How robust are predictions of galaxy clustering?

Abstract

We use the Millennium Simulation database to compare how different versions of the Durham and Munich semi-analytical galaxy formation models populate dark matter haloes with galaxies. The models follow the same physical processes but differ in how these are implemented. All of the models we consider use the Millennium N-body Simulation; however, the Durham and Munich groups use independent algorithms to construct halo merger histories. We compare the predicted halo occupation distributions (HODs) and correlation functions for galaxy samples defined by stellar mass, cold gas mass and star formation rate. The predictions for the HOD are remarkably similar for samples ranked by stellar mass. The predicted bias averaged over 5-25 Mpc/h is consistent between models to within 10%. At small pair separations there is a difference in the predicted clustering. This arises because the Durham models allow some satellite galaxies to merge with the central galaxy in a halo when they are still associated with resolved subhaloes. The agreement between the models is less good for samples defined by cold gas mass or star formation rate, with the small scale clustering differing by an order of magnitude, reflecting the uncertainty in the modelling of star formation. The model predictions in these cases are qualitatively similar, with a markedly shallower slope for the correlation function than is found for stellar mass selected samples and with the HOD displaying an asymmetric peak for central galaxies. We provide illustrative parametric fits to the HODs predicted by the models. Our results reveal the current limitations on how well we can predict galaxy bias in a fixed cosmology, which has implications for the interpretation of constraints on the physics of galaxy formation from galaxy clustering measurements and the ability of future galaxy surveys to measure dark energy.

14 pages, 14 figures

References in corpus (7)

• The hierarchical formation of the brightest cluster galaxies
• A primer on hierarchical galaxy formation: the semi-analytical approach
• A Halo Model of Galaxy Colors and Clustering in the SDSS
• The abundance of (not just) dark matter haloes
• The recycling of gas and metals in galaxy formation: predictions of a dynamical feedback model
• Monte Carlo Markov Chain Parameter Estimation in Semi-Analytic Models of Galaxy Formation
• Revisiting the Baryon Fractions of Galaxy Clusters: A Comparison with WMAP 3-year Results

Cited by in corpus (67)

• The Impact of Assembly Bias on the Galaxy Content of Dark Matter Halos
• The impact of assembly bias on the halo occupation in hydrodynamical simulations
• Galaxy formation in the Planck Millennium: the atomic hydrogen content of dark matter halos
• Galaxies in the EAGLE hydrodynamical simulation and in the Durham and Munich semi-analytical models
• The Completed SDSS-IV extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: exploring the Halo Occupation Distribution model for Emission Line Galaxies
• The host dark matter halos of [OII] emitters at 0.5< z< 1.5
• The Evolution of Assembly Bias
• Galaxy and Mass Assembly (GAMA): Projected Galaxy Clustering
• PRIMUS: Galaxy Clustering as a Function of Luminosity and Color at 0.2<z<1
• Predictions for deep galaxy surveys with JWST from $\Lambda$CDM
• A flexible modelling of galaxy assembly bias
• The galaxy-halo connection of emission-line galaxies in IllustrisTNG
• A flexible subhalo abundance matching model for galaxy clustering in redshift space
• Hi intensity mapping with MeerKAT: Primary beam effects on foreground cleaning
• TheHaloMod: An online calculator for the halo model
• The Completed SDSS-IV extended Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey: N-body Mock Challenge for the eBOSS Emission Line Galaxy Sample
• Evolution of Star-forming Galaxies from z = 0.7 to 1.2 with eBOSS Emission-line Galaxies
• Dark Matter Halo Models of Stellar Mass-Dependent Galaxy Clustering in PRIMUS+DEEP2 at 0.2<z<1.2
• Large-scale redshift space distortions in modified gravity theories
• The H-alpha luminosity-dependent clustering of star-forming galaxies from z~0.8 to z~2.2 with HiZELS
• Do model emission line galaxies live in filaments at z~1?
• The galaxy - dark matter halo connection: which galaxy properties are correlated with the host halo mass?
• nIFTy Cosmology: the clustering consistency of galaxy formation models
• Extensions to the halo occupation distribution model for more accurate clustering predictions
• Small-scale galaxy clustering in the EAGLE simulation
• Linear bias forecasts for emission line cosmological surveys
• The MillenniumTNG Project: Inferring cosmology from galaxy clustering with accelerated N-body scaling and subhalo abundance matching
• The evolution of the galaxy content of dark matter haloes
• Groups in the Millennium Simulation and in SDSS DR7
• Are the halo occupation predictions consistent with large scale galaxy clustering?
• Galactic conformity measured in semi-analytic models
• Dissecting the roles of mass and environment quenching in galaxy evolution with EAGLE
• The PAU Survey: Spectral features and galaxy clustering using simulated narrow band photometry
• A new methodology to test galaxy formation models using the dependence of clustering on stellar mass
• Linear bias and halo occupation distribution of emission line galaxies from Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope
• Real- and redshift-space halo clustering in $f(R)$ cosmologies
• Construct the emission line galaxy-host halo connection through auto and cross correlations
• Modelling galaxy clustering in redshift space with a Lagrangian bias formalism and $N$-body simulations
• Consistent and simultaneous modelling of galaxy clustering and galaxy-galaxy lensing with Subhalo Abundance Matching
• The VIMOS Public Extragalactic Redshift Survey (VIPERS). Measuring nonlinear galaxy bias at z~0.8
• [OII] emitters in MultiDark-Galaxies and DEEP2
• HOD-Dependent Systematics in Emission Line Galaxies for the DESI 2024 BAO analysis
• The assembly bias of emission line galaxies
• Galaxy and Mass Assembly (GAMA): Small-scale anisotropic galaxy clustering and the pairwise velocity dispersion of galaxies
• Constraints on a scale-dependent bias from galaxy clustering
• The Diversity of Growth Histories of Milky Way-mass Galaxies
• Angular clustering and host halo properties of [OII] emitters at $z>1$ in the Subaru HSC survey
• Building a digital twin of a luminous red galaxy spectroscopic survey: galaxy properties and clustering covariance
• The impact of systematic uncertainties in N-body simulations on the precision cosmology from galaxy clustering: a halo model approach
• Clustering of Extremely Red Objects in Elais-N1 from the UKIDSS DXS with optical photometry from Pan-STARRS1 and Subaru
• The sparkling Universe: Clustering of voids and void clumps
• Compact groups from semi-analytical models of galaxy formation -- I: a comparative study of frequency and nature
• Probing Gravitational Lensing of the CMB with SDSS-IV Quasars
• SHAMe-SF: Predicting the clustering of star-forming galaxies with an enhanced abundance matching model
• Halo Occupation Distribution of Emission Line Galaxies: fitting method with Gaussian Processes
• Voids and Superstructures: correlations and induced large-scale velocity flows
• Compact groups from semi-analytical models of galaxy formation -- II: Different assembly channels
• Linking galaxies to dark matter haloes at $z\sim 1$ : dependence of galaxy clustering on stellar mass and specific star formation rate
• A semi-analytical perspective on massive galaxies at $z\sim 0.55$
• Investigating the galaxy-halo connection of DESI Emission-Line Galaxies with SHAMe-SF
• Validating the clustering predictions of empirical models with the FLAMINGO simulations
• Clustering of emission line galaxies with IllustrisTNG I.: fundamental properties and halo occupation distribution
• Exploring the physical origins of halo assembly bias from early times
• New insight into the variability of the Be star $\pi$ Aquarii: Determination of stellar and disk parameters
• CFHTLenS: Galaxy bias as function of scale, stellar mass, and colour. Conflicts with predictions by semi-analytic models
• Sensitivity analysis of a galaxy formation model
• The evolution of Balmer jump selected galaxies in the ALHAMBRA survey