A Minimum Column Density of 1 g cm^-2 for Massive Star Formation

Abstract

Massive stars are very rare, but their extreme luminosities make them both the only type of young star we can observe in distant galaxies and the dominant energy sources in the universe today. They form rarely because efficient radiative cooling keeps most star-forming gas clouds close to isothermal as they collapse, and this favors fragmentation into stars <~1 Msun. Heating of a cloud by accreting low-mass stars within it can prevent fragmentation and allow formation of massive stars, but what properties a cloud must have to form massive stars, and thus where massive stars form in a galaxy, has not yet been determined. Here we show that only clouds with column densities >~ 1 g cm^-2 can avoid fragmentation and form massive stars. This threshold, and the environmental variation of the stellar initial mass function (IMF) that it implies, naturally explain the characteristic column densities of massive star clusters and the difference between the radial profiles of Halpha and UV emission in galactic disks. The existence of a threshold also implies that there should be detectable variations in the IMF with environment within the Galaxy and in the characteristic column densities of massive star clusters between galaxies, and that star formation rates in some galactic environments may have been systematically underestimated.

Accepted for publication in Nature; Nature manuscript style; main text: 14 pages, 3 figures; supplementary text: 8 pages, 1 figure

References in corpus (29)

• Dust Grain Size Distributions and Extinction in the Milky Way, LMC, and SMC
• A General Theory of Turbulence-Regulated Star Formation, From Spirals to ULIRGs
• The Formation of Massive Stars from Turbulent Cores
• Slow Star Formation in Dense Gas: Evidence and Implications
• Star Formation Thresholds in Galactic Disks
• The Universality of Turbulence in Galactic Molecular Clouds
• Radiation-Hydrodynamic Simulations of Collapse and Fragmentation in Massive Protostellar Cores
• Massive star formation: Nurture, not nature
• Efficiencies of Low-Mass Star and Star Cluster Formation
• Massive star formation in 100,000 years from turbulent and pressurized molecular clouds
• Connecting Dense Gas Tracers of Star Formation in our Galaxy to High-z Star Formation
• The initial mass function : from Salpeter 1955 to 2005
• The Physical Conditions for Massive Star Formation: Dust Continuum Maps and Modeling
• The earliest phases of high-mass star formation: a 3 square degree millimeter continuum mapping of Cygnus X
• The stellar mass spectrum from non-isothermal gravoturbulent fragmentation
• Dense Gas and Star Formation: Characteristics of Cloud Cores Associated with Water Masers
• Equilibrium Star Cluster Formation
• A CS J=5-4 Mapping Survey Towards High-mass Star Forming Cores Associated with Water Masers
• Radial variation of attenuation and star formation in the largest late-type disks observed with GALEX
• Radiation Feedback and Fragmentation in Massive Protostellar Cores
• The Jeans mass and the origin of the knee in the IMF
• Time Dependence of the Ultraviolet Radiation Field in the Local Interstellar Medium
• Probing Pre-Protosellar Cores with Formaldehyde
• Star Formation in Space and Time: The Orion Nebula Cluster
• The Diverse Stellar Populations of the W3 Star Forming Complex
• Stellar Mass Spectra from Non-Isothermal Gravoturbulent Fragmentation
• Far-Infrared Spectral Energy Distributions of Embedded Protostars and Dusty Galaxies: I. Theory for Spherical Sources
• The Detection of Molecular Gas in the Outskirts of NGC 6946
• A Parameter Study of the Dust and Gas Temperature in a Field of Young Stars

Cited by in corpus (231)

• Star Formation in the Milky Way and Nearby Galaxies
• Clouds, filaments and protostars: the Herschel Hi-GAL Milky Way
• Outflow Feedback Regulated Massive Star Formation in Parsec-Scale Cluster Forming Clumps
• The Big Problems in Star Formation: the Star Formation Rate, Stellar Clustering, and the Initial Mass Function
• The Effects of Radiative Transfer on Low-Mass Star Formation
• Stellar Populations in the Central 0.5 pc of the Galaxy II: The Initial Mass Function
• The Dynamics of Radiation Pressure-Dominated HII Regions
• The stellar and sub-stellar IMF of simple and composite populations
• How Many Infrared Dark Clouds can form Massive Stars and Clusters?
• The Properties of Massive, Dense, Clumps: Mapping Surveys of HCN and CS
• Filaments and ridges in Vela C revealed by Herschel: from low-mass to high-mass star-forming sites
• Formation of Massive Molecular Cloud Cores by Cloud-cloud Collision
• Collapse of massive magnetized dense cores using radiation-magneto-hydrodynamics: early fragmentation inhibition
• Inverse dynamical population synthesis: Constraining the initial conditions of young stellar clusters by studying their binary populations
• The Interplay of Magnetic Fields, Fragmentation and Ionization Feedback in High-Mass Star Formation
• Stellar Feedback in Molecular Clouds and its Influence on the Mass Function of Young Star Clusters
• Magnetic Fields in High-Mass Infrared Dark Clouds
• The ALMA Survey of 70 $\mu$m dark High-mass clumps in Early Stages (ASHES). I. Pilot Survey: Clump Fragmentation
• The flat oxygen abundance gradient in the extended disk of M83
• Properties of Hi-GAL clumps in the inner Galaxy]{The Hi-GAL compact source catalogue. I. The physical properties of the clumps in the inner Galaxy ($-71.0^{\circ }<\ell <67.0^{\circ }$)
• Radiation-Hydrodynamic Simulations of the Formation of Orion-Like Star Clusters II. The Initial Mass Function from Winds, Turbulence, and Radiation
• Collapse, outflows and fragmentation of massive, turbulent and magnetized prestellar barotropic cores
• The Simultaneous Formation of Massive Stars and Stellar Clusters
• The Fragmentation of Magnetized, Massive Star-Forming Cores with Radiative Feedback
• Mid-Infrared Extinction Mapping of Infrared Dark Clouds II. The Structure of Massive Starless Cores and Clumps
• High mass star formation in normal late-type galaxies: observational constraints to the IMF
• The Dynamics of Massive Starless Cores with ALMA
• The Star Formation Law at Low Surface Density
• The dynamics and outcome of star formation with jets, radiation, winds, and supernovae in concert
• The identification of filaments on far infrared and submillimiter images. Morphology, physical conditions and relation with star formation of filamentary structure
• A Massive Prestellar Clump Hosting no High-Mass Cores
• The Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey. VII. Characterizing the Properties of Massive Star-Forming Regions
• Radiation-Hydrodynamic Simulations of Massive Star Formation with Protostellar Outflows
• Radiation-Hydrodynamic Simulations of the Formation of Orion-Like Star Clusters I. Implications for the Origin of the Initial Mass Function
• Caught in the Act: Strong, Active Ram Pressure Stripping in Virgo Cluster Spiral NGC 4330
• The early stages of star formation in Infrared Dark Clouds: characterizing the core dust properties
• The first Hi-GAL observations of the outer Galaxy: a look to star formation in the third Galactic quadrant in the longitude range 216.5 < l < 225.5
• Radiation Feedback, Fragmentation, and the Environmental Dependence of the Initial Mass Function
• ATOMS: ALMA Three-millimeter Observations of Massive Star-forming regions -- I. Survey description and a first look at G9.62+0.19
• The Hi-GAL compact source catalogue -- II. The 360° catalogue of clump physical properties
• Chemistry in Infrared Dark Clouds
• Distributed star formation throughout the Galactic Center cloud Sgr B2
• ATLASGAL - Kinematic distances and the dense gas mass distribution of the inner Galaxy
• The Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey. XIV. Physical Properties of Massive Starless and Star Forming Clumps
• A New Catalog of HII Regions in M31
• Proper motions of the Arches cluster with Keck-LGS Adaptive Optics: the first kinematic mass measurement of the Arches
• Galaxy-scale Star Formation on the Red Sequence: the Continued Growth of S0s and the Quiescence of Ellipticals
• Detection of two power-law tails in the probability distribution functions of massive GMCs
• ATLASGAL-selected massive clumps in the inner Galaxy, II: Characterisation of different evolutionary stages and their SiO emission
• The earliest phases of high-mass star formation, as seen in NGC 6334 by \emph{Herschel}
• A necklace of dense cores in the high-mass star forming region G35.20-0.74N: ALMA observations
• Field O stars: formed in situ or as runaways?
• Clustered star formation as a natural explanation of the Halpha cutoff in disc galaxies
• Search for starless clumps in the ATLASGAL survey
• On the Origin of Stellar Masses
• The Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey V: HCO+ and N2H+ Spectroscopy of 1.1 mm Dust Continuum Sources
• Radial distribution of stars, gas and dust in SINGS galaxies. III. Modeling the evolution of the stellar component in galaxy disks
• Star formation in extremely faint dwarf galaxies
• Is protostellar heating sufficient to halt fragmentation? A case study of the massive protocluster G8.68-0.37
• A Census of Large-Scale ($\ge$ 10 pc), Velocity-Coherent, Dense Filaments in the Northern Galactic Plane: Automated Identification Using Minimum Spanning Tree
• SMA observations of Infrared Dark Clouds: A tale of two cores
• The Effects of Magnetic Fields and Protostellar Feedback on Low-mass Cluster Formation
• Weak and Compact Radio Emission in Early High-Mass Star Forming Regions: I. VLA Observations
• Evidence of Star Formation in Local S0 Galaxies: Spitzer Observations of the SAURON Sample
• Physical properties of high-mass clumps in different stages of evolution
• A Herschel study of YSO evolutionary stages and formation timelines in two fields of the Hi-GAL survey
• The rate and latency of star formation in dense, massive clumps in the Milky Way
• The ALMA Survey of 70 $\mu$m Dark High-mass Clumps in Early Stages (ASHES). IX. Physical Properties and Spatial Distribution of Cores in IRDCs
• The SEDIGISM survey: Molecular clouds in the inner Galaxy
• High CO depletion in southern infrared-dark clouds
• The Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey -- III. Characterizing Physical Properties of Massive Star-Forming Regions in the Gemini OB1 Molecular Cloud
• Different Evolutionary Stages in the Massive Star Forming Region S255 Complex
• S-bearing molecules in Massive Dense Cores
• How to Reconcile the Observed Velocity Function of Galaxies with Theory
• The Necessity of Feedback Physics in Setting the Peak of the Initial Mass Function
• The Sparsest Clusters With O Stars
• Outflows, Accretion, and Clustered Protostellar Cores around a Forming O Star
• Physical properties of Southern infrared dark clouds
• A Water Maser and Ammonia Survey of GLIMPSE Extended Green Objects (EGOs)
• The Core Mass Function Across Galactic Environments. II. Infrared Dark Cloud Clumps
• ATOMS:ALMA Three-millimeter Observations of Massive Star-forming regions -- III :Catalogues of candidate hot molecular cores and Hyper/Ultra compact HII regions
• An Initial Mass Function for Individual Stars in Galactic Disks: I. Constraining the Shape of the IMF
• Submillimeter continuum observations of Sagittarius B2 at subarcsecond spatial resolution
• Cluster assembly and the origin of mass segregation in the STARFORGE simulations
• The Universal Initial Mass Function In The XUV Disk of M83
• Understanding star formation in molecular clouds IV. Column density PDFs from quiescent to massive molecular clouds
• The Onset of Massive Star Formation: The Evolution of Temperature and Density Structure in an Infrared Dark Cloud
• The ACS Nearby Galaxy Survey Treasury II. Young Stars and their Relation to Halpha and UV Emission Timescales in the M81 Outer Disk
• The ATLASGAL survey: The sample of young massive cluster progenitors
• A Census of Early Phase High-Mass Star Formation in the Central Molecular Zone
• Collisional debris as laboratories to study star formation
• Initial phases of massive star formation in high infrared extinction clouds. II. Infall and onset of star formation
• Herschel Observations of the W3 GMC: Clues to the Formation of Clusters of High-Mass Stars
• A Wide-field Near- and Mid-Infrared Census of Young Stars in NGC 6334
• The Protostellar Mass Function
• The dense gas mass fraction in the W51 cloud and its protoclusters
• On the Nature of Star Formation at Large Galactic Radii
• Millimeter interferometry of W3 IRS5: A Trapezium in the making
• Metallicity and the Universality of the IMF
• Resolving the Vela C ridge with P-ArTeMiS and Herschel
• A Method for Measuring Variations in the Stellar Initial Mass Function
• Fragmentation and dynamical collapse of the starless high-mass star-forming region IRDC18310-4
• The Darkest Shadows: Deep Mid-Infrared Extinction Mapping of a Massive Protocluster
• A Mid-Infrared Census of Star Formation Activity in Bolocam Galactic Plane Survey Sources
• Distributed Low-Mass Star Formation in the IRDC G34.43+00.24
• Surveys of Clumps, Cores, and Condensations in Cygnus X: I. a New Catalog of ~0.1 pc Massive Dense Cores
• The onset of high-mass star formation in the direct vicinity of the galactic mini-starburst W43
• Star Formation in Molecular Clouds
• High-mass star formation possibly triggered by cloud-cloud collision in the HII region RCW 34
• High-mass Starless Clumps in the inner Galactic Plane: the Sample and Dust Properties
• Young massive star cluster formation in the Galactic Centre is driven by global gravitational collapse of high-mass molecular clouds
• Multi-wavelength study of the star-formation in the S237 H II region
• Discovery of massive star formation quenching by nonthermal effects in the center of NGC 1097
• Are Infrared Dark Clouds Really Quiescent?
• Star formation in W3 - AFGL333: Young stellar content, properties and roles of external feedback
• ALMA-IRDC: Dense gas mass distribution from cloud to core scales
• The Formation of Very Massive Stars
• Distance biases in the estimation of the physical properties of Hi-GAL compact sources-I. Clump properties and the identification of high-mass star forming candidates
• The core population and kinematics of a massive clump at early stages: an ALMA view
• Bondi-Hoyle Accretion in an Isothermal Magnetized Plasma
• HII regions and high-mass starless clump candidates II. Fragmentation and induced star formation at ~0.025 pc scale: An ALMA continuum study
• KFPA Examinations of Young STellar Object Natal Environments (KEYSTONE): Hierarchical Ammonia Structures in Galactic Giant Molecular Clouds
• Initial phases of massive star formation in high infrared extinction clouds. I. Physical parameters
• Multi-scale dynamics in star-forming regions: the interplay between gravity and turbulence
• The Dynamical State of The Serpens South Filamentary Infrared Dark Cloud
• Nobeyama 45-m mapping observations toward nearby molecular clouds, Orion A, Aquila Rift, and M17: Project overview
• Variations in the Mass Functions of Clustered and Isolated Young Stellar Objects
• A Hi-GAL study of the high-mass star-forming region G29.96-0.02
• Linking pre- and proto-stellar objects in the intermediate-/high-mass star forming region IRAS 05345+3157
• Effects of the environment on the multiplicity properties of stars in the STARFORGE simulations
• The census of dense cores in the Serpens region from the Herschel Gould Belt Survey
• The Lifetimes of Phases in High-Mass Star-Forming Regions
• ATOMS: ALMA Three-millimeter Observations of Massive Star-forming regions -- XII: Fragmentation and multi-scale gas kinematics in protoclusters G12.42+0.50 and G19.88-0.53
• The Comparison of Physical Properties Derived from Gas and Dust in a Massive Star-Forming Region
• Star Formation Activity in the molecular cloud G35.20$-$0.74: onset of cloud-cloud collision
• The Physical Properties of High-Mass Star-Forming Clumps: A Systematic Comparison of Molecular Tracers
• Thermal balance and comparison of gas and dust properties of dense clumps in the Hi-GAL survey
• The Balloon-Borne Large Aperture Submillimeter Telescope (BLAST) 2005: A 10 deg^2 Survey of Star Formation in Cygnus X
• Herschel observations of the Galactic HII region RCW 79
• Triggered/sequential star formation? A multi-phase ISM study around the prominent IRDC G18.93-0.03
• Molecular clouds and star formation toward the Galactic plane within 216.25${}^{\mathrm{o}}\le$ l $\le$218.75${}^{\mathrm{o}}$ and $-$0.75${}^{\mathrm{o}}\le$ b $\le$1.25${}^{\mathrm{o}}$
• Lack of high-mass prestellar cores in the starless MDCs of NGC6334
• Dense gas in IRAS 20343+4129: an ultracompact HII region caught in the act of creating a cavity
• The G305 star-forming complex: radio continuum and molecular line observations
• Characterizing the line emission from molecular clouds. II. A comparative study of California, Perseus, and Orion A
• LABOCA mapping of the infrared dark cloud MSXDC G304.74+01.32
• A detailed study of the accretion disk surrounding the high-mass protostar NGC 7538S
• Star formation towards the southern Cometary HII region IRAS 17256-3631
• LABOCA 870 micron dust continuum mapping of selected infrared-dark cloud regions in the Galactic plane
• Earliest Stages of Protocluster Formation: Substructure and Kinematics of Starless Cores in Orion
• An analysis of star formation with Herschel in the Hi-GAL Survey. II. The tips of the Galactic bar
• Very Massive Stars (VMS) in the Local Universe
• Star-forming cores embedded in a massive cold clump: Fragmentation, collapse and energetic outflows
• An All-Sky Sample of Intermediate-Mass Star-Forming Regions
• The Interstellar Bubbles of G38.9-0.4 and the Impact of Stellar Feedback on Star Formation
• Formation of Very Young Massive Clusters and implications for globular clusters
• The role of SiO as a tracer of past star-formation events: The case of the high-mass protocluster NGC 2264-C
• The SOFIA Massive (SOMA) Star Formation Survey. IV. Isolated Protostars
• On the emergent System Mass Function: the contest between accretion and fragmentation
• Different Evolutionary Stages in the Massive Star Forming Region W3 Main Complex
• Comparing the Inner and Outer Star Forming Complexes in the Nearby Spiral Galaxies NGC 628, NGC 5457 and NGC 6946 using UVIT Observations
• The SOFIA Massive (SOMA) Star Formation Survey. III. From Intermediate- to High-Mass Protostars
• Herschel Observations of the W3 GMC (II): Clues to the Formation of Clusters of High-Mass Stars
• Physical effects on compact high-velocity clouds in the circumgalactic medium
• A global view on star formation: The GLOSTAR Galactic plane survey IV. Radio continuum detections of young stellar objects in the Galactic Centre region
• Wide-Field ${}^{12}$CO ($J=2-1$) and ${}^{13}$CO ($J=2-1$) Observations toward the Aquila Rift and Serpens Molecular Cloud Complexes. I. Molecular Clouds and Their Physical Properties
• Fragmentation in the massive G31.41+0.31 protocluster
• The effects of ionization feedback on star formation: A case study of the M16 H II region
• High-angular resolution observations of methanol in the infrared dark cloud core G11.11-0.12P1
• A Sample of Intermediate-Mass Star-Forming Regions: Making Stars at Mass Column Densities <1 g/cm^2
• A network of filaments detected by Herschel in the Serpens Core: A laboratory to test simulations of low-mass star formation
• Large-scale molecular gas distribution in the M17 cloud complex: dense gas conditions of massive star formation?
• High-mass star formation at high luminosities: W31 at >10^6 L_sun
• X-ray source population study of the starburst galaxy M83 with XMM-Newton
• CARMA-NRO Orion Survey: unbiased survey of dense cores and core mass functions in Orion A
• The Evolutionary Status of Protostellar Clumps Hosting Class II Methanol Masers
• Probing the massive star forming environment - a multiwavelength investigation of the filamentary IRDC G333.73+0.37
• The TOP-SCOPE survey of PGCCs: PMO and SCUBA-2 observations of 64 PGCCs in the 2nd Galactic Quadrant
• The Role of Column Density in the Formation of Stars and Black Holes
• Physical characteristics of G331.5-0.1: The luminous central region of a Giant Molecular Cloud
• The star formation law in Galactic high-mass star-forming molecular clouds
• Environmental variation of the low-mass IMF
• Star forming activity in the H II regions associated with IRAS 17160-3707 complex
• A Search for In-Situ Field OB Star Formation in the Small Magellanic Cloud
• Emergence of high-mass stars in complex fiber networks (EMERGE). I. Early ALMA Survey: observations and massive data reduction
• HII regions and high-mass starless clump candidates I: Catalogs and properties
• Three isotopologues CO survey of Molecular Clouds in the CMa OB1 complex
• A multi-wavelength study of a double intermediate-mass protostar - from large-scale structure to collimated jets
• The Effect of Shock Wave Duration on Star Formation and the Initial Condition of Massive Cluster Formation
• The Initial Mass Function in the Extended Ultraviolet Disk of M83
• Near-infrared and Millimeter-wavelength Observations of Mol 160: A Massive Young Protostellar Core
• The mass distribution of clumps within infrared dark clouds. A Large APEX Bolometer Camera study
• G133.50+9.01: A likely cloud-cloud collision complex triggering the formation of filaments, cores and a stellar cluster
• Infrared Dark Clouds and high-mass star formation activity in Galactic Molecular Clouds
• On the origin of very massive stars around NGC 3603
• Star formation conditions in a Planck Galactic Cold Clump, G108.84-00.81
• Cluster-forming site AFGL 5157: colliding filamentary clouds and star formation
• Sagittarius B2 Main: A Cluster of Ultra-Compact HII Regions and Massive Protostellar Cores
• A Multi-wavelength Study on the Formation of AFGL 333-Ridge
• A Comparison of the UV and HI Properties of the Extended UV (XUV) Disk Galaxies NGC 2541, NGC 5832 and ESO406-042
• 870 micron continuum observations of the bubble-shaped nebula Gum 31
• Star Formation in Extreme Environments: A 200 pc High Velocity Gas Stream in the Galactic Centre
• Cloud structures in M17 SWex : Possible cloud-cloud collision
• A clustered origin for isolated massive stars
• Early Science with the Large Millimetre Telescope: Fragmentation of molecular clumps in the Galaxy
• Galatic HII region IRAS 17149$-$3916 -- A multiwavelength study
• Constraining the top-light initial mass function in the extended ultraviolet disk of M83
• Star formation in IRDC G31.97+0.07
• ALMAGAL VI. The spatial distribution of dense cores during the evolution of cluster-forming massive clump
• Not a galaxy: IRAS 04186+5143, a new young stellar cluster in the outer Galaxy
• WISE Green Objects (WGOs): the massive star candidates in the whole Galactic Plane ($\mid b\mid <2^{\circ }$)
• A multi-transition molecular line study of infrared dark cloud G331.71+00.59
• Massive Star Formation, Outflows, and Anomalous H2 Emission in Mol 121 (IRAS 20188+3928)
• ALMAGAL V. Relations between the core populations and the parent clump physical properties
• In search for infalling clumps in molecular clouds -- A catalogue of CO blue-profiles
• Interaction between the Supernova Remnant W44 and the Infrared Dark Cloud G034.77-00.55: shock induced star formation?
• Emergence of high-mass stars in complex fiber networks (EMERGE) III. Fiber networks in Orion
• The Milky Way Project: Probing Star Formation with First Results on Yellowballs from DR2
• Can molecular clouds live long?
• On the evolution of irradiated turbulent clouds: A comparative study between modes of triggered star-formation
• Comparison of Low-Mass and High-Mass Star Formation
• G305.136+0.068: A massive and dense cold core in an early stage of evolution
• Rescuing the Initial Mass Function for Arp 78
• Do Red Galaxies Form More Stars Than Blue Galaxies?
• Which Molecular Cloud Structures Are Bound?
• Identification of Anomalous E+A Galaxies in GAMA Using an Isolation Forest
• Gauging the Impact of Cosmic Ray Feedback on the Stellar Initial Mass Function
• Star Formation with Adaptive Mesh Refinement Radiation Hydrodynamics
• Investigating the physical properties and fragmentation of the AFGL 333-Ridge
• ATOMS: ALMA Three-millimeter Observations of Massive Star-forming regions -- V. Hierarchical fragmentation and gas dynamics in IRDC G034.43+00.24
• The first Galaxy scale hunt for the youngest high-mass protostars