I: The Stellar Mass Function
- Semi-Analytic Galaxies - I. Synthesis of environmental and star-forming regulation mechanisms
- The environmental dependence of the stellar mass function at z~1: Comparing cluster and field between the GCLASS and UltraVISTA surveys
- The influence of the environmental history on quenching star formation in a CDM universe
- A Comparison between Semi-Analytic Model Predictions for the CANDELS Survey
- The VIPERS Multi-Lambda Survey. II. Diving with massive galaxies in 22 square degrees since z = 1.5
- Galaxies in the EAGLE hydrodynamical simulation and in the Durham and Munich semi-analytical models
- The effect of metal enrichment and galactic winds on galaxy formation in cosmological zoom simulations
- H-based star formation laws in hierarchical models of galaxy formation
- Evolution of the atomic and molecular gas content of galaxies in dark matter haloes
- The GOGREEN Survey: A deep stellar mass function of cluster galaxies at 1.0<z<1.4 and the complex nature of satellite quenching
- Surveying Galaxy Proto-clusters in Emission: A Large-scale Structure at z=2.44 and the Outlook for HETDEX
- Galaxy formation in the Planck cosmology - IV. Mass and environmental quenching, conformity and clustering
- Which galaxies dominate the neutral gas content of the Universe?
- The ACS LCID project. X. The Star Formation History of IC 1613: Revisiting the Over-Cooling Problem
- Reconciling the observed star-forming sequence with the observed stellar mass function
- A dynamical model of supernova feedback: gas outflows from the interstellar medium
- Equilibrium Model Constraints on Baryon Cycling Across Cosmic Time
- MAGIICAT III. Interpreting Self-Similarity of the Circumgalactic Medium with Virial Mass using MgII Absorption
- A Semi-Analytical Line Transfer (SALT) model to interpret the spectra of galaxy outflows
- Towards a physical picture of star-formation quenching: the photometric properties of recently-quenched galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- On the Origin of the Hubble Sequence: I. Insights on Galaxy Color Migration from Cosmological Simulations
- The metallicity evolution of low mass galaxies: New constraints at intermediate redshift
- Gemini Observations of Galaxies in Rich Early Environments (GOGREEN) I: Survey Description
- A Dichotomy in Satellite Quenching Around L* Galaxies
- The Hierarchical Origins of Observed Galaxy Morphology
- The MaGICC volume: reproducing statistical properties of high redshift galaxies
- Star Formation and Clumps in Cosmological Galaxy Simulations with Radiation Pressure Feedback
- The evolution of the star forming sequence in hierarchical galaxy formation models
- Cosmological Zoom Simulations of z = 2 Galaxies: The Impact of Galactic Outflows
- Resolved galaxy scaling relations in the EAGLE simulation: star formation, metallicity and stellar mass on kpc scales
- The MOSDEF Survey: Metallicity Dependence of the PAH Emission at High Redshift and Implications for 24 micron-inferred IR Luminosities and Star Formation Rates at z~2
- Dwarf galaxy populations in present-day galaxy clusters - II. The history of early-type and late-type dwarfs
- The GOGREEN survey: Post-infall environmental quenching fails to predict the observed age difference between quiescent field and cluster galaxies at z>1
- Star Formation and Stellar Mass Assembly in Dark Matter Halos: From Giants to Dwarfs
- Chemical enrichment of Damped Lyman Alpha systems as a direct constraint on Population III star formation
- UVUDF: UV Luminosity Functions at the cosmic high-noon
- First results from SMAUG: The need for preventative stellar feedback and improved baryon cycling in semi-analytic models of galaxy formation
- A simple model linking galaxy and dark matter evolution
- Galaxy properties and the cosmic web in simulations
- Long way to go: how outflows from large galaxies propagate through the hot halo gas
- The emergence of passive galaxies in the early Universe
- Formation of disk galaxies in preheated media: a preventative feedback model
- Nature versus nurture: what regulates star formation in satellite galaxies?
- The effect of Warm Dark Matter on galaxy properties: constraints from the stellar mass function and the Tully-Fisher relation
- Isolated galaxies in hierarchical galaxy formation models - present-day properties and environmental histories
- The evolution of galaxy metallicity scaling relations in cosmological hydrodynamical simulations
- Chandra Survey of Nearby Highly Inclined Disc Galaxies - III: Comparison with Hydrodynamical Simulations of Circumgalactic Coronae
- Isolated elliptical galaxies in the local Universe
- Bayesian inferences of galaxy formation from the K-band luminosity and HI mass functions of galaxies: constraining star formation and feedback
- A parametric study of possible solutions to the high-redshift overproduction of stars in modeled dwarf galaxies
- Anti-hierarchical evolution of the Active Galactic Nucleus space density in a hierarchical universe
- Semi-analytic galaxy formation in f(R)-gravity cosmologies
- Spatial and luminosity distributions of galactic satellites
- The VIMOS Ultra Deep Survey. Luminosity and stellar mass dependence of galaxy clustering at z~3
- Delayed star formation in high-redshift stream-fed galaxies
- The New Numerical Galaxy Catalogue (ν^2 GC): Properties of Active Galactic Nuclei and Their Host Galaxies
- Constraining the Warm Dark Matter Particle Mass through Ultra-Deep UV Luminosity Functions at z=2
- Cosmic CARNage I: on the calibration of galaxy formation models
- I. Apples to apples : realistic galaxy simulated catalogs and photometric redshift predictions for next-generation surveys
- The Mass Dependance of Satellite Quenching in Milky Way-like Halos
- The evolution of the mass-metallicity relations from the VANDELS survey and the GAEA Semi-Analytic model
- Strong stellar-driven outflows shape the evolution of galaxies at cosmic dawn
- On Physical Scales of Dark Matter Halos
- What do simulations predict for the galaxy stellar mass function and its evolution in different environments?
- Damped Lyα Absorption Systems in Semi-Analytic Models with Multiphase Gas
- The definition of environment and its relation to the quenching of galaxies at z=1-2 in a hierarchical Universe
- GOGREEN: a critical assessment of environmental trends in cosmological hydrodynamical simulations at z ~ 1
- Galaxy Formation in Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter Models
- Cosmic CARNage II: the evolution of the galaxy stellar mass function in observations and galaxy formation models
- Simulations of isolated dwarf galaxies formed in dark matter halos with different mass assembly histories
- How the first stars shaped the faintest gas-dominated dwarf galaxies
- Galaxy stellar mass assembly: the difficulty matching observations and semi-analytical predictions
- Chemical constraints on the contribution of Population III stars to cosmic reionization
- On the mass assembly of low-mass galaxies in hydrodynamical simulations of structure formation
- The GOGREEN Survey: Constraining the Satellite Quenching Timescale in Massive Clusters at
- A Machine Learning Approach to Measuring the Quenched Fraction of Low-Mass Satellites Beyond the Local Group
- SDSS-IV MaNGA: Environmental dependence of the Mgb/<Fe>-sigma_* relation for nearby galaxies
- Constraints on the Evolution of the Galaxy Stellar Mass Function I: Role of Star Formation, Mergers and Stellar Stripping
- The Diversity of Growth Histories of Milky Way-mass Galaxies
- Growing up in a megalopolis: Environmental effects on galaxy evolution in a supercluster at z~0.65 in UKIDSS UDS
- MaNGA galaxy properties -- II. A detailed comparison of observed and simulated spiral galaxy scaling relations
- Gas Accretion and Galactic Chemical Evolution: Theory and Observations
- The ages of stellar populations in a warm dark matter universe
- Star formation in mergers with cosmologically motivated initial conditions
- The UV luminosity function at 0.6 < z < 1 from UVCANDELS
- What Regulates Galaxy Evolution? Open Questions in Our Understanding of Galaxy Formation and Evolution
- GalICS 2.1: a new semianalytic model for cold accretion, cooling, feedback and their roles in galaxy formation
- The Mass Growth and Stellar Ages of Galaxies: Observations versus Simulations
- Assembly Bias of Dwarf-sized Dark Matter Haloes
- Semi-Analytic Galaxy Formation in Massive Neutrino Cosmologies
- SDSS-IV MaNGA: The MaNGA Dwarf Galaxy Sample
- Supersonic turbulence in 3D isothermal flow collision
- The abundance and colours of galaxies in high redshift clusters in the cold dark matter cosmology
- On the phase-space structure of galaxy clusters from cosmological simulations
- Semi-analytic galaxy formation in coupled dark energy cosmologies
- Panchromatic Spectral Energy Distributions of simulated galaxies: results at redshift
- Characterizing simulated galaxy stellar mass histories
- The Ursa Major Association of Galaxies. VI: A relative dearth of gas-rich dwarf galaxies
- A Model of the Cosmic Infrared Background Produced by Distant Galaxies
- A study on the multicolour evolution of Red Sequence galaxy populations: insights from hydrodynamical simulations and semi-analytical models
- Anatomy of galactic star formation history: Roles of different modes of gas accretion, feedback, and recycling
- Insights into environmental quenching at : an enhancement of faint, low-mass passive galaxies in clusters