No Clear, Direct Evidence for Multiple Protoplanets Orbiting LkCa 15: LkCa 15 bcd are Likely Inner Disk Signals

Abstract

Two studies utilizing sparse aperture masking (SAM) interferometry and $H_{\alpha }$ differential imaging have reported multiple jovian companions around the young solar-mass star, LkCa 15 (LkCa 15 bcd): the first claimed direct detection of infant, newly-formed planets ("protoplanets"). We present new near-infrared direct imaging/spectroscopy from the SCExAO system coupled with the CHARIS integral field spectrograph and multi-epoch thermal infrared imaging from Keck/NIRC2 of LkCa 15 at high Strehl ratios. These data provide the first direct imaging look at the same wavelengths and in the same locations where previous studies identified the LkCa 15 protoplanets and thus offer the first decisive test of their existence. The data do not reveal these planets. Instead, we resolve extended emission tracing a dust disk with a brightness and location comparable to that claimed for LkCa 15 bcd. Forward-models attributing this signal to orbiting planets are inconsistent with the combined SCExAO/CHARIS and Keck/NIRC2 data. An inner disk provides a more compelling explanation for the SAM detections and perhaps also the claimed $H_{\alpha }$ detection of LkCa 15 b. We conclude that there is currently no clear, direct evidence for multiple protoplanets orbiting LkCa 15, although the system likely contains at least one unseen jovian companion. To identify jovian companions around LkCa 15 from future observations, the inner disk should be detected and its effect modeled, removed, and shown to be distinguishable from planets. Protoplanet candidates identified from similar systems should likewise be clearly distinguished from disk emission through modeling.

arXiv comment12 pages, 4 figures, 1 table; Astrophysical Journal Letters in press

References in corpus (51)

• Direct Imaging of Multiple Planets Orbiting the Star HR 8799
• Angular Differential Imaging: a Powerful High-Contrast Imaging Technique
• Images of a fourth planet orbiting HR 8799
• Detection and Characterization of Exoplanets and Disks using Projections on Karhunen-Loeve Eigenimages
• Discovery of a planetary-mass companion within the gap of the transition disk around PDS 70
• A new algorithm for point spread function subtraction in high-contrast imaging: a demonstration with angular differential imaging
• The Subaru Coronagraphic Extreme Adaptive Optics system: enabling high-contrast imaging on solar-system scales
• Fundamental limitations of high contrast imaging set by small sample statistics
• LkCa 15: A Young Exoplanet Caught at Formation?
• Mapping the Shores of the Brown Dwarf Desert II: Multiple Star Formation in Taurus-Auriga
• Accreting Protoplanets in the LkCa 15 Transition Disk
• A Combined Subaru/VLT/MMT 1--5 Micron Study of Planets Orbiting HR 8799: Implications for Atmospheric Properties, Masses, and Formation
• On the Diversity of the Taurus Transitional Disks: UX Tau A & Lk Ca 15
• Radiative transfer in very optically thick circumstellar disks
• Transitional Disks as Signposts of Young, Multiplanet Systems
• A Spitzer IRS Study of Infrared Variability in Transitional and Pre-Transitional Disks around T Tauri Stars
• Detection and Characterization of Exoplanets using Projections on Karhunen-Loeve Eigenimages: Forward Modeling
• Resolving the HD 100546 Protoplanetary System with the Gemini Planet Imager: Evidence for Multiple Forming, Accreting Planets
• Direct Imaging Confirmation and Characterization of a Dust-Enshrouded Candidate Exoplanet Orbiting Fomalhaut
• Imaging of a Transitional Disk Gap in Reflected Light: Indications of Planet Formation Around the Young Solar Analog LkCa 15
• What is the Mass of a Gap-Opening Planet?
• Direct Imaging and Spectroscopy of a Candidate Companion Below/Near the Deuterium-Burning Limit In The Young Binary Star System, ROXs 42B
• A Closer Look at the LkCa 15 Protoplanetary Disk
• Searching for circumplanetary disks around LkCa 15
• Optical imaging polarimetry of the LkCa 15 protoplanetary disk with SPHERE ZIMPOL
• Confidence Level and Sensitivity Limits in High Contrast Imaging
• Sparse aperture masking at the VLT I. Faint companion detection limits for the two debris disk stars HD 92945 and HD 141569
• Resolving the planet-hosting inner regions of the LkCa 15 disk
• Investigation of the inner structures around HD169142 with VLT/SPHERE
• Deep Thermal Infrared Imaging of HR 8799 bcde: New Atmospheric Constraints and Limits on a Fifth Planet
• Planet or Brown Dwarf? Inferring the Companion Mass in HD 100546 from the Wall Shape using Mid-Infrared Interferometry
• Far-infrared to millimeter data of protoplanetary disks: dust growth in the Taurus, Ophiuchus, and Chamaeleon I star-forming regions
• SCExAO/CHARIS Near-Infrared Direct Imaging, Spectroscopy, and Forward-Modeling of kappa And b: A Likely Young, Low-Gravity Superjovian Companion
• Separating extended disc features from the protoplanet in PDS 70 using VLT/SINFONI
• GPI PSF subtraction with TLOCI: the next evolution in exoplanet/disk high-contrast imaging
• Resolving the gap and AU-scale asymmetries in the pre-transitional disk of V1247 Orionis
• The architecture of the LkCa 15 transitional disk revealed by high-contrast imaging
• Inner disk structure of the classical T Tauri star LkCa 15
• Identification of Young Stellar Variables with KELT for K2 I: Campaign 13 Taurus Dippers and Rotators
• Full 2D radiative transfer modelling of transitional disk LkCa 15
• High-Resolution Near-Infrared Polarimetry of a Circumstellar Disk around UX Tau A
• Multi-epoch Direct Imaging and Time-Variable Scattered Light Morphology of the HD 163296 Protoplanetary Disk
• Subaru/SCExAO First-Light Direct Imaging of a Young Debris Disk around HD 36546
• Spectro-astrometry of the pre-transitional star LkCa 15 does not reveal an accreting planet but extended H$\alpha$ emission
• Sparse Aperture Masking Observations of the FL Cha Pre-transitional Disk
• New Spatially Resolved Observations of the T Cha Transition Disk and Constraints on the Previously Claimed Substellar Companion
• Near-Infrared Imaging Polarimetry of LkCa 15: A Possible Warped Inner Disk
• Laboratory and On-Sky Validation of the Shaped Pupil Coronagraph's Sensitivity to Low-Order Aberrations With Active Wavefront Control
• A Resolved Near-Infrared Image of The Inner Cavity in The GM Aur Transitional Disk
• Imaging protoplanets: observing transition disks with non-redundant masking
• V819 Tau: A Rare Weak-Lined T Tauri Star with a Weak Infrared Excess

Cited by in corpus (69)

• Population-Level Eccentricity Distributions of Imaged Exoplanets and Brown Dwarf Companions: Dynamical Evidence for Distinct Formation Channels
• Kinematic detection of a planet carving a gap in a protoplanetary disc
• Dust depleted inner disks in a large sample of transition disks through long-baseline ALMA observations
• Images of Embedded Jovian Planet Formation At A Wide Separation Around AB Aurigae
• On the diversity of asymmetries in gapped protoplanetary disks
• Direct Imaging and Astrometric Detection of a Gas Giant Planet Orbiting an Accelerating Star
• Perturbers: SPHERE detection limits to planetary-mass companions in protoplanetary disks
• Annular substructures in the transition disks around LkCa 15 and J1610
• Magnetospheric Accretion as a Source of H$\alpha$ Emission from Proto-planets around PDS 70
• The widest H$\alpha$ survey of accreting protoplanets around nearby transition disks
• Transition disks: the observational revolution from SEDs to imaging
• Gas temperature structure across transition disk cavities
• Accreting protoplanets: Spectral signatures and magnitude of gas and dust extinction at H alpha
• HST/WFC3 H$\alpha$ Direct-Imaging Detection of a Point-like Source in the Disk Cavity of AB Aur
• ALMA Detection of Dust Trapping around Lagrangian Points in the LkCa 15 Disk
• ISPY -- NACO Imaging Survey for Planets around Young stars: Survey description and results from the first 2.5 years of observations
• Protoplanetary disks in $K_s$-band total intensity and polarized light
• Mapping Protoplanetary Disk Vertical Structure with CO Isotopologue Line Emission
• The Planetary Luminosity Problem: "Missing Planets" and the Observational Consequences of Episodic Accretion
• Searching for proto-planets with MUSE
• The Giant Accreting Protoplanet Survey (GAPlanetS) -- Results from a Six Year Campaign to Image Accreting Protoplanets
• WIde Separation Planets In Time (WISPIT): A Gap-clearing Planet in a Multi-ringed Disk around the Young Solar-type Star WISPIT 2
• Searching for H${}_{\alpha }$-emitting sources in the gaps of five transitional disks. SPHERE/ZIMPOL high-contrast imaging
• Zodiacal Exoplanets in Time (ZEIT) XIII: Planet Orbits and Atmospheres in the V1298 Tau System, a Keystone in Studies of Early Planetary Evolution
• The Endgame of Gas Giant Formation: Accretion Luminosity and Contraction Post-Runaway
• New constraints on the dust and gas distribution in the LkCa 15 disk from ALMA
• SCExAO/MEC and CHARIS Discovery of a Low Mass, 6 AU-Separation Companion to HIP 109427 using Stochastic Speckle Discrimination and High-Contrast Spectroscopy
• The Separation and H-alpha Contrasts of Massive Accreting Planets in the Gaps of Transitional Disks: Predicted H-alpha Protoplanet Yields for Adaptive Optics Surveys
• Hydrodynamic Model of H$\alpha$ Emission from Accretion Shocks of Proto-Giant Planet and Circumplanetary Disk
• Constrained Reference Star Differential Imaging: Enabling High-Fidelity Imagery of Highly Structured Circumstellar Disks
• Systematic Multi-Epoch Monitoring of LkCa 15: Dynamic Dust Structures on Solar-System Scales
• Disentangling protoplanetary disk gas mass and carbon depletion through combined atomic and molecular tracers
• Observability of Forming Planets and their Circumplanetary Disks IV. -- with JWST & ELT
• A faint companion around CrA-9: protoplanet or obscured binary?
• The Giant Accreting Protoplanet Survey (GAPlanetS): Optimization Techniques for Robust Detections of Protoplanets
• The Keck Planet Imager and Characterizer: Demonstrating advanced exoplanet characterization techniques for future extremely large telescopes
• Dynamical detection of a companion driving a spiral arm in a protoplanetary disk
• Gap Opening and Inner Disk Structure in the Strongly Accreting Transition Disk of DM Tau
• The COBREX archival survey: improved constraints on the occurrence rate of wide-orbit substellar companions. I. A uniform re-analysis of 400 stars from the GPIES survey
• Inverse-problem versus principal component analysis methods for angular differential imaging of circumstellar disks. The mustard algorithm
• SCExAO and Keck Direct Imaging Discovery of a Low-Mass Companion Around the Accelerating F5 Star HIP 5319
• Exoplanet accretion monitoring spectroscopic survey (ENTROPY) I. Evidence for magnetospheric accretion in the young isolated planetary-mass object 2MASS J11151597+1937266
• From Dust to Nanodust: Resolving Circumstellar Dust from the Colliding-Wind Binary Wolf-Rayet (WR) 140
• Combining reference-star and angular differential imaging for high-contrast imaging of extended sources
• Multiband imaging of the HD 36546 debris disk: a refined view from SCExAO/CHARIS
• Detection of H$\alpha$ emission from PZ Tel B using SPHERE/ZIMPOL
• Strong H$\alpha$ emission in the young planetary mass companion 2MASS J0249-0557 c
• Amplitude Modulation of Short-Timescale Hot Spot Variability
• An extended scattered light disk around AT Pyx -- Possible planet formation in a cometary globule
• Zodiacal Exoplanets in Time (ZEIT) XII: A Directly-Imaged Planetary-Mass Companion to a Young Taurus M Dwarf Star
• MIRACLES: atmospheric characterization of directly imaged planets and substellar companions at 4-5 $\mu$m. II. Constraints on the mass and radius of the enshrouded planet PDS 70 b
• Atmospheric Characterization and Further Orbital Modeling of $\kappa$ And b
• First light of a holographic aperture mask: Observation at the Keck OSIRIS Imager
• Modeling the arc and ring structures in the HD 143006 disk
• LBT search for companions and sub-structures in the (pre)transitional disk of AB Aurigae
• Dynamics of small grains in transitional discs
• High-Contrast Integral Field Spectrograph (HCIFS): multi-spectral wavefront control and reduced-dimensional system identification
• High-contrast integral field spectropolarimetry of planet-forming disks with SCExAO/CHARIS
• Occurrence rates of accreting companions from a new method for computing emission-line survey sensitivity: application to the H-alpha Giant Accreting Protoplanet Survey
• New constraints on the presence of debris disks around G 196-3 B and VHS J125601.92-125723.9 b
• SCExAO, a testbed for developing high-contrast imaging technologies for ELTs
• exoALMA XXIII. Estimating Disk and Planet Properties from Dust Morphologies with DBNets2.0
• On-sky performance and recent results from the Subaru coronagraphic extreme adaptive optics system
• Update on the Preliminary Design of SCALES: the Santa Cruz Array of Lenslets for Exoplanet Spectroscopy
• Optimising reference library selection for reference-star differential imaging of discs with SPHERE/IRDIS
• SCExAO/CHARIS Multi-Wavelength, High-Contrast Imaging of the BD+45${}^{\circ }$598 Debris Disk
• Performance and Early Science with the Subaru Coronagraphic Extreme Adaptive Optics Project
• Longterm Stability of Planetary Systems formed from a Transitional Disk
• Two Rings and a Marginally Resolved, 5 AU, Disk Around LkCa 15 Identified Via Near Infrared Sparse Aperture Masking Interferometry