Hamiltonian vs stability and application to Horndeski theory
arXiv:1803.11444 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.98.104050
Abstract
A Hamiltonian density bounded from below implies that the lowest-energy state is stable. We point out, contrary to common lore, that an unbounded Hamiltonian density does not necessarily imply an instability: Stability is indeed a coordinate-independent property, whereas the Hamiltonian density does depend on the choice of coordinates. We discuss in detail the relation between the two, starting from k-essence and extending our discussion to general field theories. We give the correct stability criterion, using the relative orientation of the causal cones for all propagating degrees of freedom. We then apply this criterion to an exact Schwarzschild-de Sitter solution of a beyond-Horndeski theory, while taking into account the recent experimental constraint regarding the speed of gravitational waves. We extract the spin-2 and spin-0 causal cones by analyzing respectively all the odd-parity and the even-parity modes. Contrary to a claim in the literature, we prove that this solution does not exhibit any kinetic instability for a given range of parameters defining the theory.
arXiv comment32 pages, 2 figures; v2: covariant writing of the stability criterion added in Eqs. (10)-(12)
References in corpus (79)
- Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger
- GW170817: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Neutron Star Inspiral
- Modified Gravity and Cosmology
- The Confrontation between General Relativity and Experiment
- Gravitational Waves and Gamma-rays from a Binary Neutron Star Merger: GW170817 and GRB 170817A
- 4D Gravity on a Brane in 5D Minkowski Space
- Quantum Gravity at a Lifshitz Point
- k-Inflation
- The galileon as a local modification of gravity
- Essentials of k-essence
- Kinetically Driven Quintessence
- Massive Gravity
- From k-essence to generalised Galileons
- Covariant Galileon
- Dark Energy after GW170817: dead ends and the road ahead
- Strong constraints on cosmological gravity from GW170817 and GRB 170817A
- Dark Energy after GW170817 and GRB170817A
- Implications of the Neutron Star Merger GW170817 for Cosmological Scalar-Tensor Theories
- Healthy theories beyond Horndeski
- Generalized Galileons: All scalar models whose curved background extensions maintain second-order field equations and stress tensors
- Imperfect Dark Energy from Kinetic Gravity Braiding
- Degenerate higher derivative theories beyond Horndeski: evading the Ostrogradski instability
- Transforming gravity: from derivative couplings to matter to second-order scalar-tensor theories beyond the Horndeski Lagrangian
- Classical and Quantum Consistency of the DGP Model
- Exploring gravitational theories beyond Horndeski
- k-Essence, superluminal propagation, causality and emergent geometry
- Gravitating Non-Abelian Solitons and Black Holes with Yang-Mills Fields
- Dressing a black hole with a time-dependent Galileon
- Degenerate higher order scalar-tensor theories beyond Horndeski up to cubic order
- Extended Scalar-Tensor Theories of Gravity
- Generalization of the Proca Action
- Breaking a Dark Degeneracy with Gravitational Waves
- Degenerate higher order scalar-tensor theories beyond Horndeski and disformal transformations
- Black holes with non-minimal derivative coupling
- Challenges to Self-Acceleration in Modified Gravity from Gravitational Waves and Large-Scale Structure
- DBI and the Galileon reunited
- Cosmic Acceleration from Abelian Symmetry Breaking
- Disformal invariance of second order tensor-scalar theories: framing the Horndeski action
- Asymptotically locally AdS and flat black holes in Horndeski theory
- Arbitrary p-form Galileons
- Field-theoretical formulations of MOND-like gravity
- Hamiltonian analysis of higher derivative scalar-tensor theories
- A formal introduction to Horndeski and Galileon theories and their generalizations
- Black hole perturbation in the most general scalar-tensor theory with second-order field equations I: The odd-parity sector
- Black hole perturbation in the most general scalar-tensor theory with second-order field equations II: the even-parity sector
- Black holes and stars in Horndeski theory
- Healthy degenerate theories with higher derivatives
- On causality and superluminal behavior in classical field theories. Applications to k-essence theories and MOND-like theories of gravity
- Universal Field Equations with Covariant Solutions D.B. Fairlie
- Horndeski: beyond, or not beyond?
- Solutions in the scalar-tensor theory with nonminimal derivative coupling
- Third order equations of motion and the Ostrogradsky instability
- The Paths of Gravity in Galileon Cosmology
- Ostrogradsky in Theories with Multiple Fields
- Counting the degrees of freedom of generalized Galileons
- Stability of a black hole and the speed of gravity waves within self-tuning cosmological models
- Escaping from the black hole?
- Hamiltonian structure of scalar-tensor theories beyond Horndeski
- Neutron stars in Horndeski gravity
- Black Holes and Abelian Symmetry Breaking
- Time-dependent spherically symmetric covariant Galileons
- Cosmological self-tuning and local solutions in generalized Horndeski theories
- Euler Hierarchies and Universal Equations
- Instability of hairy black holes in shift-symmetric Horndeski theories
- Solutions in the generalized Proca theory with the nonminimal coupling to the Einstein tensor
- Black holes in a cubic Galileon universe
- Black holes and solitons in an extended Proca theory
- Gravity and Scalar Fields
- Universal Field Equations with Reparametrisation Invariance
- Self tuning scalar tensor black holes
- Instability of a four-dimensional de Sitter black hole with a conformally coupled scalar field
- Linear perturbation analysis of hairy black holes in shift-symmetric Horndeski theories: Odd-parity perturbations
- Black hole perturbations in vector-tensor theories: The odd-mode analysis
- Holographic self-tuning of the cosmological constant
- Black holes in quartic-order beyond-generalized Proca theories
- Cosmic structures and gravitational waves in ghost-free scalar-tensor theories of gravity
- Black hole stability under odd-parity perturbations in Horndeski gravity
- Universal instability of hairy black holes in Lovelock-Galileon theories in D dimensions
- From Lovelock to Horndeski's generalised scalar-tensor theory
Cited by in corpus (53)
- Horndeski theory and beyond: a review
- Rotating Black Holes in Higher Order Gravity
- Perturbations of Stealth Black Holes in DHOST Theories
- Constraints on scalar-tensor theory of gravity by the recent observational results on gravitational waves
- Exact black hole solutions in shift-symmetric quadratic degenerate higher-order scalar-tensor theories
- Linear stability analysis of hairy black holes in quadratic degenerate higher-order scalar-tensor theories: Odd-parity perturbations
- Weakly-coupled stealth solution in scordatura degenerate theory
- Hairy black holes in DHOST theories: Exploring disformal transformation as a solution-generating method
- General Relativity solutions with stealth scalar hair in quadratic higher-order scalar-tensor theories
- Disforming the Kerr metric
- Black holes with primary scalar hair
- Existence and Instability of Novel Hairy Black Holes in Shift-symmetric Horndeski Theories
- Quasinormal modes and grey-body factors of regular black holes with a scalar hair from the Effective Field Theory
- Black hole perturbations in DHOST theories: Master variables, gradient instability, and strong coupling
- Destabilization of black holes and stars by generalized Proca fields
- Nonlinear definition of the shadowy mode in higher-order scalar-tensor theories
- Black hole perturbations in modified gravity
- Spherical inhomogeneous solutions of Einstein and scalar-tensor gravity: a map of the land
- Quasinormal Modes from EFT of Black Hole Perturbations with Timelike Scalar Profile
- Gravitational Collapse in Cubic Horndeski Theories
- Generalized Regge-Wheeler Equation from Effective Field Theory of Black Hole Perturbations with a Timelike Scalar Profile
- Perturbations and quasi-normal modes of black holes with time-dependent scalar hair in shift-symmetric scalar-tensor theories
- Circular orbits and accretion process in a class of Horndeski/Galileon black holes
- Square Peg in a Circular Hole: Choosing the Right Ansatz for Isolated Black Holes in Generic Gravitational Theories
- Linear stability of black holes in shift-symmetric Horndeski theories with a time-independent scalar field
- Perturbations of a rotating black hole in DHOST theories
- Deformed black hole in Sagittarius A
- Instability of vectorized stars
- Tidal Love Numbers from EFT of Black Hole Perturbations with Timelike Scalar Profile
- The sound of DHOST
- Stability of Hairy Black Holes in Shift-Symmetric Scalar-Tensor Theories via the Effective Field Theory Approach
- Linear perturbations of Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet black holes
- On the effective metric of axial black hole perturbations in DHOST gravity
- Approximately stealth black hole in higher-order scalar-tensor theories
- Stealth black holes in shift symmetric kinetic gravity braiding
- Black hole perturbations in higher-order scalar-tensor theories: initial value problem and dynamical stability
- Functors of actions
- Critical collapse in K-essence models
- Emergence of ghosts in Horndeski theory
- Black hole ringdown from physically sensible initial value problem in higher-order scalar-tensor theories
- Black holes in self-tuning cubic Horndeski cosmology
- Stealth black hole perturbations in kinetic gravity braiding
- Rotating stealth black holes with a cohomogeneity-1 metric
- Causality and Stability from Acoustic Geometry
- Parametrized Tidal Dissipation Numbers of Non-rotating Black Holes
- A Critique of Covariant Emergent Gravity
- Static topological black hole with nonminimal derivative coupling and nonlinear electromagnetic field of Born-Infeld type
- Large black-hole scalar charges induced by cosmology in Horndeski theories
- Q-balls in K-field theory
- Linear instability of hairy black holes in Horndeski theory
- Domain walls without a potential
- Hamiltonian vs stability in alternative theories of gravity
- Cherenkov radiation as ghost instability