Cosmic CARNage I: on the calibration of galaxy formation models

Abstract

We present a comparison of nine galaxy formation models, eight semi-analytical and one halo occupation distribution model, run on the same underlying cold dark matter simulation (cosmological box of co-moving width 125$h^{-1}$ Mpc, with a dark-matter particle mass of $1.24\times 10^9{h}^{-1}$ Msun) and the same merger trees. While their free parameters have been calibrated to the same observational data sets using two approaches, they nevertheless retain some 'memory' of any previous calibration that served as the starting point (especially for the manually-tuned models). For the first calibration, models reproduce the observed z = 0 galaxy stellar mass function (SMF) within 3-σ. The second calibration extended the observational data to include the z = 2 SMF alongside the z~0 star formation rate function, cold gas mass and the black hole-bulge mass relation. Encapsulating the observed evolution of the SMF from z = 2 to z = 0 is found to be very hard within the context of the physics currently included in the models. We finally use our calibrated models to study the evolution of the stellar-to-halo mass (SHM) ratio. For all models we find that the peak value of the SHM relation decreases with redshift. However, the trends seen for the evolution of the peak position as well as the mean scatter in the SHM relation are rather weak and strongly model dependent. Both the calibration data sets and model results are publicly available.

arXiv comment20 pages, 14 figures (+5 supplementary figures in the Appendix), accepted for publication in MNRAS

References in corpus (79)

• Planck 2013 results. XVI. Cosmological parameters
• The cosmological simulation code GADGET-2
• Coevolution (Or Not) of Supermassive Black Holes and Host Galaxies
• Cosmic Star Formation History
• The many lives of active galactic nuclei: cooling flows, black holes and the luminosities and colours of galaxies
• The broken hierarchy of galaxy formation
• The Average Star Formation Histories of Galaxies in Dark Matter Halos from z=0-8
• High Redshift Galaxies in the Hubble Deep Field. Color Selection and Star Formation History to z=4
• The hierarchical formation of the brightest cluster galaxies
• The Rockstar Phase-Space Temporal Halo Finder and the Velocity Offsets of Cluster Cores
• Galactic star formation and accretion histories from matching galaxies to dark matter haloes
• Physical Models of Galaxy Formation in a Cosmological Framework
• Revisiting the Scaling Relations of Black Hole Masses and Host Galaxy Properties
• From dwarf spheroidals to cDs: Simulating the galaxy population in a LCDM cosmology
• Constraints on the relationship between stellar mass and halo mass at low and high redshift
• The CANADA-FRANCE REDSHIFT SURVEY XIII: The luminosity density and star-formation history of the Universe to z ~ 1
• A fundamental relation between mass, SFR and metallicity in local and high redshift galaxies
• Semi-Analytic Modelling of Galaxy Formation: The Local Universe
• Mass assembly in quiescent and star-forming galaxies since z=4 from UltraVISTA
• The Evolution of the Stellar Mass Functions of Star-Forming and Quiescent Galaxies to z = 4 from the COSMOS/UltraVISTA Survey
• Galaxy formation in the Planck Cosmology - I. Matching the observed evolution of star formation rates, colours and stellar masses
• The Nature of High-Redshift Galaxies
• Gravitationally Consistent Halo Catalogs and Merger Trees for Precision Cosmology
• A primer on hierarchical galaxy formation: the semi-analytical approach
• New constraints on the evolution of the stellar-to-dark matter connection: a combined analysis of galaxy-galaxy lensing, clustering, and stellar mass functions from z=0.2 to z=1
• Galaxy Stellar Mass Functions from ZFOURGE/CANDELS: An Excess of Low-Mass Galaxies Since z=2 and the Rapid Buildup of Quiescent Galaxies
• A unified multi-wavelength model of galaxy formation
• Dark matter and cosmic structure
• A fundamental plane for field star-forming galaxies
• The distribution of stellar mass in the low-redshift Universe
• The Many Manifestations of Downsizing: Hierarchical Galaxy Formation Models confront Observations
• Galaxy And Mass Assembly (GAMA): The galaxy stellar mass function at z < 0.06
• A Budget and Accounting of Metals at z~0: Results from the COS-Halos Survey
• Evolution of the Galaxy - Dark Matter Connection and the Assembly of Galaxies in Dark Matter Halos
• Galaxy formation in WMAP1 and WMAP7 cosmologies
• The star formation histories of galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• The Current Status of Galaxy Formation
• Semi-Analytic Galaxy Evolution (SAGE): Model Calibration and Basic Results
• The MORGANA model for the rise of galaxies and active nuclei
• The Galaxy-Halo Connection Over The Last 13.3 Gyrs
• Simulations of the galaxy population constrained by observations from z=3 to the present day: implications for galactic winds and the fate of their ejecta
• The Evolution of Stellar Mass and the Implied Star Formation History
• On the galaxy stellar mass function, the mass-metallicity relation, and the implied baryonic mass function
• Suppressing star formation in quiescent galaxies with supermassive black hole winds
• Cold gas properties of the Herschel Reference Survey. II. Molecular and total gas scaling relations
• Galaxy assembly, stellar feedback and metal enrichment: the view from the GAEA model
• A new model of galaxy formation: How sensitive are predicted galaxy luminosities to the choice of SPS model?
• An algorithm to build mock galaxy catalogues using MICE simulations
• CFHTLenS: Co-evolution of galaxies and their dark matter haloes
• A fundamental problem in our understanding of low mass galaxy evolution
• The origin of scatter in the stellar mass - halo mass relation of central galaxies in the EAGLE simulation
• The Parameter Space of Galaxy Formation
• Deconstructing the Galaxy Stellar Mass Function with UKIDSS and CANDELS: the Impact of Colour, Structure and Environment
• A Comparison between Semi-Analytic Model Predictions for the CANDELS Survey
• The fundamental plane of star formation in galaxies revealed by the EAGLE hydrodynamical simulations
• Galaxies in the EAGLE hydrodynamical simulation and in the Durham and Munich semi-analytical models
• Chemo-Archaeological Downsizing in a Hierarchical Universe: Impact of a Top Heavy IGIMF
• Monte Carlo Markov Chain Parameter Estimation in Semi-Analytic Models of Galaxy Formation
• The stellar-subhalo mass relation of satellite galaxies
• Probing the galaxy-halo connection in UltraVISTA to $z\sim 2$
• On the Mass-Metallicity-Star Formation Rate Relation for Galaxies at $z\sim 2$
• On ths assembly history of stellar components in massive galaxies
• The evolution of quiescent galaxies at high redshift (z > 1.4)
• Is There a Missing Galaxy Problem at High Redshift?
• The evolution of the star forming sequence in hierarchical galaxy formation models
• Calibration of semi-analytic models of galaxy formation using Particle Swarm Optimization
• Sussing Merger Trees: the influence of the halo finder
• Building a Predictive Model of Galaxy Formation - I: Phenomenological Model Constrained to the $z=0$ Stellar Mass Function
• The evolution of the stellar mass versus halo mass relationship
• The new semianalytic code GalICS 2.0 - Reproducing the galaxy stellar mass function and the Tully-Fisher relation simultaneously
• Constraining the last 7 billion years of galaxy evolution in semi-analytic models
• Constraints on galaxy formation models from the galaxy stellar mass function and its evolution
• A parametric study of possible solutions to the high-redshift overproduction of stars in modeled dwarf galaxies
• Sussing Merger Trees : The Impact of Halo Merger Trees on Galaxy Properties in a Semi-Analytic Model
• nIFTy Cosmology: the clustering consistency of galaxy formation models
• Convergence of Galaxy Properties with Merger Tree Temporal Resolution
• On the scatter in the relation between stellar mass and halo mass: random or halo formation time dependent?
• The galaxy correlation function as a constraint on galaxy formation physics
• Missing Halo Baryons and Galactic Outflows

Cited by in corpus (23)

• Shark: introducing an open source, free and flexible semi-analytic model of galaxy formation
• The Three Hundred project: a large catalogue of theoretically modelled galaxy clusters for cosmological and astrophysical applications
• The stellar-to-halo mass relation over the past 12 Gyr
• Large-scale dark matter simulations
• Semi-Analytic Galaxies - I. Synthesis of environmental and star-forming regulation mechanisms
• Atomic hydrogen in IllustrisTNG galaxies: the impact of environment parallelled with local 21-cm surveys
• The first Super Massive Black Holes: indications from models for future observations
• Quiescent galaxies at $z\gtrsim 2.5$: observations vs. models
• Semi-Analytic Galaxies - II. Revealing the role of environmental and mass quenching in galaxy formation
• Semi-analytic galaxies -- III. The impact of supernova feedback on the mass-metallicity relation
• The Intrinsic Scatter of Galaxy Scaling Relations
• Massive quiescent galaxies at $z\sim 3$: a comparison of selection, stellar population and structural properties with simulation predictions
• Cosmic CARNage II: the evolution of the galaxy stellar mass function in observations and galaxy formation models
• Candidate Massive Galaxies at $z\sim 4$ in the Dark Energy Survey
• GalICS 2.1: a new semianalytic model for cold accretion, cooling, feedback and their roles in galaxy formation
• First Light and Reionisation Epoch Simulations (FLARES) X: Environmental Galaxy Bias and Survey Variance at High Redshift
• Cosmic Pathways for Compact Groups in the Milli-Millennium Simulation
• Environmental effects on associations of dwarf galaxies
• Associations of dwarf galaxies in a $\Lambda$CDM Universe
• UNITSIM-Galaxies: data release and clustering of emission-line galaxies
• Halo Merger Tree Comparison: Impact on Galaxy Formation Models
• Variations of the stellar Initial Mass Function in Semi-Analytic Models: implications for the mass assembly of galaxies in the GAEA model
• A semi-analytical perspective on massive red galaxies: I. Assembly history, environment & redshift evolution