Semianalytical Accretion-Tracer Emission: Forming Planets Are Intrinsically Faint

Abstract

Direct-imaging surveys have looked for accreting planets through their accretion tracers such as H alpha but have been less fruitful than expected. However, up to now, hydrogen-line emission at accreting planets has been estimated primarily with extrapolations of stellar-scaling relationships or with theoretical spherically-symmetric computations. To predict the line emission intensity during the formation phase, we follow the consequences of angular momentum conservation of the material accreting onto a gas giant in a protoplanetary disc. We focus on the limiting case that magnetospheric accretion does not occur, which yields a conservative estimate of the line emission and should correspond to certain epochs during formation. We extend but simplify an existing analytical description of the multidimensional gas flow onto an accreting gas giant, the ballistic infall model, and combine this with detailed shock emission models. Applying this to data from a global planet formation model, we confirm that the line-emitting accretion rate is a minuscule fraction of the gas inflow into the Hill sphere. Also, forming planets are mostly fainter than PDS 70 b and c or WISPIT 2 b, with a maximum H alpha line luminosity Lline near 1e-7 Lsol, roughly independent of planet mass. Most surveys have not been sensitive to such faint planets. Other hydrogen lines in the near-IR are fainter by 1--2 dex. This implies that accreting planets are fainter than from past estimates, such that the non-detections are not as constraining as thought. A deeper look closer in to the host stars could well reveal many forming super-Jupiters.

ApJ printed (Volume 1000, Issue 1), now linked on NASA ADS. 17 pages and 10 figures, appendices in addition. This version matches the printed, open-access version in terms of content (excluding e.g. some typographical details). The delay between submission and revision was entirely due to me. V.4: Fixes a typo in this comment line and hopefully does not introduce a new one

References in corpus (69)

• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA)
• New evolutionary models for pre-main sequence and main sequence low-mass stars down to the hydrogen-burning limit
• On the Luminosity of Young Jupiters
• The Gemini Planet Imager Exoplanet Survey: Giant Planet and Brown Dwarf Demographics From 10-100 AU
• Two accreting protoplanets around the young star PDS 70
• X-Shooter spectroscopy of young stellar objects in Lupus: Accretion properties of class II and transitional objects
• Models of the in situ formation of detected extrasolar giant planets
• Hints for a Turnover at the Snow Line in the Giant Planet Occurrence Rate
• A Circumplanetary Disk Around PDS70c
• The New Generation Planetary Population Synthesis (NGPPS). I. Bern global model of planet formation and evolution, model tests, and emerging planetary systems
• PARSEC V2.0: Stellar tracks and isochrones of low and intermediate mass stars with rotation
• One Relation for All Wavelengths: The Far-Ultraviolet to Mid-Infrared Milky Way Spectroscopic R(V) Dependent Dust Extinction Relationship
• Images of Embedded Jovian Planet Formation At A Wide Separation Around AB Aurigae
• Cool Jupiters greatly outnumber their toasty siblings: Occurrence rates from the Anglo-Australian Planet Search
• The New Generation Planetary Population Synthesis (NGPPS). II. Planetary population of solar-like stars and overview of statistical results
• Constraining the Nature of the PDS 70 Protoplanets with VLTI/GRAVITY
• Characterization of exoplanets from their formation III: The statistics of planetary luminosities
• Angular Momentum Accretion onto a Gas Giant Planet
• Hubble Space Telescope UV and H$\alpha$ Measurements of the Accretion Excess Emission from the Young Giant Planet PDS 70 b
• The widest H$\alpha$ survey of accreting protoplanets around nearby transition disks
• Revisiting the pre-main-sequence evolution of stars I. Importance of accretion efficiency and deuterium abundance
• GIARPS High-resolution Observations of T Tauri stars (GHOsT). IV. Accretion properties of the Taurus-Auriga young association
• Comparison of planetary Hα-emission models: A new correlation with accretion luminosity
• Meridional Circulation of Dust and Gas in the Circumstellar Disk: Delivery of Solids onto the Circumplanetary Region
• Strong H$\alpha$ emission and signs of accretion in a circumbinary planetary mass companion from MUSE
• HST/WFC3 H$\alpha$ Direct-Imaging Detection of a Point-like Source in the Disk Cavity of AB Aur
• Accreting protoplanets: Spectral signatures and magnitude of gas and dust extinction at H alpha
• JWST/NIRSpec Observations of the Planetary Mass Companion TWA 27B
• Near-infrared Accretion Signatures from the Circumbinary Planetary Mass Companion Delorme 1 (AB)b
• Molecular mapping of the PDS70 system: No molecular absorption signatures from the forming planet PDS70 b
• On the structure and mass delivery towards circumplanetary discs
• Emission line variability of young 10-30 Mjup companions : I. The case of GQ Lup b and GSC 06214-00210 b
• The Planetary Luminosity Problem: "Missing Planets" and the Observational Consequences of Episodic Accretion
• The Giant Accreting Protoplanet Survey (GAPlanetS) -- Results from a Six Year Campaign to Image Accreting Protoplanets
• Searching for proto-planets with MUSE
• WIde Separation Planets In Time (WISPIT): A Gap-clearing Planet in a Multi-ringed Disk around the Young Solar-type Star WISPIT 2
• The maximum accretion rate of a protoplanet: how fast can runaway be?
• ALMA Observations of the Young Substellar Binary System 2M1207
• Searching for H${}_{\alpha }$-emitting sources in the gaps of five transitional disks. SPHERE/ZIMPOL high-contrast imaging
• On the radial distribution of giant exoplanets at Solar System scales
• Resolved near-UV hydrogen emission lines at 40-Myr super-Jovian protoplanet Delorme 1 (AB)b: Indications of magnetospheric accretion
• Three Years of High-Contrast Imaging of the PDS 70 b and c Exoplanets at Hα with MagAO-X: Evidence of Strong Protoplanet Hα Variability and Circumplanetary Dust
• The Planetary Accretion Shock. III. Smoothing-free 2.5D simulations and calculation of H alpha emission
• The Separation and H-alpha Contrasts of Massive Accreting Planets in the Gaps of Transitional Disks: Predicted H-alpha Protoplanet Yields for Adaptive Optics Surveys
• Hydrodynamic Model of H$\alpha$ Emission from Accretion Shocks of Proto-Giant Planet and Circumplanetary Disk
• Constraining the gas distribution in the PDS 70 disk as a method to assess the effect of planet-disk interactions
• Boundary Layer Circumplanetary Accretion: How Fast Could an Unmagnetized Planet Spin Up Through Its Disk?
• A Theoretical Framework for the Mass Distribution of Gas Giant Planets forming through the Core Accretion Paradigm
• Evidence for Variable Accretion onto PDS 70 c and Implications for Protoplanet Detections
• Constraints on PDS 70 b and c from the dust continuum emission of the circumplanetary discs considering in situ dust evolution
• Determining stellar accretion rates from $P{a}_{\alpha }$ and $B{r}_{\beta }$ emission lines with JWST NIRSpec
• The vertical structure of the boundary layer around compact objects
• Revisiting the Helium and Hydrogen Accretion Indicators at TWA 27B: Weak Mass Flow at Near-Freefall Velocity
• Search for exoplanets and brown dwarfs with VLBI
• Magnetic Fields and Accreting Giant Planets around PDS 70
• Exoplanet accretion monitoring spectroscopic survey (ENTROPY) I. Evidence for magnetospheric accretion in the young isolated planetary-mass object 2MASS J11151597+1937266
• Protostellar disks subject to infall: a one-dimensional inviscid model and comparison with ALMA observations
• Differentiating Formation Models with New Dynamical Masses for the PDS 70 Protoplanets
• Tidal truncation of circumplanetary disks fails above a critical disk aspect ratio
• Direct Measurement of Extinction in a Planet-Hosting Gap
• PENELLOPE VII: Revisiting empirical relations to measure accretion luminosity
• Keplerian motion of a compact source orbiting the inner disc of PDS 70: a third protoplanet in resonance with b and c?
• Analyzing JWST/NIRSpec Hydrogen Line Detections at TWA 27B: Constraining Accretion Properties and Geometry
• Meridional Circulation driven by Planetary Spiral Wakes in Radiative and Magnetized Protoplanetary Discs
• High strehl and high contrast for the ELT instrument METIS -- Final design, implementation, and predicted performance of the single-conjugate adaptive optics system
• Formation and Structure of Circumplanetary Disks and Envelopes during the Late Stages of Giant Planet Formation
• Planetary line-to-accretion luminosity scaling relations: Extrapolating to higher-order hydrogen lines
• ExoplaNeT accRetion mOnitoring sPectroscopic surveY (ENTROPY) - II. Time series of Balmer line profiles of Delorme 1(AB)b
• Occurrence rates of accreting companions from a new method for computing emission-line survey sensitivity: application to the H-alpha Giant Accreting Protoplanet Survey