Low-mass black holes as the remnants of primordial black hole formation
arXiv:1211.7082 · doi:10.1038/ncomms2314
Abstract
This article documents our ongoing search for the elusive "intermediate-mass" black holes. These would bridge the gap between the approximately ten solar mass "stellar-mass" black holes that are the end-product of the life of a massive star, and the "supermassive" black holes with masses of millions to billions of solar masses found at the centers of massive galaxies. The discovery of black holes with intermediate mass is the key to understanding whether supermassive black holes can grow from stellar-mass black holes, or whether a more exotic process accelerated their growth only hundreds of millions of years after the Big Bang. Here we focus on searches for black holes with masses of 10^4-10^6 solar masses that are found at galaxy centers. We will refer to black holes in this mass range as "low-mass" black holes, since they are at the low-mass end of supermassive black holes. We review the searches for low-mass black holes to date and show tentative evidence, from the number of low-mass black holes that are discovered today in small galaxies, that the progenitors of supermassive black holes were formed as ten thousand to one-hundred thousand solar mass black holes via the direct collapse of gas.
arXiv comment9 pages, 4 figures. To appear in Nature Communications in a final refereed form
References in corpus (93)
- The Sloan Digital Sky Survey: Technical Summary
- The Host Galaxies of AGN
- The slope of the black-hole mass versus velocity dispersion correlation
- The Optical and Near-Infrared Properties of Galaxies: I. Luminosity and Stellar Mass Functions
- How Massive Single Stars End their Life
- Monitoring stellar orbits around the Massive Black Hole in the Galactic Center
- Gasdynamics and Starbursts in Major Mergers
- On the Black Hole Mass - Bulge Mass Relation
- Measuring Distance and Properties of the Milky Way's Central Supermassive Black Hole with Stellar Orbits
- A luminous quasar at a redshift of z = 7.085
- A Search for "Dwarf" Seyfert Nuclei. III. Spectroscopic Parameters and Properties of the Host Galaxies
- Nuclear Activity in Nearby Galaxies
- A Survey of z>5.8 Quasars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey I: Discovery of Three New Quasars and the Spatial Density of Luminous Quasars at z~6
- Formation of Supermassive Black Holes by Direct Collapse in Pregalactic Halos
- Formation of Supermassive Black Holes
- The formation of massive black holes through collision runaway in dense young star clusters
- Intrinsic disc emission and the Soft X-ray Excess in AGN
- A relativistic jetted outburst from a massive black hole fed by a tidally disrupted star
- The Chandra Deep Field-South Survey: 4 Ms Source Catalogs
- Optical Flares from the Tidal Disruption of Stars by Massive Black Holes
- An Intermediate-mass Black Hole of Over 500 Solar Masses in the Galaxy ESO 243-49
- The First Galaxies
- Supermassive black hole formation during the assembly of pre-galactic discs
- An ultraviolet-optical flare from the tidal disruption of a helium-rich stellar core
- Rates of tidal disruption of stars by massive central black holes
- A New Sample of Low-mass Black Holes in Active Galaxies
- Consequences of gravitational radiation recoil
- A Low-Mass Central Black Hole in the Bulgeless Seyfert 1 Galaxy NGC 4395
- The evolution of massive black hole seeds
- Multiwavelength Monitoring of the Dwarf Seyfert 1 Galaxy NGC 4395. I. A Reverberation-Based Measurement of the Black Hole Mass
- Active Galactic Nuclei with Candidate Intermediate-Mass Black Holes
- Missing Link Found? --- The ``runaway'' path to supermassive black holes
- Formation of the first nuclear clusters and massive black holes at high redshift
- Formation of z ~ 6 quasars from hierarchical galaxy mergers
- The Mass Function of Active Black Holes in the Local Universe
- An Intermediate-Mass Black Hole in the Globular Cluster G1: Improved Significance from New Keck and Hubble Space Telescope Observations
- POX 52: A Dwarf Seyfert 1 Galaxy With An Intermediate-Mass Black Hole
- The Megamaser Cosmology Project. III. Accurate Masses of Seven Supermassive Black Holes in Active Galaxies with Circumnuclear Megamaser Disks
- Supermassive black holes do not correlate with galaxy disks or pseudobulges
- Fluctuations in the High-Redshift Lyman-Werner Background: Close Halo Pairs as the Origin of Supermassive Black Holes
- Precise Black Hole Masses From Megamaser Disks: Black Hole-Bulge Relations at Low Mass
- M33: A Galaxy with No Supermassive Black Hole
- An actively accreting massive black hole in the dwarf starburst galaxy Henize 2-10
- The black hole mass -- stellar velocity dispersion correlation: bulges versus pseudobulges
- New Limits on an Intermediate Mass Black Hole in Omega Centauri: II. Dynamical Models
- Inspiralling Supermassive Black Holes: A New Signpost for Galaxy Mergers
- Untangling the merger history of massive black holes with LISA
- The NGC 404 Nucleus: Star Cluster and Possible Intermediate Mass Black Hole
- Accretion onto Seed Black Holes in the First Galaxies
- Dwarf Seyfert 1 Nuclei and the Low-Mass End of the M-sigma Relation
- The Low End of the Supermassive Black Hole Mass Function: Constraining the Mass of a Nuclear Black Hole in NGC 205 via Stellar Kinematics
- VLT Kinematics for omega Centauri: Further Support for a Central Black Hole
- Evidence for a Supermassive Black Hole in the S0 Galaxy NGC 3245
- Spitzer Uncovers Active Galactic Nuclei Missed by Optical Surveys in 7 Late-type Galaxies
- The Dark Matter Density Profile of the Fornax Dwarf
- The First Galaxies: Assembly with Black Hole Feedback
- AMUSE-Virgo II. Down-sizing in black hole accretion
- The Discovery of an Active Galactic Nucleus in the Late-type Galaxy NGC 3621: Spitzer Spectroscopic Observations
- Massive black holes lurking in Milky Way satellites
- The UV Continuum of Quasars: Models and SDSS Spectral Slopes
- A Uniformly Selected Sample of Low-mass Black Holes in Seyfert 1 Galaxies
- The Radio Quiescence of Active Galaxies with High Accretion Rates
- Hubble Space Telescope Evidence for an Intermediate-Mass Black Hole in the Globular Cluster M15: I. STIS Spectroscopy and WFPC2 Photometry
- The Host Galaxy and Central Engine of the Dwarf AGN POX 52
- Density and kinematic cusps in M54 at the heart of the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy: evidence for a 10^4 M_sun Black Hole?
- A census of X-ray nuclear activity in nearby galaxies
- Supermassive Black Holes and the Evolution of Galaxies
- Massive black hole remnants of the first stars in galactic haloes
- X-ray Properties of Intermediate-mass Black Holes in Active Galaxies
- Active galactic nuclei in four metal-poor dwarf emission-line galaxies
- Are nuclear star clusters the precursors of massive black holes?
- Dynamical Constraints on The Masses of the Nuclear Star Cluster and Black Hole in the Late-Type Spiral Galaxy NGC 3621
- Low-Mass Seyfert 2 Galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
- The Incidence of Active Galactic Nuclei in Pure Disk Galaxies: The Spitzer View
- Towards a Complete Census of AGNs in Nearby Galaxies: The Incidence of Growing Black Holes
- A Young Massive Stellar Population Around the Intermediate Mass Black Hole ESO 243-49 HLX-1
- The absence of radio emission from the globular cluster G1
- Radio Emission on Sub-Parsec Scales from the Intermediate-Mass Black Hole in NGC 4395
- X-ray Properties of Intermediate-Mass Black Holes in Active Galaxies. II. X-ray-Bright Accretion and Possible Evidence for Slim Disks
- A Redshift for the Intermediate Mass Black Hole Candidate HLX-1: Confirmation of its Association with the Galaxy ESO 243-49
- Broad Band Photometric Reverberation Mapping of NGC 4395
- Evidence for an intermediate mass black hole and a multi-zone warm absorber in NGC 4395
- AMUSE-Field I: Nuclear X-ray Properties of Local Field and Group Spheroids across the Stellar Mass Scale
- Physical Properties of the Narrow-Line Region of Low-Mass Active Galaxies
- An upper limit to the velocity dispersion of relaxed stellar systems without massive black holes
- Upper Limits on Central Black Hole Masses of Globular Clusters from Radio Emission and a Possible Black Hole Detection in the Ursa Minor Dwarf Galaxy
- Low-Level Nuclear Activity in Nearby Spiral Galaxies
- Evidence for Black Hole Growth in Local Analogs to Lyman Break Galaxies
- A New Sample of Candidate Intermediate-Mass Black Holes Selected by X-ray Variability
- A search for AGN in the most extreme UV-selected starbursts using the European VLBI Network
- An upper limit on the mass of the black hole in Ursa Minor dwarf galaxy
- Ultraluminous X-ray Sources Powered by Radiatively Efficient Two-Phased Super-Eddington Accretion onto Stellar Mass Black holes
- The Candidate Intermediate-Mass Black Hole in the Globular Cluster M54
Cited by in corpus (135)
- Coevolution (Or Not) of Supermassive Black Holes and Host Galaxies
- Primordial Black Holes as Dark Matter
- Intermediate-Mass Black Holes
- Dwarf Galaxies with Optical Signatures of Active Massive Black Holes
- Massive Primordial Black Holes from Hybrid Inflation as Dark Matter and the seeds of Galaxies
- Tidal Disruption Events
- Formation of the First Stars
- Observational evidence for intermediate-mass black holes
- A Supermassive Black Hole in an Ultracompact Dwarf Galaxy
- The origins of massive black holes
- Planck stars
- Blossoms from black hole seeds: properties and early growth regulated by supernova feedback
- Intermediate-mass black holes in dwarf galaxies out to redshift 2.4 in the Chandra COSMOS Legacy Survey
- Swift J1644+57 gone MAD: the case for dynamically-important magnetic flux threading the black hole in a jetted tidal disruption event
- Supermassive black holes in cosmological simulations I: M_BH-M_star relation and black hole mass function
- Formation of supermassive black hole seeds
- The Observational Signatures of Supermassive Black Hole Seeds
- Improved Dynamical Constraints on the Masses of the Central Black Holes in Nearby Low-mass Early-type Galactic Nuclei And the First Black Hole Determination for NGC 205
- X-ray constraints on the local supermassive black hole occupation fraction
- Nearby Early-Type Galactic Nuclei at High Resolution: Dynamical Black Hole and Nuclear Star Cluster Mass Measurements
- Gravitational Wave Detection with High Frequency Phonon Trapping Acoustic Cavities
- Measuring the mass of the central black hole in the bulgeless galaxy NGC 4395 from gas dynamical modeling
- Formation of massive protostars in atomic cooling haloes
- A population of intermediate-mass black holes in dwarf starburst galaxies up to redshift=1.5
- Supermassive Seeds for Supermassive Black Holes
- Identifying AGNs in low-mass galaxies via long-term optical variability
- X-ray Detected Active Galactic Nuclei in Dwarf Galaxies at
- An X-ray Selected Sample of Candidate Black Holes in Dwarf Galaxies
- Thanks for the memory: measuring gravitational-wave memory in the first LIGO/Virgo gravitational-wave transient catalog
- X-ray Detected AGN in SDSS Dwarf Galaxies
- Improved Dynamical Constraints on the Mass of the central Black Hole in NGC 404
- The Nature of Massive Transition Galaxies in CANDELS, GAMA, and Cosmological Simulations
- A new channel to form IMBHs throughout cosmic time
- Radio jets from AGN in dwarf galaxies in the COSMOS survey: mechanical feedback out to redshift 3.4
- Torque-Limited Growth of Massive Black Holes in Galaxies Across Cosmic Time
- Science objectives of the Einstein Probe mission
- The Black Hole -- Bulge Mass Relation including Dwarf Galaxies Hosting Active Galactic Nuclei
- Linking galaxy structural properties and star formation activity to black hole activity with IllustrisTNG
- Observational Signatures of High-Redshift Quasars and Local Relics of Black Hole Seeds
- A 10,000-solar-mass black hole in the nucleus of a bulgeless dwarf galaxy
- Dark-ages Reionization and Galaxy Formation Simulation - X. The small contribution of quasars to reionization
- GRB060218 as a Tidal Disruption of a White Dwarf by an Intermediate Mass Black Hole
- Revealing the intermediate-mass black hole at the heart of the dwarf galaxy NGC 404 with sub-parsec resolution ALMA observations
- The Limitations of Optical Spectroscopic Diagnostics in Identifying AGNs in the Low Mass Regime
- The Origins of Off-Centre Massive Black Holes in Dwarf Galaxies
- X-ray properties of TDEs
- Virgo Redux: The Masses and Stellar Content of Nuclei in Early-Type Galaxies from Multi-Band Photometry and Spectroscopy
- Chandra Survey of Nearby Galaxies: The Catalog
- OGLE16aaa - a Signature of a Hungry Super Massive Black Hole
- The Hunt for Intermediate Mass Black Holes in the JWST Era
- A Unique Multi-Messenger Signal of QCD Axion Dark Matter
- Properties of simulated galaxies and supermassive black holes in cosmic voids
- Gravitational Waves from Orphan Memory
- Star Forming Galaxies as AGN Imposters? A Theoretical Investigation of the Mid-infrared Colors of AGNs and Extreme Starbursts
- The Diagnostic Potential of JWST in Characterizing Elusive AGNs
- Chandra Survey of Nearby Galaxies: A Significant Population of Candidate Central Black Holes in Late-type Galaxies
- A Catalog of Hyper-luminous X-ray Sources and Intermediate-Mass Black Hole Candidates out to High Redshifts
- Black Hole Growth and Feedback in Isolated Romulus25 Dwarf Galaxies
- Multi-flavour SMBH seeding and evolution in cosmological environments
- A Uniformly Selected Sample of Low-Mass Black Holes in Seyfert 1 Galaxies. II. The SDSS DR7 Sample
- The impact of reionization on the formation of supermassive black hole seeds
- AGN and their host galaxies in the local Universe: two mass independent Eddington ratio distribution functions characterize black hole growth
- Dwarf AGNs from Optical Variability for the Origins of Seeds (DAVOS): Insights from the Dark Energy Survey Deep Fields
- The diverse galaxy counts in the environment of high-redshift massive black holes in Horizon-AGN
- Probabilistic classification of X-ray sources applied to Swift-XRT and XMM-Newton catalogs
- Assembly of supermassive black hole seeds
- Hard X-ray selected AGNs in low-mass galaxies from the NuSTAR serendipitous survey
- RESOLVE and ECO: Finding Low-Metallicity Dwarf AGN Candidates Using Optimized Emission-Line Diagnostics
- X-ray Spectral and Variability Properties of Low-Mass AGN
- Investigating AGN Black Hole Masses and the M- relation for Low Surface Brightness Galaxies
- Fast, ultra-luminous X-ray bursts from tidal stripping of White Dwarfs by Intermediate-mass Black Holes
- Central Engine and Host Galaxy of RXJ 1301.9+2747: A Multiwavelength View of a Low-mass Black Hole Active Galactic Nuclei with Ultra-soft X-ray Emission
- Dwarf AGNs from Variability for the Origins of Seeds (DAVOS): Intermediate-mass black hole demographics from optical synoptic surveys
- A Chandra and HST View of WISE-Selected AGN Candidates in Dwarf Galaxies
- The Megamaser Cosmology Project. X. High Resolution Maps and Mass Constraint for SMBHs
- The Past and Future of Mid-Infrared Studies of AGN
- Hubble Space Telescope Imaging of the Active Dwarf Galaxy RGG 118
- Stronger Constraints on the Evolution of the Relation up to
- LeMMINGs. III. The e-MERLIN Legacy Survey of the Palomar sample. Exploring the origin of nuclear radio emission in active and inactive galaxies through the [O III] -- radio connection
- Identifying Direct Collapse Black Hole Seeds through their Small Host Galaxies
- On the AGN Nature of Broad Balmer Emission in Four Low-Redshift Metal-Poor Galaxies
- The MBHBM Project -- II. Molecular Gas Kinematics in the Lenticular Galaxy NGC 3593 Reveal a Supermassive Black Hole
- Multi-wavelength observations of SDSS J105621.45+313822.1, a broad-line, low-metallicity AGN
- A hidden population of massive black holes in simulated dwarf galaxies
- A Low Incidence of Mid-Infrared Variability in Dwarf Galaxies
- First direct dynamical detection of a dual supermassive black hole system at sub-kiloparsec separation
- On the Prevalence of Super-Massive Black Holes over Cosmic Time
- An Upper Limit on the Mass of a Central Black Hole in the Large Magellanic Cloud from the Stellar Rotation Field
- An X-ray + Radio Search for Massive Black Holes in Blue Compact Dwarf Galaxies
- Difficulties in Mid-Infrared selection of AGN in dwarf galaxies
- Merging Hierarchical Triple Black Hole Systems with Intermediate-mass Black Holes in Population III Star Clusters
- Variability and the size-luminosity relation of the intermediate mass AGN in NGC 4395
- The Diverse Morphologies and Structures of Dwarf Galaxies Hosting Optically-Selected Active Massive Black Holes
- Possible Evolution of Supermassive Black Holes from FRI quasars
- A Very Large Array Search for Intermediate-Mass Black Holes in Globular Clusters in M81
- X-Ray Bright Active Galactic Nuclei in Local Dwarf Galaxies: Insights from eROSITA
- Conditions for direct black hole seed collapse near a radio-loud quasar 1 Gyr after the Big Bang
- Demographics of Tidal Disruption Events with L-Galaxies: I. Volumetric TDE rates and the abundance of Nuclear Star Clusters
- Gravitational waves from merging intermediate-mass black holes : II Event rates at ground-based detectors
- Jetted Tidal Disruptions of Stars as a Flag of Intermediate Mass Black Holes at High Redshifts
- Bringing faint active galactic nuclei (AGNs) to light: a view from large-scale cosmological simulations
- Discovery of An Active Intermediate-Mass Black Hole Candidate in the Barred Bulgeless Galaxy NGC 3319
- An Enhanced Massive Black Hole Occupation Fraction Predicted in Cluster Dwarf Galaxies
- Parameterizing the Outflow from a Central Black Hole in Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxies: A 3D Hydrodynamic Simulation
- Dark Energy Survey Identification of A Low-Mass Active Galactic Nucleus at Redshift 0.823 from Optical Variability
- La Freccia Rossa: An IR-dark cloud hosting the Milky Way intermediate-mass black hole candidate
- The VIRUS-P Exploration of Nearby Galaxies (VENGA): Radial Gas Inflow and Shock Excitation in NGC 1042
- Study on the detectability of gravitational radiation from single-binary encounters between black holes in nuclear star cluster: the case of hyperbolic flybys
- The evolution of high-redshift massive black holes
- eROSITA Detection Rates for Tidal Disruptions of White Dwarfs by Intermediate Mass Black Holes
- Growing a nuclear star cluster from star formation and cluster mergers: The JWST NIRSpec view of NGC 4654
- A NuSTAR and XMM-Newton Study of the Two Most Actively Star-forming Green Pea Galaxies (SDSS J0749+3337 and SDSS J0822+2241)
- Obscured AGNs in Bulgeless Hosts discovered by WISE: The Case Study of SDSS J1224+5555
- A Luminous X-ray Flare From The Nucleus of The Dormant Bulgeless Spiral Galaxy NGC 247
- The Success of Optical Variability in Uncovering AGNs in Low-stellar Mass Galaxies
- Contribution of Flares from Tidal Disruption of Stars to high-redshift AGN
- An 85-s X-ray quasi-periodicity after a stellar tidal disruption by a candidate intermediate-mass black hole
- Astrophysics with the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna
- Central accumulation of magnetic flux in massive Seyfert galaxies as a possible engine to trigger ultrahigh energy cosmic rays
- Identification of Intermediate-mass Black Hole Candidates Among a Sample of Sd Galaxies
- Feeding and feedback from little monsters: AGN in dwarf galaxies
- Merger Criteria of Multiple Massive Black Holes and the Impact on the Host Galaxy
- A compact symmetric ejection from the low mass AGN in the LINER galaxy NGC 4293
- Exploring the evolution of a dwarf spheroidal galaxy with SPH simulations: II. AGN feedback
- Detecting Intermediate-Mass Black Holes out to 20 Mpc with ELT/HARMONI: The Case of FCC 119
- Detection for Intermediate-mass Binary Black Holes in Population III Star Clusters with TianQin
- The Morphology of Dwarf Galaxies Hosting Variable Active Galactic Nuclei
- Variability as a new discovery channel for Intermediate-Mass Black Holes in the Time Domain Era
- A search for HO masers in 100 active dwarf galaxies
- Multi-component, axisymmetric dynamical models of dSphs based on distribution functions: inferences on dark matter and intermediate-mass black holes in Draco and Ursa Minor
- Time Domain Astronomy with the THESEUS Satellite
- Automatic detection of tidal disruption events and other long duration transients in XMM-Newton data
- The black hole occupation fraction as a fossil record of seeding, dynamics, and galaxy assembly
- The black hole population in low-mass galaxies in large-scale cosmological simulations
- Search of Intermediate Mass Black Holes at Low Redshift with Intra-night Variability