nIFTy Cosmology: the clustering consistency of galaxy formation models

Abstract

We present a clustering comparison of 12 galaxy formation models (including Semi-Analytic Models (SAMs) and Halo Occupation Distribution (HOD) models) all run on halo catalogues and merger trees extracted from a single ΛCDM N-body simulation. We compare the results of the measurements of the mean halo occupation numbers, the radial distribution of galaxies in haloes and the 2-Point Correlation Functions (2PCF). We also study the implications of the different treatments of orphan (galaxies not assigned to any dark matter subhalo) and non-orphan galaxies in these measurements. Our main result is that the galaxy formation models generally agree in their clustering predictions but they disagree significantly between HOD and SAMs for the orphan satellites. Although there is a very good agreement between the models on the 2PCF of central galaxies, the scatter between the models when orphan satellites are included can be larger than a factor of 2 for scales smaller than 1 Mpc/h. We also show that galaxy formation models that do not include orphan satellite galaxies have a significantly lower 2PCF on small scales, consistent with previous studies. Finally, we show that the 2PCF of orphan satellites is remarkably different between SAMs and HOD models. Orphan satellites in SAMs present a higher clustering than in HOD models because they tend to occupy more massive haloes. We conclude that orphan satellites have an important role on galaxy clustering and they are the main cause of the differences in the clustering between HOD models and SAMs.

17 pages, 7 figures

References in corpus (12)

• The hierarchical formation of the brightest cluster galaxies
• A primer on hierarchical galaxy formation: the semi-analytical approach
• The MORGANA model for the rise of galaxies and active nuclei
• The Population of Dark Matter Subhaloes: Mass Functions and Average Mass Loss Rates
• The Correlation of Star Formation Quenching with Internal Galaxy Properties and Environment
• An algorithm to build mock galaxy catalogues using MICE simulations
• A Halo Model of Galaxy Colors and Clustering in the SDSS
• Modelling galaxy clustering in a high resolution simulation of structure formation
• The abundance of (not just) dark matter haloes
• Metal Enrichment of the ICM: a 3-D Picture of Chemical and Dynamical Properties
• Sussing Merger Trees : The Impact of Halo Merger Trees on Galaxy Properties in a Semi-Analytic Model
• A new methodology to test galaxy formation models using the dependence of clustering on stellar mass

Cited by in corpus (26)

• First results from the IllustrisTNG simulations: matter and galaxy clustering
• The Connection between Galaxies and their Dark Matter Halos
• Dark Matter Substructure in Numerical Simulations: A Tale of Discreteness Noise, Runaway Instabilities, and Artificial Disruption
• The Three Hundred project: a large catalogue of theoretically modelled galaxy clusters for cosmological and astrophysical applications
• Galaxy formation in the Planck Millennium: the atomic hydrogen content of dark matter halos
• Modeling the Connection Between Subhalos and Satellites in Milky Way-like Systems
• The Galaxy Clustering Crisis in Abundance Matching
• On stellar mass loss from galaxies in groups and clusters
• Updated Results on the Galaxy-Halo Connection from Satellite Kinematics in SDSS
• The Signatures of Self-Interacting Dark Matter and Subhalo Disruption on Cluster Substructure
• Cosmic CARNage I: on the calibration of galaxy formation models
• The Three Hundred Project: Substructure in hydrodynamical and dark matter simulations of galaxy groups around clusters
• The PAU Survey: Spectral features and galaxy clustering using simulated narrow band photometry
• UniverseMachine: Predicting Galaxy Star Formation over Seven Decades of Halo Mass with Zoom-in Simulations
• Observing Merger Trees in a New Light
• Structure and dynamics in low density regions: galaxy-galaxy correlations inside cosmic voids
• The SAGA Survey. V. Modeling Satellite Systems around Milky Way-mass Galaxies with Updated UniverseMachine
• Testing the consistency of three-point halo clustering in Fourier and configuration space
• Compact groups from semi-analytical models of galaxy formation -- I: a comparative study of frequency and nature
• Compact groups from semi-analytical models of galaxy formation -- II: Different assembly channels
• Tracking the orbit of unresolved subhalos for semi-analytic models
• Galaxy and Mass Assembly (GAMA): the clustering of galaxy groups
• Comparing Galaxy Clustering in Horizon-AGN Simulated Lightcone Mocks and VIDEO Observations
• ELG$\times$LRG distribution through dark matter halo dynamics
• Halo Merger Tree Comparison: Impact on Galaxy Formation Models
• Exploring the effect of baryons on the radial distribution of satellite galaxies with GAMA and IllustrisTNG