Quashing a suspected selection bias in galaxy samples having dynamically-measured supermassive black holes

Abstract

Local early-type galaxies with directly-measured black hole masses, $M_{\mathrm{bh}}$, have been reported to represent a biased sample relative to the population at large. Such galaxies with Spitzer Space Telescope imaging have been purported to possess velocity dispersions, $\sigma$, at least $\sim$0.1 dex larger for a given galaxy stellar mass, $M_{\ast ,\mathrm{gal}}$, than is typically observed among thousands of early-type galaxies imaged by the Sloan Digital Sky Survey. This apparent offset led Shankar et al. to reduce the normalisation of the observed $M_{\mathrm{bh}}\propto {\sigma }^5$ relation by at least $\sim$0.5 dex to give their "intrinsic relations", including $\sigma$-based modifications to the $M_{\mathrm{bh}}$-$M_{\ast ,\mathrm{gal}}$ relation. These modifications were based on the untested assumption that the stellar masses had been derived consistently between the two samples. Here, we provide the necessary check using galaxies common to the Spitzer Survey of Stellar Structure in Galaxies (S${}^4$G) and the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS). We find that the stellar masses of galaxies with and without directly measured black holes had appeared offset from each other due to the use of inconsistent stellar mass-to-light ratios, ${{\rm Y}}_{\ast }$, for the optical and infrared data. We briefly discuss the "intrinsic relations" and why some of these will at times appear to have had partial success when applied to data based on similarly inconsistent values of ${{\rm Y}}_{\ast }$. Finally, we reiterate the importance of the $\upsilon$ (lower-case ${\rm Y}$) term, which we previously introduced into the $M_{\mathrm{bh}}$-$M_{\ast }$ relations to help avoid ${{\rm Y}}_{\ast }$-related mismatches.

arXiv commentTo appear in MNRAS. 10 pages, including 6 figures and references

References in corpus (79)

• Galactic Stellar and Substellar Initial Mass Function
• Measuring Reddening with SDSS Stellar Spectra and Recalibrating SFD
• The Seventh Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• Coevolution (Or Not) of Supermassive Black Holes and Host Galaxies
• The Demography of Massive Dark Objects in Galaxy Centres
• The Infrared Array Camera (IRAC) for the Spitzer Space Telescope
• The slope of the black-hole mass versus velocity dispersion correlation
• The Optical and Near-Infrared Properties of Galaxies: I. Luminosity and Stellar Mass Functions
• On the Black Hole Mass - Bulge Mass Relation
• The M-sigma and M-L Relations in Galactic Bulges and Determinations of their Intrinsic Scatter
• Some Aspects of Measurement Error in Linear Regression of Astronomical Data
• Revisiting the Scaling Relations of Black Hole Masses and Host Galaxy Properties
• The SAURON project - IV. The mass-to-light ratio, the virial mass estimator and the fundamental plane of elliptical and lenticular galaxies
• Observational constraints on growth of massive black holes
• HyperLEDA. III. The catalogue of extragalactic distances
• Supermassive Black Holes in Galactic Nuclei: Past, Present and Future Research
• Linear Regression for Astronomical Data with Measurement Errors and Intrinsic Scatter
• Galaxy And Mass Assembly: Stellar Mass Estimates
• Beyond the Bulge: a Fundamental Relation Between Supermassive Black Holes and Dark Matter Halos
• The cosmological evolution of quasar black-hole masses
• The Spitzer Survey of Stellar Structure in Galaxies (S^4G)
• Gravitational waves from binary supermassive black holes missing in pulsar observations
• The Masses of Nuclear Black Holes in Luminous Elliptical Galaxies and Implications for the Space Density of the Most Massive Black Holes
• The AGN Black Hole Mass Database
• The SINFONI Black Hole Survey: The Black Hole Fundamental Plane revisited and the paths of (co-) evolution of supermassive black holes and bulges
• Reconstructing the stellar mass distributions of galaxies using S4G IRAC 3.6 and 4.5 micron images: II. The conversion from light to mass
• A New Empirical Model for the Structural Analysis of Early-type Galaxies and a Critical Review of the Nuker Model
• The (black hole mass)-(host spheroid luminosity) relation at high and low masses, the quadratic growth of black holes, and intermediate-mass black hole candidates
• Selection bias in dynamically-measured super-massive black hole samples: its consequences and the quest for the most fundamental relation
• The Spitzer Survey of Stellar Structure in Galaxies (S${}^4$G): Precise Stellar Mass Distributions from Automated Dust Correction at 3.6 microns
• Analytical approximations of K-corrections in optical and near-infrared bands
• On the Correlations between Galaxy Properties and Supermassive Black Hole Mass
• Revisiting the Hubble sequence in the SDSS DR7 spectroscopic sample: a publicly available bayesian automated classification
• The Spitzer/IRAC view of black hole - bulge scaling relations
• A catalogue of 2D photometric decompositions in the SDSS-DR7 spectroscopic main galaxy sample: preferred models and systematics
• A universal ultraviolet-optical colour-colour-magnitude relation of galaxies
• An Observed Fundamental Plane Relation for Supermassive Black Holes
• The Black Hole Mass - Spheroid Luminosity relation
• On Quasar Masses and Quasar Host Galaxies
• How Well Can We Measure the Stellar Mass of a Galaxy: The Impact of the Assumed Star Formation History Model in SED Fitting
• How well can we really estimate the stellar masses of galaxies from broadband photometry?
• Galaxy luminosities, stellar masses, sizes, velocity dispersions as a function of morphological type
• On The Linearity of The Black Hole - Bulge Mass Relation in Active and in Nearby Galaxies
• The Black Hole to Bulge Mass Relation in Active Galactic Nuclei
• Breaking the law: the M_{bh}-M_{spheroid} mass relations for core-Sersic and Sersic galaxies
• Supermassive black holes and their host spheroids II. The red and blue sequence in the $M_{\mathrm{BH}}-M_{\ast ,\mathrm{sph}}$ diagram
• The (black hole)-bulge mass scaling relation at low masses
• Kinematic Properties and Stellar Populations of Faint Early-Type Galaxies. I. Velocity Dispersion Measurements of Central Coma Galaxies
• Black Hole Mass Scaling Relations for Early-Type Galaxies: $M_{BH}$-$M_{\ast ,sph}$ and $M_{BH}$-$M_{\ast ,gal}$
• Formation and evolution of dwarf elliptical galaxies I. Structural and kinematical properties
• A Local Baseline of the Black Hole Mass Scaling Relations for Active Galaxies. I. Methodology and Results of Pilot Study
• Galaxy bulges and their massive black holes: a review
• Black Hole Mass Scaling Relations for Spiral Galaxies. I. $M_{\mathrm{BH}}$-$M_{\ast ,\mathrm{sph}}$
• Systematic Uncertainties in Stellar Mass Estimation for Distinct Galaxy Populations
• Selection bias in the M_BH-sigma and M_BH-L correlations and its consequences
• Black Hole Mass Scaling Relations for Spiral Galaxies. II. $M_{\mathrm{BH}}$-$M_{\ast ,\mathrm{tot}}$ and $M_{\mathrm{BH}}$-$M_{\ast ,\mathrm{disk}}$
• Selection bias in dynamically-measured super-massive black hole samples: consequences for pulsar timing arrays
• Revealing Hidden Substructures in the $M_{BH}$-$\sigma$ Diagram, and Refining the Bend in the $L$-$\sigma$ Relation
• Supermassive black holes and their host spheroids I. Disassembling galaxies
• Beyond Ellipse(s): Accurately Modelling the Isophotal Structure of Galaxies with $Isofit$ and $Cmodel$
• The Fundamental Relation between Supermassive Black Holes and Their Host Galaxies
• Supermassive Black Holes and Their Host Galaxies - II. The correlation with near-infrared luminosity revisited
• The Mass Of Black Holes in the Nuclei Of Spirals
• The Mass-to-light Ratios and the Star Formation Histories of Disk Galaxies
• The Impact of Star Formation Histories on Stellar Mass Estimation: Implications from the Local Group Dwarf Galaxies
• Correlation Between the Total Gravitating Mass of Groups and Clusters and the Supermassive Black Hole Mass of Brightest Galaxies
• Overmassive black holes in the $M_{\mathrm{BH}}-\sigma$ diagram do not belong to over (dry) merged galaxies
• A Brief History of AGN
• Probing black hole accretion tracks, scaling relations and radiative efficiencies from stacked X-ray active galactic nuclei
• A galaxy classification grid that better recognises early-type galaxy morphology
• Stellar Mass-to-light Ratios: Composite Bulge+Disk Models and the Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation
• The local supermassive black hole mass density: corrections for dependencies on the Hubble constant
• Expected intermediate mass black holes in the Virgo cluster. II. Late-type galaxies
• The Mid-Infrared Fundamental Plane of Early-Type Galaxies
• Expected intermediate-mass black holes in the Virgo cluster. I. Early-type galaxies
• The (black hole mass)-(color) relations for early- and late-type galaxies: red and blue sequences
• Building robust AGN mock catalogs to unveil black hole evolution and for survey planning
• Disc cloaking: Establishing a lower limit to the number density of local compact massive spheroids/bulges and the potential fate of some high-z red nuggets
• The (Black Hole Mass)-(Spheroid Stellar Density) Relations: $M_{\mathrm{BH}}$--$\mu$ (and $M_{\mathrm{BH}}$--$\Sigma$) and $M_{\mathrm{BH}}$--$\rho$

Cited by in corpus (7)

• Reading the tea leaves in the $M_{\mathrm{bh}}$-$M_{\ast ,\mathrm{sph}}$ and $M_{\mathrm{bh}}$-$R_{\mathrm{e},\mathrm{sph}}$ diagrams: dry and gaseous mergers with remnant angular momentum
• Splitting the lentils: Clues to galaxy/black hole coevolution from the discovery of offset relations for non-dusty versus dusty (wet-merger-built) lenticular galaxies in the $M_{\mathrm{bh}}$-$M_{\ast ,\mathrm{spheroid}}$ diagram
• Probing supermassive black hole growth and its dependence on stellar mass and star-formation rate in low-redshift galaxies
• Discovery of a Planar Black Hole Mass Scaling Relation for Spiral Galaxies
• Outflows in the Gaseous Discs of Active Galaxies and their impact on Black Hole Scaling Relations
• Probing the Low-mass End of the Black Hole Mass Function via a Study of Faint Local Spiral Galaxies
• Causal Discovery in Astrophysics: Unraveling Supermassive Black Hole and Galaxy Coevolution