Breaking a Dark Degeneracy with Gravitational Waves

Abstract

We identify a scalar-tensor model embedded in the Horndeski action whose cosmological background and linear scalar fluctuations are degenerate with the concordance cosmology. The model admits a self-accelerated background expansion at late times that is stable against perturbations with a sound speed attributed to the new field that is equal to the speed of light. While degenerate in scalar fluctuations, self-acceleration of the model implies a present cosmological tensor mode propagation at < 95% of the speed of light with a damping of the wave amplitude that is > 5% less efficient than in general relativity. We show that these discrepancies are endemic to self-accelerated Horndeski theories with degenerate large-scale structure and are tested with measurements of gravitational waves emitted by events at cosmological distances. Hence, gravitational-wave cosmology breaks the dark degeneracy in observations of the large-scale structure between two fundamentally different explanations of cosmic acceleration - a cosmological constant and a scalar-tensor modification of gravity. The gravitational wave event GW150914 recently detected with the aLIGO instruments and its potential association with a weak short gamma-ray burst observed with the Fermi GBM experiment may have provided this crucial measurement.

24 pages, 4 figures; v2 updated following GW150914 observation

References in corpus (35)

• Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger
• Cosmology and the Fate of Dilatation Symmetry
• Healthy theories beyond Horndeski
• The Large Scale Structure of f(R) Gravity
• Maximal freedom at minimum cost: linear large-scale structure in general modifications of gravity
• A Parameterized Post-Friedmann Framework for Modified Gravity
• Measuring the dark side (with weak lensing)
• A discriminating probe of gravity at cosmological scales
• Measuring primordial non-gaussianity without cosmic variance
• New Perspective on Galaxy Clustering as a Cosmological Probe: General Relativistic Effects
• Correlation of CMB with large-scale structure: I. ISW Tomography and Cosmological Implications
• Distinguishing Modified Gravity from Dark Energy
• Combined analysis of the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect and cosmological implications
• Non-linear Evolution of f(R) Cosmologies III: Halo Statistics
• The Effective Theory of Quintessence: the w<-1 Side Unveiled
• Anisotropic stress as signature of non-standard propagation of gravitational waves
• A unifying description of dark energy
• The acceleration of the universe and the physics behind it
• Constructing stabilized brane world models in five-dimensional Brans-Dicke theory
• Ghosts in the self-accelerating universe
• Modified Gravity N-body Code Comparison Project
• Constraints on a New Post-General Relativity Cosmological Parameter
• Non-linear Evolution of Matter Power Spectrum in Modified Theory of Gravity
• Piercing the Vainshtein screen with anomalous gravitational wave speed: Constraints on modified gravity from binary pulsars
• The observational status of Galileon gravity after Planck
• Constraining chameleon models with cosmology
• Weakly Broken Galileon Symmetry
• Measuring the speed of cosmological gravitational waves
• Effects of modified gravity on B-mode polarization
• Measuring Speed of Gravitational Waves by Observations of Photons and Neutrinos from Compact Binary Mergers and Supernovae
• Unscreening Modified Gravity in the Matter Power Spectrum
• Friction in Gravitational Waves: a test for early-time modified gravity
• Semi-dynamical perturbations of unified dark energy
• Classifying Linearly Shielded Modified Gravity Models in Effective Field Theory
• How chameleons core dwarfs with cusps

Cited by in corpus (293)

• Planck 2018 results. I. Overview and the cosmological legacy of Planck
• Science Case for the Einstein Telescope
• Dark Energy after GW170817: dead ends and the road ahead
• Cosmological Backgrounds of Gravitational Waves
• Strong constraints on cosmological gravity from GW170817 and GRB 170817A
• Dark Energy after GW170817 and GRB170817A
• Implications of the Neutron Star Merger GW170817 for Cosmological Scalar-Tensor Theories
• Black holes, gravitational waves and fundamental physics: a roadmap
• Horndeski theory and beyond: a review
• Dynamical systems applied to cosmology: dark energy and modified gravity
• Binary Neutron Star Mergers: Mass Ejection, Electromagnetic Counterparts and Nucleosynthesis
• Testing General Relativity in Cosmology
• Dark Energy vs. Modified Gravity
• Science with the Einstein Telescope: a comparison of different designs
• Prospects for Fundamental Physics with LISA
• Dark Energy Survey Year 1 Results: Constraints on Extended Cosmological Models from Galaxy Clustering and Weak Lensing
• Cosmology with the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna
• New Horizons for Fundamental Physics with LISA
• The Astrophysics of Nanohertz Gravitational Waves
• Implications from GW170817 and I-Love-Q relations for relativistic hybrid stars
• Extreme Gravity Tests with Gravitational Waves from Compact Binary Coalescences: (I) Inspiral-Merger
• Testing modified gravity at cosmological distances with LISA standard sirens
• Gravitational Rainbows: LIGO and Dark Energy at its Cutoff
• Dark energy in Horndeski theories after GW170817: A review
• MICROSCOPE mission: final results of the test of the Equivalence Principle
• The gravitational-wave luminosity distance in modified gravity theories
• Generalized framework for testing gravity with gravitational-wave propagation. I. Formulation
• Signatures of $f(Q)$-gravity in cosmology
• Effective Field Theory of Dark Energy: a Review
• Modified gravitational-wave propagation and standard sirens
• Speed of Gravitational Waves and the Fate of Scalar-Tensor Gravity
• Black holes and binary mergers in scalar Gauss-Bonnet gravity: scalar field dynamics
• Galileon Gravity in Light of ISW, CMB, BAO and $H_0$ data
• Dark Energy in light of Multi-Messenger Gravitational-Wave astronomy
• hi_class: Horndeski in the Cosmic Linear Anisotropy Solving System
• Probing the theory of gravity with gravitational lensing of gravitational waves and galaxy surveys
• Generalized framework for testing gravity with gravitational-wave propagation. II. Constraints on Horndeski theory
• Strong gravitational lensing of explosive transients
• Nonlocal gravity. Conceptual aspects and cosmological predictions
• Limits on the number of spacetime dimensions from GW170817
• Precise predictions for V+jets dark matter backgrounds
• Gravitational Wave Decay into Dark Energy
• Vainshtein mechanism after GW170817
• Brane-world extra dimensions in light of GW170817
• Dark energy, $\alpha$-attractors, and large-scale structure surveys
• Is Local $H_0$ At Odds With Dark Energy EFT?
• The Observational Future of Cosmological Scalar-Tensor Theories
• On the road to percent accuracy: nonlinear reaction of the matter power spectrum to dark energy and modified gravity
• Vainshtein Screening in Scalar-Tensor Theories before and after GW170817: Constraints on Theories beyond Horndeski
• Gravitational Waves in Modified Teleparallel Theories
• What can Cosmology tell us about Gravity? Constraining Horndeski with Sigma and Mu
• Parameterized Post-Einsteinian Gravitational Waveforms in Various Modified Theories of Gravity
• Propagation of gravitational waves in symmetric teleparallel gravity theories
• Velocity correction for Hubble constant measurements from standard sirens
• Alive and well: mimetic gravity and a higher-order extension in light of GW170817
• Gravity in the Era of Equality: Towards solutions to the Hubble problem without fine-tuned initial conditions
• On the merger rate of primordial black holes: effects of nearest neighbours distribution and clustering
• Mimicking dark matter and dark energy in a mimetic model compatible with GW170817
• Self-accelerating universe in scalar-tensor theories after GW170817
• The Science of the Einstein Telescope
• Testing the general theory of relativity using gravitational wave propagation from dark standard sirens
• Cosmology and dark energy from joint gravitational wave-GRB observations
• Cosmological parameter constraints for Horndeski scalar-tensor gravity
• The Novel Probes Project -- Tests of Gravity on Astrophysical Scales
• Dark energy after GW170817, revisited
• Spontaneous scalarization in generalised scalar-tensor theory
• Unraveling the effective fluid approach for $f(R)$ models in the subhorizon approximation
• Cosmological Constraints on Horndeski Gravity in Light of GW170817
• Parity-violating gravity and GW170817
• Quasi-normal modes of black holes in Horndeski gravity
• Weak Field Limit and Gravitational Waves in $f(T,B)$ Teleparallel Gravity
• Measurements of $H_0$ in modified gravity theories: The role of lensed quasars in the late-time Universe
• Weak and strong deflection gravitational lensings by a charged Horndeski black hole
• Cosmological constraints on post-Newtonian parameters in effectively massless scalar-tensor theories of gravity
• Testing the theory of gravity with DESI: estimators, predictions and simulation requirements
• Constraints on scalar-tensor theory of gravity by the recent observational results on gravitational waves
• Multi-messenger tests of gravity with weakly lensed gravitational waves
• On the road to percent accuracy IV: ReACT -- computing the non-linear power spectrum beyond $\Lambda$CDM
• Analysis of the Yukawa gravitational potential in $f(R)$ gravity II: relativistic periastron advance
• Breaking degeneracies in modified gravity with higher (than 2nd) order weak-lensing statistics
• Large-scale structure phenomenology of viable Horndeski theories
• Cosmology and modified gravitational wave propagation from binary black hole population models
• Hamiltonian vs stability and application to Horndeski theory
• Testing the equivalence principle on cosmological scales
• Mapping nonlinear gravity into General Relativity with nonlinear electrodynamics
• hi_class: Background Evolution, Initial Conditions and Approximation Schemes
• Scalar-field dark energy nonminimally and kinetically coupled to dark matter
• Model-independent reconstruction of the linear anisotropic stress $\eta$
• KiDS+2dFLenS+GAMA: Testing the cosmological model with the $E_{\mathrm{G}}$ statistic
• Propagation of gravitational waves in teleparallel gravity theories
• Gravitational Waves in $F(R)$ Gravity: Scalar Waves and the Chameleon Mechanism
• Propagation of the gravitational waves in a cosmological background
• GW170817/GRB 170817A/AT2017gfo association: some implications for physics and astrophysics
• Void Lensing as a Test of Gravity
• A correspondence between modified gravity and General Relativity with scalar fields
• Dark energy beyond quintessence: Constraints from the swampland
• Dark degeneracy I: Dynamical or interacting dark energy?
• Speed of gravitational waves and black hole hair
• Stealth Schwarzschild solution in shift symmetry breaking theories
• Constraints on Born-Infeld gravity from the speed of gravitational waves after GW170817 and GRB 170817A
• Dark energy scenario consistent with GW170817 in theories beyond Horndeski gravity
• Positivity Bounds on Dark Energy: When Matter Matters
• Gaussian processes reconstruction of modified gravitational wave propagation
• Realistic simulations of galaxy formation in f(R) modified gravity
• Matter Power Spectrum Emulator for f(R) Modified Gravity Cosmologies
• Gravitational wave constraints on dark sector models
• Designing Horndeski and the effective fluid approach
• One Hundred Years of the Cosmological Constant: from 'Superfluous Stunt' to Dark Energy
• The road ahead of Horndeski: cosmology of surviving scalar-tensor theories
• Measuring the propagation speed of gravitational waves with LISA
• Finding Horndeski theories with Einstein gravity limits
• Cosmological constraints on dark energy in light of gravitational wave bounds
• Minimum main sequence mass in quadratic Palatini $f(\mathcal{R})$ gravity
• A search for an optical counterpart to the gravitational wave event GW151226
• Binary neutron star mergers: Effects of spin and post-merger dynamics
• Splashback in galaxy clusters as a probe of cosmic expansion and gravity
• Gravity in the infrared and effective nonlocal models
• Cosmology with Standard Sirens at Cosmic Noon
• The Well-Tempered Cosmological Constant
• Unified Dark Energy and Dark Matter from Dynamical Space Time
• Neutron star merger GW170817 strongly constrains doubly coupled bigravity
• Optimising growth of structure constraints on modified gravity
• Scalar perturbations on the background of Kerr black holes in the quadratic dynamical Chern-Simons gravity
• Reconstructing Horndeski theories from phenomenological modified gravity and dark energy models on cosmological scales
• Effective field theory for gravitational radiation in scalar-tensor gravity
• Scalar and tensor gravitational waves
• Standard Sirens as a novel probe of dark energy
• Constraints on $f(R)$ theories of gravity from GW170817
• A parametrisation of modified gravity on nonlinear cosmological scales
• Constraints on cosmological viscosity and self interacting dark matter from gravitational wave observations
• The modified gravity lightcone simulation project I: Statistics of matter and halo distributions
• Horndeski gravity and standard sirens
• Doppelgänger dark energy: modified gravity with non-universal couplings after GW170817
• Primordial gravitational waves in Horndeski gravity
• Measuring gravity at cosmological scales
• Fast and accurate predictions of the nonlinear matter power spectrum for general models of Dark Energy and Modified Gravity
• Gravitational waves in non-local gravity
• Landau damping for gravitational waves in parity-violating theories
• Behind Horndeski: Structurally Robust Higher Derivative EFTs
• Reconstructing Horndeski models from the effective field theory of dark energy
• Compact objects in scalar-tensor theories after GW170817
• An accurate perturbative approach to redshift space clustering of biased tracers in modified gravity
• Gravitational waves and geometrical optics in scalar-tensor theories
• Nonlocal gravity and gravitational-wave observations
• Cosmography with next-generation gravitational wave detectors
• Non-standard gravitational waves imply gravitational slip: on the difficulty of partially hiding new gravitational degrees of freedom
• On the screening mechanism in DHOST theories evading gravitational wave constraints
• Early evolutionary tracks of low-mass stellar objects in modified gravity
• Testing gravitational wave propagation with multiband detections
• Probing cosmological fields with gravitational wave oscillations
• Machine learning forecasts of the cosmic distance duality relation with strongly lensed gravitational wave events
• Probing lens-induced gravitational-wave birefringence as a test of general relativity
• Non-Abelian $S$-term dark energy and inflation
• Matter bispectrum beyond Horndeski
• Cosmology with the Einstein Telescope: No Slip Gravity Model and Redshift Specifications
• Limitations on Standard Sirens tests of gravity from screening
• Absorption by black hole remnants in metric-affine gravity
• Vector disformal transformation of generalized Proca theory
• General formulation of cosmological perturbations in scalar-tensor dark energy coupled to dark matter
• Hunting the stochastic gravitational wave background in pulsar timing array cross correlations through theoretical uncertainty
• Inflation from a nonlinear magnetic monopole field nonminimally coupled to curvature
• Learning how to surf: Reconstructing the propagation and origin of gravitational waves with Gaussian Processes
• Axial quasi-normal modes of scalarized neutron stars with massive self-interacting scalar field
• New constraints on cosmological modified gravity theories from anisotropic three-point correlation functions of BOSS DR12 galaxies
• Gravitational Waves in Higher Order Teleparallel Gravity
• Spatially covariant gravity: Perturbative analysis and field transformations
• $\text{Hi-COLA}$: Fast, approximate simulations of structure formation in Horndeski gravity
• Comparison of different approaches to the quasi-static approximation in Horndeski models
• Well-tempered teleparallel Horndeski cosmology: a teleparallel variation to the cosmological constant problem
• New general parametrization of quintessence fields and its observational constraints
• Forecasts for Low Spin Black Hole Spectroscopy in Horndeski Gravity
• Dark energy in scalar-vector-tensor theories
• Suppressed cosmic growth in coupled vector-tensor theories
• Constraining the propagation speed of gravitational waves with compact binaries at cosmological distances
• Boson stars in Palatini $f(\mathcal{R})$ gravity
• Scalar Fields Near Compact Objects: Resummation versus UV Completion
• Probing Palatini-type gravity theories through gravitational wave detections via quasinormal modes
• Lunar Laser Ranging constraints on nonminimally coupled dark energy and standard sirens
• Testing gravity with cosmic variance-limited pulsar timing array correlations
• Inherently stable effective field theory for dark energy and modified gravity
• Observational Constraints in Nonlocal Gravity: the Deser-Woodard Case
• Probing the speed of gravity with LVK, LISA, and joint observations
• Gravitational-wave cosmological distances in scalar-tensor theories of gravity
• Quasi-normal modes of massless scalar fields for charged black holes in the Palatini-type gravity
• Modelling the matter bispectrum at small scales in modified gravity
• Modified gravitational wave propagation and the binary neutron star mass function
• Cosmic structures and gravitational waves in ghost-free scalar-tensor theories of gravity
• New scaling solutions in cubic Horndeski theories
• Constraints on decaying early modified gravity from cosmological observations
• Gravity in mimetic scalar-tensor theories after GW170817
• The arbitrariness of potentials in interacting quintessence models
• Quasi-Normal Modes of Hairy Scalar Tensor Black Holes: Odd Parity
• Infrared modified gravity with propagating torsion: instability of torsionfull de Sitter-like solutions
• Searching for modified gravity in the astrophysical gravitational wave background: Application to ground-based interferometers
• Stealth black holes in shift symmetric kinetic gravity braiding
• Most general cubic-order Horndeski Lagrangian allowing for scaling solutions and the application to dark energy
• Well-Tempered Cosmology
• Parametrizations for tests of gravity
• Superradiant energy extraction from rotating hairy Horndeski black holes
• Testing the Speed of Gravity with Black Hole Ringdown
• Constraining Horndeski theory with gravitational waves from coalescing binaries
• Phantom crossing dark energy in Horndeski's theory
• Horndeski stars
• Constraining DHOST theories with linear growth of matter density fluctuations
• Radiative stability and observational constraints on dark energy and modified gravity
• Cosmology in Minkowski space
• Limited Modified Gravity
• Probing modified gravitational-wave propagation with extreme mass-ratio inspirals
• Cosmological Probes of Structure Growth and Tests of Gravity
• Constraints on $f(R)$ and nDGP Modified Gravity Model Parameters with Cluster Abundances and Galaxy Clustering
• The two-body potential of Vainshtein screened theories
• Constraints from growth-rate data on some coupled dark energy models mimicking a $\Lambda CDM$ expansion
• Cosmology with subdominant Horndeski scalar field
• Quasi-normal Modes of Static Spherically Symmetric Black Holes in $f(R)$ Theory
• Parameterised post-Newtonian formalism for the effective field theory of dark energy via screened reconstructed Horndeski theories
• Testing gravity with gravitational wave friction and gravitational slip
• Relativistic stars in a cubic Galileon Universe
• Do Solar System experiments constrain scalar-tensor gravity?
• Cosmological evolution of viable models in the generalized scalar-tensor theory
• Cosmologically viable generalized Einstein-Aether theories
• Gauge-ready formulation of cosmological perturbations in scalar-vector-tensor theories
• Two new approaches to the anomalous limit of Brans-Dicke to Einstein gravity
• G-inflation: From the intermediate, logamediate and exponential models
• Horndeski dark matter and beyond
• Dark energy loopholes some time after GW170817
• Geometry of Multi-Flavor Galileon-Like Theories
• A minimal self tuning model to solve the cosmological constant problem
• A local self-tuning mechanism for the cosmological constant
• Dark sector evolution in Horndeski models
• A robust cosmic standard ruler from the cross-correlations of galaxies and dark sirens
• Comparing the luminosity distance for gravitational waves and electromagnetic signals in a simple model of quadratic gravity
• Transformation of Primordial Cosmological Perturbations Under the General Extended Disformal Transformation
• Probing modified gravitational-wave propagation through tidal measurements of binary neutron star mergers
• The kinematic Sunyaev-Zel'dovich effect of the large-scale structure (II): the effect of modified gravity
• Interpretation of geodesy experiments in non-Newtonian theories of gravity
• Constraints on Scalar-Tensor Theory of Gravity by Solar System Tests
• Einstein-Cartan-Dirac gravity with $U(1)$ symmetry breaking
• No Run Gravity
• Positivity bounds on reconstructed Horndeski models
• Jointly fitting weak lensing, X-ray and Sunyaev-Zel'dovich data to constrain scalar-tensor theories with clusters of galaxies
• Imprint of Early Dark Energy in Stochastic Gravitational Wave Background
• Modified gravity as a diagravitational medium
• Late-time acceleration by a residual cosmological constant from sequestering vacuum energy in ultimate collapsed structures
• The effect of screening mechanisms on black hole binary inspiral waveforms
• The Effective Fluid approach for Modified Gravity and its applications
• Gravitational couplings in Chameleon models
• Functors of actions
• Self-tuning kinetic gravity braiding: Cosmological dynamics, shift symmetry, and the tadpole
• Horndeski theories and beyond from higher dimensions
• Is there another coincidence problem at the reionization epoch?
• Hair-dressing Horndeski: an approach to hairy solutions in cubic Horndeski gravity
• A model-independent tripartite test of cosmic distance relations
• Stealth black hole perturbations in kinetic gravity braiding
• A new test of gravity -- I: Introduction to the method
• Screening and degenerate kinetic self-acceleration from the nonlinear freedom of reconstructed Horndeski theories
• On tachyonic stability priors for dark energy
• A novel probe of graviton dispersion relations at nano-Hertz frequencies
• Cosmology with LIGO/Virgo dark sirens: Hubble parameter and modified gravitational wave propagation
• Constraints on higher curvature gravity from time delay between GW170817 and GRB 170817A
• Graviton-photon oscillation in alternative theories of gravity
• Strong Equivalence Principle and Gravitational Wave Polarizations in Horndeski Theory
• Reconstruction of $f(R)$ lagrangian from a massive scalar field
• Gravitational wave signatures from dark sector interactions
• Testing Horndeski gravity as dark matter with $\texttt{hi_class}$
• Accelerating the standard siren method: Improved constraints on modified gravitational-wave propagation with future data
• Does nonlocal gravity yield divergent gravitational energy-momentum fluxes?
• Gravitational Wave luminosity distance in viscous cosmological models
• The speed of gravitational waves and power-law solutions in a scalar-tensor model
• The effective field theory of dark energy diagnostic of linear Horndeski theories after GW170817 and GRB170817A
• Damping of gravitational waves in f(R) gravity
• Dynamical evolution of electromagnetic perturbation in the background of a scalar hairy black hole in Horndeski theory
• Precession shift in curvature based Extended Theories of Gravity and Quintessence fields
• Modified propagation of gravitational waves from the early radiation era
• Oscillating solutions of the matter density contrast in Horndeski's theory
• Compact scalar field solutions in EiBI gravity
• The gyroscopic frequency of metric $f(R)$ and generalised Brans-Dicke theories: constraints from Gravity Probe-B
• Cosmological Dynamics and Double Screening of DBI Galileon Gravity
• Vainshtein screening in Horndeski theories nonminimally and kinetically coupled to ordinary matter
• Quasilocal mass and multipole expansion in scalar-tensor gravity
• Generalized Galileon Scenario Inspires Chaotic Inflation
• Eikonal gravitational-wave lensing in Einstein-aether theory
• Gravitational wave propagation beyond general relativity: waveform distortions and echoes
• Cosmic evolution in DHOST theories with scaling solutions
• Horndeski model in nonlinearly realized supergravity
• Infrared Sensitivity of Cosmological Probes in Horndeski Theory
• Stable Islands of Weak Gravity
• An ostentatious model of cosmological scalar-tensor theory
• Simulation Study on Constraining GW Propagation Speed by GW and GRB Joint Observation on Binary Neutron Star Mergers
• An effective fluid description of scalar-vector-tensor theories under the sub-horizon and quasi-static approximations
• Testing No slip model with pulsar timing arrays: NANOGrav and IPTA
• Scalar Cherenkov radiation from high-energy cosmic rays
• Multiple-scale analysis of modified gravitational-wave propagation
• Probing modified gravitational wave propagation with strongly lensed coalescing binaries