Impact of stellar population synthesis choices on forward modelling-based redshift distribution estimates

Abstract

The forward modelling of galaxy surveys has recently gathered interest as one of the primary methods to achieve the required precision on the estimate of the redshift distributions for stage IV surveys. One of the key aspects of forward modelling a galaxy survey is the connection between the physical properties drawn from a galaxy population model and the intrinsic SEDs, achieved through SPS codes (e.g. FSPS). However, SPS requires a large number of detailed assumptions on the constituents of galaxies, for which the model choice or parameter values are currently uncertain. In this work, we perform a sensitivity study of the impact that the variations of the SED modelling choices have on the mean and scatter of the tomographic galaxy redshift distributions. We assumed the Prospector beta model as the fiducial input galaxy population model and used its SPS parameters to build 9 bands magnitudes of a fiducial sample of galaxies. We then built samples of galaxy magnitudes by varying one SED modelling choice at a time. We modelled the colour redshift relation of these galaxy samples using the SOM approach. We placed galaxies in the SOM cells according to their observed frame colours and used their cell assignment to build colour selected tomographic bins. Finally, we compared each variant's binned redshift distributions against the estimates obtained for the fiducial model. We find that the SED components related to the IMF, AGNs, gas physics, and the attenuation law substantially bias the mean and the scatter of the tomographic redshift distributions with respect to those estimated with the fiducial model. Regardless of the applied stellar mass function based re-weighting strategy, the bias in the mean and the scatter of the tomographic redshift distributions are greater than the precision requirements set by next-generation Stage IV galaxy surveys, such as LSST and Euclid.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in A&A. 29 pages, 12 figures

References in corpus (157)

• Galactic Stellar and Substellar Initial Mass Function
• On the variation of the Initial Mass Function
• The Dust Content and Opacity of Actively Star-Forming Galaxies
• Unified Schemes for Radio-Loud Active Galactic Nuclei
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA)
• Cosmic Star Formation History
• The Origin of the Mass--Metallicity Relation: Insights from 53,000 Star-Forming Galaxies in the SDSS
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Giant Planets, Oscillations, Rotation, and Massive Stars
• LSST: from Science Drivers to Reference Design and Anticipated Data Products
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Binaries, Pulsations, and Explosions
• MESA Isochrones and Stellar Tracks (MIST). I: Solar-Scaled Models
• Evolutionary tracks and isochrones for low- and intermediate-mass stars: from 0.15 to 7 M_sun, and from Z=0.0004 to 0.03
• Interstellar Dust Grains
• Infrared Emission from Interstellar Dust. IV. The Silicate-Graphite-PAH Model in the Post-Spitzer Era
• MESA Isochrones and Stellar Tracks (MIST) 0: Methods for the construction of stellar isochrones
• The propagation of uncertainties in stellar population synthesis modeling I: The relevance of uncertain aspects of stellar evolution and the IMF to the derived physical properties of galaxies
• A Simple Model for the Absorption of Starlight by Dust in Galaxies
• K-corrections and filter transformations in the ultraviolet, optical, and near infrared
• Evolution of asymptotic giant branch stars II. Optical to far-infrared isochrones with improved TP-AGB models
• UniverseMachine: The Correlation between Galaxy Growth and Dark Matter Halo Assembly from z=0-10
• Spectral Energy Distributions and Multiwavelength Selection of Type 1 Quasars
• The ages and metallicities of galaxies in the local universe
• Dark Energy Survey Year 3 Results: Cosmological Constraints from Galaxy Clustering and Weak Lensing
• The propagation of uncertainties in stellar population synthesis modeling III: model calibration, comparison, and evaluation
• The COSMOS2015 Catalog: Exploring the 1<z<6 Universe with half a million galaxies
• 3D-HST WFC3-selected Photometric Catalogs in the Five CANDELS/3D-HST Fields: Photometry, Photometric Redshifts and Stellar Masses
• Physical Properties of Wolf-Rayet Stars
• The Evolution of the Stellar Mass Functions of Star-Forming and Quiescent Galaxies to z = 4 from the COSMOS/UltraVISTA Survey
• Analysis of galaxy SEDs from far-UV to far-IR with CIGALE: Studying a SINGS test sample
• Modeling the Panchromatic Spectral Energy Distributions of Galaxies
• Constraining Warm Dark Matter candidates including sterile neutrinos and light gravitinos with WMAP and the Lyman-alpha forest
• UltraVISTA: a new ultra-deep near-infrared survey in COSMOS
• AGN Dusty Tori: II. Observational Implications of Clumpiness
• Large-Scale Galaxy Bias
• KiDS-1000 Cosmology: Multi-probe weak gravitational lensing and spectroscopic galaxy clustering constraints
• The Milky Way's Circular Velocity Curve to 60 kpc and an Estimate of the Dark Matter Halo Mass from Kinematics of ~2400 SDSS Blue Horizontal Branch Stars
• Active Galactic Nuclei: what's in a name?
• AGN Dusty Tori: I. Handling of Clumpy Media
• Dust Attenuation Curves in the Local Universe: Demographics and New Laws for Star-forming Galaxies and High-redshift Analogs
• PRIMUS: Constraints on Star Formation Quenching and Galaxy Merging, and the Evolution of the Stellar Mass Function From z=0-1
• How to Measure Galaxy Star Formation Histories II: Nonparametric Models
• The Evolution of the Stellar Mass Function of Galaxies from z=4.0 and the First Comprehensive Analysis of its Uncertainties: Evidence for Mass-dependent Evolution
• The Sloan Digital Sky Survey Quasar Catalog: Sixteenth Data Release
• Deriving Physical Properties from Broadband Photometry with Prospector: Description of the Model and a Demonstration of its Accuracy Using 129 Galaxies in the Local Universe
• COSMOS2020: A panchromatic view of the Universe to $z\sim 10$ from two complementary catalogs
• An updated analytic model for the attenuation by the intergalactic medium
• Galaxy Stellar Mass Functions from ZFOURGE/CANDELS: An Excess of Low-Mass Galaxies Since z=2 and the Rapid Buildup of Quiescent Galaxies
• Dark Energy Survey Year 3 Results: Cosmology from Cosmic Shear and Robustness to Data Calibration
• GALEX-SDSS-WISE Legacy Catalog (GSWLC): Star Formation Rates, Stellar Masses and Dust Attenuations of 700,000 Low-redshift Galaxies
• Nebular Continuum and Line Emission in Stellar Population Synthesis Models
• Reconciling the Stellar and Nebular Spectra of High Redshift Galaxies
• Evolution of asymptotic giant branch stars I. Updated synthetic TP-AGB models and their basic calibration
• JADES NIRSpec Spectroscopy of GN-z11: Lyman-$\alpha$ emission and possible enhanced nitrogen abundance in a $z=10.60$ luminous galaxy
• Weak lensing for precision cosmology
• The Mass-Metallicity and the Fundamental Metallicity Relation revisited on a fully Te-based abundance scale for galaxies
• Evidence for TP-AGB stars in high redshift galaxies, and their effect on deriving stellar population parameters
• The Dust Attenuation Law in Distant Galaxies: Evidence for Variation with Spectral Type
• SDSS IV MaNGA - Spatially resolved diagnostic diagrams: A proof that many galaxies are LIERs
• Spectral and Photometric Evolution of Young Stellar Populations: the Impact of Gaseous Emission at Various Metallicities
• KiDS+VIKING-450: Cosmic shear tomography with optical+infrared data
• The Evolution of the Galaxy Stellar Mass Function at z= 4-8: A Steepening Low-mass-end Slope with Increasing Redshift
• The galaxy stellar mass function at 3.5<z<7.5 in the CANDELS/UDS, GOODS-South, and HUDF fields
• DESI Bright Galaxy Survey: Final Target Selection, Design, and Validation
• The Dust Attenuation Law in Galaxies
• A redshift-independent efficiency model: star formation and stellar masses in dark matter halos at z>4
• An Older, More Quiescent Universe from Panchromatic SED Fitting of the 3D-HST Survey
• An Atlas of Galaxy Spectral Energy Distributions from the Ultraviolet to the Mid-Infrared
• Evolution of the AGN UV luminosity function from redshift 7.5
• The MOSDEF Survey: Excitation Properties of $z\sim 2.3$ Star-forming Galaxies
• Dusty Structure Around Type-I Active Galactic Nuclei: Clumpy Torus Narrow Line Region and Near-Nucleus Hot Dust
• Hyper Suprime-Cam Year 3 Results: Cosmology from Cosmic Shear Power Spectra
• Mapping the Galaxy Color-Redshift Relation: Optimal Photometric Redshift Calibration Strategies for Cosmology Surveys
• Target Selection and Validation of DESI Quasars
• Origins of weak lensing systematics, and requirements on future instrumentation (or knowledge of instrumentation)
• COSMOS2020: The Galaxy Stellar Mass Function: the assembly and star formation cessation of galaxies at $0.2<z\le 7.5$
• Relative Frequencies of Blue Stragglers in Galactic Globular Clusters: Constraints for the Formation Mechanisms
• Dark Energy Survey Year 3 Results: Redshift Calibration of the Weak Lensing Source Galaxies
• A New Census of the 0.2< z <3.0 Universe, Part II: The Star-Forming Sequence
• Colour corrections for high redshift objects due to intergalactic attenuation
• A New Census of the 0.2 < z < 3.0 Universe, Part I: The Stellar Mass Function
• The Complete Calibration of the Color-Redshift Relation (C3R2) Survey: Survey Overview and Data Release 1
• The Complete Calibration of the Color-Redshift Relation (C3R2) Survey: Analysis and Data Release 2
• CosmoDC2: A Synthetic Sky Catalog for Dark Energy Science with LSST
• Photometric Redshift Calibration with Self Organising Maps
• KiDS+VIKING-450: A new combined optical & near-IR dataset for cosmology and astrophysics
• Observational Constraints on the Physical Properties of Interstellar Dust in the Post-Planck Era
• Stellar mass functions: methods, systematics and results for the local Universe
• Deep Extragalactic VIsible Legacy Survey (DEVILS): Motivation, Design and Target Catalogue
• Photometric Redshifts for Next-Generation Surveys
• Phenotypic redshifts with self-organizing maps: A novel method to characterize redshift distributions of source galaxies for weak lensing
• Galaxy And Mass Assembly (GAMA): A forensic SED reconstruction of the cosmic star formation history and metallicity evolution by galaxy type
• Hot dust in Panchromatic SED Fitting: Identification of AGN and improved galaxy properties
• Measurement and Calibration of Noise Bias in Weak Lensing Galaxy Shape Estimation
• Missing Massive Stars in Starbursts: Stellar Temperature Diagnostics and the IMF
• Galaxy clustering, photometric redshifts and diagnosis of systematics in the DES Science Verification data
• The Scaling of Stellar Mass and Central Stellar Velocity Dispersion for Quiescent galaxies at z < 0.7
• Observational constraints on the specific accretion-rate distribution of X-ray selected AGN
• The Importance of Nebular Continuum and Line Emission in Observations of Young Massive Star Clusters
• The Contribution of TP-AGB and RHeB Stars to the Near-IR Luminosity of Local Galaxies: Implications for Stellar Mass Measurements of High Redshift Galaxies
• A new, Gaia based, catalogue of blue straggler stars in open clusters
• SPECULATOR: Emulating stellar population synthesis for fast and accurate galaxy spectra and photometry
• Dark Energy Survey Year 3 Results: Galaxy clustering and systematics treatment for lens galaxy samples
• The First Detections of the Extragalactic Background Light at 3000, 5500, and 8000A (III): Cosmological Implications
• Modelling type 1 quasar colours in the era of Rubin and Euclid
• GAMA/G10-COSMOS/3D-HST: Evolution of the galaxy stellar mass function over 12.5Gyrs
• Inferring More from Less: Prospector as a Photometric Redshift Engine in the Era of JWST
• KiDS-1000: cosmic shear with enhanced redshift calibration
• Self-consistent predictions for LIER-like emission lines from post-AGB stars
• Hipparcos and the Age of the Galactic Disc
• The Origin of Dust in Early-Type Galaxies and Implications for Accretion onto Supermassive Black Holes
• Quantifying the Effects of Known Unknowns on Inferred High-redshift Galaxy Properties: Burstiness, the IMF, and Nebular Physics
• The UNCOVER Survey: A First-look HST+JWST Catalog of Galaxy Redshifts and Stellar Population Properties Spanning $0.2\lesssim z\lesssim 15$
• The 5 - 10 keV AGN luminosity function at 0.01<z<4.0
• Deep Extragalactic VIsible Legacy Survey (DEVILS): Identification of AGN through SED Fitting and the Evolution of the Bolometric AGN Luminosity Function
• Circumstellar Dust Around AGB Stars and Implications for Infrared Emission from Galaxies
• The impact of spectroscopic incompleteness in direct calibration of redshift distributions for weak lensing surveys
• Horizontal-Branch Morphology and the Photometric Evolution of Old Stellar Populations
• The Mid-Infrared Luminosities of Normal Galaxies over Cosmic Time
• Millimeter mapping at z~1: dust-obscured bulge building and disk growth
• Galaxy And Mass Assembly (GAMA): The inferred mass--metallicity relation from z=0 to 3.5 via forensic SED fitting
• Blue Stragglers in Galactic Open Clusters and the Integrated Spectral Energy Distributions
• Structural parameters and blue stragglers in Sagittarius dwarf spheroidal galaxy globular clusters
• The ionisation parameter of star-forming galaxies evolves with the specific star formation rate
• Sérsic galaxy models in weak lensing shape measurement: model bias, noise bias and their interaction
• Calibrated Ultra Fast Image Simulations for the Dark Energy Survey
• A Bayesian Population Model for the Observed Dust Attenuation in Galaxies
• The redshift distribution of cosmological samples: a forward modeling approach
• Implications of a Temperature Dependent IMF I: Photometric Template Fitting
• The Frequency of Field Blue-Straggler Stars in the Thick Disk and Halo System of the Galaxy
• Forward modeling of galaxy populations for cosmological redshift distribution inference
• Measurement of the B-band Galaxy Luminosity Function with Approximate Bayesian Computation
• Galaxy surveys, inhomogeneous reionization, and dark energy
• A few StePS forward in unveiling the complexity of galaxy evolution: light-weighted stellar ages of intermediate redshift galaxies with WEAVE
• Autoencoding Galaxy Spectra I: Architecture
• DEVILS: Cosmic evolution of SED-derived metallicities and their connection to star-formation histories
• Monte Carlo Control Loops for cosmic shear cosmology with DES Year 1
• Scaling relations of metallicity, stellar mass, and star formation rate in metal-poor starbursts: II. Theoretical models
• Hierarchical Bayesian inference of photometric redshifts with stellar population synthesis models
• The PAU Survey: Measurement of Narrow-band galaxy properties with Approximate Bayesian Computation
• Probabilistic Forward Modeling of Galaxy Catalogs with Normalizing Flows
• The Blue Stragglers of the Old Open Cluster NGC 188
• ZFOURGE: Extreme 5007$\mathring{A}$ emission may be a common early-lifetime phase for star-forming galaxies at $z>2.5$
• Mass Metallicity Relationship of SDSS Star Forming Galaxies: Population Synthesis Analysis and Effects of Star Burst Length, Extinction Law, Initial Mass Function and Star Formation Rate
• Clean catalogues of blue horizontal-branch stars using Gaia EDR3
• Photometric identification of blue horizontal branch stars
• WEAVE-StePS. A stellar population survey using WEAVE at WHT
• The PAU Survey: A Forward Modeling Approach for Narrow-band Imaging
• Forward Modeling of Spectroscopic Galaxy Surveys: Application to SDSS
• Spectro-Imaging Forward Model of Red and Blue Galaxies
• Instrumental systematics and weak gravitational lensing
• Simulation-based inference of deep fields: galaxy population model and redshift distributions
• Weak Gravitational Lensing Systematics from Image Combination
• Quantifying correlations between galaxy emission lines and stellar continua
• FORECAST: a flexible software to forward model cosmological hydrodynamical simulations mimicking real observations
• DESI Complete Calibration of the Color-Redshift Relation (DC3R2): Results from early DESI data
• The 2175 Angstrom Interstellar Extinction Bump: Is the Wavelength Variable?
• Emission Line Predictions for Mock Galaxy Catalogues: a New Differentiable and Empirical Mapping from DESI

Cited by in corpus (6)

• pop-cosmos: Scaleable inference of galaxy properties and redshifts with a data-driven population model
• Learning the Universe: Cosmological and Astrophysical Parameter Inference with Galaxy Luminosity Functions and Colours
• pop-cosmos: Insights from generative modeling of a deep, infrared-selected galaxy population
• Emulating redshift mixing due to blending in weak gravitational lensing
• GalSBI-SPS: a stellar population synthesis-based galaxy population model for cosmology and galaxy evolution applications
• GalSBI: Phenomenological galaxy population model for cosmology using simulation-based inference