A Tale of Two Paradigms: the Mutual Incommensurability of LCDM and MOND
arXiv:1404.7525 · doi:10.1139/cjp-2014-0203
Abstract
The concordance model of cosmology, LCDM, provides a satisfactory description of the evolution of the universe and the growth of large scale structure. Despite considerable effort, this model does not at present provide a satisfactory description of small scale structure and the dynamics of bound objects like individual galaxies. In contrast, MOND provides a unique and predictively successful description of galaxy dynamics, but is mute on the subject of cosmology. Here I briefly review these contradictory world views, emphasizing the wealth of distinct, interlocking lines of evidence that went into the development of LCDM while highlighting the practical impossibility that it can provide a satisfactory explanation of the observed MOND phenomenology in galaxy dynamics. I also briefly review the baryon budget in groups and clusters of galaxies where neither paradigm provides an entirely satisfactory description of the data. Relatively little effort has been devoted to the formation of structure in MOND; I review some of what has been done. The amplitude ratio of the first to second peak in the CMB power spectrum was correctly predicted a priori, but the third peak is more natural to LCDM. MOND anticipates that structure forms more quickly than in LCDM. This motivated the prediction that reionization would happen earlier in MOND than originally expected in LCDM, as subsequently observed. This also provides a natural explanation for massive, early clusters of galaxies and large, empty voids. However, it is far from obvious that the mass spectrum of galaxy clusters or the power spectrum of galaxies can be explained in MOND, two things that LCDM does well. Critical outstanding issues are the development of an acceptable relativistic parent theory for MOND, and the reality of the non-baryonic dark matter of LCDM. Do suitable dark matter particles exist, or are they a modern aether?
arXiv commentImproved figure resolution; otherwise identical
References in corpus (84)
- Observational Evidence from Supernovae for an Accelerating Universe and a Cosmological Constant
- A Universal Density Profile from Hierarchical Clustering
- Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
- Final Results from the Hubble Space Telescope Key Project to Measure the Hubble Constant
- Discovery of a Supernova Explosion at Half the Age of the Universe and its Cosmological Implications
- A Flat Universe from High-Resolution Maps of the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation
- Relativistic gravitation theory for the MOND paradigm
- A 3% Solution: Determination of the Hubble Constant with the Hubble Space Telescope and Wide Field Camera 3
- Evidence for Reionization at z ~ 6: Detection of a Gunn-Peterson Trough in a z=6.28 Quasar
- Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND): Observational Phenomenology and Relativistic Extensions
- The Luminosity and Color Dependence of the Galaxy Correlation Function
- Modified Newtonian Dynamics as an Alternative to Dark Matter
- Concentration, Spin and Shape of Dark Matter Haloes as a Function of the Cosmological Model: WMAP1, WMAP3 and WMAP5 results
- Weak lensing mass reconstruction of the interacting cluster 1E0657-558: Direct evidence for the existence of dark matter
- The Baryon Census in a Multiphase Intergalactic Medium: 30% of the Baryons May Still Be Missing
- The Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation of Galaxies with Extended Rotation Curves and the Stellar Mass of Rotating Galaxies
- A direct dynamical measurement of the Milky Way's disk surface density profile, disk scale length, and dark matter profile at 4 kpc < R < 9 kpc
- The Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation of Gas Rich Galaxies as a Test of LCDM and MOND
- Lithium isotopic abundances in metal-poor halo stars
- A single low-energy, iron-poor supernova as the source of metals in the star SMSS J 031300.36-670839.3
- The Reionization of the Universe by the First Stars and Quasars
- A Bitter Pill: The Primordial Lithium Problem Worsens
- Mass Models for Low Surface Brightness Galaxies with High Resolution Optical Velocity Fields
- Testing the Dark Matter Hypothesis with Low Surface Brightness Galaxies and Other Evidence
- First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Interpretation of the TT and TE Angular Power Spectrum Peaks
- Large Scale Structure in Bekenstein's theory of relativistic Modified Newtonian Dynamics
- The Baryon Content of Cosmic Structures
- Revised Primordial Helium Abundance Based on New Atomic Data
- The speed of the `bullet' in the merging galaxy cluster 1E0657-56
- The Mass Discrepancy-Acceleration Relation: Disk Mass and the Dark Matter Distribution
- The dark matter crisis: falsification of the current standard model of cosmology
- First stars VII. Lithium in extremely metal poor dwarfs
- Clusters of galaxies with modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND)
- A substantial population of massive quiescent galaxies at z~4 from ZFOURGE
- A Novel Test of the Modified Newtonian Dynamics with Gas Rich Galaxies
- Testing the Hypothesis of Modified Dynamics with Low Surface Brightness Galaxies and Other Evidence
- On the Proof of Dark Matter, the Law of Gravity and the Mass of Neutrinos
- Review of Big Bang Nucleosynthesis and Primordial Abundances
- The Compression of Dark Matter Halos by Baryonic Infall
- The Deuterium to Hydrogen Abundance Ratio Towards the QSO SDSS1558-0031
- The local space density of Sb-Sdm galaxies as function of their scalesize, surface brightness and luminosity
- Testing Modified Newtonian Dynamics with Low Surface Brightness Galaxies --Rotation curve fits-
- A tensor-vector-scalar framework for modified dynamics and cosmic dark matter
- Tidal dwarf galaxies as a test of fundamental physics
- Local Group Dwarf Spheroidals: Correlated Deviations from the Baryonic Tully-Fisher Relation
- The Lithium Content of the Galactic Halo Stars
- Milky Way Mass Models and MOND
- Galaxies appear simpler than expected
- Can MOND take a bullet? Analytical comparisons of three versions of MOND beyond spherical symmetry
- X-ray Group and cluster mass profiles in MOND: Unexplained mass on the group scale
- Are sterile neutrinos consistent with clusters, the CMB and MOND?
- Bullet Cluster: A Challenge to LCDM Cosmology
- Andromeda Dwarfs in Light of MOND. II. Testing Prior Predictions
- The Real Problem with MOND
- Cosmology with Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND)
- Dwarf Spheroidals in MOND
- Galactic kinematics and dynamics from RAVE stars
- The failures of the standard model of cosmology require a new paradigm
- Dipolar Dark Matter and Dark Energy
- Andromeda Dwarfs in Light of MOND
- Cosmological Structure Formation under MOND: a new numerical solver for Poisson's equation
- MOND and the seven dwarfs
- Semi-Analytical Models for the Formation of Disk Galaxies II. Dark Matter versus Modified Newtonian Dynamics
- Modified Newtonian Dynamics of Large Scale Structure
- A Limit on the Cosmological Mass Density and Power Spectrum from the Rotation Curves of Low Surface Brightness Galaxies
- Constraining the NFW Potential with Observations and Modeling of LSB Galaxy Velocity Fields
- Neutrinos as cluster dark matter
- Distinguishing Between CDM and MOND: Predictions for the Microwave Background
- BOOMERanG Data Suggest a Purely Baryonic Universe
- How unusual are the Shapley Supercluster and the Sloan Great Wall?
- The formation of cosmic structure with modified Newtonian dynamics
- The abundance of galaxy clusters in MOND: Cosmological simulations with massive neutrinos
- Constraints on the Cosmic Structure Formation Models from Early Formation of Giant Galaxies
- Perseus I and the NGC 3109 association in the context of the Local Group dwarf galaxy structures
- The collision velocity of the bullet cluster in conventional and modified dynamics
- Confrontation of MOND Predictions with WMAP First Year Data
- Galactic kinematics with modified Newtonian dynamics
- Cosmological simulations in MOND: the cluster scale halo mass function with light sterile neutrinos
- Cosmology Solved? Quite Possibly!
- A Fast Route to Modified Gravitational Growth
- Galactic Halos in MONDian Cosmological Simulations
- Galaxy Cluster Bulk Flows and Collision Velocities in QUMOND
- The 21-cm Signal from the Cosmological Epoch of Recombination
- MOND in the Early Universe
Cited by in corpus (61)
- Small-Scale Challenges to the CDM Paradigm
- The Radial Acceleration Relation in Rotationally Supported Galaxies
- Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter
- One Law To Rule Them All: The Radial Acceleration Relation of Galaxies
- Indirect and direct search for dark matter
- The Planes of Satellite Galaxies Problem, Suggested Solutions, and Open Questions
- Intracluster light: a luminous tracer for dark matter in clusters of galaxies
- Testing the Strong Equivalence Principle: Detection of the External Field Effect in Rotationally Supported Galaxies
- A statistical investigation of the mass discrepancy-acceleration relation
- The origin of the mass discrepancy-acceleration relation in CDM
- Cosmology and Convention
- On the persistence of two small-scale problems in ΛCDM
- Status, Challenges and Directions in Indirect Dark Matter Searches
- Predictions and Outcomes for the Dynamics of Rotating Galaxies
- MOND vs. dark matter in light of historical parallels
- MOND Prediction for the Velocity Dispersion of the `Feeble Giant' Crater II
- MOND as a regime of quantum gravity
- The Third Law of Galactic Rotation
- Three problems about multi-scale modelling in cosmology
- The radial acceleration relation in a CDM universe
- Quantum Science and the Search for Axion Dark Matter
- Barred spiral galaxies in modified gravity theories
- Gravitational wave as probe of superfluid dark matter
- The Imprint of Spiral Arms on the Galactic Rotation Curve
- Phenomenology of Dark Matter via a Bimetric Extension of General Relativity
- Scale-Invariant Dynamics of Galaxies, MOND, Dark Matter, and the Dwarf Spheroidals
- Evolution Of Massive Black Hole Binaries In Rotating Stellar Nuclei: Implications For Gravitational Wave Detection
- Methodological Reflections on the MOND/Dark Matter Debate
- The candidate cluster and protocluster catalog (CCPC) of spectroscopically identified structures spanning
- Can Dark Matter be an artifact of extended theories of gravity?
- Fractional Scalar Field Cosmology
- Modified Dark Matter: Relating Dark Energy, Dark Matter and Baryonic Matter
- Strong Hydrogen Absorption at Cosmic Dawn: the Signature of a Baryonic Universe
- On the fundamentality of the radial acceleration relation for late-type galaxy dynamics
- Halo Acceleration Relation
- Boltzmann hierarchies for self-interacting warm dark matter scenarios
- Mass-Velocity Dispersion Relation in HIFLUGCS Galaxy Clusters
- Dark Matter in Fractional Gravity I: Astrophysical Tests on Galactic Scales
- Predictions for the sky-averaged depth of the 21cm absorption signal at high redshift in cosmologies with and without non-baryonic cold dark matter
- Integrating Dark Matter, Modified Gravity, and the Humanities
- Discord in Concordance Cosmology and Anomalously Massive Early Galaxies
- Modified general relativity
- Can CDM model reproduce MOND-like behavior?
- The Inefficiency of Genetic Programming for Symbolic Regression
- ΛCDM with baryons vs. MOND: the time evolution of the universal acceleration scale in the Magneticum simulations
- The Spectre of Underdetermination in Modern Cosmology
- Endowing with a dynamic nature: constraints in a spatially curved Universe
- Extreme parameter sensitivity in quasidilaton massive gravity
- On the problem of deformed spherical systems in Modified Newtonian Dynamics
- Quantum Effects on Cosmic Scales as an Alternative to Dark Matter and Dark Energy
- Thermal evolution of dark matter and gravitational-wave production in the early universe from a symplectic glueball model
- MOND and Methodology
- General relativity and cosmology
- The -model under test of the SPARC database
- Renzo's rule revisited: A statistical study of galaxies' baryon - dark matter coupling
- Embedding Cosmology and Gravity
- Refracted Gravity Solutions from Small to Large Scales
- A MOND model applied to the rotation curve of galaxies
- Modification of Newtonian Gravity: Implications for Hot Gas in Clusters and Galactic Angular Momentum
- Modified Newtonian dynamics and hadronic scales
- Bimetric MOND as a framework for variable- theories -- local systems and cosmology