Revisiting the Fanaroff-Riley dichotomy and radio-galaxy morphology with the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS)

Abstract

The relative positions of the high and low surface brightness regions of radio-loud active galaxies in the 3CR sample were found by Fanaroff and Riley to be correlated with their luminosity. We revisit this canonical relationship with a sample of 5805 extended radio-loud AGN from the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS), compiling the most complete dataset of radio-galaxy morphological information obtained to date. We demonstrate that, for this sample, radio luminosity does *not* reliably predict whether a source is edge-brightened (FRII) or centre-brightened (FRI). We highlight a large population of low-luminosity FRIIs, extending three orders of magnitude below the traditional FR break, and demonstrate that their host galaxies are on average systematically fainter than those of high-luminosity FRIIs and of FRIs matched in luminosity. This result supports the jet power/environment paradigm for the FR break: low-power jets may remain undisrupted and form hotspots in lower mass hosts. We also find substantial populations that appear physically distinct from the traditional FR classes, including candidate restarting sources and ``hybrids''. We identify 459 bent-tailed sources, which we find to have a significantly higher SDSS cluster association fraction (at $z<0.4$) than the general radio-galaxy population, similar to the results of previous work. The complexity of the LoTSS faint, extended radio sources demonstrates the need for caution in the automated classification and interpretation of extended sources in modern radio surveys, but also reveals the wealth of morphological information such surveys will provide and its value for advancing our physical understanding of radio-loud AGN.

arXiv comment21 pages, 4 tables, 16 Figures. Accepted for publication on Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (MNRAS). Our LoTSS morphological catalogue containing classifications for 5805 extended radio-loud AGN is available from www.lofar-surveys.org/releases.html

References in corpus (94)

• The NumPy array: a structure for efficient numerical computation
• The Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE): Mission Description and Initial On-orbit Performance
• scikit-image: Image processing in Python
• The Optical and Near-Infrared Properties of Galaxies: I. Luminosity and Stellar Mass Functions
• Astrophysics Source Code Library
• Mid-Infrared Selection of AGN with the Wide-Field Infrared Survey Explorer. I. Characterizing WISE-Selected AGN in COSMOS
• On the fundamental dichotomy in the local radio-AGN population: accretion, evolution, and host galaxy properties
• The LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey - I. Survey Description and Preliminary Data Release
• The LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey - II. First data release
• GaLactic and Extragalactic All-sky Murchison Widefield Array (GLEAM) survey I: A low-frequency extragalactic catalogue
• A relationship between AGN jet power and radio power
• EMU: Evolutionary Map of the Universe
• Mid-Infrared Selection of Active Galactic Nuclei with the Wide-Field Infrared Survey Explorer. II. Properties of WISE-Selected Active Galactic Nuclei in the NDWFS Boötes Field
• A 20cm VLA Survey of Abell Clusters of Galaxies VI. Radio/Optical Luminosity Functions
• Using the Bright Ultra-Hard XMM-Newton Survey to define an IR selection of luminous AGN based on WISE colours
• Low Resolution Spectral Templates For AGNs and Galaxies From 0.03 -- 30 microns
• The SWIRE-VVDS-CFHTLS surveys: stellar mass assembly over the last 10 Gyears. Evidence for a major build up of the red sequence between z=2 and z=1
• Radio galaxies with a `double-double' morphology: I - Analysis of the radio properties and evidence for interrupted activity in active galactic nuclei
• The radio luminosity function from the low-frequency 3CRR, 6CE & 7CRS complete samples
• Dynamical models for jet deceleration in the radio galaxy 3C 31
• The LoTSS view of radio AGN in the local Universe. The most massive galaxies are always switched on
• The active nuclei of z<1.0 3CRR radio sources
• Relativistic Jets and the Fanaroff-Riley Classification of Radio Galaxies
• LOFAR/H-ATLAS: The low-frequency radio luminosity - star-formation rate relation
• Three-dimensional Relativistic MHD Simulations of Active Galactic Nuclei Jets: Magnetic Kink Instability and Fanaroff-Riley Dichotomy
• Radio-loud AGN in the first LoTSS data release: The lifetimes and environmental impact of jet-driven sources
• The LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey (LoTSS) III. First Data Release: optical/IR identifications and value-added catalogue
• Identification of 1.4 Million AGNs in the Mid-Infrared using WISE Data
• Radio AGN in the local universe: unification, triggering and evolution
• Giant Radio Sources
• A simulation-based analytic model of radio galaxies
• Classifying Radio Galaxies with Convolutional Neural Network
• Luminosity function, sizes and FR dichotomy of radio-loud AGN
• Particle content, radio-galaxy morphology and jet power: all radio-loud AGN are not equal
• An X-ray survey of the 2Jy sample. I: is there an accretion mode dichotomy in radio-loud AGN?
• The duty cycle of local radio galaxies
• The Energetics and Lifetimes of Local Radio Active Galactic Nuclei
• Evolution of the Radio Loud Galaxy Population
• FRII{\sl{CAT}}: A FIRST catalog of FR~II radio galaxies
• The MIXR sample: AGN activity versus star formation across the cross-correlation of WISE, 3XMM, and FIRST/NVSS
• Observed properties of FRII quasars and radio galaxies at z < 1.0
• The relation between morphology, accretion modes and environmental factors in local radio AGN
• Radio Galaxy Zoo: ClaRAN - A Deep Learning Classifier for Radio Morphologies
• The WISE properties of complete samples of radio-loud AGN
• The triggering probability of radio-loud AGN: A comparison of high and low excitation radio galaxies in hosts of different colors
• A representative survey of the dynamics and energetics of FRII radio galaxies
• A new sample of giant radio galaxies from the WENSS survey II - A multi-frequency radio study of a complete sample: Properties of the radio lobes and their environment
• Search and modelling of remnant radio galaxies in the LOFAR Lockman Hole field
• Galaxy Cluster Environments of Radio Sources
• The nuclear properties and extended morphologies of powerful radio galaxies: the roles of host galaxy and environment
• The LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey IV. First Data Release: Photometric redshifts and rest-frame magnitudes
• J1420--0545: The radio galaxy larger than 3C236
• The link between accretion mode and environment in radio-loud active galaxies
• The MeerKAT International GHz Tiered Extragalactic Exploration (MIGHTEE) Survey
• LoTSS DR1: Double-double radio galaxies in the HETDEX field
• A Chandra study of particle acceleration in the multiple hotspots of nearby radio galaxies
• LOFAR discovery of a 700-kpc remnant radio galaxy at low redshift
• Remnant radio-loud AGN in the Herschel-ATLAS field
• On the Populations of Radio Galaxies with Extended Morphology at z<0.3
• LOFAR-Boötes: Properties of high- and low-excitation radio galaxies at $0.5<z<2.0$
• LoTSS/HETDEX: Optical quasars I. Low-frequency radio properties of optically selected quasars
• The environments of radio-loud AGN from the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS)
• Morphological classification of radio galaxies: Capsule Networks versus Convolutional Neural Networks
• The Environments of a Complete, Moderate-Redshift Sample of FIRST Bent-Double Radio Sources
• Hybrid morphology radio sources from FIRST survey
• Discovery of Giant Radio Galaxies from NVSS: Radio & Infrared Properties
• The new sample of Giant radio sources: I. Radio imaging, optical identification and spectroscopy of selected candidates
• A Machine Learning Based Morphological Classification of 14,245 Radio AGNs Selected From The Best-Heckman Sample
• A wide angle tail radio galaxy in the COSMOS field: evidence for cluster formation
• The ASKAP/EMU Source Finding Data Challenge
• Jet termination in wide-angle tailed radio sources
• Radio Galaxy Zoo: A Search for Hybrid Morphology Radio Galaxies
• The FIRST Classifier: Compact and Extended Radio Galaxy Classification using Deep Convolutional Neural Networks
• Radio Galaxy Zoo: The Distortion of Radio Galaxies by Galaxy Clusters
• The CoNFIG Catalogue - II. Comparison of Space Densities in the FR Dichotomy
• Interpreting radiative efficiency in radio-loud AGN
• AGN and their host galaxies in the local Universe: two mass independent Eddington ratio distribution functions characterize black hole growth
• The prevalence of FRI radio quasars
• Wide-angle tail galaxies in ATLAS
• A robust derivation of the tight relationship of radio core dominance to inclination angle in high redshift 3CRR sources
• Radio-AGN Feedback: When the Little Ones were Monsters
• The evolution of Ks-selected galaxies in the GOODS/CDFS deep ISAAC field
• Optical Spectroscopic Survey of High Latitude WISE Selected Sources
• Narrow head-tail radio galaxies at very high resolution
• Understanding the Fanaroff-Riley radio galaxy classification
• Tailed radio galaxies as tracers of galaxy clusters. Serendipitous discoveries with the GMRT
• A low-frequency study of recently identified double-double radio galaxies
• Cosmological evolution of the Fanaroff-Riley type II source population
• The WEAVE-LOFAR Survey
• The role of environment in the observed Fundamental Plane of radio Active Galactic Nuclei
• Fanaroff-Riley dichotomy of radio galaxies and the Malmquist bias
• MOIRCS Deep Survey. VII: NIR Morphologies of Star-forming Galaxies at Redshift z~1
• Fundamental properties of Fanaroff-Riley II radio galaxies investigated via Monte Carlo simulations
• A Search for Extended Radio Sources in 1.3 sr of the VLA Sky Survey (VLASS)

Cited by in corpus (126)

• The LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey -- V. Second data release
• Radio galaxies and feedback from AGN jets
• Compact steep-spectrum and peaked-spectrum radio sources
• The LOFAR LBA Sky Survey I. survey description and preliminary data release
• All-purpose, all-sky photometric redshifts for the Legacy Imaging Surveys Data Release 8
• Particle acceleration in astrophysical jets
• Search and analysis of giant radio galaxies with associated nuclei (SAGAN) -- I : New sample and multi-wavelength studies
• Jet collimation in NGC 315 and other nearby AGN
• The LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS): VI. Optical identifications for the second data release
• The duty cycle of radio galaxies revealed by LOFAR: remnant and restarted radio source populations in the Lockman Hole
• Accretion mode versus radio morphology in the LOFAR Deep Fields
• The Quasar Feedback Survey: Discovering hidden Radio-AGN and their connection to the host galaxy ionised gas
• The radio loudness of SDSS quasars from the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey: ubiquitous jet activity and constraints on star formation
• The Faraday Rotation Measure Grid of the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey: Data Release 2
• The Relativistic Jet Dichotomy and the End of the Blazar Sequence
• CNN Architecture Comparison for Radio Galaxy Classification
• Unveiling the cause of hybrid morphology radio sources (HyMoRS)
• Fundamental differences in the radio properties of red and blue quasars: enhanced compact AGN emission in red quasars
• Simulating the transport of relativistic electrons and magnetic fields injected by radio galaxies in the intracluster medium
• MIGHTEE: Are giant radio galaxies more common than we thought?
• Unveiling the rarest morphologies of the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey radio source population with self-organised maps
• Attention-gating for improved radio galaxy classification
• Simulations of AGN Driven Galactic Outflow Morphology and Content
• The LOFAR LBA Sky Survey II. First data release
• Active galactic nucleus jet feedback in hydrostatic halos
• Radio sources associated with Optical Galaxies and having Unresolved or Extended morphologies (ROGUE). I. A catalog of SDSS galaxies with FIRST core identifications
• Jets in radio galaxies and quasars: an observational perspective
• Dynamics of relativistic radio jets in asymmetric environments
• A population of galaxy-scale jets discovered using LOFAR
• The LOFAR view of FR0 radio galaxies
• The best of both worlds: Combining LOFAR and Apertif to derive resolved radio spectral index images
• Decoding the giant extragalactic radio sources
• LeMMINGs. III. The e-MERLIN Legacy Survey of the Palomar sample. Exploring the origin of nuclear radio emission in active and inactive galaxies through the [O III] -- radio connection
• Multi-frequency characterisation of remnant radio galaxies in the Lockman Hole field
• A Quick Look at the 3GHz Radio Sky. II. Hunting for DRAGNs in the VLA Sky Survey
• Life cycle of cosmic-ray electrons in the intracluster medium
• FR-type radio sources at 3 GHz VLA-COSMOS: Relation to physical properties and large-scale environment
• Do Radio Active Galactic Nuclei Reflect X-ray Binary Spectral States?
• Long-term FRII jet evolution in dense environments
• Jet-accretion system in the nearby mJy Radio Galaxies
• The Dynamics and Energetics of Remnant and Restarting RLAGN
• Radio Morphology of Red Geysers
• High energy emission component, population, and contribution to the extragalactic gamma-ray background of gamma-ray emitting radio galaxies
• The LOFAR Two Metre Sky Survey: Deep Fields. II. The ELAIS-N1 LOFAR deep field
• Placing LOFAR-detected quasars in CIV emission space: implications for winds, jets and star formation
• The Massive and Distant Clusters of WISE Survey VII: The Environments and Properties of Radio Galaxies in Clusters at z~1
• Radio Galaxy Zoo: New Giant Radio Galaxies in the RGZ DR1catalogue
• A giant radio galaxy with three cycles of episodic jet activity from LoTSS DR2
• Quantifying Uncertainty in Deep Learning Approaches to Radio Galaxy Classification
• Low-frequency observations of the Giant Radio Galaxy NGC 6251
• A low frequency study of linear polarization in radio galaxies
• A new look at old friends. I. Imaging classical radio galaxies with uGMRT and MeerKAT
• Variability and parsec-scale radio structure of candidate compact symmetric objects
• Structured Variational Inference for Simulating Populations of Radio Galaxies
• The LOFAR view of NGC 3998, a sputtering AGN
• LOFAR Deep Fields: Probing a broader population of polarized radio galaxies in ELAIS-N1
• Luminous giants populate the dense Cosmic Web: The radio luminosity-environmental density relation for radio galaxies in action
• Morphological Classification of Radio Galaxies with wGAN-supported Augmentation
• Barbell-shaped giant radio galaxy with ~100 kpc kink in the jet
• The morphological classification of distant radio galaxies explored with three-dimensional simulations
• A Polarimetric Study of 9 PG Quasars with the VLA
• Numerical simulations of MHD jets from Keplerian accretion disks I-Recollimation shocks
• The Apertif science verification campaign - Characteristics of polarised radio sources
• MeerKAT follow-up of enigmatic GLEAM 4-Jy (G4Jy) sources
• Search for hybrid morphology radio galaxies from FIRST survey at 1400 MHz
• SPARCS-North Wide-field VLBI Survey: Exploring the resolved MicroJy extra-galactic radio source population with EVN+e-MERLIN
• Deep uGMRT observations of the ELAIS-North 1 field: statistical properties of radio--infrared relations up to $z\sim$2
• Tracing the Evolution of Ultraluminous Infrared Galaxies into Radio Galaxies with Low Frequency Radio Observations
• The Quasar Feedback Survey: zooming into the origin of radio emission with e-MERLIN
• High-Energy Neutrino Emission from Espresso-Reaccelerated Ions in Jets of Active Galactic Nuclei
• Finding AGN remnant candidates based on radio morphology with machine learning
• Collimation of the kiloparsec-scale radio jets in NGC 2663
• Revealing the Unusual Structure of the KAT-7-Discovered Giant Radio Galaxy J0133$-$1302
• The Host Galaxies of Hybrid Morphology Radio Sources
• Clusters' far-reaching influence on narrow-angle tail radio galaxies
• Faint polarised sources in the Lockman Hole field at 1.4 GHz
• VLA Snapshot Continuum Survey of FRI Quasar Candidates Selected from the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS)
• Radio AGN jet alignment: Radio and Optical Position Angle of Radio Galaxies
• The GLEAM 200 MHz Local Radio Luminosity Function for AGN and Star-forming Galaxies
• Complex morphology and precession indicators of AGN jets in LoTSS DR2
• Identification of 4876 Bent-Tail Radio Galaxies in the FIRST Survey Using Deep Learning Combined with Visual Inspection
• Dynamic and Radiative Implications of Jet-Star Interactions in AGN Jets
• Matching LOFAR sources across radio bands
• On the large scale morphology of Hercules A: destabilized hot jets?
• Subarcsecond view on the high-redshift blazar GB 1508+5714 by the International LOFAR Telescope
• J0011+3217: A peculiar radio galaxy with a one-sided secondary lobe and misaligned giant primary lobes
• Hidden treasures in the unknown 3CR extragalactic radio sky: a multi-wavelength approach
• Apertif 1.4 GHz continuum observations of the Boötes field and their combined view with LOFAR
• The relation between the radio emission of the core and host galaxy properties in Fanaroff-Riley type II radio galaxies
• The role of supernovae inside AGN jets in UHECR acceleration
• Non-thermal emissions from a head-tail radio galaxy in 3D magnetohydrodynamic simulations
• A Novel Method for Estimating the Ambient Medium Density Around Distant Radio Sources from Their Observed Radio Spectra
• Identifying compact symmetric objects with high-precision VLBI and Gaia astrometry
• The LOFAR view of massive early-type galaxies: Transition from radio AGN to host emission
• Revealing the intricacies of radio galaxies and filaments in the merging galaxy cluster Abell 2255. I. Insights from deep LOFAR-VLBI sub-arcsecond resolution images
• Studying the link between radio galaxies and AGN fuelling with relativistic hydrodynamic simulations of flickering jets
• Core prominence as a signature of restarted jet activity in the LOFAR radio-galaxy population
• Radio jets: properties, life and impact
• Classification of Radio Sources Through Self-Supervised Learning
• Properties of Compact Faint Radio Sources as a Function of Angular Size from Stacking
• The Jet Paths of Radio AGN and their Cluster Weather
• A Morphological Identification and Study of Radio Galaxies from LoTSS DR2. I. The "Winged'' Radio Galaxies
• Shocked, Heated, and Now Resolved: H${}_2$ excitation in the low-luminosity AGN at M58 core with JWST
• Time-domain Radio-loudness of Active Galactic Nuclei: Intermittency, Memory, and Jet Escape
• LOFAR Deep Fields: Probing the sub-mJy regime of polarized extragalactic sources in ELAIS-N1. II. Analysis
• The phase-space of tailed radio galaxies in massive clusters
• Radio Galaxy Zoo: Using semi-supervised learning to leverage large unlabelled data-sets for radio galaxy classification under data-set shift
• Finding LoTSS of hosts for GRBs: a search for galaxy - gamma-ray burst coincidences at low frequencies with LOFAR
• Deblending the MIGHTEE-COSMOS survey with XID+: The resolved radio source counts to $S_{1.4}\approx 5\mu$Jy
• Simulating cosmic ray electron spectra and radio emission from an AGN jet outburst in a cool-core cluster
• Hosts and environments: a (large-scale) radio history of AGN and star-forming galaxies
• Multi-frequency study of large size radio galaxies 3C 35 and 3C 284
• How does environment affect the morphology of radio AGN?
• Can semi-supervised learning reduce the amount of manual labelling required for effective radio galaxy morphology classification?
• Testing the correlation between bending angle and polarization properties of bent radio galaxies
• Discovery of 178 Giant Radio Galaxies in 1059 deg${}^2$ of the Rapid ASKAP Continuum Survey at 888 MHz
• Transformer-Based Source Detection and Morphological Classification in LOFAR Deep-Field Continuum Images
• Mapping the emission and spectral properties of the FRI radio galaxy 3C 449 with LOFAR and the VLA
• Investigating the spectra and physical nature of galaxy scale jets
• The Application of Ridgelines in Extended Radio Source Cross-Identification
• Combining LOFAR and Apertif Data for Understanding the Life Cycle of Radio Galaxies
• LOFAR discovery of rare large FR-I jets in low-luminosity radio galaxy NGC 5322
• Investigating the origin of X-ray jets: A case study of four hybrid morphology MOJAVE blazars
• Low-frequency-selected Fast Radio Burst Host Galaxy Candidates
• The High Energy View of FR0 Radio Galaxies
• Radio Galaxy Zoo: Morphological classification by Fanaroff-Riley designation using self-supervised pre-training