On the Relationship Between Molecular Hydrogen and Carbon Monoxide Abundances in Molecular Clouds

Abstract

The most usual tracer of molecular gas is line emission from CO. However, the reliability of that tracer has long been questioned in environments different from the Milky Way. We study the relationship between H2 and CO abundances using a fully dynamical model of magnetized turbulence coupled to a chemical network simplified to follow only the dominant pathways for H2 and CO formation and destruction, and including photodissociation using a six-ray approximation. We find that the abundance of H2 is primarily determined by the amount of time available for its formation, which is proportional to the product of the density and the metallicity, but insensitive to photodissociation. Photodissociation only becomes important at extinctions under a few tenths of a visual magnitude, in agreement with both observational and prior theoretical work. On the other hand, CO forms quickly, within a dynamical time, but its abundance depends primarily on photodissociation, with only a weak secondary dependence on H2 abundance. As a result, there is a sharp cutoff in CO abundance at mean visual extinctions A_V < 3. At lower values of A_V we find that the ratio of H2 column density to CO emissivity X_CO is proportional to A_V^(-3.5). This explains the discrepancy observed in low metallicity systems between cloud masses derived from CO observations and other techniques such as infrared emission. Our work predicts that CO-bright clouds in low metallicity systems should be systematically larger or denser than Milky Way clouds, or both. Our results further explain the narrow range of observed molecular cloud column densities as a threshold effect, without requiring the assumption of virial equilibrium.

16 pages, 11 figures. Updated to match version accepted by MNRAS

References in corpus (16)

• Comparing the statistics of interstellar turbulence in simulations and observations: Solenoidal versus compressive turbulence forcing
• The Statistics of Supersonic Isothermal Turbulence
• The Resolved Properties of Extragalactic Giant Molecular Clouds
• Probing the evolution of molecular cloud structure: From quiescence to birth
• Simulating the formation of molecular clouds. I. Slow formation by gravitational collapse from static initial conditions
• CO Isotopologues in the Perseus Molecular Cloud Complex: the X-Factor and Regional Variations
• Simulating the formation of molecular clouds. II. Rapid formation from turbulent initial conditions
• Numerical simulations of compressively driven interstellar turbulence: I. Isothermal gas
• The Atomic to Molecular Transition in Galaxies. I: An Analytic Approximation for Photodissociation Fronts in Finite Clouds
• The Spitzer Survey of the Small Magellanic Cloud: FIR Emission and Cold Gas in the SMC
• The Atomic-to-Molecular Transition in Galaxies. III. A New Method for Determining the Molecular Content of Primordial and Dusty Clouds
• Models of turbulent dissipation regions in the diffuse interstellar medium
• Giant Molecular Clouds in M31: I - Molecular Cloud Properties
• The Structure of a Low-Metallicity Giant Molecular Cloud Complex
• Effects of turbulent diffusion on the chemistry of diffuse clouds
• Study of Photon Dominated Regions in Cepheus B

Cited by in corpus (199)

• The CO-to-H2 Conversion Factor
• Cool Gas in High Redshift Galaxies
• Calibration of X-ray absorption in our Galaxy
• Dusty Star-Forming Galaxies at High Redshift
• Fermi-LAT Observations of the Diffuse Gamma-Ray Emission: Implications for Cosmic Rays and the Interstellar Medium
• Molecular Gas and Star Formation in Nearby Disk Galaxies
• The CO-to-H2 Conversion Factor and Dust-to-Gas Ratio on Kiloparsec Scales in Nearby Galaxies
• The CO-to-H2 Conversion Factor From Infrared Dust Emission Across the Local Group
• A Molecular Star Formation Law in the Atomic Gas Dominated Regime in Nearby Galaxies
• Development of the Model of Galactic Interstellar Emission for Standard Point-Source Analysis of Fermi Large Area Telescope Data
• A General Model for the CO-H2 Conversion Factor in Galaxies with Applications to the Star Formation Law
• Regularity underlying complexity: a redshift-independent description of the continuous variation of galaxy-scale molecular gas properties in the mass-star formation rate plane
• The Big Problems in Star Formation: the Star Formation Rate, Stellar Clustering, and the Initial Mass Function
• The metallicity dependence of the CO {\rightarrow} H_2 conversion factor in z>1 star forming galaxies
• Validation of the equilibrium model for galaxy evolution to z~3 through molecular gas and dust observations of lensed star-forming galaxies
• Low CO Luminosities in Dwarf Galaxies
• The impact of interactions, bars, bulges, and AGN on star formation efficiency in local massive galaxies
• The PdBI Arcsecond Whirlpool Survey (PAWS). I. A Cloud-Scale/Multi-Wavelength View of the Interstellar Medium in a Grand-Design Spiral Galaxy
• The State of the Gas and the Relation Between Gas and Star Formation at Low Metallicity: the Small Magellanic Cloud
• CO-dark gas and molecular filaments in Milky Way type galaxies
• Feedback-regulated star formation in molecular clouds and galactic discs
• Evolution of the atomic and molecular gas content of galaxies
• ALMA observations of feeding and feedback in nearby Seyfert galaxies: an AGN-driven outflow in NGC 1433
• Tracing the total molecular gas in galaxies: [CII] and the CO-dark gas
• Photodissociation and X-Ray Dominated Regions
• Implementing Molecular Hydrogen in Hydrodynamic Simulations of Galaxy Formation
• The CO-H2 Conversion Factor in Disc Galaxies and Mergers
• Star formation and molecular hydrogen in dwarf galaxies: a non-equilibrium view
• Physical properties of interstellar filaments
• Modeling CO Emission: II. The Physical Characteristics that Determine the X factor in Galactic Molecular Clouds
• Dust temperature and CO-to-H2 conversion factor variations in the SFR-M* plane
• Dynamical Equilibrium in the Molecular ISM in 28 Nearby Star-Forming Galaxies
• The Evolution of the Baryons Associated with Galaxies Averaged over Cosmic Time and Space
• A Theory for the Excitation of CO in Star Forming Galaxies
• Revisiting the Integrated Star Formation Law. Paper I: Non-Starbursting Galaxies
• How long does it take to form a molecular cloud?
• Dust and Gas in the Magellanic Clouds from the HERITAGE Herschel Key Project. II. Gas-to-Dust Ratio Variations across ISM Phases
• Star formation in metal-poor gas clouds
• ALMA spectroscopic survey in the Hubble Ultra Deep Field: CO luminosity functions and the evolution of the cosmic density of molecular gas
• Is molecular gas necessary for star formation?
• Atomic and molecular gas in IllustrisTNG galaxies at low redshift
• The X-factor in Galaxies: I. Dependence on Environment and Scale
• Molecular Cloud Populations in the Context of Their Host Galaxy Environments: A Multiwavelength Perspective
• Low-J CO Line Ratios From Single Dish CO Mapping Surveys and PHANGS-ALMA
• Maximally Star-Forming Galactic Disks II. Vertically-Resolved Hydrodynamic Simulations of Starburst Regulation
• Planck's Dusty GEMS: Gravitationally lensed high-redshift galaxies discovered with the Planck survey
• Molecular depletion times and the CO-to-H2 conversion factor in metal-poor galaxies
• ALLSMOG: an APEX Low-redshift Legacy Survey for MOlecular Gas. I - molecular gas scaling relations, and the effect of the CO/H2 conversion factor
• Low velocity shocks: signatures of turbulent dissipation in diffuse irradiated gas
• Molecular Gas in the Halo Fuels the Growth of a Massive Cluster Galaxy at High Redshift
• Is atomic carbon a good tracer of molecular gas in metal-poor galaxies?
• CARMA Survey Toward Infrared-bright Nearby Galaxies (STING) II: Molecular Gas Star Formation Law and Depletion Time Across the Blue Sequence
• CO Abundance Variations in the Orion Molecular Cloud
• Turbulent Gas in Lensed Planck-selected Starbursts at redshifts 1-3.5
• Mapping the Milky Way bulge at high resolution: the 3D dust extinction, CO, and X factor maps
• Physical Properties of Molecular Clouds at 2 parsec Resolution in the Low-Metallicity Dwarf Galaxy NGC 6822 and the Milky Way
• The Herschel Virgo Cluster Survey: X.The relationship between cold dust and molecular gas content in Virgo spirals
• Molecular gas in low-metallicity starburst galaxies: Scaling relations and the CO-to-H${}_2$ conversion factor
• Distribution and mass of diffuse and dense CO gas in the Milky Way
• Approximations for modelling CO chemistry in GMCs: a comparison of approaches
• The environmental dependence of the X_CO conversion factor
• Evidence for a non-universal Kennicutt-Schmidt relationship using hierarchical Bayesian linear regression
• Dust-Gas Scaling Relations and OH Abundance in the Galactic ISM
• CO line emission from galaxies in the Epoch of Reionization
• SILCC-Zoom: H${}_2$ and CO-dark gas in molecular clouds -- The impact of feedback and magnetic fields
• Giant molecular clouds and massive star formation in the southern milky way
• CO(1-0) survey of high-z radio galaxies: alignment of molecular halo gas with distant radio sources
• The ${}^{12}$CO/${}^{13}$CO ratio in turbulent molecular clouds
• Radiation-Hydrodynamic Simulations of Protostellar Outflows: Synthetic Observations and Data Comparisons
• The Three-Dimensional Spatial Distribution of Interstellar Gas in the Milky Way: Implications for Cosmic Rays and High-Energy Gamma-Ray Emissions
• Cosmic rays, gas and dust in nearby anticentre clouds : I -- CO-to-H2 conversion factors and dust opacities
• The ISM scaling relations in DustPedia late-type galaxies: A benchmark study for the Local Universe
• The Relationship Between Molecular Gas, HI, and Star Formation in the Low-Mass, Low-Metallicity Magellanic Clouds
• The X_CO conversion factor from galactic multiphase ISM simulations
• The Variation in Molecular Gas Depletion Time among Nearby Galaxies: What are the Main Parameter Dependencies?
• Molecular gas as the driver of fundamental galactic relations
• How Universal is the SFR - H2 Relation?
• Galaxy metallicities depend primarily on stellar mass and molecular gas mass
• A physical model for the [CII]-FIR deficit in luminous galaxies
• Metallicity dependence of the H/H${}_2$ and C${}^{+}$/C/CO distributions in a resolved self-regulating interstellar medium
• Constraining the dense matter equation-of-state with radio pulsars
• The final data release of ALLSMOG: a survey of CO in typical local low-M* star-forming galaxies
• The Effect of Star Formation on the Redshift Evolution of Interstellar Metals, Atomic and Molecular Gas in Galaxies
• A three dimensional extinction map of the Galactic Anticentre from multi-band photometry
• The EDGE-CALIFA Survey: Using Optical Extinction to Probe the Spatially-Resolved Distribution of Gas in Nearby Galaxies
• The effects of metallicity, UV radiation and non-equilibrium chemistry in high-resolution simulations of galaxies
• The Turbulence Power Spectrum in Optically Thick Interstellar Clouds
• Modeling H2 formation in the turbulent ISM: Solenoidal versus compressive turbulent forcing
• The resolved star-formation relation in nearby active galactic nuclei
• Histogram of oriented gradients: a technique for the study of molecular cloud formation
• PHANGS-JWST First Results: Mid-infrared emission traces both gas column density and heating at 100 pc scales
• HI, CO, and Planck/IRAS dust properties in the high-latitude-cloud complex, MBM 53, 54, 55 and HLCG 92-35; Possible evidence for an optically thick HI envelope around the CO clouds
• The X-factor in Galaxies: II. The molecular hydrogen -- star formation relation
• Low Gas Fractions Connect Compact Star-Forming Galaxies to their z ~ 2 Quiescent Descendants
• CO(1-0) detection of molecular gas in the massive Spiderweb Galaxy (z=2)
• Carbon monoxide in an extremely metal-poor galaxy
• The CO-to-H2 Conversion Factor across the Perseus Molecular Cloud
• VLA Mapping of the CO(1-0) Line in SMM J14011+0252
• Photodissociation Region Diagnostics Across Galactic Environments
• Does the CO-to-H2 conversion factor depend on the star formation rate?
• First Results from the $Herschel$ and ALMA Spectroscopic Surveys of the SMC: The Relationship Between [CII]-bright Gas and CO-bright Gas at Low Metallicity
• Tracing Cold HI Gas in Nearby, Low-Mass Galaxies
• Scaling relations and baryonic cycling in local star-forming galaxies: II. Gas content and star-formation efficiency
• Neutral gas heating by X-rays in primitive galaxies: Infrared observations of IZw18 with Herschel
• Carbon in different phases ([CII], [CI], and CO) in infrared dark clouds: Cloud formation signatures and carbon gas fractions
• First Results from COPSS: The CO Power Spectrum Survey
• How well does CO emission measure the H${}_2$ mass of MCs?
• The simulation of molecular clouds formation in the Milky Way
• Dependence of $X_{\mathrm{CO}}$ on metallicity, intensity, and spatial scale in a self-regulated interstellar medium
• The Fueling Diagram: Linking Galaxy Molecular-to-Atomic Gas Ratios to Interactions and Accretion
• Interpreting the sub-linear Kennicutt-Schmidt relationship: The case for diffuse molecular gas
• Molecular CO(1-0) gas in the z~2 radio galaxy MRC 0152-209
• Synthetic observations of star formation and the interstellar medium
• Dust Abundance Variations in the Magellanic Clouds: Probing the Lifecycle of Metals with All-Sky Surveys
• Combining radiative transfer and diffuse interstellar medium physics to model star formation
• Dust-to-gas ratio, $X_{\mathrm{CO}}$ factor and CO-dark gas in the Galactic anticentre: an observational study
• The Weak Carbon Monoxide Emission In An Extremely Metal Poor Galaxy, Sextans A
• Modeling the Atomic-to-Molecular Transition and Chemical Distributions of Turbulent Star-Forming Clouds
• The Cosmic Evolution of the IMF Under the Jeans Conjecture with Implications for Bottom-Heavy Ellipticals
• The Quest for the Missing Dust: II -- Two Orders of Magnitude of Evolution in the Dust-to-Gas Ratio Resolved Within Local Group Galaxies
• The Origin of Interstellar Turbulence in M33
• The GeV-TeV Galactic gamma-ray diffuse emission I. Uncertainties in the predictions of the hadronic component
• Cold Molecular Gas Along the Merger Sequence in Local Luminous Infrared Galaxies
• Kiloparsec-Scale Simulations of Star Formation in Disk Galaxies. I. The unmagnetized and zero-feedback limit
• The turbulent fragmentation of the interstellar medium: The impact of metallicity on global star formation
• CO Emission, Molecular Gas, and Metallicity in Main-Sequence Star-Forming Galaxies at $z\sim 2.3$
• The Star Formation Rate Efficiency of Neutral Atomic-dominated Hydrogen Gas in the Outskirts of Star Forming Galaxies from z~1 to z~3
• Resolving the Dust-to-Metals Ratio and CO-to-H${}_2$ Conversion Factor in the Nearby Universe
• The Relationship between CO Emission and Visual Extinction Traced by Dust Emission in the Magellanic Clouds
• Populating H${}_2$ and CO in galaxy simulation with dust evolution
• Cosmic-rays, gas, and dust in nearby anticentre clouds : II -- Interstellar phase transitions and the Dark Neutral Medium
• Mid-J CO observations of Perseus B1-East 5: evidence for turbulent dissipation via low-velocity shocks
• The Supershell-Molecular Cloud Connection: Large-Scale Stellar Feedback and the Formation of the Molecular ISM
• Co-evolution of Dust and Chemistry in Galaxy Simulations with a Resolved Interstellar Medium
• Synthetic observations of molecular clouds in a galactic center environment: I. Studying maps of column density and integrated intensity
• An Unbiased CO Survey Toward the Northern Region of the Small Magellanic Cloud with the Atacama Compact Array. I. Overview: CO Cloud Distributions
• Why is the Milky Way X-factor Constant?
• Three regimes of CO emission in galaxy mergers
• Astrochemical Correlations in Molecular Clouds
• The Parsec-Scale Relationship Between I_CO and A_V in Local Molecular Clouds
• Reproducing the CO-to-H${}_2$ conversion factor in cosmological simulations of Milky Way-mass galaxies
• Chemical evolution of giant molecular clouds in simulations of galaxies
• The Carbon-to-H${}_2$, CO-to-H${}_2$ Conversion Factors and Carbon Abundance on Kiloparsec Scales in Nearby Galaxies
• New ALMA constraints on the star-forming ISM at low metallicity: A 50 pc view of the blue compact dwarf galaxy SBS0335-052
• Suppressed CO emission and high G/D ratios in z=2 galaxies with sub-solar gas-phase metallicity
• Tracing the cosmological evolution of stars and cold gas with CMB spectral surveys
• [C II] and [N II] from dense ionized regions in the Galaxy
• Centroid Velocity Statistics of Molecular Clouds
• The "Maggie" filament: Physical properties of a giant atomic cloud
• Wide-field CO isotopologue emission and the CO-to-H${}_2$ factor across the nearby spiral galaxy M101
• Mid-J CO Shock Tracing Observations of Infrared Dark Clouds III: SLED fitting
• Principal Component Analysis of Molecular Clouds: Can CO reveal the dynamics?
• PDRs4All. XII. FUV-driven formation of hydrocarbon radicals and their relation with PAHs
• Star-Formation in the Ultraluminous Infrared Galaxy F00183-7111
• Gas and Dust Properties in the Chamaeleon Molecular Cloud Complex based on the Optically Thick HI
• Spatially associated clump populations in Rosette from CO and dust maps
• Large Molecular Gas Reservoirs in Star Forming Cluster Galaxies
• The evolution of HCO${}^{+}$ in molecular clouds using a novel chemical post-processing algorithm
• Synthetic CO emission and the $X_{\mathrm{CO}}$ factor of young molecular clouds: a convergence study
• The filamentary structures in the CO emission toward the Milky Way disk
• Extremely weak CO emission in IZw 18
• Non-Equilibrium Abundances Treated Holistically (NEATH): the molecular composition of star-forming clouds
• Structure analysis of simulated molecular clouds with the Delta-variance
• Evidence for large-scale excesses associated with low HI column densities in the sky I. Dust excess
• Assessing the Impact of Astrochemistry on Molecular Cloud Turbulence Statistics
• GNOMES II: Analysis of the Galactic diffuse molecular ISM in all four ground state hydroxyl transitions using Amoeba
• Kpc-scale properties of dust temperature in terms of dust mass and star formation activity
• Molecular gas and nuclear activity in early-type galaxies: any link with radio-loudness?
• Molecular gas scaling relations for local star-forming galaxies in the low-$M_{\ast }$ regime
• Census of High- and Medium-mass Protostars V. CO Abundance and the Galactic $X_{\text{CO}}$ Factor
• Gas, dust, and the CO-to-molecular gas conversion factor in low-metallicity starbursts
• Sequential Star Formation in the Young SMC Region NGC 602: Insights from ALMA
• HYACINTH: HYdrogen And Carbon chemistry in the INTerstellar medium in Hydro simulations
• The Opacity of Spiral Galaxy Disks IX; Dust and Gas Surface Densities
• Weighing the Local Interstellar Medium using Gamma Rays and Dust
• The relation between mid-plane pressure and molecular hydrogen in galaxies: Environmental dependence
• CO and Fine-Structure Lines Reveal Low Metallicity in a Stellar-Mass-Rich Galaxy at z ~ 1?
• A Model for Protostellar Cluster Luminosities and the Impact on the CO-H${}_2$ Conversion Factor
• Effects of dust grain size distribution on the abundances of CO and H${}_2$ in galaxy evolution
• From Gas to Stars Over Cosmic Time
• Metallicity in the merger Seyfert galaxy NGC 6240
• Simultaneously modelling far-infrared dust emission and its relation to CO emission in star forming galaxies
• Herschel 158$\mu$m [CII] Observations of "CO-dark" Gas in the Perseus Giant Molecular Cloud
• A deep-learning approach to the 3D reconstruction of dust density and temperature in star-forming regions
• A Comprehensive All-Sky Catalog of 3345 Molecular Clouds from Three-dimensional Dust Extinction
• The unusual ISM in Blue and Dusty Gas Rich Galaxies (BADGRS)
• Effects of CO-dark Gas on Measurements of Molecular Cloud Stability and the Size-Linewidth Relationship
• Disentangling emission from star-forming regions in the Magellanic Clouds: Linking [OIII]88 micron and 24 micron
• Using CO to Measure Molecular Masses
• Cosmic rays, gas and dust in the Central Molecular Zone I -- $X_{CO}$ factors, cosmic-ray densities and dust opacities
• The molecular-gas properties in the gravitationally lensed merger HATLAS J142935.3-002836
• From Gas to Stars over Cosmic Time
• CO-to-H${}_2$ conversion factor and grain size distribution through the analysis of ${\alpha }_{\mathrm{CO}}$-$q_{\mathrm{PAH}}$ relation
• Direct detection of cool molecular gas in a star-forming galaxy at $z=7.31$
• The CHIMERA Survey: The first CO detection in Leo T, the lowest mass known galaxy still hosting cold molecular gas
• Anomaly distribution in quasar magnitudes: a test of lensing by an hypothetic Supergiant Molecular Cloud in the Galactic halo
• Systematic selection of surrogate models for nonequilibrium chemistry
• Stellar Feedback Effects on the Mass Distribution of Clouds and Cloud Complexes
• The Interstellar Medium and Star Formation in Dwarf Galaxies